Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Kris Miskim on April 02, 2020, 12:30:05 AM

Title: C/G Chord button not playing full chord. Please help.
Post by: Kris Miskim on April 02, 2020, 12:30:05 AM
Greetings all.
You encouraged me to purchase a G/C melodeon two years ago, and I've been having a blast! THANK YOU! (Had never held one before!)
Now I'm hoping you can help me again. I have 8 bass side buttons, and my shared C/G bass button works fine, but the "chord" button is suddenly only playing one note, not a blended chord (I'm sure my beginner terminology is limited, but trying to describe as well as I can ;)

I have gingerly opened it up, hoping to find a missing pad or a wire "lifter" that had slipped, but I don't see anything that looks wrong. I ONLY opened the bass side, thinking this is where the trouble lies. Should I open the other side? Or, any tips you can offer? (Or confirm it would definitely be a problem on the bass side?)

I'm in US/Washington, and not a lot of experts around here, so I'm trying to muddle thru. (I ventured into my Great Grandpa's very old Eichorn, (doesn't play a note) a couple of years ago - which gave me at least a hint of confidence in opening this one.

Any encouragement or advice you can offer would be appreciated!!! THANK YOU in advance.
(Pic of my instrument)
Title: Re: C/G Chord button not playing full chord. Please help.
Post by: playandteach on April 02, 2020, 12:39:03 AM
If you're happy opening the bellows (rather than the panel where the bass strap is) it might be worth a look at the reeds for anything foul there, sometimes anything like a bit of wax or dust or worse of course, can simply be stopping a reed from sounding. Does it happen on push AND pull (G and C)? And have you tried just to put a little more air through it?
Beyond those two things, a better person than me will be along shortly.
Title: Re: C/G Chord button not playing full chord. Please help.
Post by: Steve_freereeder on April 02, 2020, 01:09:53 AM
1. When notes stop sounding like this, it is usually because there is a piece of dust, fluff, hair or similar foreign body caught between the reed tongue and the slot in which it vibrates. There are other possibilites too, such as a loose valve which might be causing as similar jambing problem, or in an extreme case, a broken reed.

2. You need to access the bass end reed blocks by pulling out the bellows pins on the bass end side. Use a pair of pliers with a straight perpendicular pull. Don't lever or twist the pin. You can protect the area around the pin with a piece of thin fabric or leather, to stop the pliers damaging the celluloid finish, but if you are careful, you may not need to do this. Remove all the pins and place them somewhere securely so you can replace them back in the same holes afterwards. (Sometimes the pins are of slightly differing diameters, not readily discernable to the naked eye.)

3. You can then remove the bass end by gently easing it away from the bellows frame. Inside, you should see the reed blocks standing upright, a bit like in my photo, though it probably won't look exactly the same. There should be two reed blocks, one for the bass reeds, usually identifiable by the large reeds on one side. The other will be for the chords.

4. The push reeds are the ones visible on the outside of the reed block, the pull reeds are hidden inside, underneath the valves.
Have a look to see if there is anything obviously amiss, such as a loose valve trapped. If your silent reeds are for push notes, you can usually clear any debris by gently 'pinging' the reed tongues with a small thin blade or similar. Pull notes are slightly more tricky - you need to gently lift the valve and push a cocktail stick or similar down through the slot and use it to flex the underneath reed tongue up and down a few times. You may need to repeat the process a few times.

5. The problem you will have is not knowing which reeds to ping. This is solved by actually removing the reed block, usually held in place by screws and small metal clamps, or a larger bent rod which can be twisted to one side. When removing and replacing the reed block, take care not to bend or crease any of the valves.

6. Once the reed block is removed, you should be able to see the air vents underneath. By operating the chord buttons you should be able to see which pallets are opening to admit air into the reed block. This should indicate which of the reeds correspond to the problem chords and thus narrow down which reeds you need to ping or check.

7. Once you've examined and pinged/flexed as necessary, reassemble the instrument in reverse order. You can test whether the reeds are working before re-fixing the bellows pins, simply by holding the bass end in position on the bellows frame and trying the chord buttons. If all the notes are sounding, then you have cleared the problem and you can go ahead and replace the bellows pins. Make sure they are vertical and gently push back into place, taking care not to let the pin 'collapse' as you push.

Good luck - let us know how you get on.

