Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Johnny S on August 10, 2020, 06:54:48 PM

Title: Cracked Wooden Keyboard - Repair or Replace
Post by: Johnny S on August 10, 2020, 06:54:48 PM
When a keyboard has hole-to-hole cracks, what techniques are there to strengthen the crack, and to cosmetically hide it?  I guess the question also beckons, at what point would you just get a replacement keyboard?
Title: Re: Cracked Wooden Keyboard - Repair or Replace
Post by: Theo on August 10, 2020, 07:10:19 PM
Depends on the keyboard.  I assume its wood since that is the most likely to crack.  You would get more detailed advice if we could see a picture.
Title: Re: Cracked Wooden Keyboard - Repair or Replace
Post by: hickory-wind on August 10, 2020, 09:07:30 PM
I will properly add this as a new topic at some point but thought I would put a teaser here:

I have developed an alternative to repairs or full replacement of broken Hohner keyboard tops that maintains the original wood. It is a flat machined panel with 21 slots (not holes but slots like the original) and 4 countersunk screw holes. I made a milling fixture to hold either 1/8" thick or 1/16" thick aluminum extrusions by the edges. A large CNC machine was used for accurate repeatable machining. A special round-over bit was purchased to put a small radius on the full perimeter of each slot and also on the machined ends of the extrusion. The extruding process itself provides a small radius on the long edges. This radius provides a nice comfortable edge so the fingers aren't going across a sharp corner.

Scott



Title: Re: Cracked Wooden Keyboard - Repair or Replace
Post by: hickory-wind on August 10, 2020, 09:10:24 PM
The keyboard can be prepared by simply routing a rectangular pocket to the proper depth. The 1/8" thick ends up supported by the two ends but is thick and rigid enough to work fine. The 1/16th pocket still has supporting wood on all four edges although it is thin along the long edges. It seems possible that the 1/16" could be mounted right on top of the keyboard without any routing but the levers would need to be adjusted to correct the button heights. I have not tried this yet but installation would simply be the 4 screw holes into the wood. I prefer the routed sunken look as it is quite elegant.

Scott

BellingersButtonBoxes.com (http://BellingersButtonBoxes.com)
Title: Re: Cracked Wooden Keyboard - Repair or Replace
Post by: hickory-wind on August 10, 2020, 09:15:43 PM
Another benefit to this method is now access is easy for adding felt under the levers for positive button travel limiting. Here are some pictures of the machining fixture and special roundover bit.

Scott
Title: Re: Cracked Wooden Keyboard - Repair or Replace
Post by: hickory-wind on August 10, 2020, 09:17:27 PM
The CNC auto tool change machining center.

Scott
Title: Re: Cracked Wooden Keyboard - Repair or Replace
Post by: Eshed on August 10, 2020, 09:25:04 PM
Exciting!

Is the button-hitting-the-panel noise different with these?
Title: Re: Cracked Wooden Keyboard - Repair or Replace
Post by: hickory-wind on August 10, 2020, 09:26:20 PM
Typical and severe keyboard issues.

Scott
Title: Re: Cracked Wooden Keyboard - Repair or Replace
Post by: hickory-wind on August 10, 2020, 09:28:06 PM
Exciting!

Is the button-hitting-the-panel noise different with these?

It is quiet if you add thick felt under the button levers.

Scott
Title: Re: Cracked Wooden Keyboard - Repair or Replace
Post by: hickory-wind on August 10, 2020, 09:32:03 PM
Here's what it looks like on a black painted keyboard.

Scott
Title: Re: Cracked Wooden Keyboard - Repair or Replace
Post by: John MacKenzie (Cugiok) on August 10, 2020, 09:47:41 PM
That is a sweet and elegant fix.

SJ
Title: Re: Cracked Wooden Keyboard - Repair or Replace
Post by: hickory-wind on August 10, 2020, 10:01:23 PM
Hohner had a metal keytop for a short while pre WW2. It was punched from very thin sheet metal but the process created a nice radius on the finger edge. This also allows for easy button travel limiting. The last picture shows Hohners notched cardboard stop under the levers.

Scott
Title: Re: Cracked Wooden Keyboard - Repair or Replace
Post by: Theo on August 10, 2020, 10:02:18 PM
Very nice solution to a common problem, and I like the visual similarity to the old Hohner metal top plate.
Title: Re: Cracked Wooden Keyboard - Repair or Replace
Post by: hickory-wind on August 10, 2020, 10:02:43 PM
Old Hohner in CF with metal keyboard top.

Scott
Title: Re: Cracked Wooden Keyboard - Repair or Replace
Post by: boxcall on August 10, 2020, 11:33:41 PM
Similar method I used repairing a one row, I used a piece of hard wood.
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=16508.0;attach=16052;image
Very easy to repeat this process with the proper jig.
Title: Re: Cracked Wooden Keyboard - Repair or Replace
Post by: invadm on August 10, 2020, 11:48:34 PM

I have developed an alternative to repairs or full replacement of broken Hohner keyboard tops that maintains the original wood. It is a flat machined panel with 21 slots
Scott
nice one  (:) I kept hoping some to to come up with something like this.
would it be possible to make a whole face cover as one unit? -as in just stick it on top full size facing- for people like me; with no tools or woodworking skill  :(  it will make life much easier.     
Title: Re: Cracked Wooden Keyboard - Repair or Replace
Post by: Rob2Hook on August 10, 2020, 11:58:47 PM
That is a great, pragmatic repair option and, dare I say it, more elegant than the original Hohner version.  I guess if one had the patience (and dexterity) support posts could be added between the levers as was common on early models with a removable top - rather like the sound post in a violin.

If one were working in wood for a similar effect, once one was perfected accurate copies could simply be routed using it as a template for a bearing guide.  Did you also make a template for routing the top out?  Personally I'd be tempted by a stainless version - much better to clean and re-polish over the years than aluminum...

Bravo

Rob.
Title: Re: Cracked Wooden Keyboard - Repair or Replace
Post by: hickory-wind on August 11, 2020, 01:45:34 AM
That is a great, pragmatic repair option and, dare I say it, more elegant than the original Hohner version.  I guess if one had the patience (and dexterity) support posts could be added between the levers as was common on early models with a removable top - rather like the sound post in a violin.

Neither need the support posts. The 1/8" is plenty stiff enough with just the end supports. The 1/16" is supported on all 4 sides so again doesn't need extra support.

If one were working in wood for a similar effect, once one was perfected accurate copies could simply be routed using it as a template for a bearing guide.  Did you also make a template for routing the top out?  Personally I'd be tempted by a stainless version - much better to clean and re-polish over the years than aluminum...

Bravo

Rob.

Thanks Rob. I don't use a router template. I have a 2500lb milling machine with X Y tables and a digital readout. I have made a special fixture that clamps the keyboard upwards and holds it by the top edges referencing the back, sawn edge. That way the depth is always correct and holes are in the right position. There is nothing easier than making a rectangular pocket on a mill. Although I considered stainless steel the machining becomes much more difficult and costly. It is also much heavier. I personally like the look of brushed aluminum. Doug Briggs keyboard top is beautiful, elegant and aluminum. BTW for anyone wishing to try routing I recommend purchasing a 'down cut' end mill. The spiral flutes are opposite the standard cutter. Most cutters are designed to lift the chips out of the cut but on wood usually cause chipping and breakouts. The down spiral cutters eliminate that almost entirely.

Scott
Title: Re: Cracked Wooden Keyboard - Repair or Replace
Post by: hickory-wind on August 11, 2020, 01:54:13 AM
Similar method I used repairing a one row, I used a piece of hard wood.
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=16508.0;attach=16052;image
Very easy to repeat this process with the proper jig.

I like your wooden one Michael. I assume you used plywood of some sort? The green hue adds some interest too!

Scott
Title: Re: Cracked Wooden Keyboard - Repair or Replace
Post by: hickory-wind on August 11, 2020, 02:21:18 AM
Back to the original poster's question, it depends on the extent of the damage. If it is only cracked best to carefully glue it back together pic 1. I have a gluing fixture with a rectangular heavy aluminum bar and matching clear plexiglas outer clamp pic 4. The aluminum has tapped holes pic 3. I use a thin steel shim to get the glue into the crack pic 2.

Scott
Title: Re: Cracked Wooden Keyboard - Repair or Replace
Post by: hickory-wind on August 11, 2020, 02:27:21 AM
The double clamp ensures that the repair is dead flat. The clear plexi allows inspection of the glue joint so misalignment and excess glue can be prevented.

I often add cloth tape on the inside before glueing to provide additional strength to prevent future cracking.

I discuss this method in this video: https://youtu.be/uvzpD3iFJtw?t=160 (https://youtu.be/uvzpD3iFJtw?t=183)

The link starts at the discussion but there were many other repairs on this particular Hohner if you wish to watch the whole thing.

Scott
Title: Re: Cracked Wooden Keyboard - Repair or Replace
Post by: Winston Smith on August 11, 2020, 08:33:28 AM
I love to see this sort of thing; little bits of innovation to get around practical problems, or speed them up, and improve end results.
Great to see them, thanks.
Title: Re: Cracked Wooden Keyboard - Repair or Replace
Post by: boxcall on August 11, 2020, 01:03:15 PM
Similar method I used repairing a one row, I used a piece of hard wood.
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=16508.0;attach=16052;image
Very easy to repeat this process with the proper jig.

I like your wooden one Michael. I assume you used plywood of some sort? The green hue adds some interest too!

Scott
thanks Scott, I used a piece of scrap wood I believe the same stuff I used to make the box I just built, so Spanish cedar? I added two pieces of wood on the inside of keyboard to span or add support to the middle of the repair and to keep the bottom and the repair on the same plane.
In a room full of pokerworks I don’t think I’ll have any trouble finding mine :D

Edit to add : I used a top bearing template bit , made a cut out in plywood the exact size I wanted , then clamped it over the area (Face side) where I wanted to cut. Then just cut a piece to size length and width / thickness, rounded the corners to match router radius. Then I installed it, put a filler in the space inside and drilled it out using the notch marks that are on the keyboard base. I just moved it slightly by adding a shim to the fence to elongate the hole.
Title: Re: Cracked Wooden Keyboard - Repair or Replace
Post by: Johnny S on August 11, 2020, 09:15:10 PM
Back to the original poster's question, it depends on the extent of the damage. If it is only cracked best to carefully glue it back together pic 1. I have a gluing fixture with a rectangular heavy aluminum bar and matching clear plexiglas outer clamp pic 4. The aluminum has tapped holes pic 3. I use a thin steel shim to get the glue into the crack pic 2.

Scott
This is very similar to the keyboard problem i have and I can see that this solution would work and relatively ear to set up.

Additional question then:  How would you deal with the remaining trace crack.  Would you sand, fill, leave as is?   
Title: Re: Cracked Wooden Keyboard - Repair or Replace
Post by: boxcall on August 11, 2020, 09:36:11 PM
Back to the original poster's question, it depends on the extent of the damage. If it is only cracked best to carefully glue it back together pic 1. I have a gluing fixture with a rectangular heavy aluminum bar and matching clear plexiglas outer clamp pic 4. The aluminum has tapped holes pic 3. I use a thin steel shim to get the glue into the crack pic 2.

Scott
This is very similar to the keyboard problem i have and I can see that this solution would work and relatively ear to set up.

Additional question then:  How would you deal with the remaining trace crack.  Would you sand, fill, leave as is?   
If you can get it tight enough and wipe off glue joint,  I’d leave it.
Really depends on how wood has separated.
Edit: You can always touch up if not happy with the results.
Title: Re: Cracked Wooden Keyboard - Repair or Replace
Post by: Jon Stapleton on August 11, 2020, 10:13:26 PM
Those are elegant solutions to a common problem.   A very quick and simple fix (as long as lumps of wood havent disappeared) is to glue 0.8mm ply. available from everyones favourite auction site on the underside of the top of the keyboard.   then drill sand dremel or chew the holes back in place.   Not fancy or clever but cheap effective and something even i can manage.  this has the advantage of strengthening the rather fragile top as well.  if you use the 0.8 mm ply there is no effect on button travel and the keyboard will still slip over the keys for removal.
Title: Re: Cracked Wooden Keyboard - Repair or Replace
Post by: boxcall on April 08, 2025, 11:25:20 PM
Similar method I used repairing a one row, I used a piece of hard wood.
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=16508.0;attach=16052;image
Very easy to repeat this process with the proper jig.

I like your wooden one Michael. I assume you used plywood of some sort? The green hue adds some interest too!

Scott
I see that I never responded to you here.
Thanks Scott! I used Cherry for the repair and yes a plywood jig.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal