Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: risto on November 11, 2007, 12:05:23 PM

Title: Hohner Morgane (B/C)
Post by: risto on November 11, 2007, 12:05:23 PM
This first overall picture I found from the net.

(http://www.kolumbus.fi/slowsession/Morgane/Morgane.jpg)

The pictures I took  are quite large (w/ 5 meg pixel cell phone camera)  so I placed them on my web site to preserve the details. For a closer look download them and zoom in/out for the details. If you have seen the interiors of an pre-war Erika you’ll find all this quite familiar.

Treble mechanism

The mechanism is basically the same as in the pre-war Erika with an improvement to stop the button travel on the aluminium cover; felt washers under the buttons keep the stops silent. Felt is also used to prevent the sideways movement of the buttons.  The cover is slightly stepped, measured 1.5mm.

The white stripes on the front edge are cardboard I glued with double-sided tape to temporarily lift the cover to shorten the button travel. For a permanent fix the black plastic rods should be shortened. Pics:

http://www.kolumbus.fi/slowsession/Morgane/Treble_mechanism-1.jpg
http://www.kolumbus.fi/slowsession/Morgane/Treble_mechanism-2.jpg
http://www.kolumbus.fi/slowsession/Morgane/Treble_mechanism-3.jpg

Treble reeds and blocks

Reeds are with aluminium base. The reeds look much the same as those I ordered from another factory in Klingenthal Germany. Erika construction is used for the reed blocks, only the distance of the reeds (and thus air holes) is bigger  than in the Erika Club 21+4 (where the extra reeds are placed at the ends of the blocks). In the first picture you can see an Erika reed block holding the thing in position, in the second picture it is the topmost one. Pics.

http://www.kolumbus.fi/slowsession/Morgane/Treble_reeds-1.jpg
http://www.kolumbus.fi/slowsession/Morgane/Treble_reeds-2.jpg

Bass mechanism

Again same basic principles used as in the Erika. Just zoom out and you’ll see everything.

On the top right is the air release button. On the opposite side I have a piece of veneer with a V shaped hole glued to shape the air hole. The air amount is now proportionally adjustable. I will further improve this idea as I have found it to work pretty well because now I don’t need to think about the bellows position, I’ll just leak some air while playing a note to get the bellows in a better position. The veneer should be placed right under the valve, not the opposite side, to make it more precise. Now that I have the thing opened again I’ll make the improvement.

http://www.kolumbus.fi/slowsession/Morgane/Bass_mechanism-1.jpg
http://www.kolumbus.fi/slowsession/Morgane/Bass_mechanism-2.jpg

Bass reed blocks

For comparison Erika reed blocks shown too.

http://www.kolumbus.fi/slowsession/Morgane/Bass_reeds-chords.jpg
http://www.kolumbus.fi/slowsession/Morgane/Bass_reeds-single.jpg


The bellows

Again same manufacturing principles and measures used as in the old Erika. No creases used for the folds. 22 folds including those glued on the frames. The cloth does not feel like normal textile, could be some water proof stuff similar to water proof wall paper but I haven’t figured this out yet. The leather does not feel like genuine leather either, but could also be normal leather further processed for some purpose. The bellows have a tendency to close but this could be because they are new and I find it better to play with bellows as closed as possible and I haven’t been stretching them that much.

http://www.kolumbus.fi/slowsession/Morgane/Bellows_1-1.jpg

Playing the thing

Firstly, I’m a total beginner in accordion playing, so, what I say about the playing read it with that in mind. We need some pros to add further comments about this box.

The box is sturdy, build on old and tested ideas and will most likely last for years. However, Hohner standard reeds are used in the Morgane and  even as a beginner, after playing a few months,  I have started to urge for faster reeds. Shortening the button travel had a huge impact and getting 'tipo a mano' reeds could make this box a winner.

It seems that playing the box is quite comparable to car racing: you need top gear for good results. So what is the right thing to do when you feel you need something better? Is it to try to improve the almost good (get tipo a mano reeds with a few hundred euros), or is it to invest a couple of thousand euros more and buy something that other players already have found to be the best? This is what I’m wondering these days.


Title: Re: Hohner Morgane (B/C)
Post by: TomB-R on November 11, 2007, 05:52:05 PM
Fine detailed pictures. Many thanks
Tom
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane (B/C)
Post by: risto on December 17, 2007, 09:20:03 PM
Information I received from the German factory concerning the Morgane when asking for better quality reeds:

The reeds are of type T Mensur, same as in the Corona (don't know which version). (Have I just been unlucky with my reeds?)  I am waiting for an offer from them - due in January I hope - of C#/D reeds with new reed blocks. A surprise was that they have no reed blocks for C#/D and it will be a custom job.

I also have an inquiry of a spare bass mechanism with 12 basses and of a second set of an 8 bass mechanism as an option to be installed side by side with the current mechanism to get 16 basses.

I will then let you know how all these turn out.
 
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane (B/C)
Post by: Theo on December 17, 2007, 11:43:30 PM
The reeds are of type T Mensur, same as in the Corona

T Mensure are also the standard reed type used in Erica, Pokerwork, Double Ray.

The only difference I can see is that in the Morgane they are tuned swing instead of very wet.

Quote
I also have an inquiry of a spare bass mechanism with 12 basses and of a second set of an 8 bass mechanism as an option to be installed side by side with the current mechanism to get 16 basses.

Interesting ... let us know how it goes....
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane (B/C)
Post by: melodeon on December 17, 2007, 11:45:51 PM
So,  the buttons are "mushrooms"  and not the usual  disappears below the fingerboard type

or similar to Castagnari Hascy etc ?
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane (B/C)
Post by: melodeon on December 20, 2007, 11:36:50 PM
No Mushrooms ?
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane (B/C)
Post by: risto on December 21, 2007, 12:17:53 AM
No Mushrooms ?

That may be the right word used for buttons like that, I'm not sure.
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane (B/C)
Post by: Lars on December 21, 2007, 09:31:21 AM
Aren't they using the same reedblocks as in Double Ray/ Erica?

If so, why would a C#/D job be "custom", as they DoubleRay is available in that tuning? Odd...
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane (B/C)
Post by: risto on December 21, 2007, 10:40:12 AM
The Morgane bass mechnism is not available to be bought separately, at least not at present, but they said that the Erica mechanism is almost the same. So I have now ordered two sets of those and Morgane buttons. Probably some additional parts must to be done to make these to go together. I'll keep posting and send some photos when I get them...


Aren't they using the same reedblocks as in Double Ray/ Erica?

If so, why would a C#/D job be "custom", as they DoubleRay is available in that tuning? Odd...

I don't know if the blocks are identical, do you? We'll have to wait 'till January, maybe the person who forwarded my inquiry wasn't all that aware of all the finesses, but we'll see.  PS. "custom" can also mean editing something that already exists...

Title: Re: Hohner Morgane (B/C)
Post by: oldclubII on January 05, 2008, 12:26:10 AM
Just got my Morgane in D/G today: superb little box  ;D

The sound is really nice and punchy for a box that size. I like the "mushroom  button" action.

Awesome melodeon for its price. I recommend it!
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane (B/C)
Post by: risto on January 06, 2008, 09:23:05 AM
Moved here from other discussions:

Quote

The only difference in the sound is that the Morgane is tuned almost dry.  You could get the same sound from a pokerwork/Erica by changing the tuning.

Hmm, Hohner must have changed this too since last summer because my box (B/C) is so wet that I have to use it as a one voice box, taped off the other set of reeds because of the wetness.  ???

PS. In my box the wetness exceeds what here is described as 'Vibrato américain':

http://pagesperso-orange.fr/accordeons.serafini/sons.htm

PPS. 'Vibrato swing minimum' sounds what I would like to have.


There is a nice clip where we can hear a Morgane here:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hiTpLfsPpC8

The sound is definitely NOT dry!

Perhaps the first series were (the buttons had a screw in the middle), mine says "Morgane II" on the factory label and it sounds just like the one in the clip.



Hey, thanks for that, that is much much better than this one which is soaking wet.

Mine is Morgane II too.

PS. Read the discussion below the clip, seems that some of us have got wetter boxes than others.

PPS. EDIT: The clip is added in June last summer, I got mine in May but sent it almost immediately back to Hohner for bass change, got it back at the end of June. At the same time I compained about the wetness being too much, so *maybe* the reason is the date of production....
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane (B/C)
Post by: Theo on January 06, 2008, 10:02:18 AM
Very interesting, my comment was based on the one example of a Morgane that I've played, which was tuned with only the slightest amount of tremolo.

The lesson to take from this is that if you order a new box you should give the maker exact instructions about the tuning you want.  Shops should make it clear too that tuning can be customised.
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane (B/C)
Post by: risto on January 06, 2008, 10:13:59 AM
Very interesting, my comment was based on the one example of a Morgane that I've played, which was tuned with only the slightest amount of tremolo.

The lesson to take from this is that if you order a new box you should give the maker exact instructions about the tuning you want.  Shops should make it clear too that tuning can be customised.


Is it possible for you Theo to tune Morgane reeds so that only the reed blocks are sent to you? I mean, I have a thing going with Hohner (the C#/D blocks etc) but if that turns out too expensive or something I could send my blocks to you instead. (I thought I had someone here to do the job but he is moving to Italy for 6 or so months to study box building.)


BTW. Regarding the spare bass mechanisms, they cost me appr. 68 euros incl. shipping, but they have not yet arrived.
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane (B/C)
Post by: Theo on January 06, 2008, 11:33:46 AM
HI Risto

Yes I can do tuning work on reedblocks alone.

I'm not surprised at the price of the bass action.  Hohner put their prices for spare parts up by about 40% recently.  I've had plenty of occasions when I have had to wait 2 or 3 months for parts to arrive from Hohner.
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane (B/C)
Post by: risto on January 06, 2008, 01:58:38 PM
Quote
Yes I can do tuning work on reedblocks alone.

Great, then I have nothing to worry about.
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane (B/C)
Post by: EeeJay on January 09, 2008, 09:38:22 PM
I tried a Morgane today - light swing tuned, in D/G.

Review in two words - infectiously playable! ;D

Don't know if they were T reeds or XYZ reeds, the sound and balance was so just so sweet and nice I just kept on playing and playing...

I discovered these boxes in France a few years back, and I'm glad Hohner are deciding to release them to World markets. The build quality is incredibly good for the price, and some of the finer elements (button travel, thumb groove, etc.) can be sorted out by a repairman or competent woodworker...

Now... if they can produce the Galaad as a D/G, they're on to an even bigger winner...

Ed J
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane (B/C)
Post by: oldclubII on January 09, 2008, 11:49:57 PM
Yes, just got one last Friday and can't put it down!

It's driving my wife crazy...
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane (B/C)
Post by: Lin Leighton on January 10, 2008, 09:30:06 AM
Hi all
 I agree with all comments posted here that it is a good box for the money.
I tried a Morgane during the summer at a folk festival when asked for advice by a beginner melodeon-player friend who was looking for a beginner box . Based on my playing it there and then at the stall,  I suggested that she bought one.  However, it wasnt until she got it home, and I was asked to try it again that I noticed a small technical hitch - just one small niggle which hasnt been mentioned so far. and it is maybe just me that has noticed this because my hands are so small (and hence why I have difficulties playing my erica and much prefer Tommy), but ....

the base strap is adjustable by a winding nut - but I could not get it to go small enuff to make it tight enuff on my hand - it remained loose and so I was not confidant with it.

as I said, people with "normal" or larger hands would not notice this, so I believe it will only affect a few, but if you have small hands my advice would be to always adjust the bass strap to confirm that it will adjust sufficiently for your needs, whether it is the Morgane or any box.
regards
Lin
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane (B/C)
Post by: oldclubII on January 10, 2008, 02:21:32 PM
Talking of straps and belts, I also found that the shoulder straps that come with the Morgane are a bit short for me. I am rather tall at 6'2" and even with the straps set to their maximum length the accordion is a little higher that I would like it to be, especially for the right arm.

The other little thing I found with the accordeon is that some notes sound quite different compared to the others, like they are much "wetter" or "dryer" and this may create a strange effect when playing arpeggios or scales.

But again, who can complain for such a nice a box at such a nice price  ;D
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane (B/C)
Post by: risto on January 28, 2008, 02:48:24 PM
The bass mechanisms (2 x 8 = 16 basses) from Hohner finally arrived (a large picture, nees zooming):

http://www.kolumbus.fi/slowsession/Morgane/Erica_bassmechanisms.jpg

This is just the start and it certainly will not be a small or easy job. Before I do anything I need to decide whether to make it a melody bass system or single basses with corresponding 5th chords arranged as Stradella or some other way. I have two sets of new unisonoric bass reeds in one octave from D to D but probably I will be needing more reeds. New reed blocks are required in any case. I have planned to use balsa wood for these as I read an article by Peter Hyde about using of balsa wood.

EDIT TO ADD: The next step I'm taking is to model all these parts and the Morgane bass end in detail with 3D CAD to see how everything fits and to make necessary drawings for parts needed to be made or modified.

---

After Lars wondered about the Erica C#/D reeds fitting the Morgne blocks I asked this from Hohner and the production manager himself promised to order (!?!) standard Morgane reed blocks to check if the Erica reeds will fit in them. Will take at least a month to get more information.
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane (B/C)
Post by: Malcolm Austen on January 31, 2008, 12:28:26 PM
"I have planned to use balsa wood for these as I read an article by Peter Hyde about using of balsa wood"

I have looked at that article but have never seen any other discussion of balsa wood for reed blocks. Has anybody here got any views or experience?
 
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane (B/C)
Post by: an bosca ceoil on January 31, 2008, 02:32:23 PM
www.19larchclose.freeserve.co.uk/acc/
Accordion Makers Resource Site specifically links a Hyde / balsa wood block article, never read it but presume it is the one referred to!
Just clicked on the "Viewers questions" bit, makes one wonder how dated the site is!
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane (B/C)
Post by: risto on February 01, 2008, 12:42:46 AM
Quote
"I have planned to use balsa wood for these as I read an article by Peter Hyde about using of balsa wood"

I have looked at that article but have never seen any other discussion of balsa wood for reed blocks. Has anybody here got any views or experience?
 

To be exact I plan to use balsa only for the "walls" between the reed chambers and walnut for the bottom plate. Balsa is great for testing the block construction. From a hobby shop you can get balsa sheets of different thicknesses. After I have the drawings in 1:1 scale I'll attach the drawing on the balsa plate and cut the bits with a knife or jewellers saw. Sounds easy, but is it, remains to be seen...


Quote
Accordion Makers Resource Site specifically links a Hyde / balsa wood block article

That's the one.


EDITED...
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane (B/C)
Post by: Peter Stormy Hyde on February 19, 2008, 11:03:32 AM
The bass mechanisms (2 x 8 = 16 basses) from Hohner finally arrived (a large picture, nees zooming):

http://www.kolumbus.fi/slowsession/Morgane/Erica_bassmechanisms.jpg

This is just the start and it certainly will not be a small or easy job. Before I do anything I need to decide whether to make it a melody bass system or single basses with corresponding 5th chords arranged as Stradella or some other way. I have two sets of new unisonoric bass reeds in one octave from D to D but probably I will be needing more reeds. New reed blocks are required in any case. I have planned to use balsa wood for these as I read an article by Peter Hyde about using of balsa wood.

EDIT TO ADD: The next step I'm taking is to model all these parts and the Morgane bass end in detail with 3D CAD to see how everything fits and to make necessary drawings for parts needed to be made or modified.

---

After Lars wondered about the Erica C#/D reeds fitting the Morgne blocks I asked this from Hohner and the production manager himself promised to order (!?!) standard Morgane reed blocks to check if the Erica reeds will fit in them. Will take at least a month to get more information.
G'day Mates
This could be a dog’s breakfast as I'm not used to navigating around this site.

In regards to the balsa wood reed blocks that has turned up in discussion, I have been using it for many years with fantastic results. I know this at first might sound a little silly but it is stable and does not interrupt or absorb the resonation set up in the cavity. At this point you need a timber that does not respond to frequencies as you want as much as you possible can get to pass out off the accordion. My research has found in the last few years is that the timber of the accordion instrument needs to be inert, completely different to the guitar or violin type instruments. I have had a fantastic sounding piano accordion into my workshop for repairs that had Masonite (hardboard) sound boards, or should I say "dead boards."

In my last batch of acoustic boxes I put it all to the test, and made a box that was made from 90% foam, then testing with a frequency analyzer we found that we got a 33% increase in the lower partials and then it reduced to about 10-15% increase across the board in all the odd numbers with no increase in the evens. When I first played the box I thought I’d lost my top end as is sounded so low.
And by the way it is very loud!

Although I made this box about 6 months ago this is the first time I have posted anywhere that I have done this, although my friend/customer base know about it, and a few have tested it. I will have it at the National Folk Festival and Port Fairy Folk Festivals here in Aus’ over the next month or so.

My mate who analyzes my instruments who is himself a top shelf instrument maker suggested it might be better to make accordions and concertinas from MDF! I do not have time to test that one, but it might be worth testing by someone.

Back to work, and Good Health To You All.
Stormy

PS if you are searching for good Balsa wood then look in the yellow pages under Balsa Wood, as it is used by architects and theater set makers (and surf board makers here in Aus')  and the darker harder stuff is cheaper as the trades want white balsa. You will find it far cheaper than the craft shop.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal