Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Gena Crisman on March 10, 2020, 10:25:23 AM
-
Heya,
So, I've bought a GC Pokerwork project box. It may be a bit unusual in that it has 12 basses - that's not something I've seen very often I guess, but, it's hardly my area of expertise. I couldn't find really any other examples crawling the forum or elsewhere though, other than as accordion style unisonoric basses.
The box presents otherwise as your standard hohner 2915-looking amorphous 'pokerwork', standard size & everything, but of uncertain (to me) age besides 'old'. The extra basses are configured as regular diatonic basses and it seems nothing too unusual is going on in the bass mech - it doesn't seem aftermarket to me. The extra basses are kind of as I'd guessed - they're D/A and Em/B - so, as if the instrument had a 3rd row in D. Interestingly, the Em/B is flipped to so that Em is on the press, just like the GC's regular E major chord. So, rather uninspiring choices, but not unusual.
Pretty much the things that are in good or ok condition are:
- Hohner H stamped reeds on the melody and chord notes, on I'd guess zinc plates?
- Hohner T stamped reeds on the fundamentals
- Almost all valves are present - they're all past it & 1 is missing, but, being present suggests to me that it wasn't mistreated particularly.
- No noticeably broken reeds & no missing plates.
- Bellows seem like they're pretty dirty, but, without any failed gussets or obvious damage
- Keyboard mechanisms looks all OK, if ancient. (One replaced spring that I saw)
- I... think it might have a new thumb strap?
The reeds and bellows all being in good nick was my most important ask, so, I'm quite pleased with the purchase.
Flip side, the things that need fixing:
- The buttons are in a fairly unpleasant condition. I believe maybe one bass button has been replaced, and they're all varying heights. Some of the melody side buttons are a bit chewed up around the sides and one sticks in the keyboard every time.
- The pallets are all present but the leather on them might as well not exist.
- The wax is obviously toast.
- Bellows gaskets are obviously toast
- 2 of the reed blocks appear to have been repaired prior, using a screw to re-affix their flat wooden section (the part that sits against the fondo with all the round holes) - one repair has failed and the wooden piece pulls away freely. The bass fundamentals reed block has the 'intact' repair, however, it has a warp/twist going on. The others are 'mostly' flat.
- The shoulder strap is screwed directly into the body of the instrument, it seems the previous strap bracket pulled out.
- The bass mech cover is just tacked on with some domed pins of some kind.
- Bellows pins are bent/distorted and don't sit flush, but are all removable.
Photos are here: https://imgur.com/a/IZAHgPm
The shopping list for fixing things is a little longer than I'd planned. But, that's kind of good because, as things stand, this instrument is unplayable. This, to me, makes me feel more OK about trying some dumb stuff for case work & exploring bad ideas on the way to repairing it - I won't be ruining a playable instrument. I'm not entirely sure what my final goal really is, but, I've been getting the itch to do things and explore mechanical ideas, so, the reality is that my goals will probably to be a bit silly, rather than to sympathetically restore the instrument. The main thing I do intend to be sensible about is the reeds.
I have no special place in my heart for hohner instruments and generally find them to be displeasing to the touch, and I'm assuming that this instrument is neither rare nor special. At the moment, I'm mostly thinking to do some basic refurbishment, but to eventually ship-of-theseus (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ship_of_Theseus) both the melody and bass ends of this instrument - which means, bit by bit making replacements for all of the parts, across the whole instrument, until it has actually been wholly replaced. Making an entire instrument from whole cloth is too much for me as it stands, but, this presents an alluring gateway to doing so. Knowing my approach to space efficiency, it's likely to pick up some more buttons & reeds along the way.
So, I'm probably gonna be photo-blogging my activities here & seek advice where applicable - y'all have basically posted all the information I could ever need already. I think my first plan is to adapt the instrument into temporarily being a tuning bellows, and ascertaining the status of all of the reeds, off of their blocks. They certainly have no value on their blocks at current.
-
Looks like a great project, and I wish you success with it, I certainly would love to get my hands on a box like that.
SJ
-
I concur with Sir John's comments in every respect. (This urge to tinker and alter must be a further complication of MAD for some sufferers, methinks.)
-
Nice project box. It's suffered some unsympathetic repairs but they seem to be mostly cosmetic. The nasty black paint job on the keyboard is what I noticed most. Thankfully the reeds don't appear to have suffered.
The screw in the base of the reedblock is fairly standard in older Hohners, as is the failed glue joint! The best way to repair that is to take the base plate off completely once you have dismounted the reeds, then you can sand down to clean wood and re-glue, and put the screw back in too.
It is quite rare to find a Hohner two row with 12 basses, and because of that I suggest you aim to make this as good a player as possible. The old reeds on zinc plates are very responsive and have a lovely warm sound, not a bit like post 1950 Hohner brashness. You might even find you get to quite like it!
-
Great project Gena. Very useful box, a 12 bass GC.
At least you are sensible and start with a GC not like me with a 4 bass BbEb.
-
So, since I'm going to have to start thinking about it at some point:
The old reeds on zinc plates are very responsive and have a lovely warm sound, not a bit like post 1950 Hohner brashness. You might even find you get to quite like it!
How viable do we think it will be for me to find suitable replacement reeds for this instrument?
For example, for the extra basses on a 12 bass instrument, I'd typically look for:
Ab/Bm Eb/Bb (the equivalent of Eb/F#m Bb/F on a DG)
or
D/C Bm/Bb (the equivalent of A/G F#m/F on a DG)
Depending on what I wanted to do with it. Knowing me, probably the former - which offers vocabulary in the relative minors of your main keys, rather than as many chord reversals as the other choice there.
Currently they are
D/A Em/B (the equivalent of A/E Bm/F# on a DG)
If I wanted to play in D major on it (which, obviously, I do), I don't think that's the approach I would take. So, I really don't see much value in the D/A Em/B at all - they seem quite uninspiring choices. While I'm not sure how the chords are voiced yet, I can't imagine I'll be able to fully weasel other chords out of them, so, some replacements will likely be needed? I realise now I have no idea how far you can safely push fundamental reeds, but, that's to figure out later I guess.
I mean, yeah, working out my exact solution here is down the line somewhere, step one is getting everything sounding and then step 2 is stop everything leaking/falling off, but, it would be helpful to know if I've put myself of not being able to replace reed plates easily.
Also it's gonna take a long time to get used to G/C note layouts...
-
Since it’s a first project I suggest you stick with the original reeds. Get it back in playing order, then see what you can do with those basses. Once you have done all the reed work it will be a relatively familiar task to change the 4 extra bass buttons.
-
Gena, you may well be much more skilled than me, but I've always stalled when it comes to reeds. Frankly, unless you are planning to build skills in tuning, I'd be tempted to do everything but the reeds. There is a problem for some pro repairers in part working on a box that has had amateur hands on it, as the work they do might be less obviously successful because of the amateur work elsewhere. But if you can find someone to work on it with you, you might find that it turns into a better box than you think possible. Best of luck.
-
Are you keeping the thirds in all the basses?
-
I bought an old bandoneon (with zinc reed plates and a lot of notes) for $300 last winter and had a lot of fun restoring it. I am a beginner so it was quite the ordeal at times, and of course I spent much more than 300 on it. I agree reeds are the hard part. Ship of theseus is exactly right - it would be easier to buy a new one but where's the fun in that? I would next like to try fixing up a one-row and I wonder how much would/should I pay for a project box?
-
Are you keeping the thirds in all the basses?
I don't know, to be honest my inclination would be to drop the 3rds out unless I can invent something clever to swap them in and out. I do enjoy having them present but you can add them back in with the right hand.
Frankly, unless you are planning to build skills in tuning
I do indeed intend to build skills in tuning. But, I'm also prepared to throw my hands up in the air if it doesn't go well and accept the consequences. I've played around with steel bronze reeds you can find on a single plate in old one rows, as well as reversed some accidental plates. But, not without incident. My hope is to have learned from those mistakes. The depth of my knowledge currently really only extends to 'if reed no work, how make work?'. The finer points of how to get the tuning to be the actual tuning that you'd want in the instrument, especially without assembling and taking the instrument apart each and every time, is not something I've managed to achieve thus far.
In terms of project progress type things, I had a go at it today, taking some of the the first rudimentary steps. I took apart the whole melody side, and brushed out all the cruft that had accumulated in the mechanism.
Some photos from today:
https://imgur.com/a/nFfU6UF
Points of note:
1) The 'replacement' spring is very weak by comparison to it's brethren, and I suspect it will leak under bellows pressure.
2) I pulled off all of the melody pallets - the wood was all very unpleasant, and the ancient leather perhaps more so.
3) There's a small piece of chipped out wood between some of the holes in the fondo that I ought to repair.
4) After some light sanding they all looked ok and like something I would be willing to touch.
5) I think the buttons have all been painted, too? I imagine at this point, my best bet is to replace all of the buttons with something new, and non-horrid. I'm not sure with what, exactly - the bass buttons would need the same treatment.
They're 12.5mm and I assume stick onto the button arms in some way, I imagine Charlie Marshal sells replacements, but, idk spending 30-40 pounds on a whole new set of buttons for both ends of the instrument seems a bit hefty. I typically play & prefer stepped keyboards, and know better how those all fit together, so, I'm not sure what approach to take yet.
I guess my plan for the next time I have a play is: pull the reeds off, diagnose any misbehaving ones, and then (presumably) bash the failing reed blocks apart, clean & glue them back together as well as looking to level them out. I should be able to get some pallet facing material, valves and reed wax from my mum probably on Thursday, who has surplus from buying supplies to do up some other instruments. Perhaps I'll have some viable reed blocks by then, too.
There's quite a lot of rust on some surfaces of the treble keyboard mechanism - is that of any concern? Just remembered I'm going to need some glue for the valves, so, will make sure I have something suitable for that.
-
If it is indeed a 2915 style, you can replace the whole treble mechanism with buttons for a quite modest sum here:
http://www.hohner-cshop.de/en/Accordion/Diatonic/2-row/Erica/ (http://www.hohner-cshop.de/en/Accordion/Diatonic/2-row/Erica/)
I'm pretty sure it's the same mech. You can get an Erica bass mech but you'd need a few mods to fit it to your box. Otherwise I think the plan would just be to clean it up.
Bass buttons can be found on the 2915 page but to my mind are expensive. The site is still worth a browse for bits.
-
From what Theo says, it sounds like these reeds are a bit special. Worth making sure they don't suffer anything irreversible.
-
Gena, I've cleaned up the odd mechanism in my trials to date. I've used a rust rubber to get the worst off, and left it at that. Just don't push too hard on the bendy bits. It also did a good job on the axle, though of course that's an especially vulnerable part. Bear in mind you are probably several steps ahead of my skills anyway.
-
"I guess my plan for the next time I have a play is: pull the reeds off, diagnose any misbehaving ones, and then (presumably) bash the failing reed blocks apart"
For heavens sake don't bash them!
Where glue joints have failed and you want to take the pieces of wood apart ease the nose of a vegetable knife into a point where the two piecs of wod have seperated, as you get it further in the glued faces will progrssively split from each other, with the knife blade not cutting but acting as a wedge to sperate the glued faces.
-
How viable do we think it will be for me to find suitable replacement reeds for this instrument?
Easier than finding a bottle of TCP at the moment I would venture!
2 of the reed blocks appear to have been repaired prior, using a screw to re-affix their flat wooden section (the part that sits against the fondo with all the round holes)
That screw is supposed to be there. I think someone has already pointed that out.
