Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Hugh Taylor on May 26, 2020, 08:10:05 PM
-
My Mory has the Andy Cutting bass layout ( I think) so the extra basses are Eb and Bb on the push, with Fnat and F# on the pull. I use the Two F basses regularly, but I don’t think I’ve ever used the other two. Under what circumstances would/could I use them?
-
Imagine combining those chords with the G and C basses, as we do B and D major or A and C major. It is a stretch. However, by doing so, you can achieve a Gm7 and Cm7. Some G major tunes can enjoy having a C minor chord slipped in.
You can also make use of the Eb bass + B major chord to create B/D#, a slightly different sounding B major chord, which is useful for E harmonic minor.
Try out playing a tune in G minor and D minor, and you'll find that these extra basses are very useful in these keys.
If you can take out your thirds, you can also explore playing in keys that include Bb and Eb chords, such as the keys of F major (one flat) and E major (4 sharps).
-
Faced with a similar concern, I decided to swap the F#m basses from pull to push and the Eb basses from push to pull. My reasoning was that the F#m basses can add some variety by being used on occasion in place of pushed D basses and having the Eb basses on the pull gives a bit more flexibility when playing in keys like Bb and Gm.Of course, this depends on the layout of the melody end of your box, but it was a definite improvement when combined with my three-row layout.
-
My Mory has the Andy Cutting bass layout ( I think) so the extra basses are Eb and Bb on the push, with Fnat and F# on the pull. I use the Two F basses regularly, but I don’t think I’ve ever used the other two. Under what circumstances would/could I use them?
Admitedly, I don't use them often, but the pull F# bass and F#m chord are useful when playing in the key of B minor, which I feel is not explored often enough on a D/G box. It's a powerful key and sits quite nicely right in the middle of the D/G keyboard.
Here attached is a tune which I've used sometimes in workshops: the wonderful English triple-time hornpipe 'If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go' (it's worth learning just because of its title (:)). The F#m basses and chords can be used where shown.
-
Hi, I have the same basses on my Mory and as a relative newcomer to the extra buttons I’m still exploring the possibilities. The E flat and B flat basses are very useful for playing in G minor (as long as you have a B flat, E flat and F natural on your half row, this is doable). I’m currently using the Rose of Raby to learn more about playing in this key. I like the difference in sound it gives you, and as this tune uses all of your top basses regularly I’ve found it’s a good one for finding my way round!
Vicky
-
It is a good question.
As a 2 row 8 bass - er I've often wondered what you'd do with these extra basses so will read this thread with interest.
I have just started learning a tune in Bm and it calls for a F#7 accompniament against a melody note of F# and C.
On my 2r8b the only thing I can do is pull an E bass/A chord. I have no idea what it is but it's the only pull I can get to sound reasonable.
Would love an F# bass option!
Q
-
I have just started learning a tune in Bm and it calls for a F#7 accompniament against a melody note of F# and C.
On my 2r8b the only thing I can do is pull an E bass/A chord. I have no idea what it is but it's the only pull I can get to sound reasonable.
Well, assuming you're meaning C# rather than C anyway, that's going to be either A5/E or A/E depending on if you have your thirds in or out. Effectively, while it is a slash chord, it is an inversion of A; E + A ( + C#). F#m is F# + A + C# and then F#m7 is F#+A+C#+E, so, you can kinda see why it would work there. Inversions are typically less stable, which in this case is likely exactly what you're looking for.
If you have your thirds in, you can also play a pull D chord and A chord together, which gets you a very busy chord composed of D F# A + A C# E, which could be reframed as F# A C# D E, so like, F#m7add6 or something? Chord spelling isn't my jam really, though. Without a strong F# to ground it, it is kinda just some noise though, so you probably don't wanna be playing it for long.
For context, in E minor, you'll sometimes see a tune mostly use Em and D chords, then in the penultimate bar, use a Bm. Like you can have a whole tune use just those + Em, and it's all good. A simplistic description is that for the key of E minor, Em chords release stored tension, and D and particularly Bm build it.
But, when playing in the key of B minor on an 8 bass DG, the two chords that do that would be A and particularly F#m. But F#m not an option, so we only A to build tension, and if we just replace all F#ms with A, sometimes the tune just doesn't sound right any more and we're playing the A chord a lot. For alternatives, A/E is a good shout, as is my almost-nonsence chord above. However, an effective approach for these tunes can be to change how we release the tension by using eg G and D, which partially overlap B minor, to pad out the 'release' sections of the tune, leaving more in the bank and allowing for a better resolution at the end.
While some tunes are easy going and are happy to have at least some kind of harmonic interplay going on, some just... don't sound right unless you can play a particular chord - consider how often you might use C and G chords when playing in the key of E minor for parallels in their effectiveness+importance. Sometimes, they don't matter, but sometimes they're super important and seem to bring a tune to life.
So, to get back on topic: to some extent, this is why having the Eb and Bb chords can be very useful in 'sellng' tunes. You can play G minor by just taking your thirds out, as you'd have chords that will work for Gmin, Cmin and Dmin. But, these extras give you some more colours to play with, and note that:
Eb = Eb G Bb
Bb = Bb D F
You can see that these both overlap Gm = G Bb D.
Some 12 bass layouts choose to offer reversals of A major and G major though, which can be useful in simplifying your need for reversals on the melody side and help prevent you from getting tongue tied. It depends on what you are interest in playing that will be the better choice for you. Accidental direction choice, too.
-
Thanks Gena, and yes C was a typo, I should have said C#, as you guessed.
Yes I'd worked out roughly my E bass A chord should sort of work, and it sounds ok. It push pulls alternating with Bm and I use it in the first part of the A music which does give a tension before it relaxes into the tune . Will play around with D/A chords tomorrow!
Thanks.
Q
-
My Pariselle box has the F#/F and A/G at the chin end. I find the pull G useful as I haven't got reversals of e in any octave. I've never used the A as I learned on a 8 bass box to pull the a off the g row.
Now Bb, I can see the use of that and have wanted it a few times. In trying out adding multiple basses on other boxes I've replaced the A with Bb (actually G with Ab as it's on CF boxes) and it works well. I can't get the Eb too, but it's all compromise anyway. (And I do have the bass note on the extra two chin end buttons)
So yes, the more you delve into minors keys and get further from D and G th more you'll use the extra notes.
To see how the "basic" 12 bass Mory can be used read Paul Young's explanation of his layout on his website.