Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: CAB on August 06, 2020, 11:36:19 PM

Title: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: CAB on August 06, 2020, 11:36:19 PM
This is a really basic question but I've had no luck searching the archives for an answer so I'm hoping someone can point me in the right direction.  I'm putting it under Teaching and Learning but it's also a design/layout question.

I've generally played a DG 8 bass but something I've rarely made any use of is the pushed C chord and bass.  If I want to play a C chord with a right hand G note, I use a pulled G from the D row.  In fact, on an instrument I bought around 10 years ago, I had the pushed C replaced by an F chord and bass (effectively a Club system left hand?)  - with pushed right hand Fs to match.  It's been nice for a few tunes but grossly underused.  I'd have done better to have an F# minor, giving me an F# bass for playing in D.

But everyone seems to go with the C chord both ways so I'm obviously missing something.  I'd love to know how people use them.  I can see 3 possible uses:
1.  to play a C chord with a G bass;
2.  to use as C minor (3rd out) with a pushed right-hand Eb;
3.  maybe a few nice crunchy discords. 

Otherwise I'm flummoxed. 

How do you use yours please?
Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: george garside on August 06, 2020, 11:54:24 PM
use it when it sounds ok, don't when it doesn't.  Same goes for the other  bass/chord buttons on a DG box.

george
Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: Gena Crisman on August 07, 2020, 03:28:05 AM
How do you use yours please?

Here are some ideas:

Hope that helps - I might be able to think of some other uses later.
Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on August 07, 2020, 08:36:41 AM
I've just started using it as a G bass and C chord.
Instead of G bass then G chord the melody sits better with the C chord, almost as a passing note onto the next part of the tune.
One of those incidents when the hand took over from the brain and.... it works .
Q
Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: Ellisteph on August 07, 2020, 10:09:17 AM
This is a really basic question but I've had no luck searching the archives for an answer so I'm hoping someone can point me in the right direction.  I'm putting it under Teaching and Learning but it's also a design/layout question.

I've generally played a DG 8 bass but something I've rarely made any use of is the pushed C chord and bass.  If I want to play a C chord with a right hand G note, I use a pulled G from the D row.  In fact, on an instrument I bought around 10 years ago, I had the pushed C replaced by an F chord and bass (effectively a Club system left hand?)  - with pushed right hand Fs to match.  It's been nice for a few tunes but grossly underused.  I'd have done better to have an F# minor, giving me an F# bass for playing in D.

But everyone seems to go with the C chord both ways so I'm obviously missing something.  I'd love to know how people use them.  I can see 3 possible uses:
1.  to play a C chord with a G bass;
2.  to use as C minor (3rd out) with a pushed right-hand Eb;
3.  maybe a few nice crunchy discords. 

Otherwise I'm flummoxed. 

How do you use yours please?
One fairly obvious use which occurs to me is if you want to play in the key of C on your DG. Here's a modest example from me; admittedly I'm also using an F chord which you wouldn't have on an 8 bass DG, but there are ways of fudging round that:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M0qdeetKb54
Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: rees on August 07, 2020, 10:28:36 AM
I find the push C chord essential. It gives a feeling of suspension before resolving back to the G chord.
I think I use it more often than I think I do (if that makes any sense!)
Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: Julian S on August 07, 2020, 10:49:16 AM
On one of my 12 bass D/Gs, rather than a unisonoric C bass/chord I've got a C pull paired with a F push, and a Cpush with a G pull. It was confusing for  the first five years of ownership but does work - particularly playing in C I think. Now I'm only confused when I change between instruments...

J
Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: Tufty on August 07, 2020, 04:54:20 PM
use it when it sounds ok, don't when it doesn't.  Same goes for the other  bass/chord buttons on a DG box.

george
And I thought I was the only one who still played that way  ;)
Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: rees on August 07, 2020, 09:25:22 PM
use it when it sounds ok, don't when it doesn't.  Same goes for the other  bass/chord buttons on a DG box.

george
And I thought I was the only one who still played that way  ;)

Join the club :)
Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: Anahata on August 07, 2020, 11:07:16 PM
My only common use for it is for a C chord when I'm playing a G.
And of course, that's not essential becasuse there a pull G on the D row.
I have a Club box and the push chord (not F but Eâ™­ on a C/F box) is rarely a problem, and only then when I forget through force of habit.

The only problem with that being an F chord is that the only right hand note it fits is the A on the D row. Better if your Fâ™® accidental is on push, but that has other disadvantages.

Making it an F♯ is an interesting idea. It opens up the possibilities for playing in B minor. (and, as suggested above, an F♯ bass when playing in D.) And playing whole tunes in G on the bass buttons...
Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: Steve_freereeder on August 08, 2020, 08:46:52 AM
use it when it sounds ok, don't when it doesn't.  Same goes for the other  bass/chord buttons on a DG box.

george
And I thought I was the only one who still played that way  ;)

Join the club :)

Me too!
I'm a great believer in what is attributed to Norfolk melodeon maestro Tony Hall - 'I just pokes about a bit and if it sounds alright, I use it'
Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: george garside on August 08, 2020, 09:41:44 AM
for those not familiar with Tony Halls playing there are several  youtube vids of him. 'tony hall melodeon' should bring them up

george
Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on August 08, 2020, 10:13:21 AM
I remember asking Owen Woods of this parish the same question regarding adding right hand notes to form chords.
Same answer " poke about with your finger and if it sounds right.... "
The mantra for us melodeonistas 😎
Q
Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: george garside on August 08, 2020, 10:44:40 AM
on the basis that only one finger is required at any given point to play the 'tune note' there will always be 3 fingers available to bring in other right hand notes to form chords which we don't even need to know the name of!  the 'spare' fingers can also/ instead be used to beat a bit of extra rhythm  here and there  '

A good way of facilitating/getting the hang of this is to have a go at playing a few tunes using just one finger a'nd than a different one etc

This exercise  helps to get away from the idea that a particular figner has to be used to play a particular note  , introduces compulsory 'staccato' playing ( the one finger has to be lifted off a button bwteen notes on different buttons)  and facilitates playing other notes with whatever finger is available. Winster gallop is quite easy and of course waltzes and slow aires are even easier to 'one finger'
'
This is obviously an exercise and I am not suggesting it is used  in 'normal' playing. 

Doing things with spare right hand fingers is greatly facilitated by having the box firmly attached to the person rather than gripping the edge of the keyboard to steady it.

george

 







w
Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on August 08, 2020, 11:01:35 AM
George, I think I've heard JK say similar things regarding just using one finger when trying to learn a tune.
Q
Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: CAB on August 08, 2020, 04:15:59 PM
for those not familiar with Tony Halls playing there are several  youtube vids of him. 'tony hall melodeon' should bring them up
george

I'd forgotten about the great Tony Hall, who I used to listen to back in the day.  Fieldvole Music was rarely far from the turntable.  George's timely reminder led me straight to this clip which, along with one of Gena's tips (sort of), provides one answer to my original query.  Admittedly, he's not using a C-both-ways drone here on Calliope House but droning the A bass and chord and playing much of the tune (in A) on the draw - with great air-button control.  But it does demonstrate nicely the effect of playing over a drone, though personally I'd have gone into a more varied accompaniment second time round.  I'm not fond of what he does with the second tune on the video, 100 Pipers as a waltz in D, but that first minute or so is magic.  By coincidence, 100 Pipers works very well in A on a DG as a jig.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9gZ01ByPQj8 (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9gZ01ByPQj8)
As George says, there are some great recordings of him on Youtube, even one where he's reprising a track from Penguin Eggs with Nick Jones & son.

So glad I asked this question!  Some brilliant responses, which I shall respond to shortly.  I'm not a proponent of the "poke about a bit" school.  Apart from very occasional serendipity, I like to know what I'm aiming for and why it works.  This includes reviewing the available left-hand chords and deciding which one sounds best before deciding on the row and bellows direction for particular notes and phrases.  I  agree it can work for finding right hand chords, mind.
Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on August 08, 2020, 05:24:24 PM
...I'm not a proponent of the "poke about a bit" school.  Apart from very occasional serendipity, I like to know what I'm aiming for and why it works.  This includes reviewing the available left-hand chords and deciding which one sounds best before deciding on the row and bellows direction for particular notes and phrases.  I  agree it can work for finding right hand chords, mind.

In fairness, I think those who apply the poke about a bit approach generally do so in full awareness of what they're poking and why (or why not), it might work in a particular situation They are not really idiot savants.
Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: Dick Rees on August 08, 2020, 05:58:51 PM
for those not familiar with Tony Halls playing there are several  youtube vids of him. 'tony hall melodeon' should bring them up
george
I'm not a proponent of the "poke about a bit" school.  Apart from very occasional serendipity, I like to know what I'm aiming for and why it works.  This includes reviewing the available left-hand chords and deciding which one sounds best before deciding on the row and bellows direction for particular notes and phrases.  I  agree it can work for finding right hand chords, mind.

"There are more things in heaven and Earth, Horatio, / Than are dreamt of in your philosophy."

Shakey Willie

T Hall on da Tube:

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC_mV36o-c9f--UCBItLRmuw

Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: Gena Crisman on August 08, 2020, 07:00:07 PM
In fairness, I think those who apply the poke about a bit approach generally do so in full awareness of what they're poking and why (or why not), it might work in a particular situation They are not really idiot savants.

I mean, in that case, you might expect that their advice wouldn't be 'just poke at stuff', but would be a fair bit more nuanced? You can definitely build up a knowledge library of things that sound good together, and which buttons in which directions sound good with each chord, empirically, and just go to that toolbox whenever you want it. Like, it's not as if that isn't what I'm also doing, I'm just, y'know, going about it differently.

In any case, the push C chord is definitely the weakest chord in the standard D/G setup in terms of notes it jams with on the melody side. It has only the 1 chord tone, G, typically being found in the same direction. Pull D typically has 2 chord tones along with push B major maybe only have 2 (3 with a push D#), and with the rest having all 3 chord tones present.

Given we don't have the F# minor chord from our D major scale on the box (the only absent non-diminished diatonic chord across the keys of G and D), you could I suppose consider putting that in the mix? however F# minor is made of F A C#, so, not being able to pair it with the C# ever is a bit sad. I generally think of it as being a pull chord, but, IIRC some 2.5/12 layouts (with the A & G reversals maybe?) put it as a press chord and don't offer a push C# so I'm sure it is a survivable compromise, so... idk maybe ditching push C would work for some people?

As an accidental flipper, though, I really do rely on it being available both ways.
Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: george garside on August 08, 2020, 07:55:50 PM
for what its worth I often use the pull C bass note rather than the chord when playing in G and similarly use the  pull B bass note when playing in D.

Its very each to his or her own  the pokers and prodders  having little or no formal 'classical' music  theory training  whilst those with  a modicum or more of theory understandably keep this in mind to a great or lesser degree'

Both 'schools' have  a mixture of crap and brilliant button box players   and everything in between,

I do however personally think that historically the melodeon is an unsophisticated 'folk; instrument  that responds very well to a simple intuitive  approach. 

But of course each to their own and  there is probably a lot to be said for using 'a bit of both' approaches

george


Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: Tufty on August 08, 2020, 09:06:54 PM
In fairness, I think those who apply the poke about a bit approach generally do so in full awareness of what they're poking and why (or why not), it might work in a particular situation They are not really idiot savants.
[/quote]
I am! (Or at least half way ;D)
Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on August 08, 2020, 09:10:32 PM
Quote
In fairness, I think those who apply the poke about a bit approach generally do so in full awareness of what they're poking and why (or why not), it might work in a particular situation They are not really idiot savants.
I am! (Or at least half way ;D)

Just because you don't hang labels on things doesn't mean you don't know what it sounds like. It's clear that you know how to make it sound good.


I mean, in that case, you might expect that their advice wouldn't be 'just poke at stuff', but would be a fair bit more nuanced? ...

To put it another way, you can make your judgements based on what it sounds like, rather than what it looks like on paper. As an approach, it's not without nuance.
Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: Dave Praties on August 09, 2020, 09:44:48 AM
In fairness, I think those who apply the poke about a bit approach generally do so in full awareness of what they're poking and why (or why not), it might work in a particular situation They are not really idiot savants.
I am! (Or at least half way ;D)
[/quote]

I agree. The great improvisations of Bach, and Gunner Idenstam today are just informed pokings about. Nothing wrong with it at any level though, I poke about on a duet concertina at a very low level, but am learning by the process. Not sure how happy it makes my poor wife though!
Dave
Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: CAB on August 09, 2020, 10:33:06 AM
T Hall on da Tube:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC_mV36o-c9f--UCBItLRmuw

Good link thanks, Dick.   Never had that album so I shall enjoy that.
I no longer have the wherewithal to play my old 1970s vinyl copy of the earlier Fieldvole Music, which seems not to be on Youtube, but I see it's now available as a CD
https://www.free-reed.co.uk/frrr03  ... along with some of the label's other great recordings, including How to Make a Bakewell Tart!  Great stuff!
https://www.free-reed.co.uk/frrrs1

On the subject of "poking about" It just sounds like misplaced modesty to me.  Some fine players generously share their skills here and too much humility is not always helpful.  Just my two pennorth, as they say.  Loadsa good ideas from others.  And two camps do seem to have developed as to what the phrase means!  For me, as soon as it's informed, it stops being poking about.  But let's not get into semantics.
Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: Anahata on August 09, 2020, 10:46:55 AM
The skill isn't in the poking about, it's in recognising which of those experiments sounds good.
Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: george garside on August 09, 2020, 11:41:08 AM
absolutely agree!   
According to the Oxford dictionary 'nuance'  means 'subtle shade of meaning, feeling, colour etc'.
Good 'by ear''  players  have ,by definition, to indulge in a great deal of nuancing! and have the freedom so to do. 
some readers may find it more difficult as they endeaver to reproduce exactly what is written
nk
some less than good players  of either sort  think playing the right notes in the right order is doing the job!

Perhaps  those who do a bit of both have the best chance of going to town on nuancing and  thereby of putting their own stamp on what they play.

george
Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: Howard Jones on August 09, 2020, 12:18:11 PM
I frequently use the push C chord with the G bass.  No doubt someone will be able to put a name to what I'm doing, I just poke buttons until I find a sound I like.

I taught myself to play guitar from a book where chords were represented by "windows", diagrams of the strings and frets with dots to show where the fingers go. I learned to think of chords as shapes rather than as groups of notes.  When I started playing anglo concertina I poked about until I found the chords I wanted.  Later I worked out what some of them are called, but I still think of them as shapes rather than notes.  When I picked up a melodeon I just started playing tunes, without worrying about what the notes were called - I can find the G and D but after that I have to work my way up the scale.  I know the main chord button pairs but couldn't put names to cross-rowed chords.  Over the years I've picked up a few bits of music theory but I don't actually consciously apply it when I play.

I do have what Gena called a "toolkit" and I know how to achieve the sound I want, usually without too much trial and error, but I lack the theoretical background to explain it or the vocabulary to talk about it.
Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on August 09, 2020, 01:17:51 PM
I frequently use the push C chord with the G bass.  No doubt someone will be able to put a name to what I'm doing, I just poke buttons until I find a sound I like.

You're playing the C chord with a G bass  :D
Guitar speak, C/G
Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: Winston Smith on August 09, 2020, 01:25:30 PM
Thanks for that full explanation, Howard. Other than that I've never played the push C chord over a G bass, I could have written it about my own learning path to date, but your version is more thoroughly elucidated.
Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on August 09, 2020, 01:30:24 PM
Last year in a workshop, the tutor made the point that generally in musical notation "bass goes under the chord" as Greg describes.
I've taken to use this notation when adding basses and chords to my abc transcriptions.
If it's a bass run then I'd notate it as /G,  /A, /B for a G-A-B bass run.
Annoyingly abc apps don't seem to 'see' this.....
Q
Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: CAB on August 09, 2020, 03:49:25 PM
I taught myself to play guitar from a book where chords were represented by "windows", diagrams of the strings and frets with dots to show where the fingers go. I learned to think of chords as shapes rather than as groups of notes.  When I started playing anglo concertina I poked about until I found the chords I wanted.  Later I worked out what some of them are called, but I still think of them as shapes rather than notes.  When I picked up a melodeon I just started playing tunes, without worrying about what the notes were called - I can find the G and D but after that I have to work my way up the scale.  I know the main chord button pairs but couldn't put names to cross-rowed chords.  Over the years I've picked up a few bits of music theory but I don't actually consciously apply it when I play.

After many years of playing, on and off, the melodeon remains the only instrument I play where I don't automatically know which note I'm playing at a given moment without having to think about it.  Muscle memory lets me find a tune and play basic chords without thinking about it.  It's only when I want to do something more interesting that I consciously apply musical knowledge or theory.  Then gradually, those theoretically worked out bits become embedded in the muscle memory and crop up automatically in other tunes. 
Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: Calum on August 09, 2020, 04:29:24 PM
In fairness, I think those who apply the poke about a bit approach generally do so in full awareness of what they're poking and why (or why not), it might work in a particular situation They are not really idiot savants.
I mean, in that case, you might expect that their advice wouldn't be 'just poke at stuff', but would be a fair bit more nuanced?

I got in trouble last time I suggested that what people, even very good players, say and what they do may be two different things, consciously or unconsciously.  And given our societal worship of "talent" as opposed to "hard work", there is a certain amount of prestige involved in being known to be an "idiot savant"...
Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: Lester on August 09, 2020, 05:31:35 PM
Can we please stop using the 'idiot savant' term, now it is usually referred to as savant syndrome or autistic savant. The use of idiot to describe some one with learning or mental disabilities should be, and in my house is, considered offensive.
Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on August 09, 2020, 05:40:26 PM
Can we please stop using the 'idiot savant' term, now it is usually referred to as savant syndrome or autistic savant. The use of idiot to describe some one with learning or mental disabilities should be, and in my house is, considered offensive.

Apologies. Ididn't realise it might be offensive.
Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: CAB on August 11, 2020, 05:22:43 PM
  Big thank you to all who responded to my original query and contributed to this thread.  I shall be trying out the ideas in the coming weeks.  Here's what I think has been suggested:

USING THE PUSHED C BASS & CHORD ON A DG MELODEON

1.  Combining the chord with a RH note to create a new chord: 
a) Thirds out, with a RH Eb to give a C minor chord.  Nice when playing in G minor or in D Freygish
b) With RH Bb to give C7

2.  The C bass combined with another chord:
a) With D chord to suggest D7
b) With G chord as appropriate, either block chord or G bass followed by C chord

3.  Playing a C chord/bass with a RH note that exists only on the push, e.g. bottom octave G

4.  Holding a C chord/bass for suspense when the phrase cannot be played all on the pull, i.e. in the absence of pulled Ds

5.  To get the bellows back in when there’s too much pull in the tune – e.g. some A minor tunes

6.  To minimise row-crossing, e.g. when playing in C or doing the suspense thing.

ALTERNATIVE LAYOUTS
 1.  Replacing pushed LH C with F major, as on a club, has some value if you have pushed RH Fs.  I find this useful for playing in G mix and Am (with pushed RH A) but also possibly in C major and Dm (3rds out)
 2. Replacing pushed LH C with F# minor opens up several possibilities – a rocking bass when playing in D; a complete G scale in the bass; and a useful chord for playing tunes in D major and in B minor.

Title: Re: Using the pushed C chord on a DG
Post by: Theo on August 11, 2020, 05:41:02 PM
Another one C chord plus D bass, C9 chord available on both directions. 
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal