Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: mike delta on January 17, 2008, 09:36:49 PM

Title: octave identification
Post by: mike delta on January 17, 2008, 09:36:49 PM
Hi All,
I believe that the Italian makers of melodeon's et cetera use a method for planning the order of notes on a keyboard (written out first on paper of course) using a system wherebye each note is given its name followed by a number to identify which octave it is in. For example the note 'A' would be written as 'A' but designated a number. Something like this: 'A' 1 or 'A' 2 and so on...
Can anyone please explain the system to me? Or better still some kind of scanned image showing the system.
It is unclear to me where one would start. For example the note 'A' below middle 'C' would be 'A' 0 or 1 or even 2????
Your help would be greatly appreciated.
Mike.

 
Title: Re: octave identification
Post by: Waltham on January 17, 2008, 09:52:34 PM
If it's a letter and a number it's probably scientific pitch notation.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_pitch_notation
Title: Re: octave identification
Post by: an bosca ceoil on January 17, 2008, 11:22:05 PM
Hi All,
I believe that the Italian makers of melodeon's et cetera use a method for planning the order of notes on a keyboard (written out first on paper of course) using a system wherebye each note is given its name followed by a number to identify which octave it is in. For example the note 'A' would be written as 'A' but designated a number. .

 
Mike,
Have a look at this - www.geocities.com/shublom/reed_diagram.jpg - it applies  to unisonic reeds but might be what you refer to.
Regards,Bruce
Title: Re: octave identification
Post by: Pushpull on January 18, 2008, 09:06:23 AM
Mike,
Have a look at this - www.geocities.com/shublom/reed_diagram.jpg - it applies  to unisonic reeds but might be what you refer to.


That looks as though it answers it. Interesting. Apart from Wikipedia mentioned earlier there is an article on several different systems for naming octaves (though not the Italian accordion one) on the excellent Dolmetsch website - see,  "distinguishing octaves" at http://www.dolmetsch.com/musictheory1.htm.

Actually the series of articles on the Dolmetsch site is an excellent primer for anyone interested in music theory. They're not just recorder makers!!

Roy.
Title: Re: octave identification
Post by: Theo on January 18, 2008, 11:47:25 AM
Italian makers also still use Sol Fa.  Look at the reed blocks of almost any Italian box and you will see "Re Sol"  for D/G for example.

When I'm, ordering reeds that are in non-standard sets I sometimes send an image of the notes on staff notation.  I find that clears up any ambiguity, especially on accidentals  where its not obvious from the context which octave I want.
Title: Re: octave identification
Post by: BruceHenderson on January 18, 2008, 01:51:40 PM
Italian makers also still use Sol Fa.  Look at the reed blocks of almost any Italian box and you will see "Re Sol"  for D/G for example.

   As do makers and players in Quebec.

Quote
When I'm, ordering reeds that are in non-standard sets I sometimes send an image of the notes on staff notation.  I find that clears up any ambiguity, especially on accidentals  where its not obvious from the context which octave I want. 

   I recently ordered a one-row in A.  I had had problems playing with fiddlers in "A" on the A-row of my "Benny" because (like the A-row on a D/A box), the "home buttons" (i.e. 3-6) are an octave below a fiddler's normal playing range.  If I was trying to play with a fiddler (and avoid things like playing the same notes but an octave lower), I had to use button 6 for the lower tonic and hope that I ddin't run out of range at the top.  Playing in that range also was a little harder by ear since the relative locations are different (i.e. A and B aren't on the same button -- yeah, I know, I should practice until I don't have any problem with that ... so, shoot me). 

   So, I specified "tuned in A with the third button with the paired violin reeds at A=440 or the A above middle C; tuning should be Bassoon=220, Violin=440, Piccolo=880)".  It seemed clumsy and less than elegant but the accordeon arrived exacty as I wanted it -- tuned an octave below the usual range for the A-row on an ADG or D/A.
Title: Re: octave identification
Post by: Stiamh on January 18, 2008, 02:06:38 PM
So, I specified "tuned in A with the third button with the paired violin reeds at A=440 or the A above middle C; tuning should be Bassoon=220, Violin=440, Piccolo=880.  It seemed clumsy and less than elegant but the accordeon arrived exacty as I wanted it -- tuned an octave below the usual range for the A-row on an ADG or D/A.

Don't you mean above? If so, your top end must be even higher into bat and dog whistle territory than the G row of a D/G!

You seem like a good candidate for an Accordéon Bouchard, Bruce...
Title: Re: octave identification
Post by: BruceHenderson on January 18, 2008, 08:04:29 PM
So, I specified "tuned in A with the third button with the paired violin reeds at A=440 or the A above middle C; tuning should be Bassoon=220, Violin=440, Piccolo=880.  It seemed clumsy and less than elegant but the accordeon arrived exacty as I wanted it -- tuned an octave below the usual range for the A-row on an ADG or D/A.

Don't you mean above? If so, your top end must be even higher into bat and dog whistle territory than the G row of a D/G!

You seem like a good candidate for an Accordéon Bouchard, Bruce...

    Yeah -- you've got to understand my posts for what I mean not what I say !!!!   ;D   (And I think that I was thinking that I moved the "basic tonic" to the third button which is below but actually above ...  Did somebody say that the Italians have worked out a simple way to express this stuff????)  And I'm not sure about A-Bouchard.  I talked to Sabin about them over New Years and he thinks that they're great, but I'm not a "real musician" and I'm not sure that I can find notes if they're not where they should be.  Also, any phrase that doesn't end in a push is a killer for me ... that's part of my struggle with minor keys.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal