Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Winston Smith on August 12, 2020, 06:37:48 PM
-
Hi Mark, and best wishes for your success in finding students.
It's a coincidence that melodeon tutoring was among the topics of conversation at our weekly outdoor, and socially distanced, NE melodeon group. I (innocently) asked the question if anyone new whether the various melodeon tutors had any teaching qualifications.
So now, I'll ask more widely. Do our many melodeon tutors have relevant teaching qualifications?
-
Hi Mark, and best wishes for your success in finding students.
It's a coincidence that melodeon tutoring was among the topics of conversation at our weekly outdoor, and socially distanced, NE melodeon group. I (innocently) asked the question if anyone new whether the various melodeon tutors had any teaching qualifications.
So now, I'll ask more widely. Do our many melodeon tutors have relevant teaching qualifications?
Luckily, teaching qualifications are optional. As someone with a BEd, I suspect they would not be of much help. Not as much as relevant expertise and experience, anyway.
-
I nearly started playing over 40 years ago but simply didn't know where to start so got diverted into concertina with a tutor book.
I am so pleased that now there are tutor books, tutors, workshops for all levels, slow and easy sessions, Skype and zoom to counteract distances, Melnet!!,
People simply willing to pass on their skills to help others whether at a professional or amateur level. Professional or amateur help doesn't matter, the fact that there is help out there is the important bit.
We live in a great time to learn melodeon.
Q
-
[[ADMIN]]
I've split this off into a new topic because it's a valid topic in it's own right and it's taking attention away from the original intention to advertise Mark Insley"s teaching services.
The original topic by Mark Insley is here. http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,25869.0.html
-
I'm sorry for putting you to so much trouble Theo, but it is a serious question.
I wonder just how members would feel about someone, without relevant qualifications, taking over their jobs? I expect that there are 1 or 2 teachers on here, and what would there reaction be to say; their local education authority bringing in unqualified teachers, because they were cheaper, or whatever? Or would members willingly employ unqualified car mechanics, or builders etc.?
-
I think the tricky question here is what are the relevant qualifications? My girlfriend is a trained teacher (biology) - not sure that would make her a good music teacher though, because the skills of classroom teaching are quite different from those for teaching music. In general, jobs which are dangerous if done wrong or paid for out of the public pocket are heavily regulated and have "qualifications" of some sort or another (doctor, teacher, mechanic, builder spring to mind) - but private music teaching on a not-very-fashionable folk instrument is not heavily regulated, perhaps unsurprisingly. What qualification would you like to see in a teacher Winston? For me the main things would be that they can play better than me and that they're good at communicating - and patient! But none of those things require a degree necessarily.
-
I'd certainly avoid qualification above musicianship and experience. Once you've tried a lesson you will be well placed to decide if that person's approach and skills are what you need. You also don't necessarily want the big names as teachers, Brian Cox is an excellent motivator and communicator for physics but there are better teachers out there. On the other hand don't use 'qualifications' as an inverse snobbery to suggest that someone who has only been playing for 8 years may be inferior as a player or teacher to those with many years of playing.
Word of mouth and suck it and see are the best approaches. No one has the right to keep students in the face of new talent, but a qualification isn't the final arbiter of relevant experience either.
It's a big world with room for more, especially now. But equally no need for people to worry about losing their stable of students.
-
"What qualification would you like to see"
That's not a question which I have actively considered, as I won't ever be using a teacher. (I'm a hopeless student and consequently have to find my own way.) That is possibly why I haven't progressed very much since we met at the NE playgroup thing, on your third(?) day of first handling a box and playing like an old hand!
What qualifications do music teachers require? I'm not questioning the skill of our known tutors, as I only have experience of a few. (Whose expertise, or methods, went straight over my head!)
-
Whose expertise, or methods, went straight over my head!
Did you let them know this at the time? And if so did they try to help you out?
-
"What qualification would you like to see"
That's not a question which I have actively considered, as I won't ever be using a teacher. (I'm a hopeless student and consequently have to find my own way.) That is possibly why I haven't progressed very much since we met at the NE playgroup thing, on your third(?) day of first handling a box and playing like an old hand!
What qualifications do music teachers require? I'm not questioning the skill of our known tutors, as I only have experience of a few. (Whose expertise, or methods, went straight over my head!)
I do not "teach". Rather, I mentor and assist the seeker by answering their questions. If you have no questions, there are no answers, QED.
If the presentation goes over your head, perhaps the presenter failed to find out where your head was at. Effective instructors/tutors/mentors make this effort.
Perhaps this is a qualifier.
Please pardon my ending a sentence with a preposition...
-
"Did you let them know this at the time? "
I think I did, they were all quite a while ago. (Steve Dumpleton did get through, a bit.) The others were in group situations; and not wanting to keep others back, I just made my excuses and left.
But this isn't about me and my obvious failings, I'm interested just for interest's sake. I had a friend, many tears ago, who was an English teacher, but she became a peripatetic teacher of guitar for our local education committee. It was better money, or so she told me and I don't think she had any formal music qualification.
-
... I had a friend, many tears ago, who was an English teacher, but she became a peripatetic teacher of guitar for our local education committee. It was better money, or so she told me and I don't think she had any formal music qualification.
I didn't know you knew my wife. That's exactly what she did.
Is the unspoken question:
1. Is a learner being short changed if their teacher doesn't have a formal qualification in teaching the instrument in question, or
2. Are formally qualified instructors being undermined, in their efforts to make a living, by competition from unqualified charletans?
-
As someone who holds teaching qualifications and has been a teacher, a lecturer and a researcher into styles of teaching and learning before I even began teaching music workshops and one-to-one lessons, I might be expected to think that trained teachers make better melodeon tutors, but I don't think it is quite that simple. Some qualified teachers have a 'one-size-fits-all' approach to teaching, which can be frustrating for students who don't suit that particular style, while others are more successful because they are more flexible in their approach.
Some people who have had no training whatsoever have a natural rapport with students and make very effective melodeon tutors. While knowing something about teaching and learning styles and educational theory can be beneficial, I don't think it is essential and I could name several very successful melodeon tutors who have no knowledge of educational theory.
-
I guess you could expect that someone with a teaching qualification (academic) would have certain knowledge and ability in terms of communicating and knowledge sharing but unless coupled with some serious amount of playing skill I don't think it would count for much in the arena of melodeon teaching - certainly not compared with being a stonkingly good player who is enthusiastic and encouraging.
Simlarly someone who is a qualified music teacher would (hopefully) have good communication skills and know how to present material. They would also undoubtedly have a depth of knowledge of music theory at their disposal. I'm not sure whether it is necessarily an advantage though given that there are no formal grades and standards in melodeon playing and most players are partly or largely self taught. I'd rather learn from great melodeon player rather than a melodeon player who has trained to teach music - I guess that's mostly to do with the nature of traditional music and the crazy instrument we play.
I've been taught by a wide range of melodeon players, mostly at workshops. Most were in the extremely good to amazing range in terms of playing skill. Some were amazing communicators, enthusiasts and extremely able to explain and encourage - others really, really weren't. I can think of three workshop leaders who I would avoid in future but many more who I would recommend.
Lockdown aside, these days I don't really go to workshops much except for Saul Rose's Melodeon Masterclass at Sidmouth. I don't think anyone would say that Saul's style is that of a conventional teacher in any way - but his masterclass is brilliant, inspiring and challenging. There is also the small fact that he is an absolutely brilliant musician - give me that over qualifications and theory any day.
-
"I didn't know you knew my wife."
Ooh, Greg! That begs the question, "Who else hasn't she told you about?" Hehe!
But seriously; both of those unspoken questions could well be part of it, but not confined to only them.
Hello Bob, and thanks for your two penn'orth. Your wide and long experience is most valued, but (although I realise you're talking about "successful" as being in bringing students along) your assertion that, "Some qualified teachers have a 'one-size-fits-all' approach to teaching, which can be frustrating for students who don't suit that particular style, while others are more successful because they are more flexible in their approach." does open up another aspect! Qualifications can deliver financial "success" to a teacher who is actually hopeless at their job, which must be slightly frustrating to those of you who draw the same salary for doing the job well? But that's not a subject for a melodeon based forum, is it?
Looking at Theo's list of freelance Melodeon Teachers (which I hadn't come across before) it would seem that many on there do seem to have teaching qualifications of one sort or another. Which I do find reassuring? And, there are also others, without formal or written qualifications, who, on the strength of their reputations, are excellent tutors/mentors or whatever and who manage to persevere with dolts like me and turn them into passable musicians. But I suppose that there are also melodeon teachers, with or without qualifications, who don't do too well and therefore struggle to make any sort of living at it.
Thanks to all who've contributed, I think that my question has been more or less answered now.
-
Qualified music teachers are generally, to my knowledge, qualified in classical or orchestral instruments such as the string family ( violin, cello etc ) wind ( clarinet, bassoon, flute, oboe etc ) or keyboard such as piano.
Many started learning within a formal structure and at an early stage.
None of this is true for melodeon.
As I said earlier, not long ago there was *no* opportunity to be taught. You had to do it all yourself. Or not bother with the instrument.
Now we are starting to become more organised in our approach to the instrument. People have produced tutor books become tutors and set up informal websites to discuss and advise in all things melodeon.
Their qualification is simple. An ability to play well.
Often they are professional musicians earning a living through melodeon because they play well enough that others enjoy listening to them and are willing enough to pay money to go to concerts or buy their recorded music.
In addition there are some people who have great communication skills and though may not be professional musicians, have the ability to deconstruct and explain things in simple terms and communicate this to a beginner.
I'm immediately thinking that a primary school teacher has different skills to an A level teacher, both have their place in the umbrella of teaching from reception class students to older more accomplished students.
I am aware other cultures have a more formal teaching structure that have been established for a long time - Irish dancing, Irish music, Northumbrian Pipers, Scottish societies (?) and Melnet members here going to France for extended workshops etc....
I don't know if these are with formally qualified teachers or based on those people accomplished in their instrument or performance, 'ability lead'.
We are only just starting to assemble a structure for teaching melodeon.
I wonder how that will evolve in the future, and if it will become more formalised.
Q
-
Ah......I pressed 'send' as Winston posted!
-
I tend towards the 'you've either got it or you haven't' cliche when it comes to teaching/tutoring.
I suspect that a modern teaching qualification would make you a better teacher of a group for a series of lessons based on a learning programme.
That's not the same as being a good tutor/mentor where the ability to inspire and encourage is probably more important.
I should add one assumes a qualification might cover teaching reluctant learners, which isn’t all that relevant if we are talking about helping melodeon players who are motivated and keen to learn.
-
I guess you could expect that someone with a teaching qualification (academic) would have certain knowledge and ability in terms of communicating and knowledge sharing but unless coupled with some serious amount of playing skill I don't think it would count for much in the arena of melodeon teaching - certainly not compared with being a stonkingly good player who is enthusiastic and encouraging.
Simlarly someone who is a qualified music teacher would (hopefully) have good communication skills and know how to present material. They would also undoubtedly have a depth of knowledge of music theory at their disposal. I'm not sure whether it is necessarily an advantage though given that there are no formal grades and standards in melodeon playing and most players are partly or largely self taught. I'd rather learn from great melodeon player rather than a melodeon player who has trained to teach music - I guess that's mostly to do with the nature of traditional music and the crazy instrument we play.
I've been taught by a wide range of melodeon players, mostly at workshops. Most were in the extremely good to amazing range in terms of playing skill. Some were amazing communicators, enthusiasts and extremely able to explain and encourage - others really, really weren't. I can think of three workshop leaders who I would avoid in future but many more who I would recommend.
Lockdown aside, these days I don't really go to workshops much except for Saul Rose's Melodeon Masterclass at Sidmouth. I don't think anyone would say that Saul's style is that of a conventional teacher in any way - but his masterclass is brilliant, inspiring and challenging. There is also the small fact that he is an absolutely brilliant musician - give me that over qualifications and theory any day.
The London college of music do offer grades in traditional music and melodeon is one of the instruments listed. Tbf it’s a choice between Irish or Scotttish trad but still, you can do grades on the melodeon. They also do teaching diplomas in trad music.
https://lcme.uwl.ac.uk/exams/traditional-music/irish-traditional-music
-
Thanks Sharon.
In my opinion there are two very good points there.
There are courses available now. I'm not sure exactly what Newcastle and Sheffield provide but am aware they offer courses in traditional music.
I have been fortunate in attending a workshop run by one of their graduates and excellent it was too.
My cd collection contains people who have graduated from these courses and perhaps this new generation coming through represent a new more formally trained traunch of people.
Sharon's comment illustrate something that I have been aware of during my time dancing.
As a nation we put *no value* on our traditional cultures.
Others such as our Irish and Scots neighbours value their culture, as do many other nations to the point of supporting it and providing opportunities to learn it as a recognised form of music.
English traditional music nearly died out until it's revival in the early 1970's. Since then we've learnt to play it, become more accomplished in our playing, started grass roots methods of teaching and now started to recognise this at national level with universities and colleges offering courses and their graduates starting to be seen in the teaching environment.
Others have been doing it for many years...
Q
-
"As a nation we put *no value* on our traditional cultures."
Is that because government (and/or their advisors) have put more emphasis on facilitating the introduction of other cultures in the laws and regulations which they have made; and therefore encouraged the indoctrination of much of our younger generations with exciting unintelligible profanities masquerading as song lyrics and the like? "Multiculturalism" seems to have been the enduring buzz word of the last 50 years or so, and surely that emphasis is part of what has brought "English" traditional culture to this present precarious state?
As you say, the Scotch and Irish have persevered (despite having the same overarching leaders) probably because of their innate sense of "otherness".
-
Thanks Sharon.
In my opinion there are two very good points there.
There are courses available now. I'm not sure exactly what Newcastle and Sheffield provide but am aware they offer courses in traditional music.
I have been fortunate in attending a workshop run by one of their graduates and excellent it was too.
My cd collection contains people who have graduated from these courses and perhaps this new generation coming through represent a new more formally trained traunch of people.
Sharon's comment illustrate something that I have been aware of during my time dancing.
As a nation we put *no value* on our traditional cultures.
Others such as our Irish and Scots neighbours value their culture, as do many other nations to the point of supporting it and providing opportunities to learn it as a recognised form of music.
English traditional music nearly died out until it's revival in the early 1970's. Since then we've learnt to play it, become more accomplished in our playing, started grass roots methods of teaching and now started to recognise this at national level with universities and colleges offering courses and their graduates starting to be seen in the teaching environment.
Others have been doing it for many years...
Q
I do think it’s a shame there isn’t an English trad syllabus (and let’s not forget Welsh folk music too!) Yes, there are a couple of Folk / trad music degree courses - I know because I spent some time having a look at the options, not that I’m likely to do one sadly lol! Mostly because it would cost a fortune as I already have a degree >:( and mmm I’m not saying I’m too old to do one because I don’t believe that for a minute but it’s not so easy when you have a house, commitments etc.
-
I think being a good communicator and educator is as important, if not more so, than how great the player doing the tutoring is - obviously they need to be good but I know of some amazing players who are totally incapable of relaying what they're playing to anyone else. The tutor also needs to want to do it, be able to motivate and be proud of their students achievements. As with any small business owner, they need to put customer satisfaction high up the list of requirements - they need to be on time, prepared, capable of listening and adapting their teaching to the student. None of these involve any kind of formal qualifications.
Mostly my experience of tutors has been amazing through to good. Only twice have I come across tutors I didn't like - one where the course had been misadvertised (so not entirely his fault) and one who had done no prep and wasn't interested in teaching, just noodling around showing how clever he was. The latter was the only teacher I've ever formally complained about to the organisers of the workshops.
A very long winded way of saying I don't really think teaching qualifications are that relevant for melodeon tuition (although they can't actually do any harm). It's all the other stuff that matters.
-
This is an interesting discussion. Apart from boxes, the other great interest in my life is football. (Apologies to all those for whom this is a complete turn-off.) In that sphere it's often been noted that the best players often don't make the best coaches. The really outstanding players can't always analyse just why they do what they do - how they know when to time a run, how they can anticipate which way another player will turn - there's a whole lot of instinct there which is really hard to teach. I remember watching the great Tony Adams years ago at Boundary Park, Oldham (great player, pretty mediocre coach) utterly failing to explain to Wycombe's defensive line how to push up together, and just resorting to "just do it". There's a tier of competent but not exceptional players who've gone on to be much the best coaches, because they have the additional ability to analyse, unpick, explain, motivate, encourage, all of which are different skills from playing. None of this has anything much to do with qualifications. But it does suggest to me that people looking for a teacher should perhaps look for a range of things beyond only how well someone plays.
-
I have a PGCE and taught English, History, R E(because it was an RC school) and for one quite extraordinary term Dance ( you probably need to know me in the flesh to appreciate the irony of that one...) :|glug
There is no way I could teach the melodeon...other than going "In out, in out, in out...out in. Off you go...".
Good luck to those who can and do. :|glug
-
Winston, this isn't about governments and their policies, this is about us as a nation and our mentality.
We have always embraced the new and therefore discarded the present. It has gone on forever.
In recent history, the minstrel troupes were the 'great new thing' as illustrated by a long lost film emerging some years back on BBC2 documenting life around Manchester in 1902. The very long carnival procession had every other float being minstrels.
The Big Band music of WWII became massive, brought to us from across the Pond, then came rock and roll.
Whatever the 'thing' was it erased that which went before, as no one wanted to do the old stuff......
The decline of the village bands and musicians was slow and long, and therefore the music they played stood no chance against the next new trend.
Bob of this parish can give chapter and verse about how the waltz became fashionable and the polka, again it replaced the older style dances.
New replaces old.
Having danced at festivals in other countires the village or town supported them to an incredible degree.
My first encounter was in Brittany, dancers from local villages and us had massive banquet - 600+ foreign teams - all laid on by a small village. In Italy massive support from a small town meant the hospitality given to performers was immense and also in Paris where they had a civic hotel especially to put up guests of the town.
They support their cultures and totally respect traditional music and dance from other places.
We do not.
Try going to a party where you are not known and start chatting and asked 'oh what do you do?'
If you reply along the lines of 'morris dancing' or 'folk music' watch for the stifled smirk!
It is no wonder we nearly lost English music.
Q
-
.....they have the additional ability to analyse, unpick, explain, motivate, encourage, all of which are different skills from playing. None of this has anything much to do with qualifications. But it does suggest to me that people looking for a teacher should perhaps look for a range of things beyond only how well someone plays.
This is so true. I have been playing melodeon for just over a year now but played other instruments to a high standard from a young age. It’s really important to find a teacher who understands what you want to achieve and works with you rather than just following their own tried and tested ‘plan’. I already have a lot of musical experience and training but I’m still having lessons - because it’s good (for me anyway) to have feedback from someone who is much more experienced at playing the melodeon than I am and to have someone challenge you maybe a bit more than you might challenge yourself (if that’s what you are looking for)
-
"We have always embraced the new and therefore discarded the present. It has gone on forever.
In recent history, the minstrel troupes were the 'great new thing' as illustrated by a long lost film emerging some years back on BBC2 documenting life around Manchester in 1902. The very long carnival procession had every other float being minstrels.
The Big Band music of WWII became massive, brought to us from across the Pond, then came rock and roll.
Whatever the 'thing' was it erased that which went before, as no one wanted to do the old stuff......
The decline of the village bands and musicians was slow and long, and therefore the music they played stood no chance against the next new trend."
I'm certain that most of the above is undeniably true, and I would not wish to argue against it. However, I think it's too simplistic to just say that it's our "mentality".
Surely, just as we're agreed that a good melodeon instructor has to lead the pupil into the right paths and habits, and that by demonstrable example, then we must also accept that a country's "leadership" will have the same (or maybe better to say, similar) influence when leading by lawmaking and example?
"Having danced at festivals in other countires the village or town supported them to an incredible degree.
My first encounter was in Brittany, dancers from local villages and us had massive banquet - 600+ foreign teams - all laid on by a small village. In Italy massive support from a small town meant the hospitality given to performers was immense and also in Paris where they had a civic hotel especially to put up guests of the town.
They support their cultures and totally respect traditional music and dance from other places.
We do not."
Again, I'm convinced! However, these attributions must be inherent in the local (and/or national) civic leadership, or the resulting knees-ups and festivals etc. just couldn't happen. I'm convinced that everything has a political input which either encourages or discourages any particular population (or section within that population) in any and every social circumstance, however subtle.
-
I don't know what Paul Youngs "teaching" qualifications are, but I learnt more from his "Donkey Riding" YouTube video than from several tutor books and workshops.
Sometimes teaching isn't teaching. No words. Simple presentation. HIGHLY recommended.
-
Idle speculation makes me wonder what some of the 'young guns' coming from formal education think. Cohen B-K, who posts on c.net, would be an example perhaps of recent experience with teachers/tutors dealing with a free-reed player . Ok, he was damn good when he was barely a teenager, but I wonder if he felt his instrumental skill was moved froward by guidance from a qualified teacher any more than by his own perseverance or whether it was the material he was expected to play which stretched him. There are, after-all, 2 strands to learning, how to play and what to play, and a 'normal' qualified teacher of music as has been said, will probably not be likely to have skill in teaching free-reed playing techniques, but will be able to introduce musical challenges. I would speculate that someone who has enough love of their instrument to want to pass that on would not necessarily be disadvantaged by not having a formal teaching qualification. The key is knowing how to break down the learning into achievable steps and I would suggest that the choice of material helps as a learning platform, but knowledge of the instrument is prime and training and experience as a qualified teacher sharpens and hones that analytical thinking, no more and no less. I also think that the balance between teaching instrumental skill and musical knowledge shifts with developing playing ability, so your tutor needs to be clear where the skill-set they are teaching is aimed and you as a player, need to be honest in your self-assessment, otherwise you will be disappointed/frustrated. The, of course, does this person inspire me!
-
I think being a good communicator and educator is as important, if not more so, than how great the player doing the tutoring is - obviously they need to be good but I know of some amazing players who are totally incapable of relaying what they're playing to anyone else. The tutor also needs to want to do it, be able to motivate and be proud of their students achievements.
Exactly!
Bob.
-
Winston, leadership and politicians can't tell us what to think and do ... that's the stuff of the Thought Police and Big Brother >:E
Rileycat, yes many good points there.
I agree you must be honest in assessing your own ability to give a tutor the pointers to help you progress.
If you ask me what I want to learn then I'm never sure how to answer that!
As opposed to teaching specifics, such as a tune I've enjoyed the teaching of Ann Niepold, a stunning Belgian lady on the DG Weekend at Halsway Manor. She tends to play more jazz inspired improvisation rather than 'tunes'. Consequently you get all sorts of things coming at you which is refreshing and mind expanding...and great fun!
Q
-
I'll keep this short and then duck.
As someone who taught in secondary education for thirty five years, including twenty as a deputy head, I'm afraid I hold the heretical view that teaching qualifications do not correlate well with the ability to teach: if you can't do it, you can't be trained to do it; if you can .... >:E. I don't see why teaching an instrument should be different from any other discipline.
(I have to confess to having no professional teaching qualifications at all, beyond simply having a degree. :|bl )
-
I'll keep this short and then duck.
As someone who taught in secondary education for thirty five years, including twenty as a deputy head, I'm afraid I hold the heretical view that teaching qualifications do not correlate well with the ability to teach: if you can't do it, you can't be trained to do it; if you can .... >:E. I don't see why teaching an instrument should be different from any other discipline.
(I have to confess to having no professional teaching qualifications at all, beyond simply having a degree. :|bl )
You won't need to duck from me. There is of course a basic minimum standard that trained teachers will meet that might not be met by those who don't have them, but beyond that, I fully agree. I do believe, however, that you can get much better at it with time and opportunity (irrespective of qualifications). I also think that it can be good to be taught by people who have struggled with their own playing: I have some big gaps in my playing skills (compensated in other areas) and that actively helps me see why people might struggle and my understanding of my own weaknesses helps me support others with theirs.
There are many educational buzzwords that come and go, but 'reflective practitioner' does ring true for me.
I do think that the learner has a right to be taught in the way they want to learn. It might not give the quickest or surest progress, but we are talking about keeping a hobby alive, and if someone just wants to play duets with a stronger player, then I think they should be allowed to spend their money that way. If I'm paid to train someone for the profession, though, then I have to teach the skills I know matter.
Winston, on a different matter, I don't know your strategy for dealing with the beliefs of those distant friends, but I'm not sure I could be as generous as you seem to be.
-
"I'm not sure I could be as generous as you seem to be."
I don't think that telling them that they're talking absolute rubbish is being particularly generous. But, sadly, they are not allowed independent thought and must believe what they're told! Engaging with oppressed peoples can only be a good thing, in my opinion.
-
Full marks for engaging. Being in the tent.
-
"Full marks for engaging."
Pete, being simple, I'm not sure whether you're being facetious or not. And as for being "in the tent"; our NE branch of the "Sons of the Desert" (Laurel and Hardy appreciation society) was known as "The Tent", when it was running many years ago.
-
It is an interesting reflection on modern times that Winston used the word “qualificationsâ€, as though some form of formal training and assessment were a prerequisite of being able to impart skills and knowledge to others. He is not the only one, I have seen elsewhere the notion that if a qualification exists, it cannot be possible to accomplish the task if you don’t hold it.
This in turn throws up the qualified/unqualified thing, which does not fit well in a folk process where qualifications, if they exist, are rare and of questionable validity anyway. If you formalise it, is it still folk?
It raises the empty point of the unqualified taking work away from the qualified, a situation that afaik does not exist and, in the melodeon world, is not about to happen soon.
Perhaps “Teaching abilities†would be a more relevant and happier title?
-
Malcolm, I too was thinking along similar lines earlier but sidetracked myself making another point.
I agree, 'folk' implies 'of the people' and in my mind an informality. Songs and tunes passed on from one to another, possibly family member to family member, old singer/player in the village pub to the next generation.
I remember Alistair Anderson relating a story that Billy Pig learnt Northumbrian Small Pipes by cycling miles over to sit at the feet of Tom Clough after a day's working in the pit ( I hope my memory serves me right with those names )
I'm sure there was no discussion over formal teaching qualifications, it was 'ah he can play, I must learn from him...'
In modern times when travel and communications have changed immensely, learning from someone at a festival workshop or perhaps via Skype or Zoom is a modern version of the old way of passing things on?
.... and long may it continue!
-
You have the names right, I’ve heard the same story from Alistair.
I think it’s unlikely that Tom Clough would have had any formal qualification as a teacher, but he was qualified in away because he won numerous piping competitions. Piping competitions were a big thing in the Northeast with significant cash prizes as well as kudos. Complex varitations were written specifically as competition test pieces, and the whole process seems to have inspired an almost academic approach among aspiring pipers.
As a slightly relevant aside, I worked in the same school as a maths teacher called Tom Clough. The piper Tom was his grandfather.
-
I'm sure many of us,in our school days have had experience confirming that a deep knowledge of the subject, and a teaching qualification, is no guarantee of teaching ability ! Unfortunately we didn't have a choice of teacher ! (On the other hand, I have great memories of one inspirational history teacher who suggested a reenactment of the French Revolution by storming the Headmaster's office...)
An old friend asked me whether I'd ever done any melodeon teaching. OK, I've been playing for many years, but I have neither the patience nor ability to teach others - I taught myself and it still surprises me that I achieved that ! Equivalent of the melodeon university of life I suppose.
I discovered melodeon and other musical 'workshops' very late on, and I sincerely believe that I've learned something in every one I've been to - whether based on learning by ear or at the other extreme learning complex tunes in strange (to me) time signatures and keys, from the dots. But whether that learning has really sunk in is questionable - that depends on the work one is prepared to do afterwards. Like a ski lesson - it's fantastic following the leader down an easy slope but it's when you are faced by difficult terrain, on your own, that you know whether skills have been learned. And just like a group ski lesson, participants are at different levels, learn at different pace, may prefer different teaching styles - and may feel the need to look for the nearest bar when things don't go well. And some well 'qualified' ski instructors may have wonderful ski technique but be appalling at teaching...but at least melodeon playing isn't that risky !
I can see the benefits of a more formal approach to learning traditional instruments, as happens in some other countries. And it would be great if traditional music and dance was recognised as being more important in England - but for so many it has little relevance. Given the appalling lack of priority given to any musical education - and the arts in general I can't see things changing.
I've experienced the wonderful community atmosphere of fest-noz(and deiz) in Brittany, where the music and dance is much more than a tourist spectacle - but equally I had Breton friends who looked askance at it and saw it as irrelevant. Being taught dance and music in schools is no guarantee of subsequent enthusiasm but at least it meant callers are superfluous at fest-noz... Can't get much further from ceilidhs in England - we don't even have our own term for them - not that they are even possible at the moment.
Rambling on and digressing - sorry. I'm just hoping that the Leveret week at Halsway in November happens - I have no idea whether Andy, Rob, and Sam have formal teaching qualifications and frankly don't care ! I can attest to their skills - but equally recognise that their approach might not suit all.
Julian
-
My experience of teaching is 37 years teaching History, including Head of Dept. and Advanced Skills Teacher, so I might be assumed to think that formal qualifications for teaching melodeon would be a good thing. However I am not so sure. More important is to get the right match between teacher and learner. I learn by ear and have no music theory, so get nothing out of teachers who base their teaching on such theory. In the past I have left workshops half way through because the learning style just did not suit me. However someone else might rave about that style of tuition and actively want the music theory that is lost on me. (No doubt some people would suggest that I should learn the theory but honestly that is not going to happen!)
When I have attempted to teach melodeon myself the main, perhaps only, thing that I took from my old job was understanding the need to plan, to have specific aims for the day and to try to match the teaching to the students. I asked the students to complete a questionnaire in advance and planned the day around what the group had identified as their learning needs. Fortunately for me they identified playing by ear as a target! If they had identified sight reading I would have been in big trouble. So for me qualifications are much less important than matching the learner with the right teacher for them.
I would strongly agree that playing ability does not always make someone an effective teacher. In my experience of attending workshops the person who best combines the two skills is John Kirkpatrick, a great player who puts a lot of thought and planning into his teaching.
-
I think that a good teacher needs to be able to analyse what they are doing and why (not always easy when your own playing has simply evolved over time) and be not only a good communicator but able to change their approach to adapt to students' own learning styles. A formal teaching qualification may have conveyed some of these skills but is certainly not necessary in order to have them. On the other hand, simply being a good player does not necessarily mean that you will have the skills to be an effective teacher.
-
Theo, good to know my memory is ok!
I gathered from Alistair the importance of the pipers competitions. I've always been a touch jealous that the Pipers had the wherewithal to be organised and formalised their playing as signified by the competition. It means the playing and tunes have stood up far better than in other parts of the country.
I'm sure Tom Clough had no formal qualifications, just a brilliant player, and a lovely little aside from you!
Essentially we melodeonistas are doing the same thing as those Pipers - seeking out good players and learning from them.
I'd even go so far as to say, in the internet age, learning can be distanced. I've learnt a huge amount from watching good players, members of this forum. The ability to watch, listen and learn via YouTube means I don't have to cycle miles to meet someone after a day down the pit!
I've accompanied Julian on a couple of workshop weekends and I too have learned so much. It's often not obvious, but a few weeks or months down the line a lightbulb goes on in the brain! Often not a specific way to play the learned tune, just some little comment or point that hits the mark.
I enjoy them and am saddened at missing two excellent weekends this year.
Damned virus >:E
Q
-
Wot Tufty said
"...... understanding the need to plan, to have specific aims for the day and to try to match the teaching to the students. I asked the students to complete a questionnaire in advance and planned the day around what the group had identified as their learning needs.............. So for me qualifications are much less important than matching the learner with the right teacher for them. "
So true. I've wasted money on courses delivered by brilliant players who showed no evidence of planning or matching.
-
to me , not a trained/qualified 'teacher' , the most important thing is to have a carefully prepared ''lesson plan '' and to stick to it particularly when running workshops. This should prevent being dragged off into numerous possibly irelevent diversions with the result that the object of the workshop or series of workshops is not achieved and most participants are less than chuffed.
Obviously at the start of a workshop an explanation of the 'lesson plan' is needed together with an indication of the level of ability /playing experience needed to get the best out of the workshop ( eg if its at beginners level it gives smart arses chance to bugger off, and if advanced level beginners may like to sit in and soak up information without feeling short changed etc etc)
This has worked well for me over the years in workshops of 6 to 40.participnats and at various levels.
As to individual tuition an overall plan to fit in with a students need over a series on ''lessons'' is needed which can off course be modified by mutual agreement as the need arises.us
I teach mainly to play by ear but am happy for good readers to use the dots if it helps them in the initial stages to grasp the bare bones of a tune quickly but normally I use carefully graded ( by me) tunes to gradually introduce instrumental skills ,phrasing, dynamics , rhythm etc etc as we progress.
I am sure there are other ways of 'teaching ' the box but this format has worked very well for me for the past 40 or so years.
george
-
When I have attempted to teach melodeon myself the main, perhaps only, thing that I took from my old job was understanding the need to plan, to have specific aims for the day and to try to match the teaching to the students.
I hope you remembered your SEAL...or had you left the chalkface by then? >:E
-
"Full marks for engaging."
Pete, being simple, I'm not sure whether you're being facetious or not. And as for being "in the tent"; our NE branch of the "Sons of the Desert" (Laurel and Hardy appreciation society) was known as "The Tent", when it was running many years ago.
I'm not the facetious type.
-
Like most of the replies, I am not concerned as to whether a teacher has formal qualifications. Indeed, in the classic sense that might even put me off unless I had it by word of mouth that the teacher had not lost their flair by going through training themselves! I don't enjoy playing scales for the sake of it, though over the years I have from time to time found myself repeating phrases in tunes where the problem area was a scale in a key I was not familiar with where the tune modulated.
There is an extra facet to the matching of goals. I'm sure everyone can relate to having picked up useful techniques from other players, whether in person or by observation of videos and that's where one should chose the teacher, mentor or player who can offer you the most. Although it may sound unfair to the master, I did attend a workshop with JK and there were parts of his explanations of how he approaches a piece that were useful, but most of the exercises he chose to work were of little or no use to me. To explain, he wanted us to play in octaves - and my hands are small, making this nigh on impossible. At the other end of the scale I used to often play with a Scot and picked up more than I realised from his style. Years later a bagpiper commented on how I was playing the grace notes and open pipe notes in the few Scottish tunes we used.
I now know I'd be flogging a dead horse trying to learn from a teacher with big hands and long, elegant fingers. I wish it was as easy to figure out whether I could match their mental capacity - but I think I already know the answer to that one.
Rob (a bear of little brain)
-
Are we asking about general music teachers who are full time teachers in schools, or are we talking about specific instrument teachers/tutors who provide lessons to adults? Or to young people & children? On eg school grounds or from their home?
Aren't almost all the qualifications and certificates you can get either for a) working with children / working in a school or b) more relevant as being evidence of having learnt the instrument to begin with (ABRSM grades / music degree).
I think electric guitar has had to live outside of the world of formal education for decades, and has only now started to be 'accepted' into that space, so, I guess I'd draw parallels with those kinds of guitar teacher from when I was going up. I think a lot of people (of my generation and younger) who try to do music as their main career path nowadays do have to supplement their income with some teaching.
-
Gena, I think formal lessons for an instrument are regionalised.
i.e. I'm sure I've been told on Shetland, as a school aged person if you wish to play violin you get a classical violin teacher, if you wish to play traditional music you get a fiddler with no difference in perception that one is better than the other.
I have no idea if the traditional fiddler is formally trained though.......
I suspect such regional differences are country specific.
I'd like to know if diatonic button accordion is an option in France, with their strong formalised styles, in Italy or elsewhere in Europe, and whether other countires teach traditional music as an option at school.
Q
-
Malcolm Bebb; your challenging post has me thinking, and I'd like to reply in bits (even though this reply may be edited out as not being sufficiently melodeon related) if that's OK?
"It is an interesting reflection on modern times that Winston used the word “qualificationsâ€, as though some form of formal training and assessment were a prerequisite of being able to impart skills and knowledge to others. He is not the only one, I have seen elsewhere the notion that if a qualification exists, it cannot be possible to accomplish the task if you don’t hold it.
Firstly, I'm the very last person who would believe in the supposed "prerequisite" which you mention. But, and secondly, a (possibly) more interesting reflection on modern times i.e. on the road to some sort of regulatory Utopia which local and national politics seems to be taking us, it isn't a case of, "if a qualification exists, it cannot be possible to accomplish the task if you don’t hold it." more a case of you won't be allowed to accomplish it! Possibly something akin to several jobs being only open to graduates, when a person with years of experience; and I mean, who knows the job inside out, is barred from even applying, and thereby from making a decent living. Or, there are many jobs where people have been employed (or self-employed) but then suddenly find that those who lead us decide that extra qualifications are required to carry on with a lifetimes work, and it ALWAYS costs!
"This in turn throws up the qualified/unqualified thing, which does not fit well in a folk process where qualifications, if they exist, are rare and of questionable validity anyway. If you formalise it, is it still folk?"
Simple answer, in my opinion, "No!"
"It raises the empty point of the unqualified taking work away from the qualified, a situation that afaik does not exist and, in the melodeon world, is not about to happen soon."
I don't think it's an "empty point", this is not allowed to happen in the protected world of formal teaching, and our beloved leaders are making sure, little by little, that every person who has a skill will eventually be required to be qualified through payment, for a licence, to some quango or other before he/she is allowed to practice it. Sadly, at the bottom of the pile, many skilled manual workers are being priced out of their livelihood, in the spurious belief that extra qualifications, or a licence, somehow make their work better of more safe or whatever, which is about as much tosh as suggesting that only qualified teachers should be allowed to teach in the "folk process"
"Perhaps “Teaching abilities†would be a more relevant and happier title?"
I don't think so, Malcolm. My purpose was to elicit proper reactions from members, which I think has been achieved, so I'll leave it there and thank everyone who has participated.
(Perhaps I should apologise for this final rant, as I'm already in trouble elsewhere through having my intent misunderstood.)
-
I'm currently having a few golf lessons from a young man whom I taught music to in school a few years ago. It's a lovely circular experience. He's very good at demonstrating (hardly surprising, given his skill levels) but also very good at helping to improve a swing that has faults borne from bodged fix on top of bodged fix. This bit came from his degree in golf. He is also a patient and kind young man. He is also getting a decent wodge of readies for his patience and skills. He is bang up to date with on the spot specific golf video software for analysis.
I do think (when I teach) that I try to get students away from the grade they hope to achieve and into the skills they might develop (was there ever a worse time for the worship of grades over skills?).
What got me having lessons was his official position as golf pro at the local club. What got him the position was a combination of local reputation as a player and qualification for dealing with swing improvements rather than building a great swing from scratch. What keeps me going back are his soft and hard skills and his personality.
Qualifications can be akin to the damning comment: a man who knows the price of everything, but the value of nothing.
For me, the hunt for qualifications has some benefits - it can make sure that people keep learning because they need to prove themselves but it also directs subjects down the path of teaching that which can be measured.
Every time teachers get good at interpreting the syllabus to produce good results - they change the syllabus. Maybe that's not the terrible thing I once thought.
As a post-script. I've been following some forum threads again -after quite a long lay off. Getting re-involved in the forum meant that I've picked up the melodeon today. Didn't sound great, didn't sound bad. Everything was still in A minor (my happy place). Maybe I need a teacher.
-
Mention of the pipers maybe brings up a point worth considering. Many traditional musicians, from all parts of Britain and Ireland, have historically not subscribed to the "work it out" school of learning to play traditional music. There was a right and a wrong, and moreover their way was right. Perhaps that attitude was strongest on instruments that required most guidance, such as pipes and fiddle. The Inverness fiddler Donald Riddell was keen for the Scottish fiddle tradition to evolve a set standard in the way the pipers did. And although they would never be so rude as to come out and say it, Billy Pigg's experiments on the NSP are not universally admired. Tom Clough (old and young) certainly had a very clear idea of right and wrong piping.
The modern tradition has perhaps left this idea behind a little, for many reasons which could no doubt keep a PhD candidate amused for years. But there's clearly a relationship between what makes someone an authentic teacher and what is authentic music (and you'll notice I'm being careful not to define any of these terms...)
-
Master : apprentice ;)
-
Thanks Calum, interesting stuff.
I think we as melodeon players in England are only just starting to formalise and create loose structures for learning that as you say, others such as pipers and fiddles north of the border have had for years.
This not only improves individuals playing but ensures the traditions are kept alive and healthy.
The 'do it yourself 'option for learning melodeon was the only option until recent times. Now we seem to be really getting away from this.
By DIY learning, everyone has to go through the same process, make the same mistakes etc and essentially 're-invent' the wheel.
Having tutors and a formal learning system means you don't all fall into the same traps, if you do you have advice on how to resolve the problems.
I think we are way behind in all this, but are now starting to make structures to improve our learning process.
As p&t illustrates, there are advantages in people having qualifications.
I'm thinking of gas engineers who need to regularly update their qualification. This means they are up to date with the latest knowledge, can service safely the latest kit and the qualification necessary means they *have* to do it.
Simply learning on the job means you don't necessarily keep up to date, or if lazy don't want to keep up to date.
Saying that, melodeons don't explode that often and so perhaps qualifications aren't necessary in this field.
-
Gena, I think formal lessons for an instrument are regionalised.
i.e. I'm sure I've been told on Shetland, as a school aged person if you wish to play violin you get a classical violin teacher, if you wish to play traditional music you get a fiddler with no difference in perception that one is better than the other.
I have no idea if the traditional fiddler is formally trained though.......
I suspect such regional differences are country specific.
I'd like to know if diatonic button accordion is an option in France, with their strong formalised styles, in Italy or elsewhere in Europe, and whether other countires teach traditional music as an option at school.
Q
I don't kknow that in what the situation is at present but I do know that under Highland Regional Council (1974-96) piping was taught, by both instructors and teachers. Those who held teaching qualfications e.g PGCE were classed as music teachers nd paid a such. Those who didn't were merely "instructors" and were paid less.
-
If an expectation of qualifications emerges, leading to standards which need to be widely recognised, and then followed by metrics and associated tests to allay the insecurities of those arranging the funding (especially if public), and the need to deploy those metrics nationally to achieve wide acceptance, cost effectiveness and critical mass - is this not the path to grey uniformity across the land?
-
If an expectation of qualifications emerges, leading to standards which need to be widely recognised, and then followed by metrics and associated tests to allay the insecurities of those arranging the funding (especially if public), and the need to deploy those metrics nationally to achieve wide acceptance, cost effectiveness and critical mass - is this not the path to grey uniformity across the land?
It would be the death of traditional music, but is the life blood of the Royal Schools of Music.
-
Thanks Peadar, so it appears there were some teachers recognised with formal qualifications and some without
Malcolm, hmmm possibly!.
I once commented regarding teaching melodeon on the continent along similar lines. I repeated a comment from a well known player and tutor that we'd and was resoundedly told off!
My daughter plays flute and at school did grades and has played in regional youth orchestras. It has given her a solid foundation of music and allowed her to fully understand her instrument. It hasn't produced a clone flute player, it has produced someone with an understanding, given her the tools to go on and play what she wants.
I can see that a similar understanding would be an advantage for us.
Ah Peadar has replied.... see above!
-
Thanks Peadar, so it appears there were some teachers recognised with formal qualifications and some without
Malcolm, hmmm possibly!.
I once commented regarding teaching melodeon on the continent along similar lines. I repeated a comment from a well known player and tutor that we'd and was resoundedly told off!
My daughter plays flute and at school did grades and has played in regional youth orchestras. It has given her a solid foundation of music and allowed her to fully understand her instrument. It hasn't produced a clone flute player, it has produced someone with an understanding, given her the tools to go on and play what she wants.
I can see that a similar understanding would be an advantage for us.
Ah Peadar has replied.... see above!
No names but the particular Ross-shire instructor I was thinking of had been a piping instructor in the army. Because he didn't have a univerity awarded certificate of education he would never qualify for teacher's pay and conditions, whereas a qualified class room teacher (e.g. a former maths teacher) whose qualifications in piping were limited to winning prizes on the games circuit would be graded as a teacher, with teacher's pay and pension, though at secondary level piping was invariably one to one tuition.
I should add that there is a clear distinction between the pipe band music developed by the red army (during the 19th century) which stylistically owes more to the band of the grenadier guards than it does to Gaidhlig traditional music- something which has been gradually dawning on the piping world over the last twenty years or so.
-
Does lecturing at a Medical School count? 🤔 Not had many melodeon protagés, but there is defo a skill to it.
The Grenoble lot actively teach “didactics†and my own tutors Stéf Milleret and Patrick Reboud are very good. The latter incidentally plays a large CBA! His lessons were about music.
Pignol doesn’t teach at all. You have to be able to communicate at the pupil’s level. Norbert’s ideas can be pretty stratospheric.
Actually, I think that’s perhaps the key? The ability to simplify.
-
If an expectation of qualifications emerges, leading to standards which need to be widely recognised, and then followed by metrics and associated tests to allay the insecurities of those arranging the funding (especially if public), and the need to deploy those metrics nationally to achieve wide acceptance, cost effectiveness and critical mass - is this not the path to grey uniformity across the land?
It would be the death of traditional music, ...
I think that is an overly pessimistic view. People would still (and do) go ahead and play traditional instruments and tunes anyway, regardless of whether they had tuition or not. I don't think traditional music can be killed off as easily as you fear.
Also, isn't piping highly formalised and regulated anyway? Perhaps I'm wrong, but I get the impression from my Highland piping friend that if you get even one single grace note out of place you are marked down. There's a whole world of difference between that sort of 'traditional music' and a dozen or so friends playing tunes in a Suffolk pub for the sheer enjoyment of good music, good ale and good company.
-
Does lecturing at a Medical School count? 🤔 Not had many melodeon protagés, but there is defo a skill to it.
Not in the Scottish education system it doesn't.
Going back to my own brief period on the staff of one of the Scottish Central Institutions in the mid '80's (in their day the equivalent of the English polytechnics) an Indian academic of my aquaintance was recruited to a professorship and to his quiet fury was required to register with the GTCS as a probationer teacher. ::)
-
It feels like teaching fundamental instrument skills and a grounding in music is poles apart from the strict piping rules of the competition. Perhaps opposite ends of the concept of teaching traditional music?
With my previous example of my daughter and flute lessons, she has that basic grounding in instrument and theory but the pieces learnt during that formal period I've never heard her play since. It was a means to an end.
Whereas morris tunes.... !
-
Also, isn't piping highly formalised and regulated anyway?
I wouldn't describe it exactly like that. There are some historic threads, like the army influence (which I'm never sure is as negative an influence as it is sometimes painted these days), but I think it is just like any other traditional instrument, just further along that spectrum where right and wrong becomes more black and white. And as for having a gracenote out of place, it's almost a suggestion that doesn't quite make sense to me. There's a construction of embellishment that is idiomatic, and you can do anything within that that remains idiomatic. But the idiom for certain tunes is very narrow, but for others it is broader.
Historically the piping community has suffered from perhaps less than ideal instruction (here I think the army's influence was negative, promoting a pedagogy that could be described as shouting at a problem until it goes away), but a lot has changed certainly in my piping lifetime since the early 90s.
Competition of course is a whole other topic entirely, but if you enjoy sport, and you enjoy music, the idea that playing music for prizes doesn't seem like something that wouldn't appeal to a certain sort of mind.
-
Actually, I think that’s perhaps the key? The ability to simplify.
absolutely agree!
george
-
My thoughts on teaching melodeon and other skills.
It is challenging work teaching something that you know well inside yourself and then trying to pull that knowledge out of your being and share it with another person or persons. I do not have teaching qualifications for music but have taught mostly young people melodeon, in groups and individually. Sometimes a connection is made and on others not so much. What you know, and how it is shared, and the ability to share it openly and with encouragement is in my opinion the way forward.
Lizzy
-
I remember music teachers in my youth. Some were stultifyingly boring and sucked the enthusiasm out of their pupils, others kindled just that enthusiasm and encouraged their pupils to overcome difficulties to achieve a truly musical result. I guess this is always true. As a community we have the advantage of being (mostly) adult and can choose to change teachers if they don't suit us. I'm no teacher but have mentored people at times, e.g. taking a learner driver out between lessons, I've even had other players ask how I play a particular phrase that they find difficult. The level of success always depends on finding a way to express what your trying to get across in a calm manner and slow enough and repeated (with variations) until the penny drops. Language is imprecise at the best of times but trying to explain timing, feeling, etc. shows how words can mean different things to different people in a given circumstance.
If you can get a pupil to understand how something feels when it's right, then you can teach them to do it. Of course it helps if you can at least demonstrate how it sounds when it's right, too.
Rob
-
As you say, the Scotch and Irish have persevered (despite having the same overarching leaders)
"overarching leaders"
What's that supposed to mean?