The bass fundamentals reed block has the 'intact' repair, however, it has a warp/twist going on. The others are 'mostly' flat.
If you mean it is not sitting flat/flush, then it's an easy fix.
This, to me, makes me feel more OK about trying some dumb stuff for case work & exploring bad ideas on the way to repairing it
I've been getting the itch to do things and explore mechanical ideas, so, the reality is that my goals will probably to be a bit silly, rather than to sympathetically restore the instrument.
Why would you want to take that approach?
Your box is not in bad shape at all. It's just an old beat-up, run-of-the-mill thing.
There's loads of good advice on repairs/restoration available here. Why not just follow that?
to eventually ship-of-theseus both the melody and bass ends of this instrument - which means,
bit by bit making replacements for all of the parts, across the whole instrument, until it has actually been wholly replaced.
I don't get it. You intend literally making replacement parts?
Why do that?
I think my first plan is to adapt the instrument into temporarily being a tuning bellows, and ascertaining the status of all of the reeds, off of their blocks.
They certainly have no value on their blocks at current.
How are you going to do that if the reeds are loose?
You will need to also make a device to test individual reeds. That's a bit tricky.
Besides, you are not going to gain a huge amount with that approach.
My advice would be to test them on the blocks. The wax is shot and the valves are leaky, but that doesn't
matter at this stage.
If you have any seriously defective reeds, it might show up at this stage.
My approach would be to remove and clean the reeds. Forget about your tuning bellows for the moment.
I think the buttons have all been painted, too? I imagine at this point, my best bet is to replace all of the buttons with something new
Clean them. I wouldn't bother replacing them unless I wanted bigger buttons maybe, and that might involve reaming out the button holes. All completely unnecessary in my opinion.
There's a small piece of chipped out wood between some of the holes in the fondo that I ought to repair
I wouldn't worry too much about it.
I have no special place in my heart for hohner instruments and generally find them to be displeasing to the touch
I'm sure you don't mean that really!
-
My approach would be to remove and clean the reeds. Forget about your tuning bellows for the moment.
I agree with Pearse. You can't assess anything successfully unless the reeds are clean and have properly working valves.
That's really your first job.
1. Take all the reeds off the reed blocks, strip off all the old valves and bin them. Don't try to re-use old valves, it's simply not worth it.
2. Clean off all old wax from the reed plates and the reed blocks. I use a shallow bath of acetone* to clean residual wax from the reed plates and a blunt knife blade to gently scrape old wax off the reed blocks.
(Now is the time to repair any structural defects on the reed blocks - e.g. re-glue cracked base plates, sand down any warped or bowed base plates)
3. Check the reed tongues on both sides for rust and if there is any, gently scrape it off with a screw-driver blade or some 600-grit carborundum paper or file. Remember to support the reed tongues with a thin metal shim while you do this. In your photos the reed tongues look reasonably rust free, so hopefully this won't be a major issue.
4. Fit new valves to the reed plates and then re-wax them into place.
Only when you have done all the above can you begin to assess how the reeds are performing; for instance whether the reed tip gaps are correct and how out of tune the reeds are.
* Work in a well ventilated place away from any source of ignition. Aluminium foil take-away curry containers are good; plastic ones dissolve!
Industrial grade acetone is readily available and cheap as chips. I get mine from here:
https://www.mbfg.co.uk/acetone.html
-
Steve's right. Get the reeds usable before you can do any else.
For surface rust on the inside face of the reed tongue I have a bit of snapped off fibreglass rod.
It was a pull through fish rod for electrical cables.
It's filed to a blunt point and cleans up a treat inside the slot in the plate.
Be aware of the dust though and take precautions.
I have a little block of plywood with a hole cut in it for rough mounting reeds to get them close to what I want before waxing in. This is when you can check for even gaps, speaking easily etc.
-
For heavens sake don't bash them!
The bottom section is was attached via hide glue. My understanding is that, hide glue is brittle, and (especially partially failed) joints respond quite readily to a shock when one wishes to separate them. So, I don't think what I said there is an unreasonable thing to have said?
You'll be pleased to hear the offending section has been successfully displaced, in any event. I did use a small metal prying tool to encourage it to finish separating along the internal spine of the reed block, where the thinnest pieces of wood is & that I was most worried about. Then, used manual rotation to persuade the larger remaining area at the tail piece of the block. It separated without any damage.
So, this doesn't really seem like it needs to be a reversible joint. I also think this is the only wood to wood bond I need to do? (Unless I find other important-to-repair damage) It's a bit earlier than I was thinking I would be doing any, so, I guess I'll need to figure out what I want to do for glue. It was hide glue before, but, that joint did fail... so... hmm. This thread (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,21478.0.html) and pariselle course (https://youtu.be/6Qmni8h-kpY?t=99) instruments appear to be pva wood glued together so that should be appropriate here, I think.
If it is indeed a 2915 style, you can replace the whole treble mechanism with buttons for a quite modest sum here
Wow, that's a great tip, Malcolm, thank you! I shall keep that in mind if I suffer a total loss.
Why would you want to take that approach?
...
I'm sure you don't mean that really!
Hi Pearse.
So, bottom line, it's because I want to have fun, and, the stakes to me are literally 0.
So, imagine for a second I do actually mean that, really. Imagine I don't particularly want a restored 2 row 12 bass hohner pokerwork. Imagine that what I want to do, is the thing I said I wanted to do - I want to slowly replace an instrument with things I built myself, like for like, and then replace for not-like. I want to build a keyboard & I want to see what I could do with the same bellows footprint, I want to learn about & play with the mechanisms that I could use, think about what might/might not work for me. I want to invent things and solve novel-to-me problems, and enjoy myself. I've no idea why someone wouldn't want to do that.
Fixing up the instrument is a part of that process, sure, but, it isn't really my end goal. This instrument, to me, presents a playground. I've no interest in destroying it, but, it is in no way sacred to me either.
