Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Pete Dunk on August 06, 2020, 06:23:43 PM
-
A little while ago I bought a pressed-wood Hohner 1040C that was in a pretty sorry state. Notably the bellows were in need of major refurbishment or replacement, there were cracks around the action boards, reeds falling off the blocks, pallets in a state and straps/fixings missing, also a broken bass button. So, the usual fare, but the woodwork was fairly tidy and the price was right.
I already have a 1040C in the more common Vienna or pokerwork style livery and I like it a lot. What I really wanted was a 1040 in D but I don't think such a thing was ever made by Hohner and I decided to refurb it in C. Anyway, I set to and stripped all of the pallets out and refaced them, limited the treble action, then sorted out various cracks in and around the "soundboards" and replaced the bellows gaskets. In the meantime I'd ordered bellows tape and replacement valve sets for this job and a two row that I also have on the bench at the moment, along with various other bits and bobs from Charlie Marshall.
Then, a couple of weeks ago, I had an unexpected modest windfall and I thought it would be nice to use it to buy myself a keepsake to mark the occasion, then I came up with the idea of making the 1040 into a D box using a new set of reeds that I would be playing for years to come, perfect.
Charlie doesn't stock any loose Hohner reeds, just the ones already mounted on sets of new blocks and suggested I bought some from the C Shop but I didn't fancy that and had a chat with him about using Cagnoni reeds instead. His only reservation was that the Italian bass reeds were mounted on noticably smaller and thicker plates. I also wanted to swap out the standard lowest treble plates to give me a pull B3 on the first button, the easiest thing I could do was use G3/B3 plates and tune the two Gs down to F# but he wasn't sure these would fit the existing blocks. I've had to modify the four bass reed block apertures to make them slightly shorter and narrower which was straightforward enough and the new G/B plates went straight in the treble end which was a bonus. All still to tune up of course but I gave it a quick blast (as you do) and it sounds glorious already!
Pics of refurbished bellows and new reeds to follow, once finished I'll knock up a sound file too. Has anyone else converted a 1040 to D?
-
I bought a factory 1040 D from a melnetter in Dorset I think. This was after posting a wanted ad on here (for any key!) Excellent box, I sold it to a melnetter in USA.
-
hi i converted a 1040c using Cagnoni TAM reeds into D about 20 years ago but stopped playing the melodeon due to RS i play banjo and fiddle and it was interfering ! it sounded great but has not been played for 20 years i should sell it if interested phone 07792997789
-
Pics as promised. Old bellows tape stripped off and cutting new papers for the folds.
-
Pasting the papers and one side complete.
-
Long sides taped, ready to start the top and bottom sides.
-
Taping every other fold to leave room to work. When dry, tape the rest.
-
Has anyone else converted a 1040 to D?
Yes, I put a mano Binci MM reeds in D into one back in the 1990s and it made a great box! I'm not sure who bought it and where it is now, but I hope it's still playing away.
You do occasionally come across original 1040 boxes (and related models - i.e. Vienna style 1-row boxes with 10 melody keys, 4 basses, and melody reeds on individual plates, flat-mounted) in D, as was mentioned above. I have an unrestored example of one of these, from the 1930s with nice D reeds on zinc plates. Currently torn between the effort to restore its pretty beat-up bellows and case, or to transplant those nice reeds into a 1950s goldbrand example that's near mint but in the more common key of C.
PG
-
That's coming on nicely, Pete.
The corners look like they haven't suffered too much before you got your hands on it.
My latest one was rubbish!
-
I was lucky enough to pick up a Mike Rowbotham 1930's presswood in D from the Melnet buy and sell column. Anyone familiar with Mike's work will know how nicely this instrument has been set up. "D" is marked on the wooden keyboard, so it is in the original key, making it a rare beast indeed.
The 1040s are strident instruments, due to the flat mounted reeds. Mine is a touch mellower, perhaps due to the circa 1930s reeds. Nonetheless, it has tons of punch. I'm glad to have it.
-
I have two 1040-Vienna in D,original Hohner came in card box.Hohner did make them but in small quantity I'd guess.
I'd be very interested to hear the sound once finished, good job :||:
-
I'll probably come in for some stick as I'm tuning it pretty dry. :o
-
I decided to get the reed waxing out of the way next. Out with the old and in with the new.
-
I decided to tackle the broken bass button next but the lot had to come off to bush the holes out. I was a bit pensive about removing the old buttons but in the end it was just a careful tug-o-war!
-
I then uncoupled the lever springs and removed the bass mech from the box.
-
I straightened out the levers and bent them here and there to get the lengths even. I then reamed out the button holes (good job I already had a violin peg reamer).
-
Then cut and fitted felt bushing. Sorry about all of the single posts but most of my pics are slightly too big to get two in a post!
-
Refitted the bass mech, all ready to fit the buttons.
-
One new button looked a bit odd really so I fitted a complete new set. Time for tuning!
-
Tuning started today and may be finished by tomorrow, I'm pretty slow at tuning!
-
First tuning completed, I like to play a box for a day or three to let it settle down then go over it again. This is probably my relative inexperience showing, I doubt old hands at tuning need to do this. I like the sound of the box being almost dry tuned. I'll see how it settles in, brush up the tuning, and then record it playing. This gives me a better idea of the overall sound for some reason, I've no idea if other people do this when tuning boxes.
-
First tuning completed, I like to play a box for a day or three to let it settle down then go over it again. This is probably my relative inexperience showing,...
On the contrary, this is a very sensible approach, especially if you are tuning to a very light tremolo.
Reeds DO take a while to settle down; it is no reflection on your tuning technique. The best thing you can do after a tuning session is to leave-play-leave-play, etc., over the course of a couple of days or so; then re-check and adjust as necessary. With typical Hohner wetness there is probably less need to do this, but anything approaching Castagnari 'light swing' needs some settling time, in my experience.
-
Thanks for the positive comments Steve, nice to know I'm not being too pedantic. :D
While allowing the reeds to settle a bit I turned my attention to a few of the minor details that needed sorting out like cleaning up the treble buttons, fixing lots of minor dings in the woodwork, sorting the treble grille out etc. The grille was rusty and quite badly pitted in places, I would ordinarily have cleaned it up as much as possible and classed it as 'patina' but I wanted to do a decent makeover on this box and considered sending it of to be cleaned up and re-plated. A brand new modern pattern grille was £30 from Charlie at CGM and I didn't think I would save much, if anything getting it re-plated, so bought a new one instead and think it looks pretty good. Here are various pics of the box as it is now, I hope to record it playing today or tomorrow, before the next (and hopefully final) round of tuning.
-
Another pic
-
There were two large holes in the back of the fingerboard where I drilled out two rivets and removed the broken thumb strap. After a bit of pondering I decided to replace the strap rather than just fill in the holes.
-
Another pic.
-
Another pic.
-
Bellows.
-
Another pic.
-
Bass end.
-
Final pic for the day, the new grille. It's a bit glaringly new but I'm happy with it, why shouldn't an old box be treated to a bit of finery now and again?
-
Yeah, the box looks cared for with new parts as needed. All in all it is really neat now. I can understand some people prefer to try to return an old box to as new and original condition, but once anything makes that impossible why not make improvements? I like the Italian bellows tape - neater, prettier and durable unlike the coloured bog paper Hohner have been using for decades. I've seen new boxes with the tape worn before they've left the shop. Sensible upgrades and replacement parts show it to be a working instrument rather than a museum piece. Believe me, a shot out grille can be painful halfway through a tune when it comes adrift (in pieces).
I believe that for a short time Hohner had some replacement stradella corners available in stainless, which would have been an ideal upgrade, but they seem to have abandoned that idea. Can't remember who it was who managed to get their old grille pressed flat and sprayed it and the corners with a semi-matt black paint. That looked great, too.
I have known cases of less experienced tuners turning a box around same day. It doesn't go down well when after a couple of days in the post it arrives more out of tune than when it was sent away!
Anyway, if it is now how you want it to be, then that's a result - and one which will many of us here a little green with envy. There's something seductive about a Pressedwood ...
Rob.
P.S. If you spray the old grille you can dress for any occasion - bling or the little black number?
-
It's lovely, Pete!
I was a bit surprised to see that it didn't have the hook type of feet on the bass end, though. Would that indicate that the Pressedwood models are post war?
-
It's lovely, Pete!
I was a bit surprised to see that it didn't have the hook type of feet on the bass end, though. Would that indicate that the Pressedwood models are post war?
[/quote
May be a replacement back plate.. I have presswood in the waiting room that has the hook feet.
-
It's lovely, Pete!
I was a bit surprised to see that it didn't have the hook type of feet on the bass end, though. Would that indicate that the Pressedwood models are post war?
May be a replacement back plate.. I have presswood in the waiting room that has the hook feet.
I'm not quite sure what is meant by hook feet, could someone post a pic?
As is the way of things, I've been prevented from getting back to this box for several days and have been plagued by some mysterious tuning issues. They're not so mysterious now as they were all caused by my inept waxing in of some of the reed plates and a number of internal valves fouling the blocks as the apertures barely leave sufficient clearance for the slightly larger Italian plates. I have them all sounding properly now but need to go back over it all with a touch up tuning.
P.S. If you spray the old grille you can dress for any occasion - bling or the little black number?
I may do that! ;D
-
'Yer 'tis!
-
Funny how interests overlap. I was looking into the possibility of making some bits to improve the realism of one of my replica air pistols and came across a Youtube video showing DIY nickel plating. If you could get the original grille cleaned flattened and polished this would be an ideal way to refinish it! And of course you now have all the time in the world to find a cost effective way of doing it.
Rob.