Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: The Oul' Boy on July 28, 2020, 11:49:56 AM
-
Hi all,
What's the right term for playing three quick notes (all the same note I think) together as an ornamentation (as demonstrated by Squeezy on his DVD)? Some people call these triplets, but that is also the term used for a tuplet where you play three notes in place of two crochets (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tuplet), which is not what I'm on about. Maybe Lester needs to do a follow-up ornamentations video on these!
Oh, and can anyone point me to a useful discussion of playing these (whatever they are called) on Melnet?
Thanks!
Warren (currently on holiday with neither my melodeon nor John's DVD...)
-
My Companion to Irish Traditional Music (Vallely, 2011) distinguishes between a triplet (3 separate notes) and a treble (the same note 3 times) but that terminology may be restricted to ITM. It's sometimes applied when what's being played is actually 2 semi-quavers + 1 quaver rather than 3 notes of strictly equal length - at speed the distinction is a fine one.
Haven't seen the Squeezy video. Are we talking about 3 fingers in quick succession on the same button?
Staimh, of this parish, explains various ornaments in this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UCDTyGblV1o (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UCDTyGblV1o) and he calls it a treble. It's the last one he explains in the video.
-
my understanding is that a 'triplet' is 3 of the same note played in the time allocated to a single ,the same, note. which normally implies very fast!
I find the easiest way to play them on the outside row a semitone box eg D row of a DG box is to , using the middle 3 fingers locked tightly together to then flick the 3 fingers ,still tightly together rapidly over the desired button towards the edge of the keyboard.
Can sometimes be done on inslde row but not as ealily.
quadruplets i.e 4 same notes separately but very quickly eg as in the tune caddam wood I find the most reliable way of getting the timing right is to
1, bring the right elbow forward of the bodyso that its in line with the edge of the keyboard
2. stiffen the wrist joint so the back of the hand AND FIRST FINGER are all in a straight line
3. use the strong elbow joint aand rigid arm and finger to pot the required button 4 times rapidly
4. return elbow to ones side and proceed with rest of tune as normal
easier to do than describe but needs quite a bit of practice separately from the tune
george
-
Are we talking about 3 fingers in quick succession on the same button?
Staimh, of this parish, explains various ornaments in this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UCDTyGblV1o (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UCDTyGblV1o) and he calls it a treble. It's the last one he explains in the video.
Yes, that's the one, three fingers on the same button (or two fingers, one twice). If I remember right John Spiers says it can be done with a single finger too, though it's not easy. Thanks! Stiamh also demonstrates it here I see: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RmJnJUmQ5Nw&list=LLd4uVJZ_nsNlDI9-2hpFhVA&index=2&t=0s
-
What's the right term for playing three quick notes (all the same note I think) together as an ornamentation (as demonstrated by Squeezy on his DVD)? Some people call these triplets, but that is also the term used for a tuplet where you play three notes in place of two crochets
Yes, both are true.
Three repetitions of a note by way of ornamentation is called a triplet in folk music. Especially by fiddlers, doing it by rapid bow reversals (more a flick of the wrist than an arm movement) I didn't know the same thing was sometimes called a treble, but maybe that's a regional thing.
Three notes in the time normally taken by two notes are called triplets in formal classical music, and they don't have to three repetitions of the same note. Also they are usually written out as compulsory notes, not as optional ornamentation.
The first type: three fingers in quick successsion on the same button, most easily done in the sequence 3-2-1 (where 1 is index finger.)
-
quadruplets i.e 4 same notes separately but very quickly eg as in the tune caddam wood I find the most reliable way of getting the timing right is to
Ha ha, thanks George, I hadn't even considered quadruplets yet!
-
Yes, both are true.
Three repetitions of a note by way of ornamentation is called a triplet in folk music. Especially by fiddlers, doing it by rapid bow reversals (more a flick of the wrist than an arm movement) I didn't know the same thing was sometimes called a treble, but maybe that's a regional thing.
Three notes in the time normally taken by two notes are called triplets in formal classical music, and they don't have to three repetitions of the same note. Also they are usually written out as compulsory notes, not as optional ornamentation.
The first type: three fingers in quick successsion on the same button, most easily done in the sequence 3-2-1 (where 1 is index finger.)
Thanks Anahata, that clarifies things nicely. I think from what Stiamh demonstrates, you can also do 2-1-2 (I think I remember Lester mention somewhere that that's how he does them). I suspect both take a lot of practice to produce smoothly and within a tune.
-
...as demonstrated by Squeezy on his DVD)? ....
If you're talking about the one were he gives a lesson to Lucy Huzzard in font of a live audience, Don't mention it to Squeezy. You'll upset him. Basically, it was a rip-off by the distributers. He never got paid for it.
-
If you're talking about the one were he gives a lesson to Lucy Huzzard in font of a live audience, Don't mention it to Squeezy. You'll upset him. Basically, it was a rip-off by the distributers. He never got paid for it.
Yes, that's the one. Christ, that's a bit pants.
-
If you're talking about the one were he gives a lesson to Lucy Huzzard in font of a live audience, Don't mention it to Squeezy. You'll upset him. Basically, it was a rip-off by the distributers. He never got paid for it.
Yes, that's the one. Christ, that's a bit pants.
The information is on this thread. Reminds me, I need to contribute.
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,25316.msg301639.html#msg301639
-
If you are referring to ornamentation known as a Cut or Tap in ITM (a passing note above or below the played note), then the technical term is a Mordent (using note below) or an Inverted Mordent (using note above), ortherwise called a Pralltriller. But that is totally different from playing the same note 3 or 4 times.
-
If you are referring to ornamentation known as a Cut or Tap in ITM (a passing note above or below the played note), then the technical term is a Mordent (using note below) or an Inverted Mordent (using note above), ortherwise called a Pralltriller. But that is totally different from playing the same note 3 or 4 times.
My session buddy Mudchutney gives a demo of the same-note-three-times decoration on CBA here but using a thumb.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rvJiZPguxMk&list=PLRa3aOMAWr-UmH7k1cW72yjiWafoRGqvo&index=2 (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rvJiZPguxMk&list=PLRa3aOMAWr-UmH7k1cW72yjiWafoRGqvo&index=2)
(Incidentally, I've just learned from a text from a young friend - well, not that young but younger than me - that CBA has another meaning in textspeak! :o)
Something I've been experimenting with recently is using the 2 pushed Ds or 2 pulled Es on a DG melodeon to get the same effect. I'm working on a reel in A minor and am alternating the E on the G row and the one on the D row to get a treble/triplet using 2 fingers on 2 buttons rather than 3 fingers on 1 button. Is that a thing or just the product of my crazed imagination? Seems to work and is less cramped.
Cuts, taps and mordents are something different, as you say, Martin. When playing wooden flute, I'd distinguish between cuts & taps (ITM ornaments which should sound as purely articulative/percussive) and mordents (classical ornaments which last long enough to be audible melodically). I guess the distinction isn't as clear on box.
-
(Incidentally, I've just learned from a text from a young friend - well, not that young but younger than me - that CBA has another meaning in textspeak! :o)
I thought of taking up the CBA but I really CBA ..........
-
What Anahata sez 👍 It’s more “about†stress, using a rhythm break, than the actual notes. I rattle a key with ring, middle index fingers. The hard thing is to keep to the allotted space 🙂
Similarly the lovely quadruplets in Grinds Hans Jässpödspolska (aka “CEGâ€), or Hal an Tow both 4 in space of 3
I “think†mordants and cuts … stay in rhythm?
-
I rattle a key with ring, middle index fingers. The hard thing is to keep to the allotted space 🙂
That's how I (try to) do them too. I'll stick to talking about "trebling", though, and keep "triplets" for 3 different notes in the space of 2, which is not just used in classical music - they crop up quite a lot in hornpipes: (3efe (3dcB (3ABA (3GFE . The two techniques are very different in execution and effect so I think it's worth having separate terms.
Looks like the former term is mainly used among the ITM fraternity. An example from a CD review on Mustrad compares the artist with the great John Kimmel:
"Wisely he doesn't attempt Kimmel's difficult technique of trebling on the same button"
I see it's been discussed here before: "Then there's "trebling" or whatever you want to call it, repeated sounding of one note in triplet time" from
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=8507.20
What's in a name?
-
The repeated-note-rhythm seems to be prone to regionalisation - triplet, treble are both common names for it, but in Scotland fiddlers often call it a birl, after a similar (though different in technique) sound on the pipes (at least that's the folk etymology, I have a suspicion it's the other way round). I've also heard it called a diddle, and tipping. Most confusingly of all, in Cape Breton it's called a cut.
As a general comment, I wouldn't use terms from classical music to describe trad ornaments for two reasons - one, the ornaments are very rarely actually the same thing, even if there's a similarity, and two, the meaning of a particular ornament in classical music often varies depending on the piece itself, classical music not being consistently the same thing in different times and places.
-
Regardless of how they're done, I can't help thinking that the whetever-they're-called are a bit over-used nowadays, maybe by players who think it shows off how technically good they are but in fact they end up sounding a bit robotic -- ooh look I can do this, even if it doesn't really fit with the tune, now let's do it again, and again...
Like any other kind of ornament they should be used only where they add to the tune, not to excess, and not exactly the same every time the same phrase comes round -- playing ornaments some times and plain others or different ornaments on repeats of the tune/phrase is much more of a musical skill than machine-gunning out the same dah-dah-dah every single time. I'm sure this is a modern melodeon thing, certainly in England you never used to hear this particular musical feature, but now it's become common and -- to my ear -- over-used.
It might be an import from some Irish box players who've taken a fiddle bowing feature and transplanted it onto the melodion (where I still think it sounds artificial compared to the same idea on the fiddle, where it's not three identical notes but usually two stronger ones with a weaker on in between), then this has been taken up by box players here, and then copied by more and more people, maybe because it's taught in workshops as an "advanced technique". Which it is technically, but one I've never found the need to use in any tune I play, in spite of using turns and mordants and trills and whatever else they're called quite a lot...
Discuss ;-)
-
Discuss ;-)
I agree with what Ian wrote!
-
Regardless of how they're done, I can't help thinking that the whetever-they're-called are a bit over-used nowadays, maybe by players who think it shows off how technically good they are but in fact they end up sounding a bit robotic
Robotic is right - and not just on the box. Young Irish players being prepared for competition at the fleadh have to show off as much technique as they can, hence the smorgasbord of cuts, taps, rolls and all the rest of it. I'm sure you're right that this has spread beyond Ireland. (and Scotland) to places where these techniques aren't necessarily appropriate.
Having said that, it's worth noting that these are rhythmic techniques rather than mere "ornaments" and are fundamental to some regional styles. There are even tunes that don't sound right without a roll, a treble or whatever at a given point. If the tune goes dG (3GGG then playing dG GG just ain't the same.
And none of this is new. Have a listen to John Kimmel playing a one-row in 1909: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y76LmMqiKL0
(Worth slowing down the speed in settings!)
-
How do
Do these differ from turns?
-
When my aunt had triplets, my grandma had a funny turn.
-
And none of this is new. Have a listen to John Kimmel playing a one-row in 1909: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y76LmMqiKL0
What he's doing is mostly not triplets or trebles, though. Mordent, I think is the technical term where you go up one note and down again, not the same as the machine gun repeats on one note.
Do these differ from turns?
In my book, a turn goes up one note, back to the original note, down one note and back again e.g. G-A-G-F♯-G.
-
Do these differ from turns?
In my book, a turn goes up one note, back to the original note, down one note and back again e.g. G-A-G-F♯-G.
Thanks Anahata.
-
Having said that, it's worth noting that these are rhythmic techniques rather than mere "ornaments" and are fundamental to some regional styles. There are even tunes that don't sound right without a roll, a treble or whatever at a given point. If the tune goes dG (3GGG then playing dG GG just ain't the same.
I agree entirely, a lot of these techniques are essential to playing the tune and it isn't always helpful to think of them as ornaments, though I think a few ornaments (ie 'twiddly bits' of any kind that are not essential to the tune) are fun too, if not overused.
-
My grasp of classical music terms is limited but I think turn is one. In one sense it's similar to a roll but there's a big difference in intention and effect.
A turn (I believe) involves decorating a note, using the notes immediately above and below. So you might play a turn on an F by playing FGFEF. I would expect all the notes to be audible as melodic events, as it were. We should hear the pitch of each of them.
A roll also involves using notes above and below the actual note but there are some important differences:
1. It may not be the notes immediately above and below. You might roll a G using a B and an F#, for example. This depends on the instrument. O'Neill's original "Dance Music of Ireland" included a section showing how rolls might be played on various instruments. In our terms, players of BC, C#D and DG boxes would each have their own ways of rolling particular notes. That's one reason why DG is often considered "wrong" for Irish music.
2. The 4 notes (short roll) or 5 notes (long roll) should not be audible as separate notes. People often talk about a 5-note roll but the effect should be one note, interrupted twice to produce something like a triplet/treble. Hard to do on any kind of button box and requires very speedy fingers.
(A cut is effectively the first part of a roll. Irish box players often articulate a note by cutting it with one above just as a classical flautist would tongue a note.)
As Calum said earlier:
As a general comment, I wouldn't use terms from classical music to describe trad ornaments for two reasons - one, the ornaments are very rarely actually the same thing, even if there's a similarity, and two, the meaning of a particular ornament in classical music often varies depending on the piece itself, classical music not being consistently the same thing in different times and places.
So Kimmel isn't using turns or mordents, he's playing rolls, cuts and certainly some trebles. Slow him down and you can hear all three techniques being used. He was known for (and influential in introducing) trebing. I might have a go at transcribing a bit of it in a minute - but don't hold your breath!
-
Context matters. You may approach this from theory, notation or (more importantly) tradition and the instrument. Rolls, turns, mordants, whatever, in the actual execution, I find subtle yet significant differences when playing fiddle, pipes, whistle, guitar or various bellows boxes.
But whatever the notation attempts to describe, it's the sound that matters.
Scots fiddle has a technique which makes the bow "chew" on the string to produce a "segmented" sound which may be likened to a treble division of the note/tone. This is accomplished by a quick flex of the forearm muscles of the bow arm. I believe I have heard Andy Cutting achieve the same effect with the bellows.
Has anyone else heard this effect from a box player?
-
Dick, I think what you're describing is digging the bow into the string a little before beginning the bow, which has the effect that it starts moving with a jerk, giving a very tight attack. If you reverse direction as soon as this movement starts, you get a very tight, scrunched treble/tripling/birl. The master of this though was Tommy People, whose treble was so crunchy it often lacked pitch entirely.
> But whatever the notation attempts to describe, it's the sound that matters.
Quite agree. The problem is often we have mental models of what we do that aren't actually correct, and cause people to do the wrong thing. I often joke that teaching kids is easy, because they ignore what you tell them and do what you do; adult students do the opposite and that's why they are harder to teach.
-
Dick, I think what you're describing is digging the bow into the string a little before beginning the bow, which has the effect that it starts moving with a jerk, giving a very tight attack. If you reverse direction as soon as this movement starts, you get a very tight, scrunched treble/tripling/birl. The master of this though was Tommy People, whose treble was so crunchy it often lacked pitch entirely.
> But whatever the notation attempts to describe, it's the sound that matters.
Quite agree. The problem is often we have mental models of what we do that aren't actually correct, and cause people to do the wrong thing. I often joke that teaching kids is easy, because they ignore what you tell them and do what you do; adult students do the opposite and that's why they are harder to teach.
Similar, perhaps, but I learned this from a great French-Canadian fiddler/violinist.
He called it "shivers" because the muscle contraction would subtly interrupt and restart the bow stroke on either an up- or down-bow. You'd hear the effect, but it was absolutely undetectable visually. It was not pressure related, not a crunch.
But enough fiddling...
-
O'Neill's original "Dance Music of Ireland" included a section showing how rolls might be played on various instruments. In our terms, players of BC, C#D and DG boxes would each have their own ways of rolling particular notes. That's one reason why DG is often considered "wrong" for Irish music.
Context matters. You may approach this from theory, notation or (more importantly) tradition and the instrument. Rolls, turns, mordants, whatever, in the actual execution, I find subtle yet significant differences when playing fiddle, pipes, whistle, guitar or various bellows boxes.
I don't mean O'Neill but Breathnach, as I've been reminded. The two sit side by side on the shelf. Attached, showing pipes, flute, fiddle and box.
-
Remember also that silences can function as notes.
-
So I'm currently learning The Gooseberry Bush for Tune of the Month, and it's coming on well, though still nowhere near film-able (and may not be by the end of the month, especially as I haven't got to grips with the slows yet). But I felt there was something missing and listening to John's playing of this tune, he does some triples, I think on the second note of the first and fifth bars of the A part of the tune. Anyway, I've been giving it a try and lo-and-behold I'm getting something reasonably convincing using the quick three-finger-rotation about every fourth or fifth attempt. It's a mush the other times (I'm trying to work out what I'm doing differently the times it works), but it can only get better. Of course, it does leave my fingers in the wrong place for the next note, but that's a minor problem! All good fun.
-
...But I felt there was something missing and listening to John's playing of this tune, he does some triples, I think on the second note of the first and fifth bars of the A part of the tune....
You're right. He consistently embellishes the first phrase of the A melody (there are some others, that are harder to spot). If you listen carefully, though, most of them aren't triplets. It's worth getting hold of something like Slow downer. You can hear quite clearly that there are subtle differences each time through. I don't know what the technical term is for them though. Grace notes of one sort, or another.
I wouldn't get too hung up on making them exactly the same way that John does. He varies them a lot in the same performance and between different performances.
I think it's a great tune for working on the this knack.
Another thing he does is vary the way he plays the tune, mostly by missing out notes.
I think I've looked too closely at it, myself. I've got so I get confused about how I'm going to play it. It happens to me, sometimes. That's why I'm leaving it alone for a bit. This usually helps.
-
So I'm currently learning The Gooseberry Bush for Tune of the Month, and it's coming on well, though still nowhere near film-able (and may not be by the end of the month, especially as I haven't got to grips with the slows yet). But I felt there was something missing and listening to John's playing of this tune, he does some triples, I think on the second note of the first and fifth bars of the A part of the tune. Anyway, I've been giving it a try and lo-and-behold I'm getting something reasonably convincing using the quick three-finger-rotation about every fourth or fifth attempt. It's a mush the other times (I'm trying to work out what I'm doing differently the times it works), but it can only get better. Of course, it does leave my fingers in the wrong place for the next note, but that's a minor problem! All good fun.
You might try doing a repetition of three fingers like this:
RMI MRM IMR MIM
It's just back and forth and sets you up to be able to start and finish your 3bl to end up with the best finger to continue out of the 3bl.
Good luck. A 2 bar string of triplets snuck into a group session can be hilarious.
-
...But I felt there was something missing and listening to John's playing of this tune, he does some triples, I think on the second note of the first and fifth bars of the A part of the tune....
You're right. He consistently embellishes the first phrase of the A melody (there are some others, that are harder to spot). If you listen carefully, though, most of them aren't triplets. It's worth getting hold of something like Slow downer.
No need - you can slow down Youtube in settings.
-
True enough.
-
same note triplets i.e. the same note played 3 times rapidly can be done on the outside D row very swiftly by holding fingers 234 tightly together add swiping them accross the required button rather like a machine gun firing. With practice can be done on inside row flat keybaord but eassier on a stepped keyboard;
This applies to both 4th aprt anad semitone boxes
george
1
-
You're right. He consistently embellishes the first phrase of the A melody (there are some others, that are harder to spot). If you listen carefully, though, most of them aren't triplets. It's worth getting hold of something like Slow downer. You can hear quite clearly that there are subtle differences each time through. I don't know what the technical term is for them though. Grace notes of one sort, or another.
I wouldn't get too hung up on making them exactly the same way that John does. He varies them a lot in the same performance and between different performances.
I must have a listen again, though I suspect there's no danger of me being able to replicate what he does closely!
-
You might try doing a repetition of three fingers like this:
RMI MRM IMR MIM
It's just back and forth and sets you up to be able to start and finish your 3bl to end up with the best finger to continue out of the 3bl.
Good luck. A 2 bar string of triplets snuck into a group session can be hilarious.
Oh wow, having sort of worked out how to get my three fingers to rapidly hit the same button in succession by kind of flicking them across it, I can't currently imagine getting anything as quick by changing the order in which they strike the button!
-
same note triplets i.e. the same note played 3 times rapidly can be done on the outside D row very swiftly by holding fingers 234 tightly together add swiping them accross the required button rather like a machine gun firing. With practice can be done on inside row flat keybaord but eassier on a stepped keyboard;
I think this is similar what I'm doing, though I'm doing it on the inside row on a Pokerwork, and it's more like a quick swipe across the button with the fingers striking it in turn.
-
same note triplets i.e. the same note played 3 times rapidly can be done on the outside D row very swiftly by holding fingers 234 tightly together add swiping them accross the required button rather like a machine gun firing. With practice can be done on inside row flat keybaord but eassier on a stepped keyboard;
This is almost the complete opposite of how I do them. My fingers are held loosely, and the movement is like drumming on a table, with a slight rotation of the wrist so the fingers all land on the same button. This is done at a diagonal angle across the row towards the grille (on the inside row) or towards the edge on the outside row. I find it easier on the inside row, and easier on a flat keyboard rather than a stepped one (but I prefer flat anyway).
I say this not to suggest that anything George said is wrong, but to observe that melodeon players seem to find many ways to skin the same cat. I was at one of Squeezy's workshops when he also said it was easier on the outside row, to which I disagreed. Try different ways until you find one which works for you.
-
same note triplets i.e. the same note played 3 times rapidly can be done on the outside D row very swiftly by holding fingers 234 tightly together add swiping them accross the required button rather like a machine gun firing. With practice can be done on inside row flat keybaord but eassier on a stepped keyboard;
This is almost the complete opposite of how I do them. My fingers are held loosely, and the movement is like drumming on a table, with a slight rotation of the wrist so the fingers all land on the same button. This is done at a diagonal angle across the row towards the grille (on the inside row) or towards the edge on the outside row.
Howard...
This is pretty much how I do what I posted up-thread, but I go back and forth across the button.
-
This is almost the complete opposite of how I do them. My fingers are held loosely, and the movement is like drumming on a table, with a slight rotation of the wrist so the fingers all land on the same button. This is done at a diagonal angle across the row towards the grille (on the inside row) or towards the edge on the outside row. I find it easier on the inside row, and easier on a flat keyboard rather than a stepped one (but I prefer flat anyway).
I say this not to suggest that anything George said is wrong, but to observe that melodeon players seem to find many ways to skin the same cat. I was at one of Squeezy's workshops when he also said it was easier on the outside row, to which I disagreed. Try different ways until you find one which works for you.
I think you might actually be describing exactly how I do it too Dick, my fingers aren't held together and it is like drumming them on the table, but as you say with movement to make sure they fall in the same place.
-
Keep the fingers as vertical as possible.
-
Keep the fingers as vertical as possible.
I'm a member of the table-drumming school as well, keeping the fingers flexible and fairly widely spaced to ensure three separate strikes. Seems to work best for me using finger tips more than pads and therefore bending the fingers more than usual. Chris could you elaborate please? Is that the opposite of what you're recommending?
(Looks like CBA players can use a thumb: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rvJiZPguxMk (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rvJiZPguxMk) )
-
No the same. That is the “conservatoire†method. But some can do a sweep with 3 fingers, some hammer it in with two. Andy Cutting once told me he could triplet with a single digit!
-
I fear that this single digit talent is a rather insignificant addition to the very long list of stuff that Andy Cutting can do which is not achievable by the rest of us. :(
-
for ? rapid quadruplets eg in caddam wood I find the most reliable method , on either row, is to bringthe elbow forward, keep the arm andfinger rigid and in a straight line and use the strong elbow joint to provide 4 tapsin quick aand even succesion.
Its a lot easier to do than to describe!
george
-
for ? rapid quadruplets eg in caddam wood I find the most reliable method , on either row, is to bringthe elbow forward, keep the arm andfinger rigid and in a straight line and use the strong elbow joint to provide 4 tapsin quick aand even succesion.
george
That seems useful when the notes are separate semiquavers, as in Caddam Woods (if written in 2/4 as a polka), and likewise when you want to hit more than one button at once. I think of the faster "ornament" triplet as being about twice as rapid. I can come close to bringing it up to speed with this one-finger method, with a lot of arm and hand tension, almost like inducing a muscle spasm - I imagine that's similar to what Andy Cutting is doing. But for most situations, the other solutions listed here are what I use, and I don't tighten my fingers together, I keep them loose - personal preference.
-
It has to be relaxed - I don't think muscle spasm and rigidity are conducive to good music. Just practice a bit more!
-
It has to be relaxed - I don't think muscle spasm and rigidity are conducive to good music. Just practice a bit more!
Not a big Wagner fan?
-
for ? rapid quadruplets eg in caddam wood I find the most reliable method , on either row, is to bringthe elbow forward, keep the arm andfinger rigid and in a straight line and use the strong elbow joint to provide 4 tapsin quick aand even succesion.
george
That seems useful when the notes are separate semiquavers, as in Caddam Woods (if written in 2/4 as a polka)....
For groups of four notes as in Caddam Wood, on my D/G box I tend to use two fingers on the repeated D notes, alternating between the G-row and the D-row. That way you don't get any finger collisions.
So in this ABC, blue notes are push on the G-row, red notes are push on the D row:
X:1
T:Caddam Wood
M:2/4
L:1/16
K:G
dddd ^c2d2|e2d2 B4|dddd G2B2|e2d2 c4|
cccc B2c2|f2e2 d4|f2e2 c2A2|e2d2 ^c2d2|
dddd^c2d2|e2d2 B4|DDDD G2B2|e2d2 c4|
cccc B2c2|f2e2 c4|fedc B2A2|G8||
dddd.B2.B2|dddd .B2.B2|d4e3.d|.d2.^c2 =c4|
cccc A2A2|cccc A2A2|f3e f2e2|e2d2 e2d2|
d2d2 dedc|.B2.B2 B4|d4e3.d|d2^c2 =c4|
c2c2 cdcB|A2A2 A4|dddd e2f2|g8|]
It doesn't solve the rapid C naturals though, as they are only available on the G-row pull. I usually just use my index flinger for those. (Andy Cutting method, I guess...)
-
Steve, that's an elegant solution if you don't want a chord (and you happen to have the note on both rows). I guess that leaves me thinking the only reason I would want to stiffen my arm and finger as George is describing is to bang out a few chords rapid-fire. Sorry for all the violent terminology Richard! To be clear, I don't do this when I play; I'm trying it out as I read these suggestions. I'm on C#/D most of the time, so I mostly am using the RMI/IMR/MIM/IMI/etc etc methods, with loose, musical, noodly fingers.
-
I asked if that was a thing a couple of months ago. Glad to hear others do the same thing.
For groups of four notes as in Caddam Wood, on my D/G box I tend to use two fingers on the repeated D notes, alternating between the G-row and the D-row. That way you don't get any finger collisions.
Something I've been experimenting with recently is using the 2 pushed Ds or 2 pulled Es on a DG melodeon to get the same effect. I'm working on a reel in A minor and am alternating the E on the G row and the one on the D row to get a treble/triplet using 2 fingers on 2 buttons rather than 3 fingers on 1 button. Is that a thing or just the product of my crazed imagination? Seems to work and is less cramped.
-
My Companion to Irish Traditional Music (Vallely, 2011) distinguishes between a triplet (3 separate notes) and a treble (the same note 3 times) but that terminology may be restricted to ITM. It's sometimes applied when what's being played is actually 2 semi-quavers + 1 quaver rather than 3 notes of strictly equal length - at speed the distinction is a fine one.
Just returning to this (and watching Stiamh's video), when you are playing a triplet (3 separate notes), is there any recommended sequence of notes you should play? For example, in Tralee Gaol (in ##) a basic way to play the second half of the first bar is to play E (quaver) F# (semiquaver) A (semiquaver). The two semiquavers can be replaced by a triplet, but which notes would you use in such a situation, and is there any set way to do it?
-
Just returning to this (and watching Stiamh's video), when you are playing a triplet (3 separate notes), is there any recommended sequence of notes you should play?
I'm not absolutely sure I know what you are asking here. Very often a triplet (3 separate notes as you say) will be played in place of a crotchet, to add a bit of interest, and the usual way is just to play your main note, followed whatever note is produced by the next kneeward button in the same bellows direction, and back to your main note.
For example if you wanted to decorate a crotchet E on a D-row, you'd probably play EGE. An A would come out as ADA.
Some B/C players would use the outer row and play ED#E or AG#A. I don't care for the effect, especially if the middle note is not in the key of the tune.
Triplets are also used to fill in gaps between two quavers: replace BD with BCD, the C being sharp or natural depending on the tune, or replace EG with EF#G. Downward runs like this are also possible although somewhat less common.
For example, in Tralee Gaol (in ##) a basic way to play the second half of the first bar is to play E (quaver) F# (semiquaver) A (semiquaver). The two semiquavers can be replaced by a triplet, but which notes would you use in such a situation, and is there any set way to do it?
I can't figure this out at all. You wouldn't normally replace two semiquavers with a triplet and I can't picture where in the first bar of Tralee Gaol you might play EF#A. Can you point me to a transcription?
Duh, I just realized thanks to your ## that you are playing the tune in E dorian/minor, instead of the usual A dorian. OK, I get it now. ;D
I could fill in the F#A transition nicely on my C#/D my playing F#-G#-A. If you're playing a D/G box, assuming you are playing the tune on the D row, you could play F-G-nat-A - which would probably sound better - by grabbing the note G on the push from your G row. You'd have to be snappy about it though! Sorry for the confusion.
If you're playing on a one-row... I wouldn't bother!
-
Have a look at the various transcriptions on thesession.org (think I gave a link earlier). One at least does what Stiamh suggests, but as a quaver and 2 semiquavers, which sometimes gets confused with a triplet. There's even one variant there which uses 4 semiquavers: EF#GA (all pulled cross row on a DG).
-
Just returning to this (and watching Stiamh's video), when you are playing a triplet (3 separate notes), is there any recommended sequence of notes you should play?
I'm not absolutely sure I know what you are asking here. Very often a triplet (3 separate notes as you say) will be played in place of a crotchet, to add a bit of interest, and the usual way is just to play your main note, followed whatever note is produced by the next kneeward button in the same bellows direction, and back to your main note.
For example if you wanted to decorate a crotchet E on a D-row, you'd probably play EGE. An A would come out as ADA.
Some B/C players would use the outer row and play ED#E or AG#A. I don't care for the effect, especially if the middle note is not in the key of the tune.
Triplets are also used to fill in gaps between two quavers: replace BD with BCD, the C being sharp or natural depending on the tune, or replace EG with EF#G. Downward runs like this are also possible although somewhat less common.
For example, in Tralee Gaol (in ##) a basic way to play the second half of the first bar is to play E (quaver) F# (semiquaver) A (semiquaver). The two semiquavers can be replaced by a triplet, but which notes would you use in such a situation, and is there any set way to do it?
I can't figure this out at all. You wouldn't normally replace two semiquavers with a triplet and I can't picture where in the first bar of Tralee Gaol you might play EF#A. Can you point me to a transcription?
Duh, I just realized thanks to your ## that you are playing the tune in E dorian/minor, instead of the usual A dorian. OK, I get it now. ;D
I could fill in the F#A transition nicely on my C#/D my playing F#-G#-A. If you're playing a D/G box, assuming you are playing the tune on the D row, you could play F-G-nat-A - which would probably sound better - by grabbing the note G on the push from your G row. You'd have to be snappy about it though! Sorry for the confusion.
If you're playing on a one-row... I wouldn't bother!
Thanks Stiamh for your help and patience with my terminology! So is playing F#-Gnat-A instead of two semiquavers F#A a triplet? It's three notes in the space of a quaver, so it seems it should be. I'm indeed playing it mostly on the D row on a DG, but playing that sequence on the pull, crossing to the G row for the F# and A (with the G nat in the 'triplet' supplied on the pull from the D row).
-
Have a look at the various transcriptions on thesession.org (think I gave a link earlier). One at least does what Stiamh suggests, but as a quaver and 2 semiquavers, which sometimes gets confused with a triplet. There's even one variant there which uses 4 semiquavers: EF#GA (all pulled cross row on a DG).
Thanks CAB! As far as I can see, none of them do what I'm talking about, which is using a triplet instead of the two semiquavers (following the quaver).
-
This'll hopefully clarify; these are bars 1 and 2 with the triplet at the end of bar 1, compared to bars 5 and 6 with no triplet, just two semiquavers.
-
Yeah, well... terminology.... As long as it's the sound you want, who cares about the name? Notating these fill-in-the-gap thingies as triplets is the most convenient but probably not the most accurate method.
When I'm transcribing tunes in ABC notation I usually put A/A/A or B/c/d instead of (3AAA or (3Bcd.
Played strictly a triplet is three evenly spaced notes in the space of two. This has a very different rhythm from semiquaver-semiquaver-quaver and would, in fact, tend to interrupt the flow of a reel (an Irish one, at least) and sound awkward. But when you see these devices noted as a triplet in the context of, say, an Irish reel, everyone knows how to make them sound. Or should do, which is not perhaps the same thing.
-
Thanks CAB! As far as I can see, none of them do what I'm talking about, which is using a triplet instead of the two semiquavers (following the quaver).
Oops sorry. I saw you'd quoted me in your query but was out all day so tried to answer quickly on my phone, with the result that I didn't read your post properly. Sticking a G in as your dots ( and Stiamh) say is certainly an option but you'd only want to use it sometimes. As it happens, if you transposed the tune to the more usual A dorian, that triplet (Bcd) would be very hard on a DG but it's straightforward enough in E dorian - maybe why Mally gives it in that key in the tutor. At polka speed, there's not much point anyway - might make more sense if the whole thing was written in 4/4 and you were then replacing a crotchet with a triplet... but that's a more fundamental change.
-
This'll hopefully clarify; these are bars 1 and 2 with the triplet at the end of bar 1, compared to bars 5 and 6 with no triplet, just two semiquavers.
A tune I'm extremely familiar with! I'll have a go at playing it with the triplet and see how it sounds.
-
... if you transposed the tune to the more usual A dorian, that triplet (Bcd) would be very hard on a DG
At speed, play it Bc#d and nobody will notice. In fact I think it sounds better with a c#!
-
Thanks CAB! As far as I can see, none of them do what I'm talking about, which is using a triplet instead of the two semiquavers (following the quaver).
Oops sorry. I saw you'd quoted me in your query but was out all day so tried to answer quickly on my phone, with the result that I didn't read your post properly. Sticking a G in as your dots ( and Stiamh) say is certainly an option but you'd only want to use it sometimes. As it happens, if you transposed the tune to the more usual A dorian, that triplet (Bcd) would be very hard on a DG but it's straightforward enough in E dorian - maybe why Mally gives it in that key in the tutor. At polka speed, there's not much point anyway - might make more sense if the whole thing was written in 4/4 and you were then replacing a crotchet with a triplet... but that's a more fundamental change.
Thanks CAB! I wouldn't mind seeing a good ITM performance of this tune on a two row if you have any suggestions.
-
How do triplets relate to turns?
(See Wyper Tutorial)
-
I wouldn't mind seeing a good ITM performance of this tune on a two row if you have any suggestions.
Not really a performance and I can't say whether it's any good ;) but you could try this (https://youtu.be/YNZEBI6eJYM).
-
Not really a performance and I can't say whether it's any good ;) but you could try this (https://youtu.be/YNZEBI6eJYM).
Thanks Stiamh, that's very helpful! As I say, I'm a DG player and that's not going to change until such times as I'm good enough (assuming that ever happens...) to start learning a new system, but it's nice to see how the other half do it.
Warren.
-
... if you transposed the tune to the more usual A dorian, that triplet (Bcd) would be very hard on a DG
At speed, play it Bc#d and nobody will notice. In fact I think it sounds better with a c#!
On a DG that means changing bellows direction and crossing rows so not a thing everyone would do, especially for a fast triplet. Easier to stick to the G row and just play Bd. (On flute or whistle I'd agree - that c# just pops in there whether you like it or not.)
-
... if you transposed the tune to the more usual A dorian, that triplet (Bcd) would be very hard on a DG
At speed, play it Bc#d and nobody will notice. In fact I think it sounds better with a c#!
On a DG that means changing bellows direction and crossing rows so not a thing everyone would do, especially for a fast triplet. Easier to stick to the G row and just play Bd. (On flute or whistle I'd agree - that c# just pops in there whether you like it or not.)
Ah. I was assuming that transposing to A dorian would mean playing the tune on the D row, where that triplet would be easy (with C-nat or C#). Not the first time I've mistakenly imagined that D/G players would do things the right way same way as C#/D players. ;)
-
If you're playing on the D row in ## the triplet is F#-G-A which is easy because they're all push notes (you'd go to the G row for the G). The problem with C or C# is that it's only available on the pull so the triplet would involve bellows reversals.
-
If you're playing on the D row in ## the triplet is F#-G-A which is easy because they're all push notes (you'd go to the G row for the G). The problem with C or C# is that it's only available on the pull so the triplet would involve bellows reversals.
It's really not a problem, Chris. There's just one reversal for the D. The Bc#d triplet is very common in Irish music particularly and you can very easily learn to do it extremely quickly - and satisfyingly.
-
If you're playing on the D row in ## the triplet is F#-G-A which is easy because they're all push notes (you'd go to the G row for the G). The problem with C or C# is that it's only available on the pull so the triplet would involve bellows reversals.
Exactly Chris. As i said, that may be why Mally gives it in that key in the book. Steve's right though, if you're prepared to slip onto the D row.
Thanks CAB! I wouldn't mind seeing a good ITM performance of this tune on a two row if you have any suggestions.
Warren, I'm guessing you searched youtube. There are several DG version on there but some I really wouldn't recommend.
However, Pikey (OTP) plays it here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DYVhSkaqz6U (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DYVhSkaqz6U)
Here's a lively version, though I prefer it before he brings the basses in: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e1SuI1EiMGY (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e1SuI1EiMGY)
There's a solid English-style version here (2nd tune): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D2iKlMZ_ZeE (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D2iKlMZ_ZeE)
For outstanding Irish DG, here's the late Simon Knight, once the centre of the ITM and set dance scene in these parts. He plays three polkas, of which the 3rd is the one we're talking about, though under its other name. Unfortunately, it's audio only and he is leading a small group, so it's by no means ideal but you can grasp his style perfectly from the first tune and get the general effect of the 3rd one:
https://soundcloud.com/jignatius-aeola/the-lonesome-road-to-dingle-newmarket-polka-as-i-walked-out-upon-the-ice/s-COclDhwBceF (https://soundcloud.com/jignatius-aeola/the-lonesome-road-to-dingle-newmarket-polka-as-i-walked-out-upon-the-ice/s-COclDhwBceF)
-
If you're playing on the D row in ## the triplet is F#-G-A which is easy because they're all push notes (you'd go to the G row for the G). The problem with C or C# is that it's only available on the pull so the triplet would involve bellows reversals.
I've going over to the G row and doing them all on the pull! Fits with the bass better.
-
Warren, I'm guessing you searched youtube.
For outstanding Irish DG, here's the late Simon Knight, once the centre of the ITM and set dance scene in these parts. He plays three polkas, of which the 3rd is the one we're talking about, though under its other name. Unfortunately, it's audio only and he is leading a small group, so it's by no means ideal but you can grasp his style perfectly from the first tune and get the general effect of the 3rd one:
https://soundcloud.com/jignatius-aeola/the-lonesome-road-to-dingle-newmarket-polka-as-i-walked-out-upon-the-ice/s-COclDhwBceF (https://soundcloud.com/jignatius-aeola/the-lonesome-road-to-dingle-newmarket-polka-as-i-walked-out-upon-the-ice/s-COclDhwBceF)
Thanks CAB! Yes, I'd looked on YouTube, but was after ITM style versions on video (on semitone boxes or whatever) rather than English-style versions, just to see what the difference was.
-
Strikes me listening to these that there really are two quite distinct versions here, as Chris pointed out earlier, though I'd maintain still the same tune, as it appears on thesession.
-
Thanks CAB! Yes, I'd looked on YouTube, but was after ITM style versions on video (on semitone boxes or whatever) rather than English-style versions, just to see what the difference was.
Did you see the link to the version by Tony MacMahon that I posted in this post on Chris Marriott's learning thread (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,26722.msg322363.html#msg322363)? Not video, unfortunately, but you won't hear a better ITM version.
Incidentally, you may wonder why the tune is being played in C-minor (dorian). To save you some head-scratching, he is playing as though in A-minor on a B/C box. Except that his accordion is in D/D#, so up a tone and a half. :P
-
Strikes me listening to these that there really are two quite distinct versions here, as Chris pointed out earlier, though I'd maintain still the same tune, as it appears on thesession.
Yes, the B part seems to come in two rather different versions.
-
Thanks CAB! Yes, I'd looked on YouTube, but was after ITM style versions on video (on semitone boxes or whatever) rather than English-style versions, just to see what the difference was.
Did you see the link to the version by Tony MacMahon that I posted in this post on Chris Marriott's learning thread (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,26722.msg322363.html#msg322363)? Not video, unfortunately, but you won't hear a better ITM version.
Incidentally, you may wonder why the tune is being played in C-minor (dorian). To save you some head-scratching, he is playing as though in A-minor on a B/C box. Except that his accordion is in D/D#, so up a tone and a half. :P
Thanks Stiamh, unfortunately the Tony MacMahon one requires payment to listen to.
-
How do triplets relate to turns?
(See Wyper Tutorial)
Peadar, meant to answer you! Although the Wyper section on turns uses an apparent triplet to transcribe them, it's actually a different thing. Most of the turns he shows are what an Irish musician would call short rolls, where you tap a note above the target note, then the target note, then one below before settling on the target note, e.g. AGFG. His "turn on a dotted note" is a long roll - basically hitting the target note three times, interrupted once with a higher and once with a lower note, e.g. GAGFG. He's attempting tp show the relative lengths of the notes in the roll - what the listener should hear is the target note with a rhythmic rattle. The notes above and below don't have to be adjacent to the target note, by the way.
-
Thanks CAB! Yes, I'd looked on YouTube, but was after ITM style versions on video (on semitone boxes or whatever) rather than English-style versions, just to see what the difference was.
Did you see the link to the version by Tony MacMahon that I posted in this post on Chris Marriott's learning thread (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,26722.msg322363.html#msg322363)? Not video, unfortunately, but you won't hear a better ITM version.
Incidentally, you may wonder why the tune is being played in C-minor (dorian). To save you some head-scratching, he is playing as though in A-minor on a B/C box. Except that his accordion is in D/D#, so up a tone and a half. :P
Thanks Stiamh, unfortunately the Tony MacMahon one requires payment to listen to.
Are you sure?
In this link (https://raelachrecords.bandcamp.com/album/scaoil-amach-an-pocaide-live-in-spiddal) (which is the one Stiamh referred to) there is a sample of the playing, close to the top of the page. Click on the play > arrow and the playback of Tony MacMahon's wonderful playing should start.
-
Are you sure?
In this link (https://raelachrecords.bandcamp.com/album/scaoil-amach-an-pocaide-live-in-spiddal) (which is the one Stiamh referred to) there is a sample of the playing, close to the top of the page. Click on the play > arrow and the playback of Tony MacMahon's wonderful playing should start.
I can listen to a couple of the tracks, but not to Máirseáil Uà Néill (unless I'm missing something).
-
Are you sure?
In this link (https://raelachrecords.bandcamp.com/album/scaoil-amach-an-pocaide-live-in-spiddal) (which is the one Stiamh referred to) there is a sample of the playing, close to the top of the page. Click on the play > arrow and the playback of Tony MacMahon's wonderful playing should start.
I can listen to a couple of the tracks, but not to Máirseáil Uà Néill (unless I'm missing something).
Ah, I wasn't sure if you'd be able to listen to all tracks. I can because I bought the record. Check your PMs. (:)
-
How do triplets relate to turns?
(See Wyper Tutorial)
Peadar, meant to answer you! Although the Wyper section on turns uses an apparent triplet to transcribe them, it's actually a different thing. Most of the turns he shows are what an Irish musician would call short rolls, where you tap a note above the target note, then the target note, then one below before settling on the target note, e.g. AGFG. His "turn on a dotted note" is a long roll - basically hitting the target note three times, interrupted once with a higher and once with a lower note, e.g. GAGFG. He's attempting tp show the relative lengths of the notes in the roll - what the listener should hear is the target note with a rhythmic rattle. The notes above and below don't have to be adjacent to the target note, by the way.
So a Turn on G ( Playing a A435 tuned British Chromatic C/C# inside out in the Wyper method)
would be CGEG ( or in concert pitch) C#G#FG#
Not that I'm going to attempt this imminently.....just sort of calculating the trajectory :||:
Edited to add: because you can't do a bellows reversal fast enough to do AGF#G .....though you could do BGF#G .... is that actually the way it's done on a modern BC?
-
Ah, I wasn't sure if you'd be able to listen to all tracks. I can because I bought the record. Check your PMs. (:)
Thanks, that's exactly what I was after!
-
TG4 video of Tony MacMahon and Steve Cooney playing O'Neill's March and Tralee Gaol as on the album Stiamh already owns and which I now intend to buy:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rB0OGwITkOc (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rB0OGwITkOc)
-
How do triplets relate to turns?
(See Wyper Tutorial)
Peadar, meant to answer you! Although the Wyper section on turns uses an apparent triplet to transcribe them, it's actually a different thing. Most of the turns he shows are what an Irish musician would call short rolls, where you tap a note above the target note, then the target note, then one below before settling on the target note, e.g. AGFG. His "turn on a dotted note" is a long roll - basically hitting the target note three times, interrupted once with a higher and once with a lower note, e.g. GAGFG. He's attempting tp show the relative lengths of the notes in the roll - what the listener should hear is the target note with a rhythmic rattle. The notes above and below don't have to be adjacent to the target note, by the way.
So a Turn on G ( Playing a A435 tuned British Chromatic C/C# inside out in the Wyper method)
would be CGEG ( or in concert pitch) C#G#FG#
Not that I'm going to attempt this imminently.....just sort of calculating the trajectory :||:
Edited to add: because you can't do a bellows reversal fast enough to do AGF#G .....though you could do BGF#G .... is that actually the way it's done on a modern BC?
I'm just looking the five turns illustrated on p. 3 of the Wyper tutor and as far as I work out not one of them could be executed on a C/C# box (either inside-out or outside-in up a semitone) without a bellows change. You could manage the "turn with a sharp" inside out BUT your first grace note would have to be a C (actually a C#) and not the A shown.
(Was PW showing these ornaments as played on some other instrument? You have to wonder.)
Unless I'm getting confused by trying to transpose all these onto a mental C outside row and C# inside row - totally possible.
If you can point us to recordings of the man himself, perhaps we could dissect what notes he is actually playing on these turns.
-
TG4 video of Tony MacMahon and Steve Cooney playing O'Neill's March and Tralee Gaol as on the album Stiamh already owns and which I now intend to buy:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rB0OGwITkOc (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rB0OGwITkOc)
Lovely to see the performance. Watch those fingers, wow! Some subtle bass working going on too. I very much intend buying the album now as well.
-
Wow! He can certainly play it better than I can 😁. Thanks for posting this.
-
How do triplets relate to turns?
(See Wyper Tutorial)
Peadar, meant to answer you! Although the Wyper section on turns uses an apparent triplet to transcribe them, it's actually a different thing. Most of the turns he shows are what an Irish musician would call short rolls, where you tap a note above the target note, then the target note, then one below before settling on the target note, e.g. AGFG. His "turn on a dotted note" is a long roll - basically hitting the target note three times, interrupted once with a higher and once with a lower note, e.g. GAGFG. He's attempting tp show the relative lengths of the notes in the roll - what the listener should hear is the target note with a rhythmic rattle. The notes above and below don't have to be adjacent to the target note, by the way.
So a Turn on G ( Playing a A435 tuned British Chromatic C/C# inside out in the Wyper method)
would be CGEG ( or in concert pitch) C#G#FG#
Not that I'm going to attempt this imminently.....just sort of calculating the trajectory :||:
Edited to add: because you can't do a bellows reversal fast enough to do AGF#G .....though you could do BGF#G .... is that actually the way it's done on a modern BC?
I'm just looking the five turns illustrated on p. 3 of the Wyper tutor and as far as I work out not one of them could be executed on a C/C# box (either inside-out or outside-in up a semitone) without a bellows change. You could manage the "turn with a sharp" inside out BUT your first grace note would have to be a C (actually a C#) and not the A shown.
(Was PW showing these ornaments as played on some other instrument? You have to wonder.)
Unless I'm getting confused by trying to transpose all these onto a mental C outside row and C# inside row - totally possible.
If you can point us to recordings of the man himself, perhaps we could dissect what notes he is actually playing on these turns.
I Think this is the earliest surviving Wyper recording.....I recognise Kelvingrove with some unusual interludes as No.2.
I think I am hearing some sort of ornamentation in there but I'm open to being told I'm talking rubbish.
https://iainpetrie.typepad.com/files/peter-wyper-empress-records.mp3
There are a number of later recordings here
https://raretunes.org/peter-wyper/
-
How do triplets relate to turns?
(See Wyper Tutorial)
Peadar, meant to answer you! Although the Wyper section on turns uses an apparent triplet to transcribe them, it's actually a different thing. Most of the turns he shows are what an Irish musician would call short rolls, where you tap a note above the target note, then the target note, then one below before settling on the target note, e.g. AGFG. His "turn on a dotted note" is a long roll - basically hitting the target note three times, interrupted once with a higher and once with a lower note, e.g. GAGFG. He's attempting tp show the relative lengths of the notes in the roll - what the listener should hear is the target note with a rhythmic rattle. The notes above and below don't have to be adjacent to the target note, by the way.
So a Turn on G ( Playing a A435 tuned British Chromatic C/C# inside out in the Wyper method)
would be CGEG ( or in concert pitch) C#G#FG#
Not that I'm going to attempt this imminently.....just sort of calculating the trajectory :||:
Edited to add: because you can't do a bellows reversal fast enough to do AGF#G .....though you could do BGF#G .... is that actually the way it's done on a modern BC?
I'm just looking the five turns illustrated on p. 3 of the Wyper tutor and as far as I work out not one of them could be executed on a C/C# box (either inside-out or outside-in up a semitone) without a bellows change. You could manage the "turn with a sharp" inside out BUT your first grace note would have to be a C (actually a C#) and not the A shown.
(Was PW showing these ornaments as played on some other instrument? You have to wonder.)
Unless I'm getting confused by trying to transpose all these onto a mental C outside row and C# inside row - totally possible.
If you can point us to recordings of the man himself, perhaps we could dissect what notes he is actually playing on these turns.
I Think this is the earliest surviving Wyper recording.....I recognise Kelvingrove with some unusual interludes as No.2.
I think I am hearing some sort of ornamentation in there but I'm open to being told I'm talking rubbish.
https://iainpetrie.typepad.com/files/peter-wyper-empress-records.mp3
There are a number of later recordings here
https://raretunes.org/peter-wyper/
I finally had a listen to most of these tracks - at least once through each tune - and I didn't spot anything that sounded to me remotely like the turns illustrated in the tutor. Perhaps you need to find an expert on P. Wyper's playing. I wondered whether Luke Daniels' project to record the tunes of a vintage Scottish player on a refurbished original instrument (refurbished by Theo I believe) might provide some insight, but a search revealed that the player concerned was Wm Hannah, not Peter Wyper, and a brief listen to those tracks on YT didn't turn up (groan) anything like what we are talking about.