Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Hugh Taylor on July 07, 2020, 07:19:25 PM

Title: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Hugh Taylor on July 07, 2020, 07:19:25 PM
I was having my weekly Zoom chat today with my mate Steve (Mcgrooger) and commenting on how much I enjoy the C17 & C18 tunes, partly because of the modality in a lot of them. I don't know much about the development of folk dance tunes (can I call them that?) but looking at most tune books that we now have access to, there is a general paucity of such modality. Yes I know there are lots of exceptions such as Vickers, but what happened to 'our' music around the end of the 1700's and the early 1800's?
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Andy Next Tune on July 07, 2020, 07:32:45 PM
I suspect the migration of people out of the countryside into towns and cities fuelled by the Industrial Revolution has a lot to do with it.

Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Calum on July 07, 2020, 09:02:44 PM
The 18th century was an age of "improvement", and it's no coincidence that much of value was torn down in this time and replaced with new and modern styles.  Poetry, literature, architecture, art, the list goes on.  This fashion had a very clear idea of what "perfection" in music looked like, guided by the new perfection in functional harmony which gave people a set of intellectual rules to judge musical quality by.  Music that was not up to the task was discarded, as were instruments incapable of playing it.  It's no accident that the great collapse in traditional music around Europe began around this time.  Yet a brief generation earlier, you would have struggled to draw a line between Baroque performers and local folk musicians, who would often have been one and the same.  For example, the Northumbrian piping tradition is essentially a strange survival of late Baroque performance practice applied to a very regional music.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: richard.fleming on July 07, 2020, 09:05:22 PM
I'm pretty sure I read somewhere that folk song and tune collectors like Cecil Sharp did not note down the music as it was but as they thought it ought to be, believing that the individual musicians and singers were ignorant and uneducated, even though they somehow also believed that the 'folk' as a whole had an ability to create sublime music collectively of which  the individuals were incapable.Maybe the modes got lost in this condescending process?
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on July 07, 2020, 09:45:27 PM
Richard is absolutely right regarding Sharpe.
He had the same opinions of the Morris when collecting dances, bending the ideas of the old men to fit his own ideals and correcting them if he thought they'd made a mistake. An upper class academic was not to be argued with if you were a lowly illiterate farm worker.
In Devon we had other collectors, song in particular. The main person, collecting song 30 years before Sharpe, was the Rev. Sabine Baring Gould. He often cleaned up some of the bawdy or risque songs for his publications for a sensitive audience but his saving grace was he kept a record of his collected material 'as was told to him'.

With such practices common in collectors, I'm sure careful detective work can sense differences in the collected material in this era.
Q

Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: CAB on July 07, 2020, 10:08:22 PM
A bit unfair on Sharp (no -e).  He certainly had some weird ideas.  A lot of the old collectors thought the "peasants" had done a good job of preserving the music but it was better performed by trained musicians and singers.  But Sharp had a good relationship with his informants and a good understanding of their music.  I'd say his transcriptions were pretty faithful.  Have a look at some here: https://www.vwml.org/search?q=henry%20cave&is=1  .  He has annotated a tune in A dorian and added a note to the effect that a G was "very nearly G# at times" - at pains to record exactly what he heard.

A few years back, it was fashionable among some politically motivated critics to knock Sharp and the rest.  I think serious scholars have a more balanced view now.  Percy Grainger, incidentally, took great pains to capture every little nuance of his Lincolnshire singers' performance, using early recording technology and devising complex transcription conventions

Sharp and the rest collected plenty of songs with modal tunes but there does seem a paucity of dance tunes to match, perhaps for the reasons stated above.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on July 07, 2020, 10:24:54 PM
Apologies, we have a dance called Sharpe with an 'e' !
I have been fortunate to spend time in the company of Roy Dommett who went over the collected dances that went into the Morris Black Book, interviewing some that as young men had been interviewed by Sharp. I have more of a dancer's view of him.
Roy said some of Sharp's companions and fellow collectors were more sympathetic to their source material, some going back to the old men Sharp had noted dancing, as they couldn't understand his notations.
In my opinion he saved a lot of material that would have disappeared, but I've heard he tried to 'improve' their source material if he thought it needed it.
.... but I concede I have a dancer's viewpoint, not a musicians'
Q

Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: CAB on July 08, 2020, 12:12:42 AM
Apologies, we have a dance called Sharpe with an 'e' !
;D    We had a stick dance called "You did that on purpose, you b*****d"

Roy once showed us a film of Eynsham (I think it was?).  There were almost as many different approaches to stepping as there were dancers.  If some of what Sharp saw contained the same kind of variation, who can blame him for trying to impose some order to make the dances teachable to others?  I bow to your knowledge of his dance transcription - I'm more familiar with his collecting of music and song  ... which is where we came in.

My initial post was a response to Richard, by the way.  Yours appeared while I was typing!
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Julian S on July 08, 2020, 07:33:21 AM
I'm certainly no musicologist, but if I had more knowledge I would certainly be wondering about looking at and analysing the available tune collections, and considering their background and context. Maybe there has already been some research into this, with comparison through the period.
As has been commented, the latter half of the 18th century was certainly a period of great social (and musical) change. I sometimes think as 'traditional' music as being something distinct from 'classical' composed music but I'm sure musicians back then didn't set boundaries in the same way, with collections including music of all kinds, including dance tunes.
Revolutions, wars, economic development - industrialisation and agricultural change...all must have had a profound effect.
Obviously the tune collections are the only record and must be only an indication of what tunes were being played (and maybe some of the tunes were no longer really current)- and I'd be interesting in comparing personal tune collections and those that were published during that period, if possible. And I also wonder whether the collections of 'favourite dance tunes for whenever' were big sellers - and whether these tunes were mainly played in the society ballrooms , or were popular in the pub (or gin shop !) as well.
Slightly off topic, but I was really interested to learn that British Napoleonic military bands commonly comprised 'professional' musicians - and often from different countries. Another way of cross fertilisation and development in music - and given that each regiment had it's own band...which later became unemployed...

J

Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on July 08, 2020, 09:05:11 AM
CAB: Roy came out of retirement and gave us three workshops towards the end of his life. As ever really thought provoking stuff.
He made the point that collecting was difficult, especially when you had no notation so had to describe things for the first time. Music and song had an advantage as there was already a universal form of notation, for Morris he had to invent a dance shorthand so there would have been obvious teething problems. To his credit it worked pretty well.
The Rev. Baring Gould had a couple of collecting accomplices who had more fundamental problems collecting. One - sorry, name gone - invented a unique one wheeled carriage to enable them to traverse the uneven terrain of Dartmoor in search of tunes and songs!

Julian, you've touched on something.
I too am not sure if the boundaries between classical and traditional were do distinct .
During the Buttrey project one of the notators found a piccolo tutor dated 1765. In it was the tune 'March from 'Scipio', written by Georg Freidrich Handel . My version of the tune is dated 1726 but not sure if that refers to Handel or the tune.
The tune was amongst other traditional tunes in the tutor and has entered the traditional and military repertoire.
It is a march used by the Grenadier Guards and I play it in sessions!
There must have been a mechanism for this to happen, so perhaps travelling foreign military musicians might provide a reasonable answer.
Q
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Bob Ellis on July 08, 2020, 09:16:11 AM
This is a huge subject into which I have undertaken quite a lot of research, but have only managed to scratch the surface. Rather than write pages and pages, which would probably bore most people, I'll just offer a few random comments.

Obviously, traditional dance music was driven by changes in the popularity of different types of dance. While gradual changes in the styles of music took place from Playford's English Dancing Master in 1651 to the end of the Napoleonic Wars in 1815, there wasn't a huge difference between the tunes popular in the late seventeenth century and those popular in the first decade of the nineteenth century. Neither were there significant differences between the contents of published collections of tunes and the tunes to be found in the manuscripts of local musicians. This is hardly surprising because many of the tunes published in the music press of the day had been collected from village musicians, while many of the tunes in manuscript tunebooks had been 'pricked out' (i.e. copied by hand) from published collections. It is impossible to know at this distance whether musically illiterate musicians played the same repertoire as those who could read music, but it is likely that their repertoires contained fewer of the tunes from the plethora of music books written and published during the late eighteenth century. What does seem to be clear is that modal tunes were more popular at that time than they were from the mid-nineteenth century onwards. The same is true for what American fiddlers sometimes call 'crooked' tunes (i.e. tunes with an irregular number of bars or with an irregular number of beats in some bars).

A significant change began to take place at the end of the eighteenth century with the introduction into Britain of the waltz, followed from around 1816 by the quadrille (reputedly introduced from France into British high society by Lady Jersey) and these rapidly became popular in all levels of society. Typical English dance evenings at the beginning of the nineteenth century comprised reels, jigs, hornpipes, cotillions, and country dances, perhaps with the occasional strathspey or allemande included. The first half of the nineteenth century saw major changes as successive crazes for the waltz, the quadrille, the polka, and the schottische swept through not only fashionable society but also middle-class professionals and tradespeople, and ordinary country folk. All of these social classes tended to refer to the dances they held as balls. By the mid-century, the majority of the dances performed in a typical ball were waltzes, quadrilles, polkas, galops, and schottisches with a few country dances and other older dances included. For some reason that I have not yet uncovered, the music for these dances was much less likely to be played in modal keys than the music for earlier dances. The incidence of 'crooked playing' also diminished significantly, probably because crooked rhythms disturbed the flow of these new dances.

Julian's comment about "military bands composed of 'professional' musicians" is also apposite. Most regiments in the British army had a 'professional' band and this even applied to the volunteer regiments (the territorials of their day), whose other ranks were part-timers but whose officers and bandmasters were often paid officials of the regiment. A fashion swept the country for quadrille bands from the 1820s until the final decades of the nineteenth century. These quadrille bands usually comprised three to six musicians and played for dances at all levels of society. Their members were often drawn, at least in part, from members of military bands or of local brass bands, so the music they played will have been influenced by the repertoires of the military and brass bands as much as by the traditional dance tunes learnt from earlier generations.

For anyone interested in further information about quadrille bands and their influence on folk dance music, I have recently written an article about the quadrille bands of the Yorkshire Dales and two further articles tracing the history of the Reeth Quadrille Band and the Leyburn Quadrille Band. These articles are now in the hands of my webmaster and will appear shortly on my website: www.dalestunes.org.uk.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on July 08, 2020, 09:27:56 AM
Thanks Bob for popping along.
Your historical  overview here is just what I needed!
Q
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Julian S on July 08, 2020, 10:08:53 AM
That's really interesting Bob. Thanks ! Just like today, the dance musicians back whenever have to be able to play suitable music for the particular dance...and the popular couple dances of the 19th century were revolutionary ( >:E) in themselves -and controversial at the time. I've never been into Playford or 18c dancing, but I do wonder about how 3/2 tunes were used...
On the subject of military bands, my old friend who used to be in charge of the Duke of Wellingtons regimental museum told me that the precursor of that regiment (33rd foot I believe) had problems in 1815 as they had laid off their band musicians just before the Waterloo campaign - and most of the musicians had headed home to German states...Unfortunately I don't think there is a tunebook lurking in the regimental archives !


J
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on July 08, 2020, 10:45:24 AM
I keep thinking of this month's Theme of the Month: tv tunes and how readily they've been played and obviously practiced for sessions and I'm sure adapted for particular dances as a bit of fun for the dancers.
I remember someone describing traditional musicians as 'magpies of the music world's,,  it seems a fitting description for us!
Q
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Rob2Hook on July 08, 2020, 11:15:59 AM
Very interesting to hear of all these influences on music development.   Also very glad to see that no-one has been tempted to argue their position against/despite others' suggestions.  I've been trying to produce a reference manuscript for each of the dance tunes used by our morris side in the style of our side.  Now that sounds simple yet in my inexpert hands I find standard musical notation cannot express style.  The conclusion I have drawn from this is that whilst the manuscript goes some way to representing the objective I will have to record a performance of the tune to demonstrate the style - and I consider my playing as being rather staid compared to some!

So no matter how good and flexible a notation system is I believe that it will invariably limit the extent to which it can represent dynamics, timing and pitch.  Much has been discussed in threads here on the iniquities of equal temperament and how it changes the character of a tune.  I well remember hearing Menuhin playing Beethoven's violin romances very late in his life.  Some of our party were of the opinion that his powers were diminishing with age as his intonation was "imperfect", but generally those of us who played instruments ourselves enjoyed his pure intonation often said to come from his gypsy origins.  Similarly there have been in my lifetime some pretty much last ditch recordings of singers from very isolated areas whose performances ignore today's musical norms and have a balance and beauty that can never be expressed in notation.

Like other things in life, universal conformity has made modern life possible yet at a high price in the loss of local variation.  Most influences in this process have more to do with increased mobiiity of populations and improved communications, the late C18 seeing a massive acceleration of these changes.

Interesting to note that Sharp's lectures were largely accompanied on a concertina - a recent newcomer and incapable of departing from equal temperament.

Rob.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on July 08, 2020, 12:53:11 PM
This is a fascinating subject, but seems to be characterised by a scarcity of information.

Can anyone recommend a good book with an in depth, knowledgeable discussion of the development of music in Europe, especially Britain.. Particularly, one that doesn't just concern classical music, but, also covers the (to me) far more interesting areas of the development of popular music and dance music  etc. and the inter-relationship of different cultures, prior to the middle 19th century, that includes more than the lyrics to folk songs? The idea seems to get dismissed because of a need to know the unknowable, but there is an enormous amount of information out there.

If not, can someone write one, please? The only man I know who could do this properly is too busy with other projects.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Chris Ryall on July 08, 2020, 01:13:59 PM
.  I well remember hearing Menuhin playing Beethoven's violin romances very late in his life.  Some of our party were of the opinion that his powers were diminishing with age as his intonation was "imperfect", but generally those of us who played instruments ourselves enjoyed his pure intonation often said to come from his gypsy origins.

He had a gypsy teacher, and many friends, eg Grappeli. But with name Yehudi was probably not one himself 🤔
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Squeaky Pete on July 08, 2020, 01:14:27 PM
Vic Gammon is the chap for this, Greg.
I don't know what books he has written, but Mr Google will tell you.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on July 08, 2020, 01:24:14 PM
Vic Gammon is the chap for this, Greg.
I don't know what books he has written, but Mr Google will tell you.

Thanks
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Rob Lands on July 08, 2020, 03:44:44 PM
Books on music development with an emphasis on folk. You probably need to cross from folk music into study of music.  Perhaps move away from Sharpe and Grainger to Karpeles etc? I have been collecting them in a very small way from the second hand market. Perhaps "Folk Music of Britain...and beyond" - Frank Howes might be of interest although on the borderline of academic and factual in will give you a 1969 overview.  He was a professor at the Royal College, a music critic at the Times and editor of the folk song journal for 20 years.  The recent books I have seen tend to be "song based".
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Corinto on July 08, 2020, 04:13:09 PM
In Flanders there are a couple of very good books about folk dance music by Hubert Boone:
- Traditionele Vlaamse Volksliederen en Dansen (2003, 352 pp.)
- Dansmelodieën uit de Vlaamse Volksmuziektraditie (2010, 676 pp.)
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: CAB on July 08, 2020, 05:57:19 PM

For anyone interested in further information about quadrille bands and their influence on folk dance music, I have recently written an article about the quadrille bands of the Yorkshire Dales and two further articles tracing the history of the Reeth Quadrille Band and the Leyburn Quadrille Band. These articles are now in the hands of my webmaster and will appear shortly on my website: www.dalestunes.org.uk.
Fascinating stuff, Bob.  I look forward to the articles when they appear. 

I run a village band (a band playing village band music, not one based in a particular village) and even today the dynamic is always interesting - the lack of comprehension between those who play largely by ear (including the fiddler with the best bowing technique) and the educated sight-readers who stick strictly to the score; the flutists who tongue every note and those who rely on throating and finger articulation.  It's very much the place where cultivated art music and folk music come together.
 
The Rev. Baring Gould had a couple of collecting accomplices who had more fundamental problems collecting. One - sorry, name gone - invented a unique one wheeled carriage to enable them to traverse the uneven terrain of Dartmoor in search of tunes and songs!
Lovely.  I'm reminded of the village player who hired a boy to wheel a barrow containing his bass viol while he marched alongside bowing it!

And I also wonder whether the collections of 'favourite dance tunes for whenever' were big sellers - and whether these tunes were mainly played in the society ballrooms , or were popular in the pub (or gin shop !) as well.
Those which appeared annually for years must have sold pretty well.  Johnson's Choice Collection of Favourite Country Dance Tunes went through eight volumes.  But yes, who was buying them?

Steve Roud's book deals with song, of course, but is helpful on where/when/by whom songs were being performed.  I don't know how much of a link there is to dance music but he is worth reading on the social history.  Rollo Woods has something to say about village bands from a West Gallery perspective in "Good Singing Still".  Vic Gammon's doctoral thesis, with which I'm sure some of you are familiar, focuses on "Popular Music in Rural Society: Sussex 1815-1914".  I don't know either what else he may have produced since then.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on July 08, 2020, 06:05:57 PM
Books on music development with an emphasis on folk. You probably need to cross from folk music into study of music.  Perhaps move away from Sharpe and Grainger to Karpeles etc? I have been collecting them in a very small way from the second hand market. Perhaps "Folk Music of Britain...and beyond" - Frank Howes might be of interest although on the borderline of academic and factual in will give you a 1969 overview.  He was a professor at the Royal College, a music critic at the Times and editor of the folk song journal for 20 years.  The recent books I have seen tend to be "song based".

There is loads of song based stuff, as you say. I'm not so interested in that.

C#  and Maud Karpeles seem to centre, mostly, around later music and don't seem to discuss the nature of the music, so much as where they found it.

i haven't sourced any of Vic Gammon's publications, apart from an academic paper that didn't address my interest directly.  I have emailed him to ask if he can make recommendations.
[I think this is the paper CAB mentions]

What I would like to find is more stuff like Bob Ellis's superb contribution.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on July 08, 2020, 06:10:10 PM
In Flanders there are a couple of very good books about folk dance music by Hubert Boone:
- Traditionele Vlaamse Volksliederen en Dansen (2003, 352 pp.)
- Dansmelodieën uit de Vlaamse Volksmuziektraditie (2010, 676 pp.)

Have you got time to translate?  ;D
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Rob2Hook on July 08, 2020, 06:39:37 PM
He had a gypsy teacher, and many friends, eg Grappeli. But with name Yehudi was probably not one himself 🤔
Yes, sorry Chris - I guess my hurried choice of the term "origins" was inappropriate.  ;D

Can't stop to think when I'm mostly hitting the right keys!

Rob.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Andy Next Tune on July 08, 2020, 09:12:44 PM

Steve Roud's recent book on English Song deals with song........
.......  however there is a chapter at the end of the book written by someone else which specifically discusses the music that was collected. I seem to recall it talks about the relative proportion of modal tunes collected and why they were common/uncommon.

At the moment, the book is with a friend so I can't provide much more assistance.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Peadar on July 08, 2020, 11:08:16 PM
"Improving" on traditional music seems to have been something of a fashion in Gaelic Scotland as well. Much of Marjory Kennedy Fraser's  work as published in the setting of English interpretation appears to have fallen into that bear trap.


Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: CAB on July 09, 2020, 12:13:05 AM

Steve Roud's recent book on English Song deals with song........
.......  however there is a chapter at the end of the book written by someone else which specifically discusses the music that was collected. I seem to recall it talks about the relative proportion of modal tunes collected and why they were common/uncommon.

Iris Bishop's chapter deals specifically with song melodies, not his collecting of dance tunes, though it does have some relevance to the present discussion.  She notes Sharp's interest in modal tunes and his conclusion that these had survived because the singers were interested in melody, not harmony, which is what had hastened the disappearance of the modes in other contexts.  She finds close similarities between Harry Cox's 1960's tune for a song and a published 18th century melody for the same song.  She also suggests that Playford's "approach (to publishing dance music ) was marked by a shift towards a broader audience including those involved in home and tavern music-making."  Many of his tunes, she writes, were those of ballads, some dating from the Elizabethan era and many surviving in basic form to be collected from country singers by members of the Folk Song Society 250 years after Playford's first edition.

So it seems that the singers, whose conscious focus was on text rather than tune (another of Sharp's observations), preserved modal tunes after their virtual disappearance from the instrumental tradition, especially where this involved ensemble playing.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Hugh Taylor on July 09, 2020, 10:52:35 AM
Thanks to all contributors to date, esp Julian and Bob who seemed to have focused on my original query.
I know that the late C19 and early C20 collectors may have reinterpreted what they heard, but I'm not interested in them. What I was referring to was the increasing knowledge that we are building from fiddlers/flute tune book, eg Village Music Project and comparing them to C17 and C18 publications such as Playford, Walsh, etc.
Julian is absolutely correct in that there is research needing to be undertaken, though I'm sure some already has, but where is it?
Chris? Vic? EFDSS?
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Julian S on July 09, 2020, 11:42:37 AM
To me, this would be an excellent subject to research if someone happened to study on the postgrad world music course led by Fay Hield (amongst others) at Sheffield. (But maybe that focusses less on the historical aspects ?)
I wonder if there is anything in back editions of the EFDSS Folk music journal ? Saying that I've just found a reference in an article in the last journal, to an unpublished master thesis by Celia Pendlebury (University of Sheffield 2015 !) 'Jigs, Reels and Hornpipes : A history of 'traditional' dance tunes of Britain and Ireland. Sounds interesting !
The article itself is about John Malchair, 1730- 1812, who categorised and collected tunes - but seemingly focussed more on Welsh, Irish and Scottish tunes.

J



Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on July 09, 2020, 12:08:59 PM
I've lost touch with EFDSS years ago after the C# House debacle caused me to end my membership. I have no idea of their current activities.
I'd have hoped with Sheffield and Newcastle Uni's involvement in folk music that this type of question poses a serious research opportunity if it hasn't already been touched on by them.
Q
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: CAB on July 09, 2020, 12:23:45 PM
Footnote:  For anyone who hasn't seen it, I've temporarily put a copy of Vic Gammon's paper here:

https://www.dropbox.com/sh/ti5u9a6c9a5wdk7/AACDYCagpLgZcaVx0A3GfFNfa?dl=0

Chapter 3 is the most obviously relevant and sections of part 3.  Of, course the discussion of modes is under the section on song.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on July 09, 2020, 12:47:53 PM
... I've just found a reference in an article in the last journal, to an unpublished master thesis by Celia Pendlebury (University of Sheffield 2015 !) 'Jigs, Reels and Hornpipes : A history of 'traditional' dance tunes of Britain and Ireland. Sounds interesting !

Celia Pendlebury is my co-musician colleague with Lizzie Dripping. I will ask her if it is possible for her to make her master's thesis available.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on July 09, 2020, 01:35:19 PM
I've just found a reference in an article in the last journal, to an unpublished master thesis by Celia Pendlebury (University of Sheffield 2015 !) 'Jigs, Reels and Hornpipes : A history of 'traditional' dance tunes of Britain and Ireland. ...


I found it freely avaiable here (you need to register)

http://etheses.whiterose.ac.uk/8262/
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: CAB on July 09, 2020, 02:28:21 PM
Thanks Greg!  Downloaded without registering.  Maybe it remembered me from a previous visit?
Abstract sounds eminently sensible.  WIll look forward to reading the rest.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on July 09, 2020, 02:54:10 PM
I've just found a reference in an article in the last journal, to an unpublished master thesis by Celia Pendlebury (University of Sheffield 2015 !) 'Jigs, Reels and Hornpipes : A history of 'traditional' dance tunes of Britain and Ireland. ...


I found it freely avaiable here (you need to register)

http://etheses.whiterose.ac.uk/8262/

Celia has just given me the same link!
No need to register, but in case of difficulties, here's a direct link to the PDF download (15 MB)...
http://etheses.whiterose.ac.uk/8262/1/Dissertation-Pendlebury-030315.pdf

If you want to put a face to the name, there are photos of Celia here:
http://www.lizziedripping.org.uk/musicians.html
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Corinto on July 09, 2020, 03:17:47 PM
In Flanders there are a couple of very good books about folk dance music by Hubert Boone:
- Traditionele Vlaamse Volksliederen en Dansen (2003, 352 pp.)
- Dansmelodieën uit de Vlaamse Volksmuziektraditie (2010, 676 pp.)
Have you got time to translate?  ;D

Both books are about traditional flemish folk dance music, most pages are music notation as found in different towns or villages, or old tunebooks, and then also text about origin of tunes and dances.

Translation:
- Traditionele Vlaamse Volksliederen en Dansen = Traditional Flemish Folktunes and Dances.
- Dansmelodieën uit de Vlaamse Volksmuziektraditie = Dancetunes from the Flemish Folkmusical Tradition.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Mike Hirst on July 09, 2020, 04:31:40 PM
A useful introduction to the main themes discussed in this thread can be found in David Johnson's book 'Music and Society in Lowland Scotland in the Eighteenth Century (https://www.amazon.co.uk/Society-Lowland-Scotland-Eighteenth-Century/dp/0193164019/ref=sr_1_1?dchild=1&keywords=Music+and+Society+in+Lowland+Scotland&qid=1594308437&sr=8-1)' (Oxford University Press, 1972). Although the context is specifically North British, there is much that is relevant to studies south of the border.

For a more in depth study I can recommend the Christopher Marsh book 'Music and Society in Early modern England (https://www.amazon.co.uk/Music-Society-Early-Modern-England/dp/1107610249/ref=sr_1_1?dchild=1&keywords=Music+and+Society+in+Early+modern+England&qid=1594308534&sr=8-1)' (Cambridge University Press, 2013). Of Particular interest here is the section 'Recreational Musicians', which contains many specific references to the Henry Atkinson manuscript.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Julian S on July 09, 2020, 05:07:46 PM
The thesis by Celia Pendlebury makes very interesting reading - many thanks to Greg - and Steve - for the links.

Julian
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on July 09, 2020, 05:28:15 PM
Thanks Greg!  Downloaded without registering.  Maybe it remembered me from a previous visit?
Abstract sounds eminently sensible.  WIll look forward to reading the rest.

:D You're right. You only need to register if you're uploading. Unlikely, so far as I'm concerned.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Hugh Taylor on July 09, 2020, 07:39:48 PM
I contacted David Atkinson who edits the EFDSS Folk Music Journal, and on of his contacts replied below:-
 A partial answer almost certainly lies in the concept of musica ficta. This refers to a practice in which specific notes in the musical notation would be raised or lowered by a semitone in performance. This certainly affected the 7th of the scale in certain contexts, which is one of the defining notes of the modes most commonly found in folk music. There were theoretical rules about when to make these changes and there was also contemporary performance practice which was absorbed from listening to, and playing, the music. Both seem likely to have played a part in more formal musical training at the time. Nevertheless, there were different kinds of musicians with different training and a variety of contexts which may have called for differing performance practices! So it's hard to be certain as to what really happened in performances and if/how far the theory was followed in practice, when, and by whom.

The main point, however, about musica ficta is that it meant that the notation as published was not necessarily the exact way in which the tune was played by the person reading that notation. We are used to notation being very exact today but this was not so in the past. Therefore the apparent difference between the published tunes and the later handwritten fiddlers' tunebooks may be more apparent than real in this regard. Especially as the published tunebook might be more aimed at more theoretically trained performers who we could surmise had a greater knowledge of musica ficta.

Another reason for the apparently modal nature of some published dance tunes (though by no means all) in the 17th and 18th c. may be to do with the sheer number of moveable type sharps and flats that the printer had at their disposal. I believe Jeremy Barlow has written about this in more detail, but I dont' think it's been generally published. There has been quite a lot of research into the differences in the tune notations between the various editions of Playford's Dancing Master and iit does not seem to have been a straightforward trend towards more 'accurate' or 'literal' notation. Indeed it's hard to account for some of the changes in the uses of accidentals.

All this makes it difficult to assert that earlier publications are evidence of a greater degree of modality in dance tunes. If only electricity and sound recording had made an earlier appearance in history!
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Bob Ellis on July 09, 2020, 10:05:42 PM
Wow, Hugh! That throws a cat among the pigeons! If that claim can be substantiated, then it appears to undermine most of the conclusions we might draw from hand-written music manuscripts and published music books prior to the modern era about changes in the popularity of modal tunes because we can't be sure whether tune notations that appeared modal actually were so. However, I would take a lot of convincing. The sheer number of modal tunes in tunebooks before the 1820s and the rapid diminution of them after that decade suggests that a change was taking place that cannot be explained away in its entirety by musica ficta and performance interpretation.

The reasons for this change are a complex interaction of factors that will take a great deal more study to unravel, if it is possible at all. However, it appears that these factors included the popularity of new dance styles such as the waltz, quadrille, polka and schottische, and the rise in the popularity of military and brass bands. The new dance styles appear to have encouraged a more disciplined style of music that conformed to musical norms more than the tunes for older country dances did. From my own research, I have been struck by how many members of 19th century quadrille bands and other groups of musicians who played for village dances and balls were also members of military or brass bands, where musical discipline was asine qua non.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Julian S on July 10, 2020, 08:54:26 AM
Fascinating ! And I wonder when musica ficta became less common - and I'd like to find out more about the 'rules' that applied. I've always wondered how the tunes in Playford (and Vickers, and Offord's collections)actually sounded in performance back then - now the story is even more complicated. It might be interesting to do some kind of analysis of the character of tunes in available manuscripts and tune books through time - but this might be misleading.

Of course, the latter half of the 18th and early 19th century was a period of much greater mobility in all senses. Putting myself in the position of a local musician back then (and someone who had enough money to afford an instrument!) then I'd be learning the tunes in demand by those who could pay...as well as the friends at the pub. I might have tunes passed on by parents in the tunebook - but just as my modern repertoire has changed the older tunes could be gradually forgotten - or themselves evolved in playing so that the style changed.
I am sure that I would also have learned music from others who might have been in military bands (if I hadn't been myself) - the local militia and Yeomanry also had bands which were seen as an important part of society - I believe that there was competition in attracting the best musicians...but of course we would have to wait for the technological revolution to allow concertinas and melodeons to be invented for better or worse !

J
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Hugh Taylor on July 10, 2020, 03:43:02 PM
Some more thoughts from one of David Atkinson's contacts that seems to make more sense to me. Why would someone copy a tune into their book and then play it differently.
"Not much to add really other than to agree that it is obviously so difficult to know what they actually did play compared to what was written. That said, it does occur to me that when copying from print into their own manuscripts, it would be odd that if the tune was especially relevant to them / favourite in their repertoire, that if there was an important or ‘nice’ or personal melodic variation towards modal or anything else, which they made during performance which wasn’t in the printed copy, that we wouldn’t see at least some of the musicians indicating this in their manuscripts – as an aide memoire perhaps? As opposed to the printed collections these musically literate musicians were able to express their own musicality and personal preference more clearly and directly to us through their manuscripts.

I have forgotten much of what I knew (which was probably very little) about musical ficta, although I always thought it was a feature relevant much earlier than late 18th  and the 19th C so I’m not sure that the amateur musicians writing the manuscripts would have been aware of this, (although like you say, it is a good reminder that what we see on the page was not necessarily what they were playing). I could be very wrong of course but if they were applying melodic changes to their handwritten versions of the tune, again I would have thought there would be marginalia to prompt them possibly, or if it was a late-18th and 19th C practice, then there would be evidence in the form of guidance notes in the printed tutor books or printed tune books they were copying from.

So perhaps it was just more simply that the later 18th and early 19th century musicians were copying, learning and playing more or less what was printed and the fashion had shifted away from modality. It is possible that the increased use of print regulated the melodies, reducing or filtering out the ‘old fashioned’ ways of doing things and the musicians who were after all seeking out popular tunes of the moment, wanted to be playing in a current fashion. Also, it would be odd that if modality was shown in earlier printed music (Playford for eg) then why, by late 18th and 19th century was this now an un-written rule, a ‘dark art’ for those in the know (!), or a performance tool, (with no guidance notes given). What caused the printers to change their ways and remove it? I think it is most likely that fashions changed and modality was no longer considered cool by the young lads playing music, and the tunes they selected weren’t modal. I’m trying to think of late 18th and 19th century tunes books which have Playford (etc) tunes copied into them – it would be interesting to look at those. I presume (but would need to check) they would copy what was written rather than actively remove any modality, so there would be modal tunes in the tune books in that situation. It’s possible that the lack of modality is largely down to the fact that the late 18th and 19th century repertoire is very different from 17th and early 18th century repertoire and the fashion in the modern tunes was more major and minor. Sadly I know of no research in this area."
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Chris Rayner on July 10, 2020, 04:07:40 PM
.  I well remember hearing Menuhin playing Beethoven's violin romances very late in his life.  Some of our party were of the opinion that his powers were diminishing with age as his intonation was "imperfect", but generally those of us who played instruments ourselves enjoyed his pure intonation often said to come from his gypsy origins.

He had a gypsy teacher, and many friends, eg Grappeli. But with name Yehudi was probably not one himself 🤔

He was born in New York of Lithuanian Jewish parents.  His father came from a long line of rabbis.  Not in any sense gypsy.  He did enjoy playing (among other non-classical musical forms) gipsy jazz with Stéphane Grappelli.  Perhaps he had associated with klezmer musicians in his formative years, given his origins that would be likely, but I know of no record of such an association.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on July 10, 2020, 04:55:46 PM
I'm finding the historical nature of this thread fascinating though confess to never quite understanding the meaning of  'modal'
One thing that has struck me was a comment from Roy Dommett when musing on the broader aspects of how our culture affected the Morris. He always maintained that as a society, we always looked forward. The minstrel troupes in the late 1800's edged out the village bands, the Big Bands edged out all before it, then rock and roll etc.
To roll this idea backwards, it makes sense that musicians were always looking for something new.
New tunes in new publications......

I have just opened the post and am looking at a new tune book publishes by our current crop of tune Smith's. It seems to me was always have looked forward...
Q
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Peadar on July 10, 2020, 05:12:14 PM

 (1)Especially as the published tunebook might be more aimed at more theoretically trained performers who we could surmise had a greater knowledge of musica ficta.

(2) Another reason for the apparently modal nature of some published dance tunes (though by no means all) in the 17th and 18th c. may be to do with the sheer number of moveable type sharps and flats that the printer had at their disposal.

(3) it does not seem to have been a straightforward trend towards more 'accurate' or 'literal' notation. Indeed it's hard to account for some of the changes in the uses of accidentals.

Comments:
(1) Substitute "educated players" for " theoretically trained performers"....The bulk market in so far as there was a bulk market would be fairly wealthy individuals - what we might today regard as the "county set" and ata time when music was an essential part of any liberal education - especially female education. And singing was high on the musical agenda.

(2) Moveable type: Late 18th early 19th century music printing appears to have been almost  exclusively on engraved plates- moveable type hardly enters into  the equation.

(3) 18th century notation. I understand that in pieces for keyboard  instruments e.g. harpsichord , A fully developed left hand accompaniment was seldom provided - perhaps a letters to indicate suitable chords. But the composer largely left accompaniement detail to the keyboard player: vamping was normal for the educated player ......which in 1829 is where the original accordeon arrives on the music scene.....Ideal instrument to accompany you on the Grand Tour.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on July 10, 2020, 05:36:14 PM
I'm finding the historical nature of this thread fascinating though confess to never quite understanding the meaning of  'modal'

I would be interested to know just what "modal" should be taken to mean in this context.
There seem to be a fair number of myxoldian, dorian, etc. tunes to be found in 19th C manuscripts and tune books. On the other hand, there do seem to be a lot more accidentals in earlier music notation, particularly (but not only) in the minor keys..
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Hugh Taylor on July 10, 2020, 05:48:06 PM
I would be interested to know just what "modal" should be taken to mean in this context.

When I refer to a tune as being modal, I'm generally meaning that it is not in a major key. They are most likely to be Dorian or Aeolian, and as Tone Dumb Greg as said are likely to have a fair sprinkling of accidentals, which makes playing on a 2 row, or even a 2.5 row rather 'challenging'!   
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on July 10, 2020, 05:55:11 PM
(3) 18th century notation. I understand that in pieces for keyboard  instruments e.g. harpsichord , A fully developed left hand accompaniment was seldom provided - perhaps a letters to indicate suitable chords. But the composer largely left accompaniement detail to the keyboard player: vamping was normal for the educated player ......which in 1829 is where the original accordeon arrives on the music scene.....Ideal instrument to accompany you on the Grand Tour.

Yes - you are broadly correct. Often the keyboard player was expected to improvise and provide a chordal accompaniment within the general expected harmonic styles of the period. But chord letters were not used; it was a 'figured bass' consisting of numbers written beneath a simple bass stave. The numbers indicated the intervals and inversions of the chords implicit by the notated bass note. I never really got to grips with the theory of it, but there's a fairly comprehensive explanation here:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Figured_bass

Figured bass is still in use today, in as much that keyboard players of baroque music are expected to 'realise' (i.e. expand and interpret) the figured bass notation in the written music.

Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Bob Ellis on July 10, 2020, 09:23:02 PM
I would be interested to know just what "modal" should be taken to mean in this context.

When I refer to a tune as being modal, I'm generally meaning that it is not in a major key. They are most likely to be Dorian or Aeolian, and as Tone Dumb Greg as said are likely to have a fair sprinkling of accidentals, which makes playing on a 2 row, or even a 2.5 row rather 'challenging'!   

This may be splitting hairs, and is a little off topic, but is it actually valid to define modal tunes as tunes in minor keys? As I understand it (but my music theory is self-taught, so might be inaccurate), strictly speaking all tunes are modal. Tunes in a major key that resolve on the key note are in the Ionian mode, so a tune with a key signature of one sharp that resolves on a G note is in the Ionian mode of G. In practice, we don't refer to the Ionian mode, but just say that the tune is in G major. Any tune with one sharp (F#) that is not in G major is regarded as modal, but there are six different modal structures besides the Ionian mode, depending on the note on which the scale of the tune starts and finishes. Continuing with the example of tunes with one sharp, tunes that start and finish on
A are in the Dorian mode;
B are in the Phrygian mode;
C are in the Lydian mode;
D are in the Mixolydian mode;
E are in the Aeolian mode (i.e. tunes that are in the relative minor);
and F# are in the Locrian mode.

An area of uncertainty for me is which of these modes are major, which are minor, or whether dividing them into major or minor modes is even a valid or worthwhile exercise.
My understanding, hazy though it is, thinks that the Ionian, Lydian, and Mixolydian modes are major; the Dorian, Phrygian, Aeolian, and Locrian modes are minor. I remember this by thinking of the three chord trick - I, IV and V. The modes that start and finish on the 1st, 4th and 5th notes of the scale are major and the others are minor. So, to return to my starting point, I don't think all of the tunes that are thought of as modal are in minor keys: it depends on the mode that they are in as to whether they are major or minor.

I would be grateful if someone with a sounder knowledge of musical theory could confirm or correct this.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Peadar on July 10, 2020, 11:17:15 PM
Replying to Bob, if only so someone with a better grip can correct me if I am wrong....
If the tune resolves on a note that means it finishes on that note and that note is the key defining  "fundemental" of the tune.
The difference between a major and a minor key is that the step from fundemental to third in a major key is 4 semitones, but in a minor key is only 3 semitones.....


Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on July 11, 2020, 12:19:18 AM
I don't think Locrian is major or minor, just weird. Otherwise  my understanding is the same as yours.

My impression is that this is not quite what Hugh means, though.

fwiw, I just took a look at my pdf copy of the Skene manuscript. This is made up of popular tunes tabulated for the lute and  dates around the end of the 16th C and the start of the 17thC. Looking at the first  twenty tunes, they are set in:

Ionian: 4 1/2
Dorian: 1
Phrygian : 1 1/2
Lydian: 0
Mixolydian: 6
Aeolian: 7
Locrian: 0

I think I might spend a few  isolation hours going through the rest of the MS and, maybe look at a few others from the next 200 years, or thereabouts.

The results may be biased by the fact that most of the documents I have from this period are Scottish. I could serve as a rough estimate of the modality of the tunes and indicate any trends.

Replying to Bob, if only so someone with a better grip can correct me if I am wrong....
If the tune resolves on a note that means it finishes on that note and that note is the key defining  "fundemental" of the tune.
The difference between a major and a minor key is that the step from fundemental to third in a major key is 4 semitones, but in a minor key is only 3 semitones.....




What you are saying is right  for most tunes Peader, though it can be tricky to pin down what the resolving note is. Also, like any rule, there can be exceptions. With some tunes the tonic (or, fundamental) and/or the mode seem to shift around.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Calum on July 11, 2020, 08:12:12 AM
On the meaning of 'modal' perhaps the best definition was given by Tom Lehrer, who explained in performance that "for the benefit of those without musical knowledge, this means that from time to time I play a wrong note" - a statement about which much could be said.

As far as minor keys go, the modal descriptors are perhaps useful to distinguish natural minors, Dorian modes, and other scales with a flat third, all of which tend to be described as "minor" to unsuspecting guitarists. 
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on July 11, 2020, 08:38:42 AM

As far as minor keys go, the modal descriptors are perhaps useful to distinguish natural minors, Dorian modes, and other scales with a flat third, all of which tend to be described as "minor" to unsuspecting guitarists.

E dorian
"Just pretend it's in E minor, but use A major chords instead of A minor. Oh, and don't touch the C major. You'll be fine."
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Gena Crisman on July 11, 2020, 02:40:29 PM
I'm pretty sure that most of the time, when someone's describing a tune as being 'modal' nowadays, it's more that they're avoiding being 'wrong' while still conveying that a tune does not fit our pattern for a common major tune. So, I think it's a pragmatic assessment, rather than a theoretical one.

This thread is not remotely any area of my expertise. However, accompanying mode based tunes in a (relatively) modern style is something I do do a lot of. Honestly, I think many people just don't learn how to do it, and treat the seemingly simple ways to accompany normal 'major' and 'minor' tunes as though they were incomprehensible magic runes, etched upon stone. I imagine the same issues were experienced by previous generations as well; if no clear instruction is given on how to accompany a tune, then, you have to figure it out. People who've been playing many years struggle with this still, today, with access to books, recordings of other players, and the internet.

Plus, there's no reason one can't write eg the word 'green' in a song about the colour 'orange'. Similarly, there are no rules that a tune, 'modal' or otherwise, has to keep to one scale the whole time, you could have an Aeolian chorus and a Dorian Verse, or perhaps a brief Lydian moment. I feel the issues presented in looking at old scores is akin to interpreting eg Shakespeare - there's the question of what to do with the words that are on the page, but also the question of, are the words on the page even 'correct'? Do we even still even have the correct word... or, did the person who wrote this down?

To Bob, yes, for surviving music in the modern day, I think dividing the modes up into those with a major tonic chord and minor tonic chord is worthwhile. It's also worthwhile to mostly ignore Locrian, as thinking about using it is a lot like looking at a bag of nuts and eyeing up the shells as though they're some delicious, misunderstood delicacy. Then again, the 'logic' that to my ear it is useless, sour, & unpleasant, could be exactly the motivation of the changes being considered in this thread. Also almost everything has no bearing outside of 12-TET, which many instruments, eg the human voice, only vaguely subscribe to.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: CAB on July 11, 2020, 04:58:04 PM
Agreed - the term modal is often used as a cover when the speaker has a pretty hazy understanding of it.  I love modal tunes but sometimes find I'm on safer ground talking about minor 3rds and 7ths than minor scales.  Yes, we perceive a scale with a minor 3rd as a minor scale but more than once I've heard guitar-playing accompanists in sessions mistake mixolydian for minor, despite it's major 3rd.  A while ago, I taught one of my own tunes, in A mixolydian, to a group of non-folkies, who thought it sounded very minor-ish.  In both cases, it's the surprise minor 7th that's having an effect on the listener.

Yes, Bob, is there any difference between major scale and ionian mode?  I've never found one.  Didn't someone suggest a while ago that it was to do with how they're harmonised???  Beats me.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Anahata on July 11, 2020, 06:13:30 PM
is there any difference between major scale and ionian mode?

No.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on July 11, 2020, 06:33:20 PM
... It's also worthwhile to mostly ignore Locrian...

I can't remember ever hearing a tune set in the locrian mode. If I have I instantly forgot it  ??? ;D
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Lester on July 11, 2020, 06:43:51 PM
I can't remember ever hearing a tune set in the locrian mode. If I have I instantly forgot it  ??? ;D
There's John Kirkpatrick's song Dust to Dust sung here by Jon Boden
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IONfXsgRYZY (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IONfXsgRYZY)
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on July 11, 2020, 07:11:06 PM
I can't remember ever hearing a tune set in the locrian mode. If I have I instantly forgot it  ??? ;D
There's John Kirkpatrick's song Dust to Dust sung here by Jon Boden
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IONfXsgRYZY (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IONfXsgRYZY)

Thanks Lester. More listenable than I expected. Sounds rather like the phrygian mode-ish.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Peadar on July 11, 2020, 07:29:49 PM
Gena - We can be pretty sure that what we have of Shakespeare is pretty much as he scribed it, if only because printing reached Englandshire in the mid 15th century. Shakespeare and other significant English playwrights and poets of the late 16th and early 17th got into print in their own lifetimes.

In the contemporary Bardic traditions of Gaelic Ireland and Scotland scribing was not unkown but printing was not available.

If it is written down it is on the historical record....the challenge and question arises when one starts collecting something from an aural tradition and casting it into a written form which carries it's own baggage.

An interesting comment appears in Margaret Fay Shaw's Folksongs and Folklore of South Uist ..."A comment some people make on first hearing Gaelic songs, is that all the tunes sound alike. This is because such people cannot accustom their ears to any other than the major and minor scales. That is why some collectors in the past ave changed notes to sound more 'agreeable', or brought the final note of a tune to where they felt it should be. To this day (1955) accompaniements are being written with notes which are not in the scale of the tune. We must forget the scales to which we are accustomed, and listen anew."

She goes on to say that there are many opinions on the subject of modes in folk music and refers to the modes of the songs in her book being named according to Mr. AH Fox Strangways' system. She gives a key to this system...which I don't really understand but if anyone requests it I'll put up a pdf.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on July 11, 2020, 08:28:41 PM


She goes on to say that there are many opinions on the subject of modes in folk music and refers to the modes of the songs in her book being named according to Mr. AH Fox Strangways' system. She gives a key to this system...which I don't really understand but if anyone requests it I'll put up a pdf.

Yes please    ;D                   
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Bob Ellis on July 11, 2020, 08:58:42 PM
I can't remember ever hearing a tune set in the locrian mode. If I have I instantly forgot it  ??? ;D
There's John Kirkpatrick's song Dust to Dust sung here by Jon Boden
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IONfXsgRYZY (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IONfXsgRYZY)

A quick search through my digital tune collection reveals that Yannick's Mazurka and La Prapoutische are both in Bm Locrian and each of the following tunes has either the A-music or the B-music in the Locrian mode: Cammeronians Ranto; Sunshine; Jupes Fendues; Bourrée de Concours; Misirlou; Jan Mijne Man; Les Patins Blancs; Asclepius; Hanter Dro No.23; and La Tripolitaine. This suggests that while Locrian tunes are quite rare and that, while they are less rare on the continent, they are not entirely unknown in Britain.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Gena Crisman on July 11, 2020, 09:29:52 PM
Can you supply/link to any of those scores? When looking up tunes with those names on abcnotation / thesession / folktunefinder, none of the ones I can find are in any kind of locrian.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on July 11, 2020, 09:34:05 PM
A quick search through my digital tune collection reveals that Yannick's Mazurka and La Prapoutische are both in Bm Locrian and each of the following tunes has either the A-music or the B-music in the Locrian mode: Cammeronians Ranto; Sunshine; Jupes Fendues; Bourrée de Concours; Misirlou; Jan Mijne Man; Les Patins Blancs; Asclepius; Hanter Dro No.23; and La Tripolitaine. This suggests that while Locrian tunes are quite rare and that, while they are less rare on the continent, they are not entirely unknown in Britain.[/color]

I am not familiar with most of those tunes but, Jan Mijne Mann is one I play. The setting I know doesn't seem  locrian, as far as I can see. More like aeolian.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Peadar on July 11, 2020, 09:35:04 PM


She goes on to say that there are many opinions on the subject of modes in folk music and refers to the modes of the songs in her book being named according to Mr. AH Fox Strangways' system. She gives a key to this system...which I don't really understand but if anyone when Greg requests it I'll put up a pdf.

Yes please    ;D                 
Sin agad e :D - not a great pdf but  I only have the "perfect bound" 1999 reprint and I don't want to break it's spine. ::)

Missing...last word on page 76 "without" and below the "key" to Strangway's system on page 77 "It is difficult to assign...."
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on July 11, 2020, 10:11:27 PM


She goes on to say that there are many opinions on the subject of modes in folk music and refers to the modes of the songs in her book being named according to Mr. AH Fox Strangways' system. She gives a key to this system...which I don't really understand but if anyone when Greg requests it I'll put up a pdf.

Yes please    ;D                 
Sin agad e :D - not a great pdf but  I only have the "perfect bound" 1999 reprint and I don't want to break it's spine. ::)

Missing...last word on page 76 "without" and below the "key" to Strangway's system on page 77 "It is difficult to assign...."

Thanks Peader. That is not the  clearest way I have ever seen of understanding modes. Possibly the muddiest puddle on the street.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Peadar on July 11, 2020, 11:38:34 PM

Thanks Peader. That is not the  clearest way I have ever seen of understanding modes. Possibly the muddiest puddle on the street.

The reference to variable notes seems to tie in with a much earlier post in the thread..... She (Margaret Fay Shaw) also seems to be saying that she is referring to pentatonic modes - Reading the key a few times I start to see that the numbers allocated to fundementals eg C 4/7 correspond to the "variable" notes F and B. In key of D F and B are respectively 3rd and 5th notes ... hence D 3/5 etc.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Gena Crisman on July 12, 2020, 01:56:01 AM
Ref the book scan from Peadar, I love the idea of trying to explain modes using both a parallel scales and a relative scales approach all at the same time, while also telling us to also forget everything we know about scales in the paragraph just before. A muddy puddle, indeed.

I've watched/read quite a bit about teaching people about the modes of the major scale and what I generally see is that there's a lot of different ways of explaining how they can work and it's usually about finding the 'right' one for how someone thinks about/experiences music/their instrument. Perhaps the one in the book is just right for someone. Then again, the explanations/ways of thinking about them back a couple hundred years was probably pretty different as well.

One thing that I would describe as perhaps a misconception that I think people tend to have is the idea that modal tunes implicitly can not 'resolve' in some way, or have a fundamental feeling of awkwardness that our 'modern' ears (or those of previous generations) struggle to tolerate. Awkwardness certainly exists, but, I think it's entirely independent and can exist in any tune, Ionian or no.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Roger Hare on July 12, 2020, 06:40:32 AM
This is probably an off-topic 'side thread', so I'll be as brief as possible...
Can you supply/link to any of those scores? When looking up tunes with those names on abcnotation / thesession / folktunefinder, none of the ones I can find are in any kind of locrian.
I can't link to any of those, but I did find this which may be Locrian:
Code: [Select]
X:136
%From Sylvain Pirons web site - www.tradfrance.com.
T:POLKA PIQUEE DE PLOEUC
Z:Yves Belotteau
M:4/4
L:1/8
Q:1/4=120
K:C
% Last note suggests Locrian mode tune
| c2 g2 g2 fe f2 g2 a3 z | G2 a2 g2 fe d2 g2 e2 c2 | c2 g2 g2 fe f2 g2 a3 z | G2 a2 g2 fe d2 g2 c3 z |
g3 z e2 fe d2 d2 e2 c2 | G3 z e2 fe d2 d2 B3 z | G3 z e2 fe d2 d2 e2 c2 | G3 z e2 fe d2 d2 B3 |
The ...Last note... comment is from the original transcriber, or some subsequent 'editor', not from myself.

Is it Locrian, then? Why? Why not? After 6 years, I still can't really get my head around how to decide the mode of a tune...

There's also James Fitton's 'Rainbow Jigs', the last part of which ('Purple Jig') is F#Locrian. See:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,18359.msg232135.html#msg232135 (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,18359.msg232135.html#msg232135)
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Anahata on July 12, 2020, 07:55:23 AM
I can't remember ever hearing a tune set in the locrian mode. If I have I instantly forgot it  ??? ;D
There's John Kirkpatrick's song Dust to Dust sung here by Jon Boden
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IONfXsgRYZY (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IONfXsgRYZY)

Thanks Lester. More listenable than I expected. Sounds rather like the phrygian mode-ish.
I've heard JK point out that he doesn't use the 6th note of the scale in it, as that would pull the key centre too strongly in other directions.
So it could be Phrygian.

Edit: PS - that's rubbish, it couldn't possibly be Phrygian. Sorry for posting while not properly awake.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on July 12, 2020, 08:52:21 AM
I've heard JK point out that he doesn't use the 6th note of the scale in it, as that would pull the key centre too strongly in other directions.
So it could be Phrygian.

Are you sure that was the 6th note of the scale and not the 5th? It's the flattened 5th that makes the scale so weird.
My ears are not clever enough to be certain, but I don't think I can hear a flattened 5th in JB's song.

The 6th note in the phrygian is the same as the 6th in the locrian. [Edit: Actually, on reflection,  I think this statement is probably wrong]

Maybe Hugh should have his thread back now   (:)
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on July 12, 2020, 08:58:13 AM
Not wishing to hi-jack this thread further, but Celia Pendlebury has informed me of a forthcoming conference which may well cover some of the subject matter discussed here. Could be very interesting...

I've started a new topic about it here:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,25769.msg306700.html#new
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Anahata on July 12, 2020, 10:59:36 AM
I've heard JK point out that he doesn't use the 6th note of the scale in it, as that would pull the key centre too strongly in other directions.
So it could be Phrygian.

Are you sure that was the 6th note of the scale and not the 5th? It's the flattened 5th that makes the scale so weird.
My ears are not clever enough to be certain, but I don't think I can hear a flattened 5th in JB's song.

You're right, it was far too early in the morning.
His tune, sung in B locrian, doesn't have a G, which is the 6th of the scale. That part is correct.
But it definitely could not be Phrygian - pretend I never said that.  :|bl
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: CAB on July 12, 2020, 11:51:44 AM
Gapped scales can be ambiguous - the first half of the slip jig The Cock and The Hen is sometimes referred to as F#minor and could be interpreted as aeolian (I think  :o) but the absence of the second step (G or G#) means it could be heard as Phrygian.  The second half goes into A major, though still without that G/G#.  I once played it at a session (nobody joined in  :-\ ) and someone murmured "phrygian" when I'd finished. 
Happy to be corrected - my head is starting to hurt.  (of course the abc key sig below is just there to define the number of sharps)

T: The Cock And The Hen
R: slip jig
M: 9/8
L: 1/8
K: Bmin
~F3 FEF c2 A | ~F3 FEF AFE | ~F3 FEF c2 d | ecA BAF AFE :|
ecA ABc d2 f | ecA ABc BAF | ecA ABc d2 B | cBA BAF AFE :|
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Gena Crisman on July 12, 2020, 12:47:54 PM
I would also be in favour of perhaps an additional thread; somewhere where we can all be wrong about modes, together. Things are often subjective enough that you can talk about them until your ears fall off.

Is it Locrian, then?
No, this is not Locrian, and, to be real with you, basically nothing is Locrian.

There's also James Fitton's 'Rainbow Jigs', the last part of which ('Purple Jig') is F#Locrian. See:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,18359.msg232135.html#msg232135 (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,18359.msg232135.html#msg232135)
Thank you for this link, I don't recall ever having seen this. I've done the same thing as the composer here, writing 1 tune per mode, and am about ready to record it properly.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Roger Hare on July 12, 2020, 03:36:05 PM
(1) I would also be in favour of perhaps an additional thread; somewhere where we can all be wrong about modes,
together
. Things are often subjective enough that you can talk about them until your ears fall off.

(2) No, this is not Locrian, and, to be real with you, basically nothing is Locrian.

(3) Thank you for this link, I don't recall ever having seen this. I've done the same thing as the composer here,
writing 1 tune per mode, and am about ready to record it properly.

(1) Yes please - me too. I was a little wary about going so far off-topic (a favourite hobby of mine) - clang...👂👂👂
There are 'child boards' for ABC and for Stolen Instruments, so one for Modes might be feasible?

(2) Yes, I was a bit hesitant about posing the question. The non-existence of locrian is a 'factoid' of which I've been
aware since 1968 - literally decades before I ever put my grubby hands on a musical instrument in cold blood.

"...if The Si-mode, which churchmen call locrian, occurs in our folk song, it has hardly been noticed..."
(Lloyd, A.L., Folk Song in England, p.40, Faber & Faber, London, 2008, 978-0-571-24547-5. First published 1967(8?).

(3) My pleasure! There is a slightly more 'detailed' ABC transcription by Paul Hardy floating around - somewhere
on his web site, I guess...
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on July 12, 2020, 10:35:01 PM
Gapped scales can be ambiguous - the first half of the slip jig The Cock and The Hen is sometimes referred to as F#minor and could be interpreted as aeolian (I think  :o) but the absence of the second step (G or G#) means it could be heard as Phrygian.  The second half goes into A major, though still without that G/G#.  I once played it at a session (nobody joined in  :-\ ) and someone murmured "phrygian" when I'd finished. 


A major something. Doesn't really matter what because it doesn't call for an E chord. One worth moving to Gena's mode thread.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Peadar on July 12, 2020, 11:11:30 PM
I understand that this thread is really about the question of whether and how English folk music might have quite abruptly changed at the end of the 18th century. There is lot of evidence for the music of Gaidhlig society being hijacked/converted into something that served London centric (or more accurately) Royal court centric patronage at the end of the 18th century. This cultural appropriation was contemporary with the Highland Clearances -but does not imply that the music of the community was fundementally changed within the community- indeed the evidence is that it wasn't
Drawing attention to Gaidhlig music as I have done can only cast a sidelight on what may or may  not have happened to English music under roughly the same time frame. English folk music may well  have been at a comparative disadvantage- because it had no seperate linguistic reservoir.

I don't think I have anything more to add to this very interesting question and so will retire gracefully from the thread.

Peadar
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Peadar on July 15, 2020, 11:43:09 PM
Was it not in the late eighteenth century that Even Temperament replaced just temperament tuning?

 That virtually ironed out modes as they would have been understood in the sixteenth century when the idea of modality was developed.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on July 16, 2020, 09:35:04 AM
Was it not in the late eighteenth century that Even Temperament replaced just temperament tuning?

Yes. I believe it became common in Europe about1790 and got taken up in England a bit later. Prior to that Well Temperament was commonly used for keyboard instruments. Worked better in some keys, than others (Bach even wrote a piece to demonstrate this, The Well Tempered Clavier) Mostly, but not only,  tied in with the rise in popularity of keyboard instruments. I think it was Galileo's father who started the ball rolling around 1600. Took a few years to make it work. There was a particular interval in Well Temperament (the Wolf Interval) that made some keys howl.

https://www.kylegann.com/histune.html

Quote
That virtually ironed out modes as they would have been understood in the sixteenth century when the idea of modality was developed.

That may be true but, if so, I don't quite see why. It will have changed the way a particular mode (or any type of key, come to that) sounded, but that could be seen to actually facilitate playing in modes by levelling out the worst discords (all be it, at the expense of the sweetest harmonies) and making a lot of modes sound better.

Let's face, we still like the sound of modes today (except, possibly, for the Locrian  ;D).
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on July 16, 2020, 10:00:55 AM
Thanks for that link Greg, it helped me to understand a little about equal temperament.
I think a few reads of it will help further!
Q
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Winston Smith on July 16, 2020, 10:08:07 AM
"Let's face, we still like the sound of modes today (except, possibly, for the Locrian"

Dunno about that, Greg. After listening again to JK's Ashes to Ashes, I really like the sound of that. In fact, I think it's so outstandingly good to listen to that I'm going back to YouTube just now!!!
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on July 16, 2020, 11:59:10 AM
"Let's face, we still like the sound of modes today (except, possibly, for the Locrian"

Dunno about that, Greg. After listening again to JK's Ashes to Ashes, I really like the sound of that. In fact, I think it's so outstandingly good to listen to that I'm going back to YouTube just now!!!

Ashes to Ashes is an exception...and I'm not convinced it's locrian since it misses the characteristic flattened 5th that makes locrian  sound so weird.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Anahata on July 16, 2020, 07:25:34 PM
It definitely has that flat fifth note.

B,2C D2E | F2D B2c | B2A F2E | D2C DB,2-B,3 
(near enough, from memory)
B is the home note and the F natural is a diminished fifth above it.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Winston Smith on July 16, 2020, 07:46:09 PM
Please excuse my complete ignorance, but about these "flattened" this and "flattened" that which I often come across in Melnet discussions. That means that tunes in this mode (or whichever tune needs these flattened thirds, fifths, sevenths or whatever) cannot be played on ordinary melodeons which are tuned to equal temperament, yes? Unless, that is, there is some mechanism for flattening notes on the fly, so to speak? 
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: CAB on July 16, 2020, 07:55:55 PM
You just have to start the scale in a different place.  So if the tune is A mixolydian you can play it in A on the D row and you'll get A with a flattened 7th (i.e. G natural instead of G sharp).  In practice, some row-crossing helps to get the chords right if you want to use them.  Don't worry about temperament, which is something more subtle that most of mere mortals can happily leave to the experts.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Winston Smith on July 16, 2020, 08:37:18 PM
I'm sorry, but that doesn't make any sense at all! Why would anyone call it a flattened G# when in actual fact, it's just a G?
Actually, never mind. I'm obviously a long long way out of my depth. Just go back to your discussions, but thanks anyway.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on July 16, 2020, 08:41:26 PM
Please excuse my complete ignorance, but about these "flattened" this and "flattened" that which I often come across in Melnet discussions. That means that tunes in this mode (or whichever tune needs these flattened thirds, fifths, sevenths or whatever) cannot be played on ordinary melodeons which are tuned to equal temperament, yes? Unless, that is, there is some mechanism for flattening notes on the fly, so to speak?

I find flattened this and thats confusing as a rule, but the locrian mode is unique in that it is the 5th note that is flattened. The fundamental chord (i.e., G major in the scale of G major, etc.) is (within the limits of intonation, which has the same effect on all modes, in equal temperament, so let's ignore it) a perfect 5th in every mode except locrian, which has a flattened 5th (aka diminished), this means that the difference sticks out like the proverbial sore thumb. The effect is not subtle.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Peadar on July 16, 2020, 11:03:28 PM
Please excuse my complete ignorance, but about these "flattened" this and "flattened" that which I often come across in Melnet discussions. That means that tunes in this mode (or whichever tune needs these flattened thirds, fifths, sevenths or whatever) cannot be played on ordinary melodeons which are tuned to equal temperament, yes? Unless, that is, there is some mechanism for flattening notes on the fly, so to speak? 

Simple guide to modes

Ionian:       Do re mi fa so la ti do
Dorian:       Re mi fa so la ti do re
Phrygian:    Mi fa so la ti do re mi
Lydian:       Fa so la ti do re mi fa
Mixolodian: So la ti do re mi fa so
Aeolian:      La ti do re mi fa so la
Locrian:      Ti do re mi fa so la ti
   ......which brings us back to Do!:

The notes for " Twinkle twinkle little star" (first line) -Ionian (the scale as we know it normally) Do Do so so la la so: fa fa mi mi re re Do:

To get the tune in locrian take everything down a note

Ti Ti fa fa so so fa: mi mi re re do do Ti:

The tune is still unmistakeably "Twinkle twinkle" but sounds very different.

Composers generally avoid Locrian because the fifth is not perfect in comparison with all the other modes...pull second and fourth button together (Ti & fa) and you'll see what I mean.

Give it a try!






Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: CAB on July 16, 2020, 11:34:32 PM
Please excuse my complete ignorance, but about these "flattened" this and "flattened" that which I often come across in Melnet discussions. That means that tunes in this mode (or whichever tune needs these flattened thirds, fifths, sevenths or whatever) cannot be played on ordinary melodeons which are tuned to equal temperament, yes? Unless, that is, there is some mechanism for flattening notes on the fly, so to speak?

Greg has a good point but locrian is pretty obscure.  As he says, the other modes have a perfect 5th (7 semitones from the tonic or home note). 
Taking the more commonly used modes, it may be more useful to think of major and minor 3rds and 7ths rather than flattened ones.
If you're in A, the note of C is 3 semitones up from A.  That's a minor 3rd.  Hence an A minor chord = A + C + E
The note C# is 4 semitones from A.  That's a major 3rd.  Hence an A major chord = A + C# + E
Still in A, G is 10 semitones up - a minor 7th; while G# is 11 semitones up - a major 7th.

The mixolydian mode has a major 3rd and a minor 7th:  A B C# D E F# G A.  The reason people talk about a flattened 7th is because they are comparing it with the major scale (or ionian mode): A B C# D E F# G# A.

D mixolydian is D E F# G A B C D
So if you want to play a tune in D mixolydian on a DG melodeon, snatch a C from the G row instead of using the C# from the D row.

Peadar's way of looking at it is really helpful even if you don't do tonic solfa.  Same sequence of notes but starting in a different place.
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Chris Ryall on July 17, 2020, 01:54:25 PM


    modal stuff moved to modal thread as per Hugh below  (:)
Title: Re: Change in music at the end of the C18?
Post by: Hugh Taylor on July 17, 2020, 03:11:45 PM
Thanks to all the contributors to this thread.

I should have realised in my original query that when I mentioned modality it would open up a can of worms. I should have said something like 'quirkiness' instead. Most of the contributions seem to have been about the various modes, and its probably a good thing that a new thread has been started under 'Tunes'. Perhaps we should draw a line under mode discussion on this thread, and try and restrict it to my original query?

The two main good things to come out of the thread have both been thanks to Steve. The Tune Conference on Oct 10/11, and the dissertation by Celia Pendlebury that I found interesting. Celia makes the point in a number of places that modal changes were not uncommon, possibly due to things like instrument restrictions, transcription errors, or the practice of the day.

More research needed!
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal