Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: ladydetemps on September 30, 2009, 12:18:34 PM
-
So I was wondering...sets (you know when one tune goes onto another etc.); Who chooses what tune goes with what tune? Is there a rule of thumb? why put tunes in sets? How many tunes can be in a set?
-
? How many tunes can be in a set?
It depends on purpose. The Sainted Mr Kirkpatrick would have only one for dancing... (:)
Baz
-
So I was wondering...sets (you know when one tune goes onto another etc.); Who chooses what tune goes with what tune? Is there a rule of thumb? why put tunes in sets? How many tunes can be in a set?
I think it came originally from ceilidh bands that wanted to put a bit of variety into their music rather than playing the same tune from the beginning of a dance to the end. A set of two or three tunes tends to be the norm (sets of two tunes are the most common in sessions). Anyone can put a couple of tunes together to make a set and there are no rules about doing so. If tunes sound right together, they can be played together. Some have become almost standard sets over the years (e.g. Horses Brawl/Morisco, Harper's Frolic/Bonny Kate and Dingle Regatta/Sweets of May).
A couple of months ago, I asked on this forum if anyone could supply the music for Weasel's Revenge and I received not only Weasel's Revenge but also another good tune called Weasel in the Grass. Having learnt them, I have put both of them into sets: Schottishe fran Norbotten/Weasel's Revenge and Weasel in the Grass/News of the Victory.
-
Here's the link to the JC article that I guess Baz is referring to,
http://www.johnkirkpatrick.co.uk/wr_MedleyMania.htm
In response to the original question,
Who chooses? - Leaving aside the B obvious (the player!,) in a session it is (or should be!) whoever starts the set.
Some people like to start a set without knowing what they'll go into and make the changes "on the fly."
There are some sets that are so time-honoured it would be a big surprise to change them.
No rules but you wouldn't normally mix tune types in an unrehearsed environment like a session, though in the Scottish tradition there are conventional mixes like "March, Strathspey and Reel"
Key changes and progressions can be nice, but there's nothing wrong with a set all in the same key.
Why? Because it's nice and sounds good! Some changes can be absolutely lovely. There are some sets that I both really enjoy, and which are spoiled by the fact that one is just waiting for the delicious change!
-
I feel a little sorry for JK, whose off the cuff and limited comments of 28 years ago have entered box-players' culture in a way I bet he never intended (listen to his great playing of a medley of tunes on the latest fRoots sample CD (it's the last track), for example!
I'm as guilty as everybody else, but it sometimes seems as if we don't have enough imagination to step outside convention, so we play the same tunes in the same order as the recording we pinched them from, thus immediately giving away the source to all other box players! Sometimes there are good reasons - for example Pete Coe's wonderful run down D,C#,C,B between Mrs Grace Bowie and the Hogmanay Jigs is such a unique feature of the 'togetherness' of the New Victory Band's playing that the two tunes deserve to be kept together for that very reason. Often, changes between tunes can be surprising, and provide a real lift to the music, which the audience can feel, and we can use this effect. (Some people say that dancers don't notice what you're playing, but I disagree, and as a player you can see the overall effect pretty clearly, if you just watch them!)
On the other hand, sometimes variations in one tune allow it to be played forever - everybody can think of examples, I'm sure, but I like the playing by Asha of 'Catharsis', written by Amy Cann, on the CD 'Into the Light' as a wonderful example - if you changed tunes, you would ruin it!
-
I feel a little sorry for JK, whose off the cuff
<snip>
Not sure that you can count an article published in English Dance & Song and then placed on a web site for all to read as being "off the cuff"?
-
Well, journalism is, as we all know, a profession that can always be relied upon to put everything perfectly in context!
I think I'm merely suggesting that JK didn't really say we should always play only one tune at a time, that's just the way many people have interpreted it.
-
I feel a little sorry for JK, whose off the cuff
<snip>
Not sure that you can count an article published in English Dance & Song and then placed on a web site for all to read as being "off the cuff"?
JK did mean what he said and has repeated it many times over the years, (for instance at workshops at Melodeons at Witney). However, let's not be precious about this. Tremendously talented though JK is, his is just one viewpoint; other equally talented musicians prefer to play sets/medleys rather than sticking with one tune throughout a dance. Each has its place: chacun a son gout!
-
I feel a little sorry for JK, whose off the cuff
<snip>
Not sure that you can count an article published in English Dance & Song and then placed on a web site for all to read as being "off the cuff"?
JK did mean what he said and has repeated it many times over the years, (for instance at workshops at Melodeons at Witney). However, let's not be precious about this. Tremendously talented though JK is, his is just one viewpoint; other equally talented musicians prefer to play sets/medleys rather than sticking with one tune throughout a dance. Each has its place: chacun a son gout!
I think your opinion is a good one Bob; one has to be realistic about this sets and medleys business.
Personally, I do favour JK's idea very much, but I am also prepared to change tunes in a set, but only after the first tune has been given a good airing and its hows and ways explored nicely.
What drives me to distraction though is the automatic running of tunes together in sets where each tune is played through just twice before moving on to the next, and then the next, and then the next..... Scottish Country Dance sets seem to be the worst offenders here. Arghh!!!.
-
To return to the original question:
You can make up your own sets with your own favourite tunes. There are is nobody setting rules. It all depends on what you like.
-
Well if you heard some of the "original, must be played for the dance, no other tune will do" tunes that are imposed on us by the RSCDS, once through would be enough for anyone. If you're playing an 8 x 32 or 8 x 48 bar reel, jig or whatever for dancers I couldn't think of anything more boring than using one tune, for the band and the dancers.
Obviously in an informal session a couple of tunes in a set would do, tho' if you're just going to play one tune and ad lib with it as you go along what are the others playing along with you [ or trying to ] going to do ?
Scottish dance bands, up until the forties, played 3 or 4 tunes in a set in the same key until Shand came along and started changing key into the 2nd tune etc. and then Bobby McLeod and Andrew Rankine recorded sets with a key change from D to F for instance, that made you sit up and listen when that happened !
Ian.
-
It's an entirely personal choice how many tunes you play and how many times you play them,and what you do depends on the circumstances.
If you are in a ceilidh band, even if you are using standard tunes, you can still be creative with them by putting them into sets with interesting changes, and it's really up to you how many times you play through each. On the other hand, if for example you have lots of different instruments in your band, you can do a lot with just one tune.
If you're at a session, however, I think it's very unfair on the other musicians to play sets where you only play a tune twice and move on to the next, as it's difficult to keep up and noone has a chance to get into the tune. Playing it through 3 times is the usual convention, but even that isn't really long enough for people who don't know the tune to pick it up, or for the others to develop it. On the other hand, if it's a mixed session and there are people in the room who aren't into those particular tunes, or there are people waiting to sing or whatever, it can be a bit unfair on them to play one tune, or set, for about 20 minutes!
(In which case the next singer may well get their revenge with a slow, 29 verse epic ballad!)
-
JK did mean what he said and has repeated it many times over the years
I don't seek to labour the point, but if you look at his article, my point was that he did not actually say that you should only ever play one tune for one dance, which many people, and perhaps the journalist's spin, have taken him to mean. I believe he was actually making a more general pont, that 'medley mania' can easily kill the quality and possible variations of each tune, which he wanted musicians to explore (and it was a point very well made). Surely JK is far too good a musician to believe in rigid restrictions on how musicians should play, he was making a plea for imagination, was he not? And if he really believed that medleys were always wrong, why is his own music so full of brilliant variety?
There are is nobody setting rules. It all depends on what you like.
Succinct, and spot on, Theo!
-
With a rgular caller, we agree as much as possible which head tunes we use and which following tunes to give the correct bar count. If the caller does not want a particular tune for a particular dance we try to oblige. with a strange caller, we try to agree all the head tunes in advance and then agree where we go thereafter.
Everyone playing for a dance has got to have a road map of the tunes used - though I did for a time play with an Irish band that went on endless flights of fancy.
-
To return to the original question:
thanks I was wondering if anyone would ;)
You can make up your own sets with your own favourite tunes. There are is nobody setting rules. It all depends on what you like.
There's nothing I hate more than 'no rules'...because usually there are rules and no one is telling.
'No rules' is usually followed by 'but not like that!'
-
Or in my case, playing a 'made up by me' set in a session, to then be told - 'interesting - we always play it followed by x' :D Still, it's a variation, so I don't feel bad about it, just make a not of it as an alternative set for the future ;D
-
I've found that if a tune is played through 3 times then I can make a fair stab at picking it up. Twice through then unless it is slow and fairly simple I don't have a chance.
Interestingly whenever I play in English sessions, playing something only twice seems obviously wrong, whereas in Scottish or Irish sessions playing it more than twice seems rather strange.
-
'No rules' is usually followed by 'but not like that!'
It depends on the context. In a band there will be some sort of leadership, someone who sets the tunes, or delegates it within the band. Just ask your band leader!
In a session its different, and all sessions are different in my experience, some have very definite views on which tunes go together, the best are open to the unexpected. In the ideal (for me) session the person who starts a tune should be listened to to see how many times (s)he want to play it, and what to follow it with. In other sessions tune A is always followed by tune B and each is always played x times, I think this is a bad idea because it can mean that the musicians stop listening to each other because they 'know' what is coming next.
Musicians not listening to each other is very, very,very bad.
If there is a rule of playing music with others it is that you must always, always, always listen to what everyone else is playing.
Rant over ;D
-
There's nothing I hate more than 'no rules'...because usually there are rules and no one is telling.
'No rules' is usually followed by 'but not like that!'
Very perceptive analysis. But be wary of asking for rules in trad music in general (I'm departing from the single question of making up sets here). I don't want to sound patronizing but beginners often want to be given rules and I think it's often a mistake.
People ask questions like "where should I put this or that ornament" or "I've heard player X and player Y playing the same tune but with a different swing - which is correct" or "please tell me what bowing to use in reels." If anyone is rash enough to give you rules in answers to questions like that, the danger is that you will try to apply them literally - a "left-brain" sort of approach - instead of a "right-brain" approach of doing what sounds right to you (which is what Theo is recommending, only more succinctly, lol).
There may be rules, but they will generally be fluid and of the kind that cannot successfully be nailed down in words. Very often it's a matter of taste or of what is "right" for a particular style of music in the judgment of the community that plays that music. Most of the members of the community won't see such conventions or matters of taste as rules, because they haven't been spelled out, but acquired over years of being immersed in the music. That's why they'll say there are no rules.
Keep your mind and your ears open and in time all these "what is the rule" type questions will become redundant - you'll know what to do. In the meantime, don't be afraid to do what you like, and don't worry too much that you might be breaking "rules"... (:)
BTW ukebert in my experience tunes are played _at least_ three times in Irish sessions - the ones I go to anyway.
-
BTW ukebert in my experience tunes are played _at least_ three times in Irish sessions - the ones I go to anyway.
Must be going to different sessions than you then :P
All this business about rules though is quite right. I gave a friend of mine an intro into how to play box and kept on saying things like "Now I do this and that, but others will say that you should do this, and so and so uses that but this chap does this, so opinion differs". In the end I think that the only thing that I told him to do strongly was get into the habit of using four fingers on the bass. For everything else (number of fingers on the treble, hand position, number of straps, cross-rowing, articulation etc.) I could think of massive variety in how people play.
-
Three times has been the default in pretty much all the sessions I've been to, including festivals.
It can be a little bit irritating when there are folks who believe that all the tunes in the sets THEY start are so inherently wonderful that they must be played four times.......
-
Three times has been the default in pretty much all the sessions I've been to, including festivals.
It can be a little bit irritating when there are folks who believe that all the tunes in the sets THEY start are so inherently wonderful that they must be played four times.......
Best avoid me at sessions then - I have been known to play some tunes 6/7 times because I like them (:)
There again at least one set I play only has tunes through once but there are a lot of them in the set.
-
Three times has been the default in pretty much all the sessions I've been to, including festivals.
It can be a little bit irritating when there are folks who believe that all the tunes in the sets THEY start are so inherently wonderful that they must be played four times.......
Best avoid me at sessions then - I have been known to play some tunes 6/7 times because I like them (:)
There again at least one set I play only has tunes through once but there are a lot of them in the set.
Some tunes ARE great and deserve it, and I'm happy to play a tune a good few times because someone loves it in particular, it's just players with a personal times-through default setting that's higher than everyone else's that I question! ;D
-
We had a great session recently where the idea was to put as many completely different tunes together as possible. Complete mahem, but jolly good.
-
My band has one set with 5 tunes, all in D. We use the first tune as a chorus, so the set goes:
tune A
tune B
tune A
tune C
tune A
tune D
tune A
tune E
tune A
If the dancers are full of beans then we go round the whole set twice.
-
Three times has been the default in pretty much all the sessions I've been to, including festivals.
While I agree about three times through being the default, there needs to be some variation from that. Some bourrees, for instance, only have four bars in the A music and four in the B, so they are over almost before they have begun if you only play them through three times. On the other hand, three times through slow airs like Dark Island or In Dreams (the Hobbit theme from Lord of ther Rings) can take a looooooooong time, so I tend to play them only twice through.
-
If the dancers are full of beans then we go round the whole set twice.
Masochists!
;D
-
My band has one set with 5 tunes, all in D. We use the first tune as a chorus, so the set goes:
tune A
tune B
tune A
tune C
tune A
tune D
tune A
tune E
tune A
If the dancers are full of beans then we go round the whole set twice.
Do you ever lose track of where you are up to, and play the wrong tune in the wrong place?
If not, how do you manage it? (:)
-
Do you ever lose track of where you are up to, and play the wrong tune in the wrong place?
Very occasionally :|bl , but as long as the fiddle player and myself are listening to each other and we both agree on who is leading then it doesn't matter. Just adds to the fun. ;D
-
Yes, Theo, we've also got a set that goes, for the same chorus reason:
Tune A
Tune A
Tune A
Tune B
Tune A
Tune C
Tune A
Tune A
Funnily enough, it isn't at all difficult to remember, because if you ever forget where you are, you can see where you are from the dance structure. The dancers seem able to understand the structure of the tunes, presumably because they can 'hear' the logic.
On the other hand, the same bandleader who arranged this masterpiece many years ago (and who sadly died a decade ago, much missed), also decided it would be a great idea to play a whole set of 5 32-bar jigs AABBAB (twice each and back to the top), in order to match a 48-bar dance. In the scores of times that we played this arrangement, I do recall one occasion when we played it right, and the dancers were somewhat perplexed by the band's cheering!
(PS: If you're up there reading this on hww.harps.net, L, I hope you're not offended! And just watch out for those bloomin' long trumpets blaring in your ear.)
-
... a whole set of 5 32-bar jigs AABBAB (twice each and back to the top), in order to match a 48-bar dance. In the scores of times that we played this arrangement, I do recall one occasion when we played it right, and the dancers were somewhat perplexed by the band's cheering!
I'm not surprised you cheered!
Funnily enough, it's the AABBAB ones I find quite easy because, as you say, you can tell where you are up to by watching the dancers.
My problem is that a lot of our sets are played Tune 1x2, Tune 2x2, Tune 1x2 etc, which shouldn't be too difficult, but I seem to be having problems counting up to 2 these days! ??? Luckily the rest of the band have got used to this and follow me regardless!
-
Gosh - very out of character for me not to have posted this thread yet. When John made his stand in that article I have to say it will not have been' off the cuff' at all. It's the sort of thing he'd consider for months
I was a very active country dancer in '81, on the move into musicianship having finally bought my concertina. Melodeon came 3 years later. We never missed Whitby, and I'd be in the Elsinore all week - learning sessioning.
I have to say I found the seemingly constant change of melody, and key :-[ and rhythm ??? a bit daunting. As my music has developed I've come to realise JK got it more or less right. I've come to see 'setting' as an excuse, avoidance even, for real musical expression. So sorry if that offends anyone.
In terms of choosing 'sets' for dance we have a very specific objective - enjoyable dance. I feel our leader can do what he wants. (One must however draw the line at those bizarre undancable rhythm changes)! But once it becomes multi medley, it's somehow almost an exercise in Set Theory (I mean maths) and can get very dull. Up in the Lakes one of the EFDSS types expounded to a scratch band
We'll do number 34 twice (:), number 43 three times ::) .. number 17 twice :-\
I don't think any thought whatsoever had been given to the beauty of the proposed music, although cubic group symmetries or whatever, and some underlying number of bars calculation would magically bring the lead dancers back to the top of the set. Hey ho.
Then our dancers spent 10 minutes walking through a 5 minute dance! Zzzzzzzz
OK (sorry for another essay). 'Sessioning'. In a session there are some 'standard mixes' and I think the music benefits from that. Mostly they seem to be what some famous band once published on a record. But a lot of people know them and that's surely to the good. But the beauty of the music is paramount, tempered by the need to include tunes that all can get to. We push the pace a bit - I don't like that as it breaks our link with dance and I think loses beauty - but it's not 'wrong'
But we really don't in Britain ever repeat melodies enough. It's only by about the third time through that people get into the groove and variation emerges. I can't guarantee it'll be beautiful, but it is real music.
I can feel it coming - the chap across the table is doing something really interesting - I simplify to just chords to give him space. But just as he starts - someone with a loud piano accordion will always switch to another tune. Then another a couple of minutes later. Gosh - we were in a nice waltz rhytm but now someone's pushing it into jig ...
The 'groove' effect never happens. We are back to treating music as a series of dots. It is more than that.
-
......
I have to say I found the seemingly constant change of melody, and key :-[ and rhythm ??? a bit daunting. As my music has developed I've come to realise JK got it more or less right. I've come to see 'setting' as an excuse, avoidance even, for real musical expression. So sorry if that offends anyone.
<snip>
The 'groove' effect never happens. We are back to treating music as a series of dots. It is more than that.
Snipped to save space, but what you say is good stuff, and nicely expressed. Thank you.
-
Spot on. DB
-
I think there are 2 separate though related issues going on here, as I'd tried to express above.
Dance sets - I say the band can do what they like. If that inspires my feet (Ran Tan a splendid example) Well done, I'll seek you out again.
... and session sets. An example here might be a morris tune with built in slow capers. I used to labour through these, but they don't always add much, and was it twice through or three times? Ah, both ways, at different ends of the table ;) Cool!
Slows put in toward the end as a reference to the dance - works nicely. But while we are just playing tunes with no dancers I'd not be too obsessive about following the Morris Book layout. Much better to explore a tune that has often stood the test of centuries of play. Which is why I'll vote 'Sherbourne Waltz' for next TOTM. And why I'd be ashamed to play it lyrically/legato when stood in front of six men with bells on.
-
Try getting a group of determined musicians and dancers OUT of "Silver Spear" or the likes, and see how far you get :D
-
... a whole set of 5 32-bar jigs AABBAB (twice each and back to the top), in order to match a 48-bar dance. In the scores of times that we played this arrangement, I do recall one occasion when we played it right, and the dancers were somewhat perplexed by the band's cheering!
I'm not surprised you cheered!
Funnily enough, it's the AABBAB ones I find quite easy because, as you say, you can tell where you are up to by watching the dancers.
My problem is that a lot of our sets are played Tune 1x2, Tune 2x2, Tune 1x2 etc, which shouldn't be too difficult, but I seem to be having problems counting up to 2 these days! ??? Luckily the rest of the band have got used to this and follow me regardless!
Quadrilles are the worst for repeats !
They just go on, and on and you just don't know where you are
Here (in Sweden) they play sessions with the dots. Wow betide if you hit a bum note. :|bl :|bl
I don't read or care. :|glug
I enjoy coming over to England for the sessions as I can play my "B" part that I've mis-learned and no one really minds.
-
I enjoy coming over to England for the sessions as I can play my "B" part that I've mis-learned and no one really minds.
I suppose that in England you can play as many bum notes as you like, all you need to do is to tell everybody that you are playing the Swedish version! :D
-
The one that really upsets the fiddlers is AA BC BC - Can't think why :)