Edit:
In my photo, the chord reed block is uppermost in the picture. The screw clamps on the left can be loosened and twisted to one side to remove the reed blocks; the wider clamps on the right don't normally need to be loosened - the thin end of the reed block base slides underneath these.
Title: Re: C/G Chord button not playing full chord. Please help.
Post by: Kris Miskim on April 02, 2020, 01:22:01 AM
Thank you both! I did ‘dive in’ that far, but got a little nervous and put it all back! I will try again, and your info is VERY helpful! Even getting a sense of which reeds to focus on! i will be back! Thank you for your quick replies!
Title: Re: C/G Chord button not playing full chord. Please help.
Post by: Kris Miskim on April 02, 2020, 01:30:00 AM
PS: it does do the same thing on BOTH the push and pull ... so no G chord and no C chord. I get one note but not the built chord. (So on the push, I get a C note, but no E or G; and on the pull, I get the G note, but no B or D) Make any sense? Thanks again.
Title: Re: C/G Chord button not playing full chord. Please help.
Post by: Steve_freereeder on April 02, 2020, 02:06:04 AM
PS: it does do the same thing on BOTH the push and pull ... so no G chord and no C chord. I get one note but not the built chord. (So on the push, I get a C note, but no E or G; and on the pull, I get the G note, but no B or D) Make any sense? Thanks again.
This is suggesting either...
(a) that there is a serious blockage to those reeds, perhaps the pallets (the 'pads' in your description) are not opening properly or stuck down somehow - so maybe re-examine the mechanics as you did previously, or...
(b) the wax has failed around those particular reed plates and the reed plates are now loose and so far out of position that they are not sounding. Can you hear a hiss of air on the silent reeds? That would suggest that air is bypassing the reed tongues.If so, open up the bass end and check.
Title: Re: C/G Chord button not playing full chord. Please help.
Post by: Nigel.H on April 02, 2020, 11:33:43 AM
If you have access to a 'socket set' ( socket wrench ? ) in the appropriate size, ie. 9/10/11mm depending on the aperture on the reed block, you can use it to make the individual pairs of reeds 'speak' - if they are going to - by sucking/blowing fairly GENTLY.  You should be able to get an indication of what they should sound like by trying the reeds that are speaking.

Don't do it too much as it will moisten the reeds slightly from your breath.  It is not a substitute for a Tuning Table/Appliance, but it is at least an indicator if you haven't got the 'kit'. 
Title: Re: C/G Chord button not playing full chord. Please help.
Post by: Steve_freereeder on April 02, 2020, 11:50:09 AM
If you have access to a 'socket set' ( socket wrench ? ) in the appropriate size, ie. 9/10/11mm depending on the aperture on the reed block, you can use it to make the individual pairs of reeds 'speak' - if they are going to - by sucking/blowing fairly GENTLY.  You should be able to get an indication of what they should sound like by trying the reeds that are speaking.

Don't do it too much as it will moisten the reeds slightly from your breath.  It is not a substitute for a Tuning Table/Appliance, but it is at least an indicator if you haven't got the 'kit'.
No, this is not a good idea. Tempting though it is, you should never try to sound reeds by blowing with your mouth. Never mind about 'not doing it too much', moisture will instantly condense on to the reed tongues on the first blow and that is not good; the potential for rust is increased. Sucking is also bad, as you risk dust, bits of wax, any other loose debris, being transported into your mouth and airways. Wax debris in particular is nasty stuff to get lodged in your lungs.

Don't do this.
Title: Re: C/G Chord button not playing full chord. Please help.
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on April 02, 2020, 02:32:26 PM
You’re right Steve, I once did this and ended up with a mouthful of Earwig!! Yuk  :o
Title: Re: C/G Chord button not playing full chord. Please help.
Post by: Anahata on April 02, 2020, 03:06:34 PM
a mouthful of Earwig

Right - that mental image should be enough to put anyone off trying it now  :o
Title: Re: C/G Chord button not playing full chord. Please help.
Post by: Lester on April 02, 2020, 03:45:37 PM

a mouthful of Earwig!! Yuk  :o

Earwig Oh! Earwig Oh! Earwig Oh!
Title: Re: C/G Chord button not playing full chord. Please help.
Post by: Nigel.H on April 02, 2020, 10:14:26 PM
I appreciate the implication of the moisture in breath on the reed - I do - I also appreciate the potential for moisture forming on the reeds of Melodeons played in Orchards in January, on hill-tops at dawn in May, on the sea-front through the season, under steamy canvas at Festivals, in hot Pubs on cold days and cool Pubs on hot days, in drizzle and actual 'rain'. 

A quick 'puff' of breath down, or drawn up, a tube which isolates it to the aperture of one chord reed to see if a reed is 'glitched', is not - I wouldn't have thought - going to render it on the way to dereliction any more than many of the above.

In the absence of any other means ie. a tuning 'rig', to isolate one of the three chord reed pairs I have found it useful to use a long reach socket. Those who are risk averse may well prefer not to, but Kris might have no other reliable option if he wants to sort it himself.   

As regards ingesting via stomach or lungs any stray wildlife or crumbs of wax. It only takes a very gentle suck to make the reed speak - if it is going to.  If, wax or stray wildlife is being ingested on the 'pull', I would hazard to suggest one probably is sucking too hard! .......or didn't check if it was something obvious before locking lips  :o :-* 
Title: Re: C/G Chord button not playing full chord. Please help.
Post by: tirpous on April 02, 2020, 10:45:11 PM
A reed maker at Binci can be seen blowing reeds in this video at about 11:10 and again 1 minute or so later:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vRu3bSofKRg&feature=youtu.be&fbclid=IwAR2e7XOfxEAtkC6DZvsyHdmxboE2_IuNM_m3XbcNVCg5-wOCpx2aFyct0R4 (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vRu3bSofKRg&feature=youtu.be&fbclid=IwAR2e7XOfxEAtkC6DZvsyHdmxboE2_IuNM_m3XbcNVCg5-wOCpx2aFyct0R4)
Title: Re: C/G Chord button not playing full chord. Please help.
Post by: Anahata on April 02, 2020, 11:05:36 PM
If, wax or stray wildlife is being ingested on the 'pull'
... you've probably found the cause of the problem  ;D
Title: Re: C/G Chord button not playing full chord. Please help.
Post by: Steve_freereeder on April 03, 2020, 12:46:31 AM
A reed maker at Binci can be seen blowing reeds in this video at about 11:10 and again 1 minute or so later:

I think he's sucking the reed, not blowing. Anyway, he's a maker and can do what he likes.
So did the 'Radium Girls', who used to paint a radioactive radium compound on to the hands of luminous watches and clocks during the early 20th century. They used to periodically moisten their fine paint brushes between their lips to achieve a sharp point. Many subsequently died of radiation poisoning from the radium they had ingested.  :o
Title: Re: C/G Chord button not playing full chord. Please help.
Post by: Squeaky Pete on April 03, 2020, 07:47:05 AM
Anyway, he's a maker and can do what he likes.
Also these reeds are new and haven't had donkeys' years of crud, dust and waxy bits lodging in the corners ready to find their way into lungs.
I wouldn't do it.
Title: Re: C/G Chord button not playing full chord. Please help.
Post by: Kris Miskim on April 03, 2020, 04:39:20 PM
Thanks for all of your input. I love this forum. I hope to dive back in this weekend and take a closer look. And, just to confirm... the problem should be somewhere on the bass side reed set, right? So i don't need to open the other end (all of the tune notes/buttons — what do you call that side, treble? — those all play fine.) Thanks again. I will let you know how it goes. Y’all stay safe, now. Nothing like playing my melodeon to help keep my spirits up. Happy music! 😉
Title: Re: C/G Chord button not playing full chord. Please help.
Post by: Steve_freereeder on April 03, 2020, 04:42:48 PM
Thanks for all of your input. I love this forum. I hope to dive back in this weekend and take a closer look. And, just to confirm... the problem should be somewhere on the bass side reed set, right?
Yes, definitely on that LH side. No need to open up the RH treble side for this particular problem.
Good luck with your investigations and let us know how it goes.
Title: Re: C/G Chord button not playing full chord. Please help.
Post by: Kris Miskim on April 04, 2020, 12:12:52 AM
Okay! I found the problem! My terminology is probably wrong, but I see the “pad” has come loose from the “foot” so the pad is not pulling back from opening when i push the button. (The pad is kind of sticking to the ‘box’, so it continues to block the opening even when the ‘foot’ is pulled away.)

It’s a little hard to get to, but wondering with some long tweezers if I could unstick it from the box, add a little glue, and press it onto the foot thru the opening (where I’ve removed the reed block.) Would any old glue be okay? I have some Titebond Hide Glue and some Weldbond. Might either of those do the trick?

Any other tips or pointers are appreciated! I’m getting close ... you are making me a happy gal! Thx!! Kris
Title: Re: C/G Chord button not playing full chord. Please help.
Post by: Steve_freereeder on April 04, 2020, 01:26:32 AM
Okay! I found the problem! My terminology is probably wrong, but I see the “pad” has come loose from the “foot” so the pad is not pulling back from opening when i push the button. (The pad is kind of sticking to the ‘box’, so it continues to block the opening even when the ‘foot’ is pulled away.)

