Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Tunes => ABC => Topic started by: Roger Hare on June 22, 2020, 08:13:03 PM
-
Sorry folks, I always seem to be asking questions about flaky ABC code. Here's another one.
I have an ABC file in which I have a multi-headed note preceded by a single character ornamentation: .[gc]
I think this is wrong - the ABC documentation clearly states that single character ornamentations (. ~ etc...)
should come immediately before the note concerned. Question: is .[gc] meant to represent [.gc] or [.g.c]
or is it 'undefined' - what did the original transcriber mean?
I think I'm canvassing 'opinion' here - I suspect it's a situation which is not 'defined' in the context of ABC.
I ask because .[gc] is playing havoc with one of my ABC-processing programs, but [.gc] is perfectly fine.
I can probably frig my program to detect this as an error, and exit gracefully, but I wondered if any of the
experts here had come across anything like this before...
Thank you.
-
The dot should apply to both notes in the chord. Isn't that how chords work? It works fine as .[gc] in my editor. Looks exactly as I would expect.
-
The dot should apply to both notes in the chord. Isn't that how chords work? It works fine as .[gc] in my editor.
Looks exactly as I would expect.
Yes, that's what I suspected. It looks OK in my editor too (EasyABC). I need to juggle my own program to take
this into account, (though it doesn't arise very often). Thank you.
-
This is confirmed by Guido Gonzato's guide, which states: "Chords behave as a single note when you have to add dots, slurs, etc. That is, it can be preceded by a dot for staccato, or by a symbol, and so on."
-
This is confirmed by Guido Gonzato's guide, which states: "Chords behave as a single note when you have to add dots, slurs, etc. That is, it can be preceded by a dot for staccato, or by a symbol, and so on."
Ah! !hank you! I missed that - I had looked in the ABC standard and couldn't see anything
(though I probably missed it there too!). Thank you very much.