Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Peadar on March 04, 2020, 11:10:37 PM
-
We can all understand Corona virus as a complication of MAD, but Coronavirus is a bit more serious.
How do we best prevent melodeons from becoming vectors for coronavioras?
Should those of us with lots of boxes just keep one out and put the rest of them away for the time being?
Any better ideas among the forum's medically qualified members?
-
Well I'm not a medic but sars-cov-2 I think needs water to survive, because now it is transmitted. So if you melodies is dry then the virus is dead.
When at work tomorrow I'll as my PHE microbiologist contacts - they'll know the answer.
-
Well I'm not a medic but sars-cov-2 I think needs water to survive, because now it is transmitted. So if you melodies is dry then the virus is dead.
When at work tomorrow I'll as my PHE microbiologist contacts - they'll know the answer.
All of my melodies are dry as dust. Only the good die young.
-
If you own a Hohner Corona then I would quarantine it. Flippancy aside, most disease vectors are organic and Covid 19 does not survive for long outside of the human body. I really wouldn't worry too much about it. Your box would need to be in direct contact with a person who is positive for Covid 19, and even then the virus would only survive for a very short time in the box.
-
Since they are now making them why would the Chinese disperse a virus aimed at most Hohners with their reputation for wetness ? I can see our fettlers on 24hour shifts removing the wetness, :Ph and charging a premium as the buckets of wet they drain out will be classed as hazardous waste >:E
Big opportunity for Winstons living near rivers, accessible at night, for a bit of fly-tuning ;)
-
Well I'm not a medic but sars-cov-2 I think needs water to survive, because now it is transmitted. So if you melodies is dry then the virus is dead.
So those of us with Hohner tremolo are in trouble, eh?
In all seriousness, I read that similar viruses can survive on surfaces for several days.
I suspect washing one's hands is going to be the most practical protection available to us.
-
To be honest the last I heard, the Covid -19 virus appears to be coated in fat molecues which enable it to stick to surfaces e.g stairway handrails and it may survive viable for 48 hours (but we don't really know how long for). Carried in cough/sneeze droplets....if someone infectious with Covid-19 sneezes over their treble end and someone else then plays the box, they could become infected from the box.
Hand wash with soap and warm water is expected to be an effective cointainment method because soapy water dissolves the fatty layer of the virus....
-
Bonfire should do the trick ;)
Or this is good time for a white lie , like you haven’t been well and it may be best that others don’t play your boxes. Coughing...
-
One should only be fearful of piano accordions. Sanitization by burning is recommended.
-
I've also tried to refrain from licking the treble buttons.
-
...Coughing...
Don't cough - you'll spread the virus...🤧
-
It's not so much the melodeon as the player ! Do wonder whether playing melodeons in sessions in any enclosed space could aid spread of germs through air circulation. But the same would apply to any blown instrument I suppose. Perhaps open air sessions are the answer ?
Meanwhile, there is some worry about possible transmission in ceilidhs, due to poor hand hygiene and close contact. Bourrees have definite advantages - many Breton dances definitely problematic. But we shouldn't panic...yet.
Stay well everyone.
Julian
-
Corona viruses steal their fatty membrane from the cell they grew in, but make their 'knobs' in the corona themselves. The knobs help it merge with the membrane of the next cell. The single strand RNA inside is fragile, and they don't take well to drying out, or to soap/ detergent!! Those make the fatty membrane soluble or dispersable in water.
The recommended disinfectants are either dilute bleach (any type) or 70% alcohol (meths, EtOH or isopropyl).
Seems that houshold kitchen sprays that 'kill 99% of germs' also work and might also be easier for eg misting bellows. I suspect that any virus that goes inside a melodeon … might never get out again. I also suspect that no one has ever checked that experimentally!
It's a fairly fragile virus - think stable soap bubble. But some strains have lasted over a week on hard surfaces 20ºC in moderate humidity. Other viruses eg Foot & Mouth have tough protein coats - F&M can travel and infect 3km on the breeze!
Bourrée is defo safer than Waltz! For non French dancers you are not allowed to touch partner in a bourrée. You "almost touch" every time you cross … therein the fun (and scope for passing on alternative infections later! >:E ). I'd offer that most Morris dancing is also fairly safe ;)
-
Current banter on a personal facebook page (involve a few melnetters) has included the following comment :-
"There is a risk of cross infection, with some reports suggesting the virus may persist for several days on hard surfaces. So the safest approach is to rotationally play one melodeon each day and then self isolate each instrument for at least 10 days before going back to it. This is just the type of crisis that those of us with MAD syndrome have been foreseeing and taking precautions for."
This looks like a good excuse to stockpile even more melodeons unless you're already extremely MAD.
-
Better buy another one quickly, as I've only got 9 playable boxes at the moment (No thanks Pete)
SJ
-
Sheep dip for 30 minutes. Hang to dry 3 days, then burn the remains.
-
That will get rid of any annoying ticks, as well.
-
Wrap the box up in 30 rolls of toilet paper >:E
And then go into self-insulation
-
Seems I misread the advice, have been practicing self oscillation, nearly got it right then became dizzy and fell off the swing.................
-
Wrap the box up in 30 rolls of toilet paper >:E
And then go into self-insulation
If the UK situation is anything like the panic buying in Australia, I don't know where you reckon you're going to buy 30 rolls of toilet paper, Nick.
Luckily, I have a huge collection of sheet music which should keep me going for a while.... >:E
-
My wife has just nearly choked with laughter when I read the comment above about a virus getting trapped inside the bellows of a melodeon and never getting out again!
‘Poor little thing! ‘She said. ‘What an appalling way to die!’
-
Those of us of a certain age will know how to deal with this.
Just cut up your favourite newspaper, thread it onto a string and hang it on a nail on the door of the outside Thunderbox . :o
-
As all melodeon makers have now been asked to switch their production into making respirators there could well be a world shortage of new melodeons in the next few months, maybe now would be a good time for MAD to take charge and snap up a new box (or two!) before supplies run out.
-
There's a tune that might help, it's called The Dettol Highlanders.
SJ
I'll get me coat . >:E
-
A word for those who feel the NCB's suggestion sounds a bit uncomfortable
IZAL
-
The big advantage of Izal, assuming that you can get even that these days, is that any left over can be put to good use when replacing bellows tape, or for other bellows repairs, since absolutely nothing sticks to it.
-
To bring ITM into it....I remember going to the toilet on a Belfast-Dundalk train in the early 80's and finding that the Izal like toilet paper had NIR stamped on every sheet. I stole a sheet as a souvenir.
(NIR = Northern Ireland Railways)
-
Sheep dip for 30 minutes. Hang to dry 3 days, then burn the remains.
I understand that protocol was written from banjos, not melodeons.
-
A word for those who feel the NCB's suggestion sounds a bit uncomfortable
IZAL
I’ll see you and raise you to Bronco
-
As all melodeon makers have now been asked to switch their production into making respirators there could well be a world shortage of new melodeons in the next few months, maybe now would be a good time for MAD to take charge and snap up a new box (or two!) before supplies run out.
In all seriousness - that may not be as stupid an idea as it sounds. With a (BBC News thismorning) projected NHS requirement for 8 times the available number of ventilators over the Corona virus peak it isn't "Spitfires" we need it is in design terms Jeeps - allegedly designed over 48 hours for an expected service life of 72 hours.....and the produuction technology of the Mosquito.
If anyone currently working in NHS bio-medical engineering can provide me with performance parameters for ventilators please drop me a PM.
-
Don’t know about the kit. My last gas project was in 1992, scotched when all spare ventilators were appropiated for the Gulf war.
Concur that this is not all going to be full ITU level. It’s possible to support and oxygenate using close fitted masks. In the end severe Corona is pneumonia. The machines need to be simple, automatic and capable of rigorous cleaning. The 1970s ones didn’t even have electronics! They seemed to work …
I’m a semi retired Xray Dr, now “working from home†😇 Used to specialise in infection, stroke, but only generalist ITU. Did have a fun 24 hours in there though, (also an ex motorcyclist) 😉
-
On a horribly serious note after all the mirth, I'd suggest Isopropyl Alcohol to wipe down the box. It doesn't have the nasty smell of meths and is safe on most surfaces - though not on cheap anti-reflective coatings. I have 5 litres being delivered for the weekend.
Rob.
-
As per above. 😀 meths does smell, and usually has dye in it, as it is pretty poisonous, origin of the phrase “blind drunkâ€. But otherwise it evaporates completely
Ethyl alcohol is just fine , but subject to much tax and duty. Also could be a waste of cask strength whisky 😉
Isopropyl is very safe on skin, the stuff on medical swabs. Not “poisonous†but don’t drink, it will truly upset your gut.
All will utterly disrupt lipid coat viruses 👍
Digression anecdote … my very first medical patient had drunk antifreeze, also a good anti viral, but also poisonous. We called the poisons people … specific antidote was … ethanol! Pharmacy had none … “oh, just use whiskeyâ€!
Whole bottle was … probably a bit much … but he went home OK, if somewhat hung over 😉
-
Is 40% alcohol too weak?
Thinking of loaning a box to a neighbour.... the smellof Whye and MacKay might be preferable to meths.
News of two Covid cases in Lewis today tells me that we are no longer beyond the front that infection has reched.
-
Don't buy anything until this scare is past. If you suspect or fear a box may be contaminated, don't touch it for at least 72 hours' If you lend a box to anybody, be prepared to isolate it, if/when you get it back.
SJ
-
Don't buy anything until this scare is past. If you suspect or fear a box may be contaminated, don't touch it for at least 72 hours' If you lend a box to anybody, be prepared to isolate it, if/when you get it back.
SJ
Genuinely sound advice- especially given the median age of the membership of this forum
-
It’s a really fragile virus. Basically a soap bubble (stolen cell membrane) stabilised by some proteins. The stalks are used to make that merge with the next cell host.
Seems it dies very quickly on soft furnishing. Has survived 3 days on “cool clean steel in humid conditionsâ€.
We discussed it in London meeting world Tb day* last month. Very similar. It “likes†to be coughed out in a tiny droplet, Get in via nose or eye (connects to nose via a duct), we don’t actually know about inhalation, but logically … yes
*Whereas absolutely NO concern came up about transmission via melodeons 🙄. i’d guess 2 days in a warm dry place would kill nearly all droplet viruses though. eg Last month I simply left any notes given in change on a radiator for a while. Don’t do that to your melodeon, the reeds might fall out 😳
Never forget that washing those hands for 20 seconds is a fantastic defence. (I’m a medic, ID background)
-
Last month I simply left any notes given in change on a radiator for a while.
I've bought very little with cash recently, and "contactless card payment" suddenly has a huge new significance!
The choreography at Screwfix was impressive when I went in to pick up some bits this morning (click and collect only, of course). Only one customer inside at at time. Table near entrance with card reader for PIN verification, then I had to step back out of the door while the young lady put the goods on the table, then I had to wait for her to retreat behind the counter before coming back in to pick them up.