It’s a little hard to get to, but wondering with some long tweezers if I could unstick it from the box, add a little glue, and press it onto the foot thru the opening (where I’ve removed the reed block.) Would any old glue be okay? I have some Titebond Hide Glue and some Weldbond. Might either of those do the trick?

Any other tips or pointers are appreciated! I’m getting close ... you are making me a happy gal! Thx!! Kris
1. Excellent - you've found the cause of the problem!

2. By 'pad' do you mean the thin leather facing material, which should be fixed to the pallet (what you are calling the 'foot)?
If you can free the 'pad' facing material with tweezers, and if it is in reasonably good condition, your probable best fix for now is to reglue it to the pallet. I would normally replace the facing with new leather, but in these coronavirus times, you may not be able to get the the right stuff, so try to salvage the facing if you can.

3. Normally I would recommend removing the pallet from the metal lever arm to do this but you may feel a bit apprehensive about the seemingly brutal act of rocking the pallet to-and-fro until it comes off.

4. I would suggest trying to discover why the pallet facing has become stuck to the fondo* in the first place. Open up the mechanism side, not the reed block side, and see if there is any sticky gunge which has caused the facing to become detached. If there is, try to use a cotton bud moistened with a little methylated spirit or isopropyl alcohol, or similar, to de-gunge the area.

5. If you can recover the old facing piece intact, use a little smear of hide glue, or white PVA glue (Elmers in the US?) to refix it to the pallet. Use a minimum amount of glue, try to spread it evenly over the whole surface, and avoid any wrinkes otherwise you will get air leaks. (This is why it's easiest to remove the pallet first.)

6. In my photo of the treble end of a Hohner Erica, the pallets are the trapezium-shaped wooden blocks, the pallet facing is the thin brown leather layer just visible on the wide rear surface of the pallet, the fondo is the vertical wood board with the air vents through to the reed blocks (not visible). The pallets are secured to the lever arms by white glue and a thin white linen disk.

7. Your bass-end mechanism will be similar except the pallets will be wider and different shapes and there will be more mechanism rods and arms in the way! Sorry - I don't have a photo to hand.

*This is the term for the wooden board/plate that the pallets open and close on to. Sometimes known as the pallet board, or sound board (the latter not a good term)

Good luck!
Title: Re: C/G Chord button not playing full chord. Please help.
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on April 04, 2020, 12:36:53 PM
Hello Kris,

Have you looked at Lester's how do it videos, at all?
https://sites.google.com/view/hohnerhotrod

I know your melodeon is not a Hohner, but you may find there are enough similarities between your instrument  and a two row Hohner to give you a better idea of what is going on inside and how to deal with issues. If nothing else, it will give you an idea of what things are called, and you may find it a confidence booster, seeing someone deal with things in a capable way.
Title: Re: C/G Chord button not playing full chord. Please help.
Post by: Steve_freereeder on April 04, 2020, 01:56:17 PM
Have you looked at Lester's how do it videos, at all?
https://sites.google.com/view/hohnerhotrod
Good point, Greg.

Kris,
Lester's videos are very clear. The bass end pallets are dealt with here:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=795&v=YSlSOple8-M&feature=emb_logo

Not sure you will want to go down the complete refacing route at the moment, but as Greg says, it gives you an idea of what it's all about and naming of parts, etc.
Title: Re: C/G Chord button not playing full chord. Please help.
Post by: Kris Miskim on April 04, 2020, 09:02:51 PM
Fixed!! Thank you soooo much! The leather was in great shape and came out easily - was really not ‘stuck’ to anything... perhaps just a little friction was holding it to the fondo. Was able to apply a thin spread of hide glue and reattach to the pallet with ease. I am back in great shape.

Thank you for your counsel, your encouragement, your teaching of terminology. And, I now know, too, that it is G/C, not C/G 😊 You all are the best!

Wishes to you for health and safety, from the ‘other side o’ the pond’.
Title: Re: C/G Chord button not playing full chord. Please help.
Post by: Steve_freereeder on April 05, 2020, 12:32:43 AM
Fixed!! Thank you soooo much!...
Hooray! Well done you!
I'm pleased it's worked out for you. Also you will have learned so much about the innards of a melodeon and how not to be afraid of doing stuff.
Now go and enjoy playing it.  (:)  :|||:
 
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal