Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Guy on October 02, 2009, 12:06:36 PM

Title: Alternatives to D/G Tommy
Post by: Guy on October 02, 2009, 12:06:36 PM
I’m thinking of finding a replacement for my D/G Tommy, used a lot for band gigs and morris. I like the size and weight, want something with 3 voices and stops on both treble and bass and would like both the low notes and accidentals on the treble. I know that there’s nothing to beat playing instruments, but I live in South Wales so can’t try things locally (unless someone knows differently!). I’m looking for suggestions at this stage-except of course, if the ideal box comes along- so any advice/opinions would be welcome-there’s so much experience out there to draw on!

Of course, this may be my latest outbreak of MAD….

Thanks,
Guy
Title: Re: Alternatives to D/G Tommy
Post by: Steve_freereeder on October 02, 2009, 12:41:40 PM
Normally, favouring Castagnari instruments over Saltarelles, I have nevertheless been very pleasantly surprised by the Saltarelle L'elfique. It's much the same size and weight as a Tommy, has 3 treble voices LMM with a stop to control the L voice and unlike the Tommy has a stop to control the 3rds in the LH chords. I believe it also has a 4th button start, so you would get both low notes and accidentals on the RH side. And it's cheaper than a Tommy.

I know Lester has/had one, and may be able to add to this.

The Music Room stocks them here:
http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php/cPath/244_249_485/products_id/2817
Title: Re: Alternatives to D/G Tommy
Post by: craigus on October 02, 2009, 12:50:54 PM
I've recently bought a Beltuna Sara 3 from Hobgoblin. I think they've got a couple more in stock.
It's very nice - similar in size to the tommy / elfique, with treble stop and bass stop. Very loud and punchy, and nice tone. I was tempted by a tommy and an excelsior, and played all three, and the beltuna definitely came out top. Beltuna are a highly regarded piano accordian maker from Italy, but fairly new to melodeons I think.
Have a listen here and see what you think: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_8e2Qj4_NaM
And here with just two voices in: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e1SuI1EiMGY
Title: Re: Alternatives to D/G Tommy
Post by: Lester on October 02, 2009, 01:01:24 PM
I know Lester has/had one, and may be able to add to this.

I indeed have a L'Elfique which I prefer to my Tommy (mind you the Tommy is 15 years old). The stop in the bass for the thirds is a boon and I prefer the Salterelle sound. Steve (in a rare display of fallibility  ;D ) is, sadly,  wrong about the 4th button start, now if that was true it would make it the best box in the whole world (YMMV)
Title: Re: Alternatives to D/G Tommy
Post by: ganderbox on October 02, 2009, 01:05:49 PM
I had a go on the Beltuna Sara 3 on the Hobgoblin stand at Sidmouth, and liked it very much. If I didn't already have a Tommy I might well have considered buying it.
Title: Re: Alternatives to D/G Tommy
Post by: craigus on October 02, 2009, 01:06:14 PM
Craig! Just realised that you are with Kneehigh. I never miss if possible. Tristan & Yseult was one of the greatest shows I have ever seen. (Sorry for severe thread drift, everyone.)

 :|bl thank you, that's very kind of you.
oh no, now my two separate identities have collided! Ah well, my kneehigh colleagues put up with my melodeon geekiness, but here it can flourish!!! ;D
Title: Re: Alternatives to D/G Tommy
Post by: EeeJay on October 02, 2009, 01:49:11 PM
Another direct, compact, Tommy equivalent is the Excelsior Bilbo (http://www.hobgoblin.com/bigpicswebsite/gr4248.jpg) (or Kerry (http://www.hobgoblin.com/bigpicswebsite/gr4248.jpg)).

I had a go on one of these last year - a jet black, 21 button closed stepped keyboard box, which was very nice and the bass end was far more balanced acoustically than a Tommy on the same shelf.

Another, 'under the radar' box worth a serious look is the Serenellini Lady (http://www.harmonicahoek.nl/archief/2009/2009_04_09/serenellini_lady.jpg). I'm slightly at odds with the model name (this keeps springing to my mind (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AxLBpa7g5fg) for some twisted reason ;D), but hey, what's in a name? Bilbo also sounds a bit daft (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mPh12Q7cpeE)... ::)

Basically, it's just a slightly bigger, 3 voice version of the Sellí model. Fitted with a stop at each end (or one, or even none, if you so wish). Very popular in Holland by all accounts... quite a few of these turn up on YouTube...

Ed J
Title: Re: Alternatives to D/G Tommy
Post by: rees on October 02, 2009, 02:20:56 PM
Due in from Castagnari in the next week or so is a D/G Sander Custom.
TAM reeds, third stop, scale starts on button 4 (low notes and accidentals). £1995.
Title: Re: Alternatives to D/G Tommy
Post by: Guy on October 02, 2009, 02:39:50 PM
Ah, Rees, you know the way to interest a person in the grip of MAD! I've never tried a Sander-how does the weight/size compare to the Tommy? And is it a 3-voice?

Ta,
Guy
Title: Re: Alternatives to D/G Tommy
Post by: rees on October 02, 2009, 02:47:40 PM
Just casting my baited hook into the pond - mwahahah  >:E

Full spec on Tommy and Sander can be found here: http://www.castagnari.it/index.php?strparam=&language=uk&sz=300 (http://www.castagnari.it/index.php?strparam=&language=uk&sz=300)

The Sander has a full size keyboard compared to the more compact Tommy.
The Sander has a fuller sound due being a larger box.
Title: Re: Alternatives to D/G Tommy
Post by: Steve_freereeder on October 02, 2009, 03:25:03 PM
Ah, Rees, you know the way to interest a person in the grip of MAD! I've never tried a Sander-how does the weight/size compare to the Tommy? And is it a 3-voice?

Ta,
Guy
Guy,
I also have a custom Sander which is my "outdoor box", and very nice it is too. It is 3-voice LMM, with TAM reeds, 4th button start, just as Rees describes. With the TAM reeds, it is pretty much like a Hascy, except it doesn't have such a fancy grille or inlaid woodwork. It definitely has a fuller sound than a Tommy, partly due to the larger size, but I think also because the bass reeds have 3 reeds instead of the Tommy's two. (unless they've changed the spec of the Tommy - edited to add: yes - I think they have, according to the Castagnari website).

On the down-side, it does not have a LH stop to take out the 3rds from the chords. But mine does have the B chord very usefully as B minor instead of B major.

The Sander is a standard sized two-row instrument (as is the Beltuna Sara 3 mentioned earlier in this thread) and definitely a bit larger than the Tommy.

... Steve (in a rare display of fallibility  ;D ) is, sadly,  wrong about the 4th button start, now if that was true it would make it the best box in the whole world (YMMV)
Ah well, you can't win 'em all. ;D
I agree with Lester about the usefulness of the 4th button start though. I'm sure it would not be too difficult to customise the Elfique to a 4BS and it would then be a great little box.


Title: Re: Alternatives to D/G Tommy
Post by: Guy on October 07, 2009, 03:04:01 PM
Thanks to everyone who sent replies-that was all very useful advice, and has cleared my mind considerably about what I actually want...I had the chance to have a try on a friend's Lilium at the weekend too as a comparison, so it's definately a smaller box rather than a "full size" two-row that I'll be looking for right now...

Ta again,
Guy
Title: Re: Alternatives to D/G Tommy
Post by: Rob2Hook on October 09, 2009, 01:42:39 PM
Oh...
the Lilium is a lovely box!  Although it is the antithesis of what you seem to be seeking, it does have a wonderful sound - but with all the stops and metalwork it comes in a little heavy.  Mind, the Trilly which replaced it has even more mechanical bits as it uses PA style selectors with all the attendant links and requires a careful posture when playing standing to preclude ahcing back and shoulders.

Rob.
Title: Re: Alternatives to D/G Tommy
Post by: Steve_freereeder on October 09, 2009, 01:56:25 PM
Oh...
the Lilium is a lovely box! 
Oh yes indeed!

Quote
but with all the stops and metalwork it comes in a little heavy.
It never seems heavy to me, perhaps because it is so responsive it just about plays itself.
I think it is a shame that Castagnari stopped making them. Mind you, the Trilly is an excellent replacement.
Title: Re: Alternatives to D/G Tommy
Post by: Guy on October 09, 2009, 11:11:06 PM
Indeed, this particular Lilium was a beautiful box too-but I could only prise it away from its owner for long enough to play a couple of tunes on it! I meant that it was enough to make me sure that I need (or, more correctly, want) a smaller two row to tote around for band gigs and Morris, as I also have a big 2.5 row....but it was VERY nice to play....and if someone had one they didn't want.....

No, I must be firm...I think....

Guy
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal