Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: fallonje on September 26, 2009, 05:10:18 PM
-
I was looking at the A/D layout of the Keyboard layout section of this forum and I think there's mistake. On my A/D Hohner Erica the accidental button on the D row is C on the push and Bb on the draw. The layout page has a C on the push and F on the draw. That seems like a strange setup to me. Anyone else?
Joe
-
My 1981 copy of Roger Watson's "Handbook for Melodeon" gives the same accidentals as your Erica, C/A#, so presumably that is the standard Hohner fingering.
Strangely, Roger's keyboard diagram gives no D# accidental, but A#/F on the A row.
So A#s in both directions.......
Does your Erica have a D#? (Mine has low notes, so I can't compare.)
Logic tells me that C/Bb on the D row and D#/F on the A row would probably be more useful, and marginally simpler to manufacture.
Edited to add that the keyboard chart http://info.melodeon.net/files/site/AD21acc.gif (http://info.melodeon.net/files/site/AD21acc.gif) also gives F accidental on the pull of both rows. Perhaps both this and Roger's book contain typos as neither really make sense to me....
-
My Erica has C/Bb on the D row and Eb/ F on the A row, which makes sense to me also. My only change, since I also play C#/D, would be to switch the C/Bb to Bb/C as the C is on the draw on the C#/D box.