Maybe I can't get much information about the reeds before cleaning them entirely. But, what's the harm in just checking it out and seeing what they look like & if they can sound or not, y'know? Thinking about it, I probably have not even heard half of them. It took like, a few minutes with a dumb bit of cardboard and some packing foam to be able to see & sound the reeds in the blocks, and a few more minutes to make a little air chamber that a reed plate could be pushed against, and it made sounds and was interesting, and that's effectively what y'all are saying 'yeah no don't do that'? Like, I'm not sure if you thought I was talking about actually tuning them, or adjusting the reed set, or whatever - what I was trying to say really was, I'm concerned that if one of these plates has a broken reed so I wanna check they seem ok - if one is busted, I might be looking for a replacement for I-have-literally-no-idea-how-long/a few days and maybe it would it be handy to know that eg today, rather than eg friday, so I can maybe have one in my hands when I want it. Shooting some air and looking at them a bit seems reasonable to me?
So, I mean, I do appreciate the advice. I mostly know the approach to take, care of the many previous posts on the forum that you may be surprised to hear I have read and researched.
Wax removal, care of http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=16036.0 & advice here.
Valve glue, organised, care of http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=20108.0 so I'll have it ready when I have some valves
Flattening Reed Block warps, care of https://youtu.be/xy8dizq8Tks?t=174 is something I might aim to do today.
Wood Glue I know to have been used in manufacture of reed blocks + clamps organised, as above (https://youtu.be/6Qmni8h-kpY?t=99).
I've looked up my reed scratcher, lifter & support options, care of eg http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,13893.0.html & intend to obtain appropriate brass.
Bellows Gasket should be available to me.
Gasket for reed blocks to be organised, presumably Olovisc care of Charlie Marshall (http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Felt_Leather_Pallets.html#15) this will be suitable.
Definitely need some replacement springs also - one is bad replacement, one seems too weak, presumably mech comes apart per advice here http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,3305.0.html - I should also check my bass springs.
Re the Paint on Buttons, that is a new problem to me, that is something I'm not sure how to approach. It doesn't seem to be a water soluble paint. The buttons look pretty groady around the edges. Bright white plastic buttons is gonna look pretty lame too, though;
Clean them.
What approach would you take to actually cleaning them, though - chemicals, abrasives etc? Clean them on the arms/off the arms? I don't have a dedicated work room, harsher chemicals may not be a comfortable option for me, & for the same reason I won't be doing anything with fibreglass. Since mentioned, Acetone should be ok.
-
Gena, I'm getting the impression that my comments/advice have irritated you.
That was certainly not my intention.
I was offering my advice, for what it's worth. Nothing more, nothing less.
I misinterpreted you here I suppose;
I'm probably gonna be photo-blogging my activities here & seek advice where applicable
Your approach to repairs/restoration is novel. Unorthodox even. I realize that now.
I'm not saying there is anything wrong with that.
Good luck with your project.
-
Yes indeed a novel approach. I would still recommend that you start off by taking the restoration process as far as possible as a first step because that will give you valuable insights into the details of Hohner design and construction. That knowledge will then inform your design and making of improved parts.
-
I would just suggest that if you think the box is in any way historically special you log the pitches of the reeds before you re-tune it into a bog standard even temparement A440. In fairnesss Hohnner production models are unlikely to be anything other than bog standard- a tribute to their mass production methods and quality control.
-
https://imgur.com/a/HE9p40C
So, I disassembled the keyboard and tested a couple of buttons with our good friend acetone to see if it would take the paint off. The answer is, yes, but it's a time consuming process.
The reward is, of course, miserable brown casein buttons, as most would have predicted.
(http://i.imgur.com/Jay7IQCm.jpg) (https://imgur.com/Jay7IQC)
So, the choice of what to do, if anything, still remains. The suggestion here (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=16817.0) of spending 1 hour per button does not seem particularly appealing. Is uh, that the reality I should expect? Since they are ostensibly just a 12.5mm diameter, 7-7.5mm tall, slightly domed physical lump, with a 3mm hole in the bottom. They really could be made of basically anything.
Anyway, the mechanism drops little rust bits on everything it touches, going to try and give it a very thorough wire brushing to deal with this. I've also kept each spring with each button, although I believe it would only matter inner v outer row.
In fairnesss Hohnner production models are unlikely to be anything other than bog standard- a tribute to their mass production methods and quality control.
I don't see any reason why a 2 row would be anything but equal temperament. But, I'll be writing down pretty much everything that does or doesn't appear to be the case about the reeds anyway so I guess we can all find out together!
Glue and clamps are in the mail so I figure I'll probably do pallets tomorrow and reed blocks all together when those that need it have been repaired.
-
You could try a dense paste of Bicarb with a little water to see if it will bring them up.
-
So, I left a button to soak for a bit, and found I was able to abrade the outer surface with a finger nail and find a lighter button material deeper inside. So, I decided to just have a go with some 180 grit sandpaper and watch what happened:
Painted, Cleaned, Sanded:
(http://i.imgur.com/fJrIQ48m.jpg) (https://imgur.com/fJrIQ48)
Macro photo of cleaned vs sanded:
(http://i.imgur.com/HjY21E4m.jpg) (https://imgur.com/HjY21E4)
So, I think this looks nice enough to not suddenly race off to make new buttons - they don't look dirty to me any more.
I can't really see any reason to not ignore the soaking & just be reasonably aggressive with an abrasive until a reasonable result is achieved. I could chase those deeper cracks but I'm not sure why I would. The appearance is much lighter, despite the deeper cracks - you can sort of see lighter colour cracks on the unsanded button on the left, which are probably still full of paint. Speaking of which, this would let me strip the paint off without dipping each button in acetone 8+ times, too. One of the buttons has suffered a chip to an edge - given I have the keyboard apart I can relocate that button to the knee end of the box.
The 180 grit leaves the button feeling I guess a little fluffy to the touch? This has also reduced the height of this button slightly, the others are around 7.2 or 7.3mm, this one is now 6.8mm high, so, we've lost 0.5mm - another reason not to chase the deeper cracks. I assume finishing the button with a finer paper should make it feel smoother - I might avoid using a polish just so it doesn't get stuck in the backs. Alternatively I could put some clear varnish on them, or something.
-
So, funny story; sometimes you write something down and then get to thinking about it;
I've also kept each spring with each button, although I believe it would only matter inner v outer row.
This is something I know only I've read it in posts on this forum shared by very knowledgeable people. But, it might not be something someone who had to repair this keyboard because a spring broke would know. Combine that with:
One of the buttons has suffered a chip to an edge - given I have the keyboard apart I can relocate that button to the knee end of the box.
Now, if I had a problem with my keyboard, and I wanted to stay in action, I'd shuffle my problems down one end of the keyboard till I got it sorted. And, one of the springs had clearly been replaced, right at the end of the row... and some of the keys feel wrong...
So, since I've kept the springs with their buttons, I measured the thickness of all of the springs (in 0.xx of a mm)
long arm 56 56 56 56 56 55 51 51 56 51 RR
short arm 50 51 51 51 57 56 51 56 56 52
Perfect consistency, and then a 50/50 split? That sounds suspicious, heh. I guess maybe the 5th button on the short arm/inside row went and then the springs got jumbled? In that case, maybe I just need one spring for the inside row, and too easy to push long armed outside row button I found just needs a bigger spring putting on it.
-
[quote/] So, since I've kept the springs with their buttons, I measured the thickness of all of the springs (in 0.xx of a mm)
long arm 56 56 56 56 56 55 51 51 56 51 RR
short arm 50 51 51 51 57 56 51 56 56 52
Perfect consistency, and then a 50/50 split? That sounds suspicious, heh. I guess maybe the 5th button on the short arm/inside row went and then the springs got jumbled? In that case, maybe I just need one spring for the inside row, and too easy to push long armed outside row button I found just needs a bigger spring putting on it.
[/quote]
Well done you - nominal wire thickness of the heavy springs - which have to be heavier to load the outer row of pallets to the same holding pressure (moment = force x distance and pressure = force/area) established as 0.56mm nominal, and the others as 0.51mm nominal.
.
-
So, funny story; sometimes you write something down and then get to thinking about it;
So, since I've kept the springs with their buttons, I measured the thickness of all of the springs (in 0.xx of a mm)
long arm 56 56 56 56 56 55 51 51 56 51 RR
short arm 50 51 51 51 57 56 51 56 56 52
Perfect consistency, and then a 50/50 split? That sounds suspicious, heh. I guess maybe the 5th button on the short arm/inside row went and then the springs got jumbled? In that case, maybe I just need one spring for the inside row, and too easy to push long armed outside row button I found just needs a bigger spring putting on it.
This seems very much that the original springs have become mixed, or partly replaced by the incorrect gauge size.
Hohner springs for Pokerwork/Erica treble levers should be 0.5 mm for the inside row (short lever arm) and 0.55 mm for the outside row (long lever arm). The longer lever arm requires the stronger, i.e. thicker, spring.
Charlie Marshall can supply the proper springs.
-
https://imgur.com/a/SZGtYIb
Been busy, although most of that time is going into the keyboard.
Main takeaway is that I do have some rust to clean up on the inside of probably all of the reed plates, but, this is one bank from that separated reed block (which should now be back in one piece):
(http://i.imgur.com/NcEaXpPm.jpg?1) (https://imgur.com/NcEaXpP)
I guess I'll have to explore fixing that at some point.
-
Easily cleaned off. Support the reed tongue with a pice of thin material then remove the rust with a polishing block, as used for manicure.
-
How would you approach the rust on the harder to reach 'inside' face of an individual reed? I've read that it's less attached than that on the outer face but I've no actual idea as I've left it alone for now.
I got some 600 grit paper per Steve's advice earlier, although I can always raid more of the manicure supplies.
-
600grit glued onto a stick will remove the rust, but it will clog up fairly quickly.
For the under surface I use a miniature screwdriver with a good unworn end. Just scrape along the back of the reed while it’s resting on a flat surface.
-
For the under surface I use a miniature screwdriver with a good unworn end. Just scrape along the back of the reed while it’s resting on a flat surface.
This approach worked well for me, excepting one of the reeds on an accidental plate from this block, which just seems to have a bit more rust going on, as well as some white corrosion on the zinc plate right next to it. Not sure if it's all that important to rectify, but, I guess, what would you do (if anything) when the screwdriver is not sufficient? I'll get a nice macro-lens photo next time I'm doing some photography.
Turning our attention to the outer side of the reeds, since I happen to already have a fresh nail buffer, I thought I'd look at what that can do for me. It's a 3 stage one in classic flat format that can bring your nails up to a shine, but, the lowest level of it will not take ridges off of, or shape, your nails. The 3m 600 grit paper I got is a fair shake more bitey than the 1st stage of my nail polishing block, so, I suspect this isn't the right kind of polishing block. Than again, I don't think the 600 is nearly as aggressive as some emery boards I've had, which, for reference, are normally what I would have used for shaping and de-ridging my nails.
Having been keeping an eye out, I finally found the one one flat lolly stick I knew I must have somewhere (all the others are round) and made the aforementioned 600-grit-on-a-stick. I tried the 3 faces of my buffer in reverse order and found that they weren't really up to this task, so it's probably not the kind that Theo uses. The 600-on-a-stick, however, did do the job well & quite easily - and if this is an acceptable approach & is not too aggressive, it is likely what I'll do for all my reeds here - how things will clog up for remains to be seen, I do only have so many reeds to clean, and, I did buy branded paper. Plus I guess I can always make another stick.
As an aside, I used an appropriate looking plastic prying tool to support the reed for these tests, which I feel should be safe as I'm working towards the tip. This tool is probably too thick to support the lower sections of the reed safely, but, this should be sufficient for now.
I have 7 melody side buttons left to de-paint and sand down to oblivion/acceptable appearance... and I want to do one more rotary-tool-powered wire brush pass on the keyboard mechanism. Then I think I'd be securing my melody pallets & adjusting keyboard to fit the enclosure. The wooden keyboard enclosure has that iffy paint job on it, and has been repaired prior in the form of some wood splits between the buttons, but, I think it will be fine for the time being. If I can do that, then it might actually feel like I've accomplished at least fixing up one part of the instrument - that'll be nice.
-
To clean up the plates I use these brass wire brushes
https://www.amazon.co.uk/Yuccer-Plastic-Handles-Cleaning-Welding/dp/B07CVJYP6L/ref=sr_1_4?dchild=1&keywords=brass+wire+brush&qid=1584295604&s=diy&sr=1-4 (https://www.amazon.co.uk/Yuccer-Plastic-Handles-Cleaning-Welding/dp/B07CVJYP6L/ref=sr_1_4?dchild=1&keywords=brass+wire+brush&qid=1584295604&s=diy&sr=1-4)
Just brush in line with the length of the plate and Robert's your father's uncle.
-
To clean up the plates I use these brass wire brushes
I happen to have just such a brush. I've found it to be effective, depending on what the definition of effective is. When cleaning, there's going to be a 'going too far' point, but, I guess in a way I'm not sure where that is.
album link: https://imgur.com/a/iHP57uh
This reed:
(http://i.imgur.com/orfgmfSm.jpg) (https://imgur.com/orfgmfS)
After a pass with the brass brush:
(http://i.imgur.com/yMBl2nWm.jpg) (https://imgur.com/yMBl2nW)
This takes a way a lot of the 'brown'ness, but, there are still a lot of splotches, I guess. Is this in line with your experience, Lester? (or, is this a fairly rusty reed?) (or does my brush/brushing technique suck)
Using the coursest section of my nail buffer after the brushing provides this result:
(http://i.imgur.com/6T2QSkmm.jpg) (https://imgur.com/6T2QSkm)
Especially near the tip there hasn't been much success, and some brown colour has returned where I guess like, some still rusty areas have opened up with the abrasion?
Using the 600 grit stick:
(http://i.imgur.com/Atf5ENQm.jpg) (https://imgur.com/Atf5ENQ)
And this absolutely must have taken away some of the reed material in the process, too, but, it's like, shiny, like you wouldn't have known it had really had rust on it. But, I guess my question is, is that amount removed going to be OK?
Also, this is the reed I was referring to, the accidental plate, with the more stubborn rust on the inside edge (including an extra image of the outside edge - the 3rd image below - we're looking at the inside edge of the reed on the left in the first two photos, and the outside edge reed on the right in the 3rd)
(http://i.imgur.com/19GDAtBm.jpg) (https://imgur.com/19GDAtB)(http://i.imgur.com/VysdPCVm.jpg) (https://imgur.com/VysdPCV)(http://i.imgur.com/IF4wBTpm.jpg) (https://imgur.com/IF4wBTp)
-
Your cleaning work with the 600 grit looks fine.
The accidental reed will be too once you have it clean. It’s good to get all the rust off the top and bottom surfaces, but the critical area is the edge of the reed which may need to be scraped and the matching edge of the vent with its whit corrosion. I find the best tool for those areas is the tip of a pointed scalpel blade.
-
... The 600-on-a-stick, however, did do the job well & quite easily - and if this is an acceptable approach & is not too aggressive, it is likely what I'll do for all my reeds here - how things will clog up for remains to be seen, I do only have so many reeds to clean, and, I did buy branded paper. Plus I guess I can always make another stick.
I don't bother with the stick. I just use a bit of 600-grit paper pushed about by the tip of my finger. So long as I have a suitable shim support* underneath the reed tongue which is wide enough, it doesn't damage the reed plate.
So long as you have wet-or-dry paper, you can periodically clean it of cloggings using soap and hot water, then set it to dry on a radiator.
*I make my shims from sections of baked beans tins - the small can type which do not have corrugations. The steel is soft enough not to damage the reed tongues nor the kitchen scissors which I use to cut the shims to length and width and then flatten them out. I then thin down the ends to a fairly sharp edges by rubbing on a diamond grinding plate, but 400-grit carborumndum paper works just as well. Works for me...
-
https://imgur.com/a/gy3rz6M
Finally put the treble end keyboard back together, after cleaning it for days. Not sure if I'll approach the bass end keyboard differently - I might seek to dip things in rust cleaner and hope for the best.
I finally got around to ordering things I knew I'd need from Charlie Marshall yesterday. And, I received them today because that's just how good his service is. I can now look at valving and fitting my C row reeds back on their block in the near future. I also need to decide if I'm putting the new reed block gaskets onto the reed blocks, as was, or, onto the fondo.
That does mean, though, that I have a G row block that has reeds on it, and a working keyboard, so, I stuck that in the box, taped up the bass end, and was able to play a tune for the first time: https://youtu.be/SP8BMwbwvuY - Shockingly, I'm no good at playing in the upper octave unless I've planned for it.
-
Well I'd put the Olivisc on the reed block, so that you can swap blocks more easily.
SJ
-
https://youtu.be/SP8BMwbwvuY (https://youtu.be/SP8BMwbwvuY)
Think it may need just a soupçon of tuning ::)
-
https://imgur.com/a/Mifsiqz
More progress - this time I valved and waxed in the C row reeds, with actual proper valves and actual proper wax. It seems to behave itself quite well. Basic dumb Soldering iron with dimmer switch worked well - no smoke etc.
Started de-rusting the bass end, since restoring the keyboard mechanisms is such a big job, apparently. I think this time I can dip parts of the button mechanism in rust remover, which so far looks to be very helpful. Additionally, they're more uniformly and only slightly, with fewer built up areas. Not sure what the buttons will look like under that paint.
-
https://imgur.com/a/E0P8Rvp
Bass mechanism clean up and working on lightning up the bass buttons.
I did get a plastic replacement bass button from Charlie but, I'm not sure it's the right call to put it on because it won't really fit in at all. For now, I'm thinking to re-attach the (literal) button to the broken stump - it won't fit in either, but, it feels somehow more appropriate since it's been with the box for quite some time? I think I could swap the broken arm with one higher up that is a very close match. Since the (literal) button has has a small divot in the middle, I might be able to use as an indicated button, to find my way around the unfamiliar 12 basses.
As it stands, I'm not currently planning on bushing the bass buttons on this instrument. I do think I should get/make some felt washers however, to restore the long demised ones that used to live beneath the bass buttons. They're 12.5mm buttons with a 7.5mm shaft, so, I guess I would probably need to get some punches of some kind to actually make some good washers. I'll have to decide if I want to go that route, or, if I want to just buy some washers and enlarge their holes, or just eyeball it with a pair of scissors. Also have to figure out what kind of felt to use, or leather, I guess. I suppose if I did get bushing felt I could use that.
Sure are a lot of jobs to do, refurbishing a box.
-
Gena, what have you done? Your link takes me to this:
"Age confirmation required
This post may contain erotic or adult imagery.
By continuing, you acknowledge that you are 18+ years of age."
Obviously, I clicked on the right place, to see what you were concealing from the tender-hearted, but wasn't allowed to go any further!
-
Can't answer that one, I'm afraid. None of the images appear to be marked as mature and I can't imagine it's decided that any of them are not pure of heart. Here are all the photos as links, anyway. Maybe one of these will expose why it's asking for a mature content check.
(http://i.imgur.com/j6PWD9Bm.jpg) (https://imgur.com/j6PWD9B)(http://i.imgur.com/4jyUmc2m.jpg) (https://imgur.com/4jyUmc2)(http://i.imgur.com/CXoZgx0m.jpg) (https://imgur.com/CXoZgx0)
(http://i.imgur.com/BZfiftcm.jpg) (https://imgur.com/BZfiftc)(http://i.imgur.com/UmL2gQZm.jpg) (https://imgur.com/UmL2gQZ)(http://i.imgur.com/XxWJFFIm.jpg) (https://imgur.com/XxWJFFI)
(http://i.imgur.com/QnN3hDUm.jpg) (https://imgur.com/QnN3hDU)(http://i.imgur.com/3qlSsJHm.jpg) (https://imgur.com/3qlSsJH)
(http://i.imgur.com/dDtzsC2m.jpg) (https://imgur.com/dDtzsC2)(http://i.imgur.com/tAK6xF3m.jpg) (https://imgur.com/tAK6xF3)(http://i.imgur.com/N3Lwhxfm.jpg) (https://imgur.com/N3Lwhxf)
(http://i.imgur.com/2Hk90Ram.jpg) (https://imgur.com/2Hk90Ra)(http://i.imgur.com/3w4tCy3m.jpg) (https://imgur.com/3w4tCy3)
(http://i.imgur.com/Gg4n7PDm.jpg) (https://imgur.com/Gg4n7PD)(http://i.imgur.com/atcaxy0m.jpg) (https://imgur.com/atcaxy0)
In any event, sorry about that. That is the downside of using an external image host but also it would take 1000 years to post 15 images as attachments here.
Apparently it's something about this incredibly saucy image:
(http://i.imgur.com/UmL2gQZm.jpg) (https://imgur.com/UmL2gQZ)
But, removing it from the gallery doesn't remove the age restriction. How sad...
-
For cleaning the buttons I recommend abrasives. Specifically wet and dry paper used wet. Start with a fairly coarse grade, maybe 300 grit, and go carefully because the button material (casein) is fairly soft. When all the paint and discoloured material has gone then go through a couple of finer grades and finish with metal polish on a cloth.
Detach the arms from the mechanism but keep the buttons on their pushrods to give you something to get hold of. This will also allow you to clean the steel parts more thoroughly. If you don’t want to have the whole mechanism in bits then a you withdraw the axle rod remove one lever to work on, then replace it and slide a thin wire in as a temporary holder.
-
Gena, check with others before doing what I did, but I had some very nice bellows corners lying around - soft thin leather. I used this material to bush the bass buttons. I did have to enlarge the holes first. It seems to be impossible to get a parallel sided new hole - but careful use of reamers from the outside and the inside means that any tapers are less of an issue.
The bellows corner bush linings have been in for a couple of years and work perfectly. The buttons did already have a cushion of felt, so it was only the side to side clack that I needed to remove. I can't see the point of cleaning up mechanisms and not bushing. Of course it is just as easy to buy the real felt. Don't try using ordinary felt as it isn't dense enough and doesn't have the structure to avoid mashing and wearing out.
-
Gena, check with others before doing what I did, but I had some very nice bellows corners lying around - soft thin leather. I used this material to bush the bass buttons. I did have to enlarge the holes first. It seems to be impossible to get a parallel sided new hole - but careful use of reamers from the outside and the inside means that any tapers are less of an issue.
The bellows corner bush linings have been in for a couple of years and work perfectly. The buttons did already have a cushion of felt, so it was only the side to side clack that I needed to remove. I can't see the point of cleaning up mechanisms and not bushing. Of course it is just as easy to buy the real felt. Don't try using ordinary felt as it isn't dense enough and doesn't have the structure to avoid mashing and wearing out.
What I do is ream from the outside until the hole is the right size (not sure how big that is anymore but its marked on my reamer) then bush to about 3/4mm with proper bushing felt (http://concertinaconnection.com/spares.htm), this obviates the need for a parallel sided hole.
-
Yeah, I don't have a reamer, or a set of punches. Since I have some extraordinarily sturdy paper clips that are the exact right thickness for replacing the pins that hold the bass button arms on, after cleaning up the rest of the bass buttons I may pin them in place and just move on for now. I need to do some wood work on the bass end to restore the four corners that the side panel would screw onto, which somehow are all missing, and refurb all the other reed blocks. The list of jobs seems unending.
So, I may have to circle back after getting some more tools & materials, which might take a while, before bushing the buttons. To be honest, I've often wondered why we don't bush the metal arms, just inside the instrument before they bend making a couple bits of wood that screw in place and clamp them between some padding.
Thanks for the link for your preferred concertina store, Lester. I do actually want some bushing felt. And I do have some leather I could use, Pete. I'm not too familiar with pokerworks to know how badly I need to bush them - I levelled the buttons out this morning and it feels pretty OK, but I don't have the bass board or strap in place to really know.
-
Yeah, I don't have a reamer, or a set of punches...
I suspect that if you want to do jobs like this well they are tools you need. Not sure where the thread is, but there was a recent one that, I think, recommended on sources. Not expensive, but very useful. It's a job I am planning to tackle on all my boxes.
-
So, I have a bunch of pictures I never shared: https://imgur.com/a/WHIPO5v and have made progress beyond this.
I've carried on from there and have dealt with both melody blocks and the chords block. Thirds are all indicated to myself in a sensible capacity should I decide to be free of them. Turns out if you stick all the reeds down and give them new valves, things start to generally be a lot better:
https://youtu.be/t6rRqgiIDSA
I have yet to revalve and rewax the bass fundamentals, still, but, imo not as big a factor since iirc they're all still actually attached to the block. They're next on the agenda though. Then, woodwork to attach the bass cover.
There's a few things still & to work out & some materials to get, and with a lot of our preferred sellers of bits (quite justifiably) closing their online doors it does leave me a bit uncertain. But, these are uncertain times.
After that it'll be isolating each bank of de-rusted, revalved reeds and just writing down where they're at, because, I guess who knows? Would be nice to know exactly how the chords are voiced.
Also: really hate cutting holes in olivisc to let air go through, not fun at all.
-
I bought a Reamer set, Ebay Item 152808416250, £6.99, Free delivery, perfect for Pokerwork's ( & Castagnari's ). As per Lesters video, 10/11mm is about the correct dia.
Before eroding those buttons, I really would try a paste of Bicarb /Baking Powder, with a little water. If you are concerned about the efficacy, you can 'spot treat' them and the 'clean' area will stick out like a sore thumb. It will not remove the paint, but I think you said that could be scratched off with your nail. It is the principal ingredient of the whitening tooth-pastes such as Arm & Hammer and works naturally. It is too messy to do when the buttons are in the box, but as they are out, you can 'dip'/submerge them for a best result.
It is possible to cut the felt for the fondo, like the original, by creating a sandwich of 300gsm card, and a paper guide with the felt in between using spray-on, re-positionable glue.
Spray the card, apply felt to card, take a pencil 'rubbing' of the reed-block holes, then spray the paper and apply that to the felt. The sandwich stops the felt moving whilst being punched and the rubbing provides a perfect 'pattern' to get the slightly offset holes in the right place. The re-positionable glue leaves no residue on the felt. The same process can be used to replicate the linen discs used to hold the pallets with 'Fish Glue' as per the originals (no disrespect to the Glue Gun ) I have found an 'Eco' Tote bag the ideal material for cutting the discs from. You can get a lifetimes worth out of one bag and they are 'free' in our house, although the wife still wonders where it went.
-
Self adhesive olivisc is not ideal material for reed block gaskets because it is rather tough and tends to pull when cutting. Added to that the adhesive is not very strong so the material tends to pull and stretch under pressure from your knife leading to a ragged edge.
Best way to reduce this is to use a scalpel with a new blade when you start this job.
Italian makers use a different material (confusingly also called olovisc because of its colour). This is a woven material with a velvety pile on one side. Fix it with pva and use a new blade and it cuts like butter.
-
Bi-card solution and buttons. These weren't the worst example imaginable, but are worse in the flesh than appears to be the case in the photo. A 20 minute soak in a "strong" solution of Baking Soda and water, agitated occasionally with a soft brush, rinsed and dried.
No scraping/rubbing etc required as the solution does the work. They come up pretty much like new. The Box is a 'post' Pokerwork one from the 40's/50's, vinyl cracked ice finish with 'H' reed's if that dates the buttons and the decades of accumulated grime.
-
The pictures are very appreciated, thank you.
So, all of my buttons have already been abraided with 180 grit to remove the paint/deepest marks, and then wet 600 grit to address the majority of the crazing & even their surface out.
I feel the buttons in my instrument here were in a significantly darker & crazed position than those on your instrument there (eg https://i.imgur.com/tAK6xF3.jpg), so, I don't regret sanding them. However, if they had been in the same condition as yours, I believe your solution would definitely yield better results - cleaning the edges with the buttons in place on the arms is quite difficult with the sand paper, and it's fairly easy to disrupt the 'roundness' of one's buttons. It's also messy and quite a bit of work, too, so, if you can just dunk them and come back to it later then that's probably better for your productivity in a day.
I was asked if I knew roughly when my instrument was made by a friend of mine, and I didn't know (still don't) - I guessed 'old'/middle of last century. There's no external stickers or stamped numbers, or anything informative really. It has a wooden keyboard shroud, casein buttons, H reeds + T reed fundamentals all on zinc plates, leather valves tip to toe. Reed blocks have G/C and 870 stamped on.