Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Paul Brennan on March 31, 2020, 05:57:30 PM
-
Hi folks,
This is a "beginners" question so I put it in the learning section - I mostly play a chromatic button box. I'm looking at diatonic boxes and trying to figure out the pros and cons.... I'm sure it will have been discussed many times so please feel free to direct to an old thread.
For example Irish musicians prefer a semitone box and Quebecois musicians prefer G/C I think? But in some cases they are playing the *same tune* or closely related so there must be some wiggle room... One issue I guess is the basses - if you're not really using the basses as much - if it's basically a melodic instrument - then a semitone box would be the most versatile, or at least the most chromatic. But if you want to play accompanied melody/chord music - Stephane Delicq for instance - then the quint layout maybe ensures that the bass/chords are more likely to be in the right place at the right time, is that correct? In that scenario, a B/C or C/C# box would seem a bit less versatile -
you can play any note but not necessarily against chords and basses that make sense (other than in B or C). Is my thinking correct on that?
- Paul
-
That's a pretty good summary. A lot of it does have to do with how much (and how) you want to use the basses, how flexible you want to be with keys, and, of course, traditional playing styles.
By the way, I think Quebecois often play single row boxes in D. G/C is popular in France, D/G in England and C/F in The Netherlands and Germany.
-
Hello Paul (cross-posted with Anahata)
Your question is bound to generate a lot of helpful answers. I would say you have it about right when talking about the use of the basses, but I would just like to comment on what you say below:
For example Irish musicians prefer a semitone box and Quebecois musicians prefer G/C I think? But in some cases they are playing the *same tune* or closely related so there must be some wiggle room...
Yes Irish musicians prefer a semitone box, but Quebecois musicians mostly play either one-row boxes (usually in D) or three-row boxes (usually in ADG or GCF). The repertoire they play on these three-row boxes is not usually closely related to Irish music. You see a few two-row boxes around, more often A/D than G/C I would guess. And a small but growing number of box players in Quebec are adopting semitone systems, mostly D/C#, a few on C#/D, and at least one on B/C (a member of this forum)!
All this to say that there isn't much in common, or wiggle room if you like, between a G/C and a semitone box as played in Irish and Quebecois music. And by the way, I would advise you to forget about the C/C# for playing in the usual keys of trad music - the key of D, for example, is bit of a pig on that system.
-
One way around all this would be interchangeable reed blocks, but that doesn't seem to be a big thing, maybe for technical reasons?
- Paul
Hello paul, nice to see you opening a nice can of worms.
To address this question, the answer is yes, it is probably the cheapest way of trying different systems if you pick your bsasic box with care. Hohners seem pretty good for this. Their two row box reeds seem to share a lot of properties. I just fitted GC reeds to my old CF with very little work.
[Edit...well...maybe not the cheapest. Begging, stealing and borrowing are all cheaper, but it is a very satisfying way of doing it, especially if you're short on space.]
-
Melodeon is essentially a word for a small diatonic button accordion. In Scotland melodeon also covers 2 row chromatic boxes with limited basses. but to an Irish player the 1 row is a melodeon and a 2 row chromatic is an accordion.
Diatonic instruments of limited range are at the core of of much traditional music. Often traditional instruments (rooted in a culture, distinguished by language) have been adapted modified / developed - particularly through the 19th century to make them "fit" into the assumed superiority of western European classical music. There is good reason to argue that the melodeon/button accordion -a product of that same century and mass produced through the period of European industrialisaton penetrated and became a folk instrument of so many different European cultures because though individual instruments were/are limited the generic instrument can be configured in so many different ways. As Anahata says G/C France D/G England &c.
I am told that D is also the usual tuning of Irish melodeons. With beginners ignorance I started a year ago with a G melodeon...to match the range of a fiddle and because the great pipe's 9 note range runs G-A' . What I didn't appreciate is that the pipe scale is A myxelodeon - the same as D major (F# and C#). I subsequently supplemented the 1 row with an A/D.
I think the attraction of the chromatic (B/C) and indeed 2 row boxes generally is that they facilitat/enable slurring whereas the melodeon creates it's own dynamic. The melodeon's limited basses create a restriction for skilled players but an opportunity to produce a simple accompaniement for the relatively unskilled player. (Exhibit number 1 being myself).
-
(Said Stiamh)
"And by the way, I would advise you to forget about the C/C# for playing in the usual keys of trad music - the key of D, for example, is bit of a pig on that system."
I am finding that out the hard way! I recently acquired a C/C# which has a pair of D/A basses....obviously the intention was to enable the box to be played in D. The waer and patination on the key board makes it obvious the the box was played most of it's life in the key of D#. .e. as a high pitched B/C. On the other hand it's dead easy playing traditional tunes in F on a C/C# box.
-
And by the way, I would advise you to forget about the C/C# for playing in the usual keys of trad music - the key of D, for example, is bit of a pig on that system.
Yes I must have been thinking of C#/D when I typed C/C#. In any case, that's very interesting about Quebecois music. It sounds a one row in D covers an awful lot of great music, particularly here in Canada.
-
To me the best semitone system is the BCC# which offers all the benefits of both a BC and a CC# box together with much easier fingering and bellowing because of duplicated notes. Put simply doing the business on the BC rows provides easy access to all the sharp keys and doingexactly the same on the CC# rows produces the flat keys.
The hohner trichord with 12 stradella ( preferably in 3 voice form) is a nice lightweight box with a bit more bass scope than on an 8 bass box . Pity nobody makes a modern version with 32 or 48 bass .
Th e trichord is quite different to handle than the larger ( up to 120 bass) BCC# boxes