Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Chris Ryall on September 27, 2009, 02:47:13 PM

Title: This week's essay ...
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 27, 2009, 02:47:13 PM
We were all taught to do a s(t)olid dum cha cha in 3/4 or even 6/8 rhythm as new players

.. dum cha cha is a bugger to unlearn and isn't all that useful as you move into further tunes. >:E

.... discuss  :|glug
Title: Re: This week's essay ...
Post by: JohnA on September 27, 2009, 03:11:18 PM
I'll be watching this one with interest. Having taken up the instrument less than five months ago, I started grappling with the left hand in the last month. I toyed with the 'dum cha cha' approach for a day or two and found it awkward and frustrating. I now have a much more flexible and intuitive approach to the left hand, on both dance tunes and other styles. So, the right approach ...... or the road to ruin......?

Cheers     John
Title: Re: This week's essay ...
Post by: Selam on September 27, 2009, 03:19:07 PM
Sorry - the dog ate my essay... ;)

I too am interested in this because I'm a beginner and am just starting out with the left hand. I don't seem to be "dum cha cha"ing because at the moment I'm just doing smooth chords but for waltzes etc I am interested in what people do instead.
Title: Re: This week's essay ...
Post by: JohnA on September 27, 2009, 03:28:39 PM
To expand on my last post - even with dance tunes I find it more satisfying to improvise the left hand to get the rhythm and appropriate emphasis for dance (I was a morris dancer in the dim and distant past, but I think I still have the feel for it).

John
Title: Re: This week's essay ...
Post by: ACE on September 27, 2009, 03:30:12 PM
Try the cha cha cha it leads to loads of variations. I was terrible for the dum cha cha as armed with a one row and a Yetties album I taught myself to play. Mind you they did alright on dum cha cha.

The sloop John B is a good cha cha cha tune with loads of variations and embellishments to play around with ending on a nice da de da dum cha cha cha. ;D
Title: Re: This week's essay ...
Post by: ladydetemps on September 27, 2009, 03:44:09 PM
Isnt the cha cha cha a latin dance?
Title: Re: This week's essay ...
Post by: Falseknight on September 27, 2009, 04:44:23 PM
I wasn't taught dum cha cha - ever - so when you presented it I heard the dum as two pulses and the cha as one.  Makes nice reggae especially when it becomes 'um cha cha.
Title: Re: This week's essay ...
Post by: juker on September 27, 2009, 08:10:32 PM
Dum cha cha comes to me very naturally (I played a PA when I was a kid) so I am going to try Chris's suggestion with 'La Marianne'. I think that the dum cha cha or dum cha dum cha suits a lot of melodeon music really well but can also sound a tad boring AND I can see that it could be hard to unlearn... so while I am still a beginner I might make the effort to try some variations. Wish I had someone more experienced to play with  :(
Title: Re: This week's essay ...
Post by: Owen Woods on September 27, 2009, 09:44:10 PM
I didn't find it difficult to unlearn, but it is certainly not effective or rather, not particularly interesting on most tunes. It depends on the context though, if you're playing on your own for dancing then having a regular bass rhythm is essential. If you're playing in a group then you may as well keep yourself from drifting off my confusing yourself with bass lines and syncopation.
Title: Re: This week's essay ...
Post by: ganderbox on September 27, 2009, 10:07:38 PM
I toyed with the 'dum cha cha' approach for a day or two and found it awkward and frustrating. I now have a much more flexible and intuitive approach to the left hand, on both dance tunes and other styles. So, the right approach ...... or the road to ruin......?

Cheers     John

I would say that was my experience too. I never really got into the habit of playing  dum cha cha (or ONE two three) relentlessly all the way through a tune, because whenever it felt awkward or clumsy (as it often did) I would always do something different, like playing a long bass note. I therefore never had any problems trying to unlearn it, as I never really did it that much anyway.
It's still a useful accompaniment to a waltz, though, as long as it's done sparingly, and in any case you should be able to get your fingers to do it.
Title: Re: This week's essay ...
Post by: Matt Langley on September 27, 2009, 10:07:49 PM
I'm gonna defend dum cha cha here - well, a bit anyway ;)

I learn't this as the 'default' backing for a waltz (cant see how it would work for a 6/8 jig mind you? dum cha dum cha surely...)

Anyway, I agree it is a bit boring, but as a learner it was fairly easy to grasp, especially when I was trying to get the left hand to play bass without having to think too much.

The good bit came some time later when I stumbled on the fact that it sounds way better if you leave notes out e.g. dum gap cha-dum gap cha-dum, or gap cha cha, or dum-um-um dum-um-um (long notes) etc. you get the idea...  

mix all of the above up (preferably in a way that complements the melody!) and I think you come up with some nice waltz accompaniments - and underneath your brain (well, my brain anyway) is still basically just doing the dum cha cha thing.  

So, I'm glad I started of with dum cha cha anyway.

Matt  
Title: Re: This week's essay ...
Post by: ladydetemps on September 27, 2009, 10:19:45 PM
I would say that was my experience too. I never really got into the habit of playing  dum cha cha (or ONE two three) relentlessly all the way through a tune, because whenever it felt awkward or clumsy (as it often did) I would always do something different, like playing a long bass note.
I have real trouble doing the dum cha cha  thing....my fingers seem to leave dums or chas out...or go dum cha dum...

My head goes Um Pah Pah, but my finger's go 'I don't think so' and do what they like.
Title: Re: This week's essay ...
Post by: HallelujahAl on September 28, 2009, 07:43:56 AM
I'm afraid I can only mange to play dum dum dum...or dum and dummer..sometimes I throw in a dum de dum...but never managed a dum cha cha
 ;D
Title: Re: This week's essay ...
Post by: LJC on September 28, 2009, 08:00:19 AM
Once I worked out how to do Bass Chord Chord for a 3/4 piece I didn't find it hard to do variations on it, and I certainly wouldn't say its held me back any. I think it can be quite useful as a stepping stone before you move onto other patterns.

I would agree that it doesn't have the best sound to it, but its only one step away from playing the bass note on the beat of one, then the chords on 2 'and' giving you a 4/4 Dum ChaCha Dum ChaCha (playing on 1 2 + 3 4 +) which can be really effective interspersed with other patterns.

the 1! 23 can also work if your playing lots of fast notes over the top - listen to Andy Cuttings bass on La Boite A Frissons/Lusignac (first track on the Lusignac album).

Ok, so he breaks it up with other things as well, but you can't have you cake and eat all of it without feeling sick!
Title: Re: This week's essay ...
Post by: Matthew B on September 28, 2009, 02:18:51 PM
We were all taught to do a s(t)olid dum cha cha in 3/4 or even 6/8 rhythm as new players
I like the Um-Pah bass sound.  It's certainly fun to dress things up with other arrangements.  But still, if you're banging out dance tunes for dancers (particularly if you're using a one-row), it works really well.  As for being taught to do that . . . I'm guessing a fair number of people here are self-taught, so it may be more of an evolutionary phenomenon than anything. 

The first great adventure I had in LH technique was discovering most of a scale lurking over there hidden in the deep notes. 

The second great adventure was discovering that Um-Pah (and also, of course, its close cousin Um-Pah-Pah) could be turned into something else entirely by learning completely different tunes.  Boeve's psalm, by Lars Hollmer (who died last year I learned to my distress: RIP Mr Hollmer, and thanks for all the tunes), was a great revelation for me. 

I'm still waiting for the third great adventure. 
Title: Re: This week's essay ...
Post by: graememackay on September 28, 2009, 02:55:57 PM
I like "dum cha cha" although I've never used it in that term.

I see my left hand as a rythm keeper as well as accompaniemenemememement (if in doubt spell it very wrong)

The stradella bass can be decorated well with various bass notes etc, so don't spend too much time on one button as it's pal is waiting for me.
Title: Re: This week's essay ...
Post by: Howard Jones on September 28, 2009, 05:34:01 PM
For waltzes, I seem to usually hold down long chords with the bass button ("oom" or "dum") and use the "pah" (or "cha" if you prefer) very lightly on top of these to give a bit of colour.  The melodic rhythm of a waltz is usually sufficiently strong that you don't need the bass buttons to emphasise it.

One of the breakthroughs for me was realising that the "um" and the "pah" don't have to be equal lengths or given equal emphasis - indeed, an unvarying "oom-pah oom-pah" is very tedious.  The revelation came at a John K workshop where he demonstrated that for playing English jigs a leading "pah oom pah oom" is often more effective.  The "pah" given more emphasis, just dropping briefly onto the "oom" which is kept short and light.

I've attempted to notate these (probably not very accurately but I hope you get the idea):


Title: Re: This week's essay ...
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 28, 2009, 06:33:13 PM
What a superb discussion already - don't you lot do any work!

I have real trouble doing the dum cha cha  thing....my fingers seem to leave dums or chas out...or go dum cha dum...  My head goes Um Pah Pah, but my finger's go 'I don't think so' and do what they like.

Sounds like a good and 'subtle' approach. Steph Mulleret said to me about 8years ago - doesn't matter what you play as long as it isn't [demo :||: dum cha cha] - (faux thé thé in French)  I think he's right and he's done more than anyone else to lighten my left hand.

Dum Ch[cut off early] [silence] anyone?  :|glug
Title: Re: This week's essay ...
Post by: Bryson on September 28, 2009, 08:58:15 PM
For waltzes, I seem to usually hold down long chords with the bass button ("oom" or "dum") and use the "pah" (or "cha" if you prefer) very lightly on top of these to give a bit of colour.  The melodic rhythm of a waltz is usually sufficiently strong that you don't need the bass buttons to emphasise it.

One of the breakthroughs for me was realising that the "um" and the "pah" don't have to be equal lengths or given equal emphasis - indeed, an unvarying "oom-pah oom-pah" is very tedious.  The revelation came at a John K workshop where he demonstrated that for playing English jigs a leading "pah oom pah oom" is often more effective.  The "pah" given more emphasis, just dropping briefly onto the "oom" which is kept short and light.

I've attempted to notate these (probably not very accurately but I hope you get the idea):

Thanks for that Howard. I'm starting to wrestle with my left hand :) after years of oom pahing away. I know that subtle differences can make an enormous difference.
Has anyone got any more subtle but earthing shattering examples of simple changes that can be made. If possible with tune based examples.
cheers
Bryson
and yes this is a quality discussion
Title: Re: This week's essay ...
Post by: OwenG on September 29, 2009, 04:56:37 PM
Quote
Dum Ch[cut off early] [silence] anyone?

Yep. Along with the closely related Dum [silence] [pause] Ch to add a bit of bounce and tension, with the Ch falling on the final quaver or semi-quaver of the bar.

Another one I use particularly if the tune moves through a series of chords is Dum Cha Dum, with the second Dum being a leading note to the following Dum in the next bar. For example, for the following chord progression - G | D | Em | G I might do the following (Capitals = Bass notes; not capitals = chords):

G g B | D d d | E em C | G gg

Clear??

Cor - it's a lot easier writing it in notation!!
Title: Re: This week's essay ...
Post by: Howard Jones on September 29, 2009, 07:45:31 PM
Thanks for that Howard. I'm starting to wrestle with my left hand :) after years of oom pahing away. I know that subtle differences can make an enormous difference.

The differences can indeed be subtle, hard to describe and even harder to notate.  Just small variations in timing or touch can make all the difference.

It's entirely understandable that novice players focus mainly on the right hand, after all they want to play tunes.  However a well-played melody can be made turgid and dull by a plodding bass.  In my opinion, it is good use of the left hand which lifts a tune and is the key to good playing.

Here's some ideas to try:


The other thing is not to let your bass patterns be disrupted by the demands of the melody - learn to play across the rows on the right hand, so when the basses call for a push and the obvious melody note is on the pull, look for the alternative note on the push - most of the RH notes are found in both directions, but on different rows.  An obvious example of this is when you want a G chord when playing in the key of D - the chord is on the push so you need to cross to the RH G row to get the G note on the push.

Once I really start working on a tune it's often the bass patterns that dictate how I play the melody, and I'll work out RH fingerings to suit the bellows directions imposed by the LH.  However, some tunes just cry out for the opposite approach, where I'll play an available chord regardless of whether it's the "correct" one!

As with everything, the secret is taste and variety - use them with discretion and where they are appropriate, and mix them up.

Listen to as many good players as you can, and really listen to what their basses are doing.  Don't be too dazzled by fancy chord sequences (they may have more bass buttons than you) but listen for the effects they use and try to figure out how they achieve them.  If you're at a session and someone's doing something you like, ask them.

Title: Re: This week's essay ...
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 29, 2009, 08:07:32 PM
Drone on E pull is useful too - you have E F# G A B and C available before you have to push - sometimes that's a lot of tune!

Hold down C bass while playing on push/pull G row works nicest in the upper part of the octave. Nice 'bright' sound. For those here who say 'modes don't matter' you are playing 'lydian' - effectively a C scale with an F# in it. Can you hear its 'tinkle'

Silence can be brilliant. I sometimes drop the left end completely in one of my fav. bourées and just rattle along on the right end. Really cuts the mustard!

Anything except dumb cha cha ...

SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal