Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Emre Enercan on May 30, 2020, 10:10:26 AM

Title: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: Emre Enercan on May 30, 2020, 10:10:26 AM
Hello there melnet, I have been figuring out things by ear since I started playing the accordion last year, and I found it rather hard trying to do the same on a melodeon while listening to a melodeon in e.g. D/G because my melodeon is in C/F and it kinda feels awkward to just copy the fingerings too since its a whole tone lower than what I hear and it messes with my head. Any tips?
Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: BobM on May 30, 2020, 10:49:12 AM
How I'm currently learning is by reading music primarily written or printed for my specific instrument, (G/C) with the Tab, of which there's no shortage of on the net.
Maybe try to find a C/F source to get yourself started, using the songs from the C/F "culture"?

Bob.





 
Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: Lester on May 30, 2020, 11:09:53 AM
It may be worth you investing some time in getting to grips with ABC notation. Most of the tunes are out there somewhere and if you use, say, EasyABC (https://sourceforge.net/projects/easyabc/) it will transpose any tune into the key you want and then play the midi back to play along with.


Alternatively Audacity (https://www.audacityteam.org/) will take mp3s and you can transpose them to play in your preferred key.
Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on May 30, 2020, 11:24:25 AM
There is software available, including The Amazing Slow Downer ( https://www.ronimusic.com/ ) and Transcribe
( https://www.seventhstring.com/xscribe/overview.html, ) that allow you to adjust the tempo and key of a recording. They do a pretty successful job of it, too.

They're not particularly expensive. Free trials are there for people to see what they think of them.
Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: Howard Jones on May 30, 2020, 11:45:32 AM
To learn by ear, put the melodeon aside and just study the tune until you can hum it to yourself.  Once you know the tune well enough you should then be able to hum it in a different key. You can then pick up the melodeon, find the starting note for the key you want to play in and go from there.
Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: mselic on May 30, 2020, 12:41:39 PM
To learn by ear, put the melodeon aside and just study the tune until you can hum it to yourself.  Once you know the tune well enough you should then be able to hum it in a different key. You can then pick up the melodeon, find the starting note for the key you want to play in and go from there.

Yes, however some will have a harder time doing this than others, and some are unable to do it at all due to audio aphantasia.  Nothing wrong with that, it just means that some will have to rely on other means to pick up tunes, such as learning ABC notation as suggested by Lester.  For those who do pick up tunes by ear, Amazing Slow Downer is indeed a good program for changing pitch and/or slowing down tunes.
Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: Emre Enercan on May 30, 2020, 01:15:33 PM
To learn by ear, put the melodeon aside and just study the tune until you can hum it to yourself.  Once you know the tune well enough you should then be able to hum it in a different key. You can then pick up the melodeon, find the starting note for the key you want to play in and go from there.

Yes, however some will have a harder time doing this than others, and some are unable to do it at all due to audio aphantasia.  Nothing wrong with that, it just means that some will have to rely on other means to pick up tunes, such as learning ABC notation as suggested by Lester.  For those who do pick up tunes by ear, Amazing Slow Downer is indeed a good program for changing pitch and/or slowing down tunes.

well, do you know where can I find some ABC notation for some songs?
Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: Dick Rees on May 30, 2020, 01:15:41 PM
To learn by ear, put the melodeon aside and just study the tune until you can hum it to yourself.  Once you know the tune well enough you should then be able to hum it in a different key. You can then pick up the melodeon, find the starting note for the key you want to play in and go from there.

I'll second this.  Even if your instrument is in the same key as the object recording/source, internalizing the tune via listening/humming/singing makes the playing of the tune much easier, builds understanding of the musico-mechanical system and enables transposition.

ABC or do-re-mi.  Pretty much the same.
Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: Theo on May 30, 2020, 01:28:04 PM
well, do you know where can I find some ABC notation for some songs?

The ABC Notation home page (https://abcnotation.com/) is a good place to start.  Lots of detail about ABC and links to tune collections.
Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 30, 2020, 01:37:16 PM
I use Amazing Slowdowner in my iPad if learning by ear.
It slows down tunes and can change key to enable you to get it on your box. It's the only app I've bought!
I also change the key by transposing using Abcexplorer. A very useful trick, and can let you transpose into either D or G ( for me ) to see which key fits best.
Two different ways to help you out.
Cheers 
Q
Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: Clive Williams on May 30, 2020, 03:11:49 PM
Another vote for Amazing Slow Downer. You can get it on Android too. It's a fantastic bit of kit.
Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on May 30, 2020, 05:53:24 PM
As far as I can tell, Transcribe does everything slow downer does and more besides. And, the full version costs less.

https://www.seventhstring.com/xscribe/overview.html
Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: Eshed on May 30, 2020, 06:35:21 PM
Hello there melnet, I have been figuring out things by ear since I started playing the accordion last year, and I found it rather hard trying to do the same on a melodeon while listening to a melodeon in e.g. D/G because my melodeon is in C/F and it kinda feels awkward to just copy the fingerings too since its a whole tone lower than what I hear and it messes with my head. Any tips?
This might not fit everyone, but as I have interval hearing - transposing a tune in my brain to the right key is almost automatic.
Instead of copying the fingering, listen to the tune until you can hum it by heart, then check the recorded start note, transpose it to your scale and continue humming from there.
Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: Emre Enercan on May 30, 2020, 09:42:19 PM
Hello there melnet, I have been figuring out things by ear since I started playing the accordion last year, and I found it rather hard trying to do the same on a melodeon while listening to a melodeon in e.g. D/G because my melodeon is in C/F and it kinda feels awkward to just copy the fingerings too since its a whole tone lower than what I hear and it messes with my head. Any tips?
This might not fit everyone, but as I have interval hearing - transposing a tune in my brain to the right key is almost automatic.
Instead of copying the fingering, listen to the tune until you can hum it by heart, then check the recorded start note, transpose it to your scale and continue humming from there.

Yup, definitely works out way better that way. I tried a piece I knew well already such as the british grenadiers, and I managed to figure it out without any issues. Just kinda makes learning new pieces a tad more intricate but hey, that's a fine excuse to train your ears into interval hearing I guess :D Thanks for all the help.
Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: Chris Ryall on May 31, 2020, 12:37:38 AM
By ear, and “hearing the intervals” is the stronger way long term. Like Eshed I’ve had interval training and can usually hear that this button or note in a 3rd, minor 3rd, 4th, 6th etc.

Copying fingerings works, but you can get more from the instrument by getting to know it intimately and expressing music you hear in your head. It’s an investment, but well worth the effort involved. There’s a parallel to playing from dots on piano. Do you want to play tunes, or play music? In the end the exact notes matter less than your timing, and what interesting variation you can extract from the melody
Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: Howard Jones on May 31, 2020, 09:34:39 AM
There's a vast amount of music on the internet in ABC format. Here's a starting point

http://abcnotation.com/tunes

There are several free programs for writing and editing ABC and these will also allow you to transpose from the original key to one which suits your instrument.

If you use tablature, TablEdit is not free but it will create tablature for diatonic accordion (and many other instruments) and it can import ABC files.
Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: george garside on May 31, 2020, 01:03:56 PM
playing by ear is a term commonly used for what is actualy ''playing from memory''.   As others have said the basic first step is to have a go at a tune you can sing,hum or whistle!

If you want to play a tune you can't sing hum or whistle  forget the box  and get the singing humming or whistling sorted first.

the other essential ingredient is  to learn how to play the box  and the essential ingredient of so doing is to be able to play whatever scales your box has the wherewithal to do. 

When you hum or whistle a tune the brain draws on the 'memory' and automatically sends instructions to the gob as to how to produce the required tune.  There are no 'concious' instructions  such as 'open wider' 'purse lips'  'breath  harder'  etc etc.  the operation of the gob being automatically  carried out by the 'processor'


so to play 'by ear/from memory'' 2 things are required-- comprehensive  familiarity with the tune to be played   and  comprehensive familiarity with whatever sscales your box  can produce

On a 4th aprt eg DG box that would be D,G,some tunes in A and related minors. on a 3 row semitone box such as BCC#  it would be  any of 12 major keys plus related minors.
on a two row semitone box all keys/scales are possible but having the C# row means 12 keys for 5 scales 

Put simply don't over complicate  matters  just memorise the tunes  and practice the scales which are simply the 'road' along which a tune travels back and forth along

george













Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on May 31, 2020, 01:20:38 PM
playing by ear is a term commonly used for what is actualy ''playing from memory''...

Not strictly true. You can learn a tune by ear, or learn from dots, or a mixture of the two. Having committed a tune to memory, after learning it from the dots, or by  ear, or through a combination of these, you can then play it from memory.

If I'd heeded some of the advice given, I would never have played anything.
Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: george garside on May 31, 2020, 01:48:18 PM
agreed!  the important thing is to get the tune into the memory by whatever means 

george
Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on May 31, 2020, 02:08:31 PM
playing by ear is a term commonly used for what is actualy ''playing from memory''...

Not strictly true. ...

Now, if you'd written "Learning by ear is a term commonly used for what is actually learning from memory", I would have been with you all the way  ;D
Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: Winston Smith on May 31, 2020, 02:17:00 PM
As a strictly ear/memory player, I obviously agree with all these "by ear" comments. However, some people just cannot play without the music to work from. I know (what I would describe as) excellent musicians who are all at sea when you take away the music in the middle of them playing a tune they've played for years!
It completely mystifies me, I have to admit.
Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: george garside on May 31, 2020, 02:41:34 PM
and some of us are equaly' at sea of someone plonks a page of dots in front of us and expects us to play therefrom!

 george ;)
Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: Winston Smith on May 31, 2020, 06:51:51 PM
Too true, Mr Garside!
Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: Howard Jones on May 31, 2020, 10:48:07 PM
I would say "playing by ear" means being able to play what you hear (whether actual sound or internally).  That is how people in sessions are able to join in with tunes they haven't heard before. I guess some short-term memory may be involved, but it's not the same as learning a tune properly, which for me is primarily about getting the melody itself stuck in my head - remembering how I play it comes later, and I often only consciously think about those phrases which require specific fingering, the rest of the tune sort of takes care of itself.
Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: george garside on June 01, 2020, 12:10:13 AM
HOW we paly a tune 'by ear/from memory' depends on who we heard playing it  toget it into our memory. 


Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on June 01, 2020, 08:17:00 AM
I think Howards' point regarding short term memory is important as a starting point in learning the tune.
Also I think sometimes tunes go no further. At a session there are tunes that I never play, but once someone starts it, I join in. It is almost like it is stuck there in short term memory and goes no further.

At the start, yes I agree you will copy the playing of the person playing the tune, but I think it then can change. To my mind, if it's a 'keeper' and one that becomes a tune you regularly play then it will mutate to become yours.
Those little personal nuances  in the way you play phrases will become embedded. You will bring things such as bass runs from other tunes and discover other little ways of playing bits of the tune.
I think a tune that you always play will change as your style changes.
Q
Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: Steve_freereeder on June 01, 2020, 08:46:53 AM
I think Howards' point regarding short term memory is important as a starting point in learning the tune.
Also I think sometimes tunes go no further. At a session there are tunes that I never play, but once someone starts it, I join in. It is almost like it is stuck there in short term memory and goes no further.

At the start, yes I agree you will copy the playing of the person playing the tune, but I think it then can change. To my mind, if it's a 'keeper' and one that becomes a tune you regularly play then it will mutate to become yours.
Those little personal nuances  in the way you play phrases will become embedded. You will bring things such as bass runs from other tunes and discover other little ways of playing bits of the tune.
I think a tune that you always play will change as your style changes.
Q

Yes - all that. Spot on, Quinton!
Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: Howard Jones on June 01, 2020, 09:46:34 AM
At a session there are tunes that I never play, but once someone starts it, I join in.

My problems begin when I sometimes start a tune in a session before realising

Provided I can overcome (2) then, because I mostly remember melodies rather than fingerings, I can usually busk my way through, at least long enough for others to join in.  However many tunes have at least one distinctive phrase where it's really helpful to have worked out, and remembered, a specific fingering - those can be tricky when you're unprepared, or on the wrong instrument.
Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: Winston Smith on June 01, 2020, 10:00:38 AM
"My problems begin when I sometimes start a tune in a session before realising

1. it is one of those tunes I usually only play when someone else is leading it
2. I'm not actually quite sure how it goes
3. I usually play it in a different key, and
4. on a different instrument"

Oooooh Dear! I'm rather pleased, now, that I don't get to any sessions. I've enough problems in just knocking out a tune at home!
Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: baz parkes on June 01, 2020, 10:53:05 AM
At a session there are tunes that I never play, but once someone starts it, I join in.

My problems begin when I sometimes start a tune in a session before realising
    [
  • on a different instrument


One of the problems I have most often is trying to play a tune on a two row that I usually play on a one row...it should be exactly the same...but it isn't.... :|bl
Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: smiley on June 02, 2020, 01:40:01 AM

One of the problems I have most often is trying to play a tune on a two row that I usually play on a one row...it should be exactly the same...but it isn't.... :|bl



One of the problems I have most often is trying to play a tune
Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: Julian S on June 02, 2020, 07:58:08 AM
Whilst I can both learn by ear and sight read reasonably well, I have a particular ability to mishear and misread (and therefore mislearn). I suppose I've always justified this on the basis that such is the folk process and I'm just playing my own version ::)! My fingers do seem to try to simplify the tricky phrases which are often the best bits of the tune - and that's when slowing down recordings and changing keys where necessary, so I can play along is most useful. I shall be trying that today with Leveret's recording of The Rising Sun - which they play slightly differently from the dots that I have found.

Having spent quite a lot of time recently attempting to record my version of  Chris Wood's North Downs Way, I can confirm that I never play a tune quite the same way twice - there are always subtle differences. Of course, the version I started with might not have been the original anyway.
But whether or not I'm playing exactly the right notes, it's the overall result that is important (not that I'm satisfied with progress to date)
 
J
Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on June 02, 2020, 08:10:37 AM
I find a combination of sight reading and listening to be the best way.
Inevitably there will be a phrase or run of notes that I find j cannot hear clearly. Having the dots in front can help me get it right, but as Julian says, only if you have the correct version!
Q
Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: Steve_freereeder on June 02, 2020, 09:39:36 AM
Whilst I can both learn by ear and sight read reasonably well, I have a particular ability to mishear and misread (and therefore mislearn). I suppose I've always justified this on the basis that such is the folk process and I'm just playing my own version ::)! My fingers do seem to try to simplify the tricky phrases which are often the best bits of the tune...

You are not alone in this - I think most of us are prone to 'simplifying' a tune because of a combination of (a) playing what we think we hear, rather than what is actually there, and (b) playing what is easier to fit under the fingers. Yes - it is partly the folk process, but over time and through multiple passings on at sessions, for morris, etc. the tune does tend to get rather degraded from its original - it has all its interesting lumps and bumps smoothed off. I suppose one analogy is like when you make a photocopy of a photocopy of a photocopy of a photocopy... The original image is still broadly recognisable but the subtleties are lost.

Quote
Having spent quite a lot of time recently attempting to record my version of  Chris Wood's North Downs Way, I can confirm that I never play a tune quite the same way twice - there are always subtle differences. Of course, the version I started with might not have been the original anyway.

Again, you are in good company! I think most of us will do this, and generally, why not? It adds interest. However, when I was listening to archive recordings of East Anglian musicians when transcribing their playing for the EATMT tunebook 'Before the Night Was Out', a recurring problem was that so often the individual musicians rarely played the tune the same way through twice. Which version was a transcriber to adopt?? A notable exception was the playing of Oscar Woods, who was very consistent on all his repeats.

I do remember a tutors' conversation about this very topic, one lunchtime in The Angel in Witney. Andy Cutting said something like "I am pleased that people like my tunes and learn to play them, but I do wish they would listen to the original properly first and learn that, before they go making any changes".
Title: Re: Figuring out by ear, on a different keyed melodeon
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on June 02, 2020, 09:52:13 AM
Some very good points there Steve, I totally agree.
Julian and I  had a similar discussion with Andy Cutting last year during a coffee break at Halsway.
He made made the point that those 'lumps and bumps' of the tune are often the bits that define the tune. The bits that make it different.
If you gloss over them and simplify them then you've lost the point of the tune!
Essentially work on those bits and try to play them accurately.
Q
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal