Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Alan Morley on July 23, 2020, 08:51:39 AM
-
Does anyone know of anyone selling new wooden grills ? My ISIS box is looking it's age...
-
Hi Alan
Have you tried Pete Ward at Acorn Instruments? He can probably help, he's done a wonderful job on a replacement grille for a mate's Tommy.
-
Thanks for the suggestion :)
-
I'm looking for a wooden grill as well (for a Saltarelle chromatic) and I'm thinking of just designing my own and having it laser cut by these people. Total cost around 50-60 USD for a 10x30cm rectangle of (in my case) walnut... https://www.ponoko.com/materials/walnut-hardwood
-
I'm looking for a wooden grill as well (for a Saltarelle chromatic) and I'm thinking of just designing my own and having it laser cut by these people. Total cost around 50-60 USD for a 10x30cm rectangle of (in my case) walnut... https://www.ponoko.com/materials/walnut-hardwood
Apart from it seeming fairly normal to consign 1 row grills to history...if you're a proper player >:E , are you going to copy the Salterelle design? The harp thing seems pretty standard.
-
To be honest, Greg, I have never been a big fan of their grills on the larger chromatics. It's not the simple floral harp you'd see on, say, a Bouebe - it's bit of a frenetic art deco butterfly-themed mess, if you ask me.
http://www.saltarelle.com/sites/default/files/chaville-4r-o.jpg
-
To be honest, Greg, I have never been a big fan of their grills on the larger chromatics. It's not the simple floral harp you'd see on, say, a Bouebe - it's bit of a frenetic art deco butterfly-themed mess, if you ask me.
http://www.saltarelle.com/sites/default/files/chaville-4r-o.jpg
Hmm. See what you mean. Maybe that's the real reason they get binned. I'll try and get a picture of the grill on my old 2.4 row Salterelle in the morning. I rather like it. You may too.
-
I also need a replacement bass -end plate for a Salterelle. I hand planned on making one, but I don’t know where to obtain the correct thickness and type of plywood. Any suggestions.
-
I also need a replacement bass -end plate for a Salterelle. I hand planned on making one, but I don’t know where to obtain the correct thickness and type of plywood. Any suggestions.
If it's cherry, perhaps one of these:
https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/1-Solid-American-Cherry-wood-Sheets-3mm-4mm-6mm-or-8mm/112654549027
-
I also need a replacement bass -end plate for a Salterelle. I hand planned on making one, but I don’t know where to obtain the correct thickness and type of plywood. Any suggestions.
If it's cherry, perhaps one of these:
https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/1-Solid-American-Cherry-wood-Sheets-3mm-4mm-6mm-or-8mm/112654549027
I think for a bass end plate you would be better off with plywood for strength.
-
I also need a replacement bass -end plate for a Salterelle. I hand planned on making one, but I don’t know where to obtain the correct thickness and type of plywood. Any suggestions.
B&Q or any local builder's merchant or boat yard. You want something with a fair face, probably 4mm- but you need to check the depth of the recess in the bass end casing. An off cut of marine ply is probably ideal unless you can use the rest of a 4 foot x 8 foot sheet. Failing that B&Q used to sell smaller sheets of it's thnner plywoods- because much of it's custom was for small DIY jobs.
-
I have found that the cheaper the plywood, the more gaps there are in the internal layers of the sandwich. So if you're making something like a grille, or a bass end plate, you need to invest in decent quality ply. Nothing is more annoying than cutting or drilling a hole or design, than finding you are left with 2 ply when you expected 3.
SJ
-
To be honest, Greg, I have never been a big fan of their grills on the larger chromatics. It's not the simple floral harp you'd see on, say, a Bouebe - it's bit of a frenetic art deco butterfly-themed mess, if you ask me.
http://www.saltarelle.com/sites/default/files/chaville-4r-o.jpg
Hmm. See what you mean. Maybe that's the real reason they get binned. I'll try and get a picture of the grill on my old 2.4 row Salterelle in the morning. I rather like it. You may too.
Photo of piroulet grill attached.
It's the same sort of thing, but less fussy. I rather like it
-
Photo of piroulet grill attached.
It's the same sort of thing, but less fussy. I rather like it
That's quite nice. I like the effect of the semicircle breaking up the filigree.
I've been looking for inspiration from various sources. These are very impressive, and done by hand:
http://www.accordions.com/kevin/n_kauriaccordion_unveiling.htm
Re: ply vs. solid wood on bass plates, that makes sense. I wonder if a salvaged fan blade would be a good fit.
-
As wooden grills are being discussed, I have an aesthetics question. I recently made a wooden grill for an old Club, as the metal one was very rusty and stained. Just adapted an old design I saw in the internet. Problem is I don't much like it. What do others think? Is a non-original rusty grill better than a new wooden one? Picture attached.
-
Dave, that looks pretty good to me. Did you have it laser cut, as I am considering doing? The color fits in the black-brown-red palette pretty well. Though, I guess the same could be said for rust. The wood does look newer than the rest, but your options are limited if you don't want to resort to "antiquing" it artificially...I guess you could put it on a chair in a pub for a few weeks and see if it ages naturally.
-
Hello Gonk, yes, I laser cut it from a piece of ply I found knocking around. I may try some more coats of dark Danish oil, rubbed down finally to a mat finish. Don’t want to spend too much time on it though - I will probably be dragged back to work soon, and am currently racing to finish building a 2.5 row I started 3 years ago or more! I am very easily distracted. Dave
-
...Is a non-original rusty grill better than a new wooden one? Picture attached.
You can always get a metal grill re-plated.
-
The great majority of the wood bodied Hohner Erika/Club II grills from the 1930s had steel grills painted silver. With careful prep they come up well with silver car paint from a spray can.
-
As wooden grills are being discussed, I have an aesthetics question. I recently made a wooden grill for an old Club,
I like it ,it as a style of it's own . you may find that it grows on you over time. the lazer cut darkens the cut edges ,which is good,they look a mess when fretsaw is used. there is a wide range of designs, some are simplistic and best suited for fretsaw cutting. lazer cutting opens up more complicated and intricate possibilities.
I was wondering about a more asymmetrical style . most designs seem to use the long side as the base of the design, even though when playing and showing off the grill,it is vertical?
I think you have made a good effort , it looks really good ,your box is now customised and a talking point!!
brian..
-
Thanks for feedback all. I did not know that they were painted originally, (thanks Theo), so I may go with that option. The old grill is un-damaged and should spray ok. I made a very similar grill last year for the box I am building at the moment, but I think it looks much better for being light cherry rather than dark mahogany-ish (ply)wood.
D
-
Ooh, Dave! That looks lovely, beautiful workmanship. Mind you, it looks as if it might be a touch on the heavy side, or is it a lightweight wood?
-
Hi Winston, thanks for the compliments! I think heavy will be the word. It is nearly finished now, and I have thinned everything down a bit in the finishing process, but it is solid cherry, felled by my wife 30 years ago, and it probably weighs nearly as much as my Mory in its case! It is 3 voice, LMM, all wooden action, with registers, and bass stops, so plenty of metalwork to add to the weight of the timber. I have tried to move to a more "continental" style of playing in recent years, with less pushing and pulling, so hopefully it will not be too much of a monster, but probably not a box to play for dance.
Cheers, D
-
That must be handy, having a lumberjack for wife. I hope, at least, that she's past the stage of sleeping all night and working all day? And that she's OK, of course. I suspect that she didn't wear high heals whilst chopping down trees, though I should imagine that the other ''unmentionables'' were already in evidence.
-
Oh yes, very handy, but I have to report that as a bit of a hippy, she has never worn high heels, nor indeed any of the other unmentionable accoutrement!
D