Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Julian S on June 14, 2020, 09:44:30 AM
-
Pipe dreaming a bit, but just wondered whether there could be any benefits in having this, and rethinking layout on the part row to keep the relationship between buttons. I know that I rarely use the dusty end on my Dony - or the top button on my part row (Eb/D). But maybe having the low octave reeds on the Mory make a difference ? I see Saltarelle use fourth start on their 2.5s.
I've looked at Bob Ellis' layout for D/G accs, which is interesting - I suppose one approach would be to have something similar whilst only having the middle buttons of the acc row...
I can't see any possibility of investing in a new instrument for at least a year but that would give plenty of opportunity for consideration, worry, and changing my mind !
J
-
I think it’s always beneficial on DG kit, as your non use of the top octave implies. Less so on a Mori … in LM or LMM voicing the top end is much less squeaky, the whole gamut of notes … more integrated.
-
I don’t think 4th button start makes sense on a Mory for two reasons.
1. You don’t need accidentals on the main rows because you have them on the third row.
2. With a low voice available the whole range right up to the top of the G row sounds good. I play a lot in the top octave and use all the buttons right up to 10 on the G row.
-
I'm not a fan of 4th button start on any box. Like Theo, I use all the high notes.
-
Idk, when I play my 3 voice, I just wanna get lower and lower, rather than higher and higher. It's LMM, not MHH! I've been with it over a year, and I haven't once wished for the notes that are off the top end. I don't know what exactly it is that I'm missing, but I can tell you that so far it's not B6 and A6. Yeah, the push only F#6 kinda sucks for smoothly transposing up top but you know, it's kinda fine?
Paul Young plays a Mory (https://www.youtube.com/user/paulyoungfolk/). He has a page on his site for a layout he likes/uses http://www.paulyoungfolk.co.uk/layouts.html which is 4th start 21 + 5 / 12 bass, and uses both the half row and 1st on-row buttons for accs. (Presumably he uses his own layout)
F4/F4 Bb4/G#4 Eb5/D5 F5/F5 Bb5/G#5
Eb4/D4
Bb3/G#3
I haven't used the layout myself, but it seems really pretty good to me based on what I'm up to nowadays, which falls at least conceptually in line with Paul's justification on his site. The cost/benefit analysis is really in "Are B6/F#6 + A6/E6 better than 2 extra accs/reversals?", my response currently would be 'lol no' but, I mean, I've been wrong before.
-
Hi Julian,
In a recent thread Anahata made this comment.
Quote:
"A nice 2.5 row layout I've seen recently is on Paul Young's site. he uses my low note layout but adds a low and mid pull D, and has F naturals in both directions in both octaves too. As you can see from his description, it's a useful layout that enables playing in a good range of keys, and If I was going to get a 2/5 row box now I'd probably choose that ..."
Not sure if the hyperlink has copied so I hope I've attached it.
Q
Ah Gena might have posted similar.
-
Hi Julian,
In a recent thread Anahata made this comment.
Quote:
"A nice 2.5 row layout I've seen recently is on Paul Young's site. he uses my low note layout but adds a low and mid pull D, and has F naturals in both directions in both octaves too. As you can see from his description, it's a useful layout that enables playing in a good range of keys, and If I was going to get a 2/5 row box now I'd probably choose that ..."
Not sure if the hyperlink has copied so I hope I've attached it.
Q
Ah Gena might have posted similar.
Interestingly, Q, I'd jotted down something very similar being a blend of layouts on my Pasty and Dony. Food for thought - thanks all for comments so far !
J
-
I have a fourth button start on my Mory, it gives me a full octave of notes below the normal playing range, useful for chords as well as taking melody down an octave. I also use the upper octave and yes, you are missing the high F#/B on the G row. I also find that the relevant accidentals on the half row line up with the main melody buttons better with the scale shifted up one button.
Previously, I'd go up to add ornamentation to a tune, now I'm tending to go down and add more bottom end harmonies.
-
Here's a 4th button layout on a Mory which I used to have. It previously belonged to Joe O'Connor who had specified the 4th button start, but I subsequently modified the half-row to my own standard which incorporates useful accidentals in their useful octaves and the Dutch reversal on the middle button.
It was a nice box but I found that I wasn't using the lowest chin-end notes, and I was running out of the notes at the knee end when playing in the high octave with LMM voicing. So in the end I sold it on and got my present Mory which is third button start with my preferred half-row layout. Like Theo and Rees, I have little or no use for those extra low notes and need the full range up the top end. Third button start for me please.
The 4th button start layout is attached; my current preferred 3rd button start Mory layout is here:
http://www.forum.melodeon.net/files/site/DGMorySteveD.jpg
-
I cannot comment on the advantages of any specific layout as I have no experience of such boxes, but am keen to hear the discussion.
One thing that strikes me with Paul Youngs' layout is the low note choice. By using the Low G layout it makes the core keyboard immediately recognisable to those coming from a 2 row box with that common layout, so that part of the keyboard is immediately playable whether that be inserted into either a 3rd or 4th button start.
Q
-
Whatever the choice, there are always pluses and minuses (as has been concluded many times before !) I'm also interested to see Clive Williams' layout, and that of Andy Cutting - but whether I can ever come to any conclusion is another matter...
Thanks again all - every comment welcome !
J
-
Here is my Pariselle layout. It's evolved over the last few months after talking to other players about their favoured systems, and has worked out very well.
I use all the buttons at the chin end also on the helper row (for example in Origin of the World), I really wanted a push E/pull D but I've got used to the C/D combination and actually prefer it now.
I'm likely to change it soon though, as in my thread on Dutch reversal.
Edit
The Pariselle has 25 buttons in a slightly different arrangement to the Mory's 26 but has to deal with the same compromises in a LMM box.
-
Whatever the choice, there are always pluses and minuses (as has been concluded many times before !) I'm also interested to see Clive Williams' layout, and that of Andy Cutting - but whether I can ever come to any conclusion is another matter...
Thanks again all - every comment welcome !
J
You'll find my layout (and Andy's) here http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/page,keyboard_25_row.html
I'm a 4th button start person; I very rarely miss the buttons at the top end if I'm honest. Then again, I tend to play in the home keys of the instrument (D/G/Em/Am/Bm) and pick up a different box to play in anything else; you'd probably want a different solution if you play in keys like Dm and Gm often.
The big difference on my layout is the bass end though. That's the game changer.
-
Thanks Clive, - I have seen your layout. Does reinforce the point that it's necessary to think through priorities given that it isn't possible to have everything one would like in a single instrument. (Yes - I know one can go for chromatic boxes, full accidental rows etc etc).
J
-
I went for a fourth button start for my Dony - layout attached. It's basically Club low notes with Steve Dumpleton's half row including the dutch reversal. As with everything, it is a compromise but has all notes from G3 to D6 and enables a lot of flexibility, right hand chords, Gm and Dm etc. It's pretty much the same as Pete at Acorn now offers as his standard 4th button start layout bar a couple of differences (he didn't at the time I got mine - see here http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,19250.msg234060.html#msg234060).
I am toying with the idea of upgrading to a Mory and I am currently leaning towards Theo's view and going back to 3rd button start. This is primarily due to having the low voice rather than only the Dony's 2 voice. The main block at the moment though is I will have to sell 3 of my 4 boxes to be able to afford it!! :o (:)
-
I am toying with the idea of upgrading to a Mory and I am currently leaning towards Theo's view and going back to 3rd button start. This is primarily due to having the low voice rather than only the Dony's 2 voice.
I just really like the LMM sound in the top octave of the Mory.
-
I am toying with the idea of upgrading to a Mory and I am currently leaning towards Theo's view and going back to 3rd button start. This is primarily due to having the low voice rather than only the Dony's 2 voice.
I just really like the LMM sound in the top octave of the Mory.
Exactly! What Theo said. (:)
-
Something to note is that almost every layout that has been posted here so far has been flavoured for push D# & push Bb - one exception being Andy Cutting's which has apparently has push D# & pull Bb.
Which way around do you like your accidentals, Julian? It might be important.
-
Why a Mory, rather than a full 3 rows? The latter doesn’t cost, or weigh all that much more 🤔. But you get your accs and reversals across nearly 3 octaves …,
-
My wish list - Bb push, Eb push, G# pull, C, D, E reversals, as many F nats as possible, middle C somewhere. Having the low voice clearly makes a difference but how much switching between voices does one do ? I haven't ruled out using button 1 on D row for accidentals. I think third button start seems to win out.
And it would be interesting to hear a Guais compared to a Mory...or any others (but not Beltuna - I made a bad buy with an Alex 3 proving too heavy on my wrist). And yes, as Chris points out, then one thinks three row DGacc - same weight on left hand unless more basses.
But I'm only short a few grand...and I don't want to sell any of my others !
The one thing about the current situation is that it gives plenty of thinking (and worrying) time to assess priorities, whilst knowing that so many of us have much more important concerns, both day to day and for the future.
J
-
I do agree with Chris. A Handry 12 with an accidental row makes a lot more sense than a Mory. Says the Mory owner :-)
-
Depends what you want to play. For my playing the Mory gives me all the extras that I need.
-
I've read somewhere that at some point Andy C changed his layout.
I don't know if the one referred to here ( on the website ) is his old or current layout. Important for those that wish to follow his footsteps....
Q
-
Why a Mory, rather than a full 3 rows? The latter doesn’t cost, or weigh all that much more 🤔. But you get your accs and reversals across nearly 3 octaves …,
I've tried a Handry on a few occasions and, tempting though it is, I know that for me and the sort of playing I do, it would eventually prove to be too heavy. You may be right Chris, about it not weighing 'all that much more'. But just that lttle bit more pushes it over the edge for me. The Mory is at the limit of what I can comfortably play. I don't need three octaves-worth of accidentals and reversals.
-
I've read somewhere that at some point Andy C changed his layout.
I don't know if the one referred to here ( on the website ) is his old or current layout. Important for those that wish to follow his footsteps.... Q
Hmmm, I bought my Mory direct in 1991! much impressed by Andy’s dêbut performance in Southport, and on the Vanilla CD. It moved my technique on some distance … but no way was I playing like Mr Cutting! 🤔
-
Sorting through some old papers, I've just come across my order for a Dony in 1986. The lay-out diagram is handwritten and marked "(final?)" but I think it was pretty much this. The Dony was 2 row + 4 in those days (photo on diagram). Some of it looks familiar and some of it fairly eccentric now but it was 34 years ago and I was working in isolation! I played it regularly till it was stolen from my car around ten years later.
-
I've just been rereading the handout notes from a workshop by Squeezy at Witney a few years ago 'A guide to approaching systems with more than two rows and eight basses'. Really useful in helping me crystallise my ideas. Possibly.
I think three rows is tempting but whether it's really worthwhile for me, in what I play - a pretty fundamental point !
I drew up a chart of different set ups for the extra five buttons in D/G - virtually all have a pair of G#/Bb (or vice versa) - with Eb/F also being a favourite. Having F in both directions is useful, as is Eb - but it's obviously very difficult (if not impossible)to have two of each,particularly as I would like C, D and E reversals ! And the right position under the fingers is so important. Five buttons just isn't quite enough...
So, at the moment I have what seems a list of random buttons - Bb/G# to replace button 1 on D row, an Eb/F, C/D, either another Eb/F or F/F, another Bb/G#, and an E push with something to be decided. There's also the idea to change duplicated low D on the G row to a C.
It's perhaps fortunate that the likelihood of me bringing this to reality is small because there needs to be an underlying logic...I'm sure this is all well trodden ground and there is no ideal solution. But in my delusion I think there still could be !
J
-
I have been trying to find the most useful to me as well and as I am digging around in old Hohner clubs to rearrange reeds it's easy to try some alternatives.
I'll detail it in my thread on Dutch reversal so as not to clog up yours.
-
My wish list - Bb push, Eb push, G# pull, C, D, E reversals, as many F nats as possible, middle C somewhere. Having the low voice clearly makes a difference but how much switching between voices does one do ? I haven't ruled out using button 1 on D row for accidentals. I think third button start seems to win out.
And it would be interesting to hear a Guais compared to a Mory...or any others (but not Beltuna - I made a bad buy with an Alex 3 proving too heavy on my wrist). And yes, as Chris points out, then one thinks three row DGacc - same weight on left hand unless more basses.
Sorry to hear about your bad experience with a Beltuna Alex. It really can be hard to find a box that offers what you want and doesn't do the things that you don't want. Did it have bass couplers, vs stops, and was that the issue do you think, for the weight?
It really is worth it to keep in mind how 3rd/4th start will impact your acc row in context - if you're searching mostly for lower accidentals/reversals, you may find that trying to add another on may push others so they feel out of place compared to the scales on the main buttons. Also, bear in mind that with looking for both C and E reversals, you're looking for more push notes than you are pull notes.
But like, 4th start can mean a lot of different things - some use 4th start to give them more options for low note reversals/scales (going down to lowest D, or having Bs both ways). Some choose 4th start to give accidentals. 3rd start could still mean having chin end accs instead of low notes. If you're committing to play higher up the instrument, then are you saying you'll need accs and reversals accs up there, too/instead of lower down?
Sometimes I think that when a whole 3rd row is on offer, it's very easy to get caught up in needing to have some kind of system that lets you spread your range further and further. But like semitone boxes vs fourth apart boxes, there's choices to be made on how much redundancy one wants to achieve better vocabulary within a subset of the options. I know that if I had to pick one pull D, I'd pick D4 over D5 for more sick chords. Which F do I want to be unisonoric the most? F4... for more sick chords. But do I need the push F4 as much if I have a pull D4? Those ideas, as solid as they feel, I guess haven't stood the test of actually being on a box. Plus it's not like those extra row is necessarily perfect for everything you wanna do.
-
I nearly did a comic nosedive pratfall when I tried on Ollie King's Alex some years back as I wasn't prepared for the weight!
I've since tried an almost new one on a friend's stall, beautifully built, creamy sound but felt very heavy.
Last year I did have a good squeeze on a Mory at a music stall at Sidmouth and was noticeably unaware of it's size by comparison. I know it's not small but it didn't feel too bad, not 'scary heavy' to me.
They must be reasonably comparable in weight but my two goes on an Alex left me thinking it is a heavy box.
-
I actually just found my layout chart for the Alex 3 - interestingly fourth button start. I made the big mistake of not thinking about layout at all and just taking their standard - but most importantly not spending enough time playing in the shop before putting in my order. Bass end was very heavy, but part of the problem I think was that I am used to the most used buttons being at the top end of my Pastourelle - very unusual I know. On my Dony I had it changed - I was getting some problems with that as well before the change.
So the lesson is clear - lots of thought and try outs before any spend. And if (and when) I decide to buy, then I know (more or less!) what I'd like. Definitely third button start anyway. But who knows, I do suffer from chronic indecision !
Thanks again everyone.
Julian
PS - my current favourite five buttons look like Eb/F, C/D, E/?(poss Eb), Eb/F and Bb/G#. First button D row Bb/G#, second button G row C/F#
-
Definitely third button start anyway. But who knows, I do suffer from chronic indecision!
Thanks again everyone.
Could you say what it was that convinced you, ultimately?
-
Sorry to hear about your bad experience with a Beltuna Alex. It really can be hard to find a box that offers what you want and doesn't do the things that you don't want. Did it have bass couplers, vs stops, and was that the issue do you think, for the weight?
If it helps, here's my experience: I had a Beltuna Alex 3 on approval from the Music Room for a couple of weeks, as part of a possible marketing/teaching deal (which never came off in the end). The Alex 3 was a gorgeous box - lovely creamy sound and superb build-quality. But too heavy. Compared with the Castagnari Mory, the Alex 3 was a bit too well built and over-engineered. Otherwise, the specifications were very similar, LMM, couplers to control the voices behind the keyboard, three-voice basses and chords with piston couplers to remove the thirds and lowest bass reeds.
-
I'm following this thread with interest. During the hardest bits of lockdown I was having a bit of a 'sod it life's too short, but a Mory' sort of phase. Then fate, in the form of a Saltarelle Rivage' intervened.
It'll need G Scaling on the main rows and there's an accidental I want flipped but this enforced period of isolation is giving me pause to think about the 'perfect' layout.
In my defence, yes I bought another box, but the Rivage came up on the day my father was admitted to hospital. He never came out. Like I said, life's too short, buy the box.
-
Yes Steve - my view of the Alex as well. Beautifully made, lovely sound...but definitely heavier than a Mory, so not just the weight of the mechanismd
My ideas for layout reflect my experience of both my Dony and my Pastourelle - each third button. On Pasty (which I've had for thirty years) I'm used to having C, D and E reversals which are much used but I feel the need for Eb push - which I have on the Dony - along with Bb push. Using the first button on the G row for Bb/G# (as I have on Pasty but in reverse) frees up a button on the part row.
The quandary I have is whether a unisonoric F is desirable - as on my Pasty.
The only way I can see of buying a Mory at the moment though, is if I sell the Dony, which I have grown to really like.
One definite problem of having different instruments is getting one's head round the layouts - and my G/C Pariselle is still a bit of a challenge ! Lately I have been spending time with all. But it's not as if I have work to go to.
(And I fully agree with Helena, about life)
Julian
-
In my defence, yes I bought another box, but the Rivage came up on the day my father was admitted to hospital. He never came out. Like I said, life's too short, buy the box.
Helena, so sorry to learn about your father. :'(
Yes - life's too short. I'm pleased you bought the Rivage. Hope you can get it fettled to your satissfaction and that it brings you joy.
-
If you dont need the 3 voices why not look at a Castagnari Rik,12 bass wit stops to take out bass notes and thirds that is if you want a full size box or a Castagnari Big 18,or a Benny,I have several layouts in stock,
Details on web site.
I also have a Castagnari Mory pre owned with a non standard layout,again details on web site
www.acorninstruments.co.uk (http://www.acorninstruments.co.uk)
-
The power of the unisonoric F is really for if you wish to venture into 0, 1 or 2 flats. You can do that without it, certainly, but, having it both ways will offer you some advantages. Effectively, as soon as the D minor chord and B flat chords come onto the scene, the option of a push F starts to hold a lot of power. The F note falls in with the usually pull C, as well as the usually push D. One big combination to consider though is F and Bb, though. Both of these notes are accidentals to the main rows, but are often found in opposite directions to one another - never the twain shall meet.
The bass set up with Eb and Bb chords really rather implies that you intend to explore those areas. While 1 and 2 flats correspond with the keys of F and Bb, they also correspond with D minor and G minor, which is critical for tunes that move to parallel major/minor keys, rather than relative ones.
'Reversed' accidentals, push Bb+D#, pull G#+F, I believe help unlock playing in the sharper keys of A, E and B. They have always made sense to me because wrt 'going sharper', the diatonic chords of a major key extend much more in that direction. The layout of the instrument means that often the 1 and 5 of each of these chords can be found in that direction, so, E+B, A+E, G+D, D+A, B+F# etc, and pretty much all come along with a suitable bass - but, this is only true for going sharper. The new note added for each # in the signature can usually come in over a 3rdless chord, and those new scale notes don't particularly end up in positions of power, harmonically, for that major key - like you don't really need a G# based chord when playing in A, but neither do you readily need one in E or B etc.
This is what I mean when I say that the sharper/flatter divide is uneven. With the key center of G, the useful diatonic chords are highlighted in bold:
Flatter <----V-----> Sharper
Ab Eb Bb F C G D A E B F# C#
|--_--------|
When going flatter, the notes you need to add to the scale become very important. When dropping to 0 sharps, the F note then quickly becomes the tonic note of 1 flat, and is then the 5th of the scale for 2 flats.
Obviously this is just the way I feel the layout of the melodeon, being mapped really pretty strongly to chords. Perhaps that's kinda why I look at unisonoric F as a large boon, but view push C+E less keenly.
One thing to bear in mind is that, if you wanted to play in G minor, but were less worried about like, actual F and B flat, the role of the both-ways F is somewhat diminished. If one looks at that same diagram above but look to where the relative minor, E, is. Now the diatonic chords mostly swing flatter. If we transpose that pattern over in the direction of D and G minor, the F, Bb and Eb note needed to shift the key signature are somewhat less important for the harmony, and having fewer options, such as excluding F over Bb chord is much more OK.
Hopefully my approach here gives you some ideas to consider re 'The quandary I have is whether a unisonoric F is desirable - as on my Pasty.'
-
I agree with Helena Handcart. If in doubt, buy (if you have the cash). You'll mostly get your money back if the purchase is a mistake, which is one of the great things about boxes (their value holds up). I also have a PA craving so it’s double trouble for me.
-
Excellent analysis and summary, Gena !
I see advantages in both approaches - it really depends on what one plays ! On my Dony I miss having the reversals I have on the Pasty, and the unisonoric F, and on my Pasty I miss having the Eb pushes - and also middle C, and not having octave 4 unisonoric F ! I may slightly change the Pasty to remedy some of the niggles. Pasty doesn't have the left hand chords of the Dony...but does have an Em push and G pull chord.
Whilst there may be other solutions out there, I can't see a way of retaining unisonoric Fs without losing something else which is desirable. Or is there something I haven't even thought of ?
After all, playing melodeon is all about making the most of limitations and I just end up picking up a different instrument quite often. What I would want out of the Mory is the sound options and overall quality, as well as layout. And I suspect I will always pick up the Pasty when I want to take just one instrument to a session or gig, whenever that is possible again.
J
-
As someone 'lurking' on this thread and trying to keep up with the bewildering variations of keyboard layout, Julian has just touched on something that interests me.
The reason I had a go on a Mory on a music stall last year was being really taken with its' sound after sitting beside the bass end of one in a pub session. It was deeply warm and rich.
I suspect, as Steve Freereeder and I have discussed privately a while ago, it could be due to it's increased size possibly absorbing some of the top end sounds thus creating a warmer mellow sound. Whatever the reason, it has a wonderful sound.
Plus, as Julian alludes to, you have a full range of options on both the treble and bass end for +/- reeds, thirds, low bass notes etc. which is personally very appealing.
I fully intended having a good go on one at some workshops' music stall to convince myself one way or the other if I should take the plunge ( and it could be 'other' ) but we all know what's happened to such events sadly.
I think I'll keep lurking and make mental notes!
Q
-
I nearly did a comic nosedive pratfall when I tried on Ollie King's Alex some years back as I wasn't prepared for the weight!
D'you know I think weight is something we can handle better as we improve as players. I remember having similar issues with and Alex and a Handry and a Mory when trying them out from various stalls.
The Rivage and the Mory are both advertised as being the same weight - 5.4kg. Much heavier than I'd usually go for but I find I can play the Rivage sitting or standing and weight is not a problem. The weight of the boxes has not changed so I guess it must be about my own ability to play and control a larger and heavier instrument.
-
Helena, I think you're absolutely right.
Until the Jilly came along my main played every day box was my Hascy. According to the Castagnari website it weighs 3.9Kg but mine on the scales is 4.5Kg and after playing it for several years I don't notice it.
Perhaps that's why the Mory, at 5.4Kg seems ok now and I'm sure muscles and fingers have now become used to balancing and playing.
-
Mory/Rivage/Alex3 etc., versus something else...
One thing that doesn't seem to have been touched on in this interesting discussion is the type and setting of the music which is being played.
I would not want to play my Mory for morris (well, Lizzie Dripping really) standing up, outside, quite fast, vigorous music. I tried it once at a practice just to see what it was like; once was enough - I ached after just a very short time. The same would go for the Alex 3 and, I guess, a Rivage.
For playing for dancing, standing up for long periods, not to mention lugging around from one dance spot to another, my standard box is a Castagnari 1914 and occasionally a 1-row 4-stop.
The Mory is reserved for playing in a non-morris setting, mostly sitting down only.