Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Danny on April 08, 2020, 06:51:50 PM
-
Just had my Sandpiper 2.5 DG converted DC" system by Mike Rowbottom who has
done a wonderful job. Any advice, tunes and tips to get used to this system
would be appreciated.
Cheers
Danny
-
Is that C#? If not what is C†? If it is C#, what have you got in the half row?
-
Possibly converted to run on battery instead of mains?
-
I would turn the question around and ask what were you wanting to be able to play on your new system?
-
I would turn the question around and ask what were you wanting to be able to play on your new system?
I have a friend who plays D/C simply so he can play The Bluebell Polka!
-
So what does the “ denote? I’m still not clear about that.
-
Hi Roger and all,
...it's a D/C# set-up!
Danny plays Irish stuff and wanted to explore a semitone system, and elected to go down the D/C# route.
The box plays really nicely, although I have to say, the system didn't fall under my fingers intuitively. But the logic is all there ...!
Cheers all!
Mike
-
I would turn the question around and ask what were you wanting to be able to play on your new system?
/
I have a friend who plays D/C simply so he can play The Bluebell Polka!
the 3 parts of the bluebell polka in G,D and C can be done on a standard DG box with first button accidentals. It is also dead easy on a BC- so what is the advantage, if any, of a DC box?
george
-
Hi Roger and all,
...it's a D/C# set-up!
Danny plays Irish stuff and wanted to explore a semitone system, and elected to go down the D/C# route.
The box plays really nicely, although I have to say, the system didn't fall under my fingers intuitively. But the logic is all there ...!
Cheers all!
Mike
Thanks Mike. What did you put in the helper row? I’m thinking some useful reversals.. (:)
-
I would turn the question around and ask what were you wanting to be able to play on your new system?
/
I have a friend who plays D/C simply so he can play The Bluebell Polka!
the 3 parts of the bluebell polka in G,D and C can be done on a standard DG box with first button accidentals. It is also dead easy on a BC- so what is the advantage, if any, of a DC box?
george
To me the advantage was that it just felt right. Id done BC CC# C#D and not found what i wanted. I've been a Joe Derrane fan since first seeing him play at St Chartier in the 90's, so I bit the bullet and swapped all the reeds over in a rouble ray and it imediately felt more natural. Then I splurged and bought a second hand Walters, LLMM, 19 key, 4 bass, with the wider button spacing, and it really took off. I some times wonder if the wider spacing is actually what makes it work for me as i have large hands.
-
Just had my Sandpiper 2.5 DG converted DC" system by Mike Rowbottom who has
done a wonderful job. Any advice, tunes and tips to get used to this system
would be appreciated.
Cheers
Danny
I recently began playing the D/C# as well, after not getting on with the more standard semitone configuration of C#/D. I find D/C# to be quite intuitive if you come from a background of playing a D one-row, which is how I approach the system. It's essentially a one-row in D with an entire other row of accidental which makes playing in any key possible (although certainly not easy in *every* key!). Tunes played in the keys of A and G, for example, are almost entirely played on the D row with the missing notes easily accessible when you need them on the C# row. You could almost think of it like a piano, with the black notes being your 'accidentals'. It is very much a push-and-draw system.
The system was originally designed for the Irish-American market. Is it Irish music that you are looking to play?
-
I recently began playing the D/C# as well, after not getting on with the more standard semitone configuration of C#/D. I find D/C# to be quite intuitive if you come from a background of playing a D one-row, which is how I approach the system. It's essentially a one-row in D with an entire other row of accidental which makes playing in any key possible (although certainly not easy in *every* key!). Tunes played in the keys of A and G, for example, are almost entirely played on the D row with the missing notes easily accessible when you need them on the C# row. You could almost think of it like a piano, with the black notes being your 'accidentals'. It is very much a push-and-draw system.
The system was originally designed for the Irish-American market. Is it Irish music that you are looking to play?
All of which is equally true of the C#/D system, to be fair.
-
All of which is equally true of the C#/D system, to be fair.
Of course, but the OP isn’t asking about a comparison between the two systems; he’s asking about playing tips for the D/C#, which is what he has.
-
My reply was to you, mselic, not the OP.
-
Hi
Just to be clear DCsharp
I want to play Irish mainly, AKA Joe Derrane
-
Hi Danny. There's basically zero instruction material out there for the C#/D system, and even less than that for D/C#. (:) Perhaps you knew that already.
But in this thread (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=13384.0) I tried (in response to a question) to distil my advice on learning C#/D. You might find the tips will apply to D/C# also.
If you have specific questions feel free to ask them on here any time. There are a few C#/D exponents here and as you can see, a couple of D/C#-ers too.
-
But it seems that some still prefer D/C...current ebay listing (I have no connection or interest)
scroll down to item description.
This would still have to be 4th button start outside row, 3rd, inside.
Many of those G tunes roll out nicely from the B/C system, even without the usual reversals of E and B.
https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Hohner-Erica-D-C-Irish-Dry-Tuned-21-button-accordion-Used/233558003534?hash=item3661244f4e:g:JMsAAOSwoJ5elE7z
-
But it seems that some still prefer D/C...current ebay listing (I have no connection or interest)
scroll down to item description.
This would still have to be 4th button start outside row, 3rd, inside.
Many of those G tunes roll out nicely from the B/C system, even without the usual reversals of E and B.
https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Hohner-Erica-D-C-Irish-Dry-Tuned-21-button-accordion-Used/233558003534?hash=item3661244f4e:g:JMsAAOSwoJ5elE7z
I’ve never heard of a D/C system - I believe the one listed in the link above states that it is a one-off modification for a one-row Melodeon player who wanted a C row as well as a D row. I don’t believe that system would work very well for Irish music and it certainly isn’t chromatic.
In case there is any confusion, the system we are discussing here is D/C#, not D/C.
-
Danny, I would recommend you check out Stiamh’s instructional YouTube videos. Although they are designed for C#/D players, much of what he teaches applies to D/C# as well. I would suggest beginning with learning tunes in the key of D, which is the same fingering on both systems. You can then move on to tunes in G and A (and relative minors) and when he reaches outside for those missing notes, you simply reach inside for those same notes instead. As he mentioned, there is no teaching material specific to D/C#, so this is the next best thing IMHO!
-
"I don’t believe that system would work very well for Irish music"
I don't know anything about Irish music, but I've seen lots and lots of videos where Irish music is being played on a 1 row and this instrument is simply two one rows in one box! The seller says that it was especially tuned with that purpose in mind.
-
Strikes me as a very good system indeed. But no I don't want one.
-
"I don’t believe that system would work very well for Irish music"
I don't know anything about Irish music, but I've seen lots and lots of videos where Irish music is being played on a 1 row and this instrument is simply two one rows in one box! The seller says that it was especially tuned with that purpose in mind.
Except that the key of C is rarely used in Irish music.
Strikes me as a very good system indeed. But no I don't want one.
How so?
-
The ebay listing suggests that the previous owner of the D/C box, (not D/Csharp,) was primarily a single row player, but could also play this same box in a similar manner, (albeit in a limited way) by using B/C fingering patterns. (The C sharp and F sharp buttons on the outside D row falling in the right place.)
This would facilitate some of those G tunes which can be more of a challenge or don't sit well on
the D row ...and also provide a C row for when the singing starts.
I can identify with these reasons, as I find it easier to play most G tunes on a B/C box than say, on the G row of a D/G box. :o
Like Peadar, I wouldn't want one though!
I posted this for interest just to show how quirky we can be with our systems.
Good luck to Danny, the O.P., with your D/C sharp box, a great system.
-
<grumble alert>It's been clear for quite a while now that Danny meant to write D/C# in his original post. So posts about a D/C system and its possible pros and cons, or its desirability to particular members, are not helpful to Danny, or to anyone really, and are just littering up this thread uselessly. If D/C merits discussion, why not start a new topic about it?</grumble>
-
Oh dear...Don't be grumbly...My last post was in response to mselic's question and to wish Danny good luck.
The official moderators will likely close this down now anyway? (:)