Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Recordings and Videos => Topic started by: Helena Handcart on August 15, 2020, 09:26:32 AM
-
Hi Melnetters,
I'm looking for recommendations for a suitable USB mic for recording the melodeon, nothing fancy - I probably don't want to spend more than £100. Any suggestions folks?
Helena
-
I use my Zoom H1, sounds fine and comes in under the £100
-
My suggestion is to see what Thomann (http://thomann.de) offer because you'll probably get it cheaper there than anywhere else. The Röde NT-USB might be a good choice but it's a bit oversensitive and could be overloaded with a loud melodeon.
Also check Podcastage channel on YouTube (https://youtube.com/podcastage) for entertaining and informative reviews. One of them is entitled "Best USB microphone under $100"... got to be worth a look. Don't be put off at first by his presentation style - he's knowledgeable, consistent and thorough.
-
Hi Helena
I have previously used a Zoom H1 stereo recorder as a USB mike. I found it easy to use as there is a visual display of the levels, and you can set the recording level to one that suits you. (or choose auto, but then it listens out for the lawnmower in the distance). I was able to record directly from the H1 to replace my built-in laptop mike, using this with the windows Photos app with the laptop webcam (Without any editing of the soundwave)
But, influenced by Paul Young's posts I sent for a diaphragm mike from Thomanns (their cheapest USB),(mono). However, this is much harder to use. There is no immediate display of the level, and no way of setting the level on the mike itself. So you have to use other software to set the level, such as the audio software within windows. The new mike seems more sensitive than the previous one, putting out a VERY LOUD signal to direct headphones.
So I'll probably go back to using the H1, as it's simpler... and also gives stereo sound, which I like.
The non-idiotuser-friendliness of the new mike is only a problem if you want to record direct. If you are clever enough to use editing software to manage the audio file, then obviously the better diaphragm mike is the way to go.
-
My suggestion is to see what Thomann (http://thomann.de) offer because you'll probably get it cheaper there than anywhere else.
I agree - I have a T-bone SC440 and have nothing but praise for it. And it's only 44 quid.
Graham
-
Snowballs are pretty good.
-
Buying a USB only mic is buying a mic with not a lot of versatility beyond that use, so, be sure you don't have aspirations of recording a band or a duo/trio all working in a daw, as using it in a multi mic setup may cause all sorts of problems.
Additionally, a USB mic may tie you to a computer. That may be ok. You may also be able to connect it to other devices such a tablets or mobiles via USB otg but I've not had good experiences with that so far. Sometimes I record outside, or record morris performances, and have used the same equipment as I use for home recording.
I do imagine that all counts as something fancy, but I feel it bears mentioning.
I use a zoom h2n (although I wish I had an h4n, for the xlr input) to record audio for my videos but it's... I would say it's really pretty ok? You do pay a bit extra for the mobility and the rest of the tech inside it and the sd card etc, and seems much more of a room mic rather than an instrument mic, which in melodeon land may be an advantage since you can more easily get away with just one. I also have a discrete audio interface on my pc, which can take xlr and 1/4 inch etc, but, I don't really like playing music in the room where it lives right now and I don't have a mic that's really as good as the h2n to connect to it - I just bought the cheapest ok looking xlr mic to get started with and have yet to revisit that little project. To get to that point probably is going to blow the budget, but it's the startings of a home recording studio.
-
Just a couple of months ago got a Samson GoMic; cost less than 50 USD to my door, and sounds great, at least to me and my on-line colleagues who have heard it.
-
My microphone habit is slightly worse than my melodeon habit and I tend to use a USB interface for recording to a computer- that way you can plug in different microphones and more of them.
Mics can be quite good value second hand on ebay- it’s the sort of thing that people tend to buy, use once, then move on when they lose interest. And the better makes are usually well made so they are robust.
I have a Protools MBOX2 interface which is now fairly old but good quality, it will record 2 mics, has nice knobs for gain, a headphone out, a very simple mix knob for direct monitoring (i.e. avoiding latency) and I picked the last one up for less than £40 on eBay.
For mics I think small diaphragm pencil condensers often give a slightly more realistic sound for melodeon than large condensers and I have a pair of SE 1A’s that are very good (but my son stole them). I’ve seen the little behringer c2 pencils recommended on this forum (but not used them myself) and at £36 for a pair from Thomann that would bring you in under budget and would give you a mic for each end of the box.
I agree that Gena’s idea is a very good one, a Zoom would serve multiple purposes, and with possibly less faffing about, but you can’t use other mics with the H2 and ... well ...microphones are lovely things you know?
Gren
-
...I agree that Gena’s idea is a very good one, a Zoom would serve multiple purposes, and with possibly less faffing about, but you can’t use other mics with the H2 and ... well ...microphones are lovely things you know?
Gren
If you come into a bit of money, there's always the Zoom R16. It is a battery powered 8 channel mixer with built in pre-amps, phantom power and a couple of quite decent built in mics (probably similar to the H2N), a surface controller and a 16 track recorder. Does the lot. Gives great connectivity at a low price for this sort of kit.
https://www.soundonsound.com/reviews/zoom-r16
-
I use a Zoom H2n as a USB mic and also for stand-alone recordings to a SD card. The sound quality is really very good indeed, and although I have other mics, I nearly always use the H2n for its sheer convenience and ease of use.
...I’ve seen the little behringer c2 pencils recommended on this forum (but not used them myself) and at £36 for a pair from Thomann that would bring you in under budget and would give you a mic for each end of the box....
I also have a pair of these Behringer C2 mics and again they are superb value for the money. But I think the sound quality is marginally better on the Zoom H2n though. My main use for the Behringers was for ceilidh band playing - the XLR cables went straight into the mixing desk. For recording to a computer though, you need a USB audio interface, so that's another bit of kit to add on. I use a M-Audio Fast Track Pro, which cost about £90 quite a few years ago.
Overall, for home recording, I think the H2n takes a lot of beating.
-
Lots of good suggestions if you need a mic for a nuber of purposes or are thinking of a multi-mic setup, but if all you need is a single mic with a simple interface, then a reasonable usb mic (I've alreday made my recommendation) and Audacity or a similar audio editor will do the job very satsfactorily. It's the KISS principle.....
Graham
-
There's a few things we don't know about your ideas, Helena. If you already have a full recording setup, and trust its quality, then GPS makes a good point. If on the other hand, you want simply to record yourself playing on the box, then one of the Zoom recorders would to my mind be the simplest and best, and will give you superb quality, great flexibility and ease of use. I have a Zoom H2 which I use all the time. It is simply wonderful for plonking in a room of musicians, or in front of you as you play in order to record yourself, or for your audio input to an online session or other media (using the inbuilt audio/digital interface). You can use it as storage device for music, if you want, and plug it into a car stereo, so you can learn stuff as you drive, or just playback music when you want. It is highly portable, and rugged (mine is now covered with wear scuffs from so much use.) And then you just download the file into goldwav or something as an mp3, to tweak it by cutting out the ends, and hey presto, an immediate high quality recording to email round to your chums at around 5Mb (so that it doesn't get blocked). You will find that they use it as a rehearsal recording too.
-
Thanks everyone for your suggestions. I think I have this sorted now.
-
...there's always the Zoom R16...
I use both a Zoom H2 and an R16 and they are very different devices. The internal mics on the R16 are said by some to use the same capsules as the H2. I have never had a great deal of success using them. The R16 is good for a small band but for a personal recorder the H2 is perfect.
The H2 (and the H2n) give very good quality either as USB mics or stand alone recorders. The H2n is available for £130 from Thomann (other retailers are available) and that price includes a download code for a copy of Cubase LE.
-
...there's always the Zoom R16...
I use both a Zoom H2 and an R16 and they are very different devices. The internal mics on the R16 are said by some to use the same capsules as the H2. I have never had a great deal of success using them. The R16 is good for a small band but for a personal recorder the H2 is perfect.
To put it in context, the R16 and the H2 have different advantages.
1. Using the internal mics both give very similar results (I have never been able to tell much difference).
2. The H2 is very portable. Easy to carry around and unobtrusive. It is what it is.
3. The R16 is still quite portable: I used to use mine a lot. Not so much recently. It travels in a laptop bag and fits it nicely. It has the advantage of it being easy to add more instruments and microphones, in appropriate situations. Perfect for a small band but easily usable by an individual, either as a stand alone recorder with internal mics, or a USB mic into a PC. A new costs about £300, if you shop around, a second hand one half that, or less. The mic pre-amps sometimes get a bit of stick for being noisy, but you wouldn't notice that in the sort of applications being talked about. Quiter than the Behringer ones I've used.
-
Here's a recording made on a Zoom H2 in my front room a few years ago. Recorded using the H2 as a USB mic straight to a laptop computer. Minimal post-processing in GaragerBand; just the fade-in at the beginning and the fade-out at the end.
https://soundcloud.com/steve_freereeder/when-the-king-enjoys-his-own
-
Thanks everyone for your suggestions. I think I have this sorted now.
Good. Enjoy!
-
Small detail on recording. I use a Zoom recorder (which I like). I notice that if you sit well back from the recorder, it picks up a lot less of the inevitable button clatter and you get a nice sound balance from both sides of the box. I normally sit about 2m away from the recorder (and this was pre-COVID!).
-
Hi,
following this discussion with great interest. Can anyone tell me if its possible to use the H2n Zoom as a high quality USB mic? It states on the description that 'in addition, the H2n's USB port allows recorded files to be imported into computer editing software such as the supplied WaveLab LE. You can even use the H2n as a 2-in/2-out audio interface or as a USB microphone'. But if Im going to mostly use it attached to a computer is that a waste of money and would I be better purchasing a high quality USB mic?
Thanks !
-
Hi,
following this discussion with great interest. Can anyone tell me if its possible to use the H2n Zoom as a high quality USB mic? It states on the description that 'in addition, the H2n's USB port allows recorded files to be imported into computer editing software such as the supplied WaveLab LE. You can even use the H2n as a 2-in/2-out audio interface or as a USB microphone'. But if Im going to mostly use it attached to a computer is that a waste of money and would I be better purchasing a high quality USB mic?
Thanks !
It's very easy to use the Zoom H2n as a USB mic. The H2n has a mini-USB port. You simply connect it to the computer with a standard USB cable. Once connected, you get an option on the H2n screen to connect directly to the computer. This powers the H2n (so no battery drain) and also bypasses its SD card, so you will need to record to a sound application on your computer (e.g. Audacity, or Garageband (Mac); not sure what the PC equivalent is.
The H2n acts as its own USB interface, so there's no need for any additional kit.
The sound quality of the H2n's microphones is very good indeed. But if you really think you want better quality, you would need to be looking at recording studio quality mics and set up.
-
Thanks Steve thats perfect!
E
-
But if Im going to mostly use it attached to a computer is that a waste of money and would I be better purchasing a high quality USB mic?
Bear in mind that the space by your computer may not have the best acoustics to record in. Having a free standing recorder is useful because you can experiment recording in different parts of your home until you find the sweet spot where your instrument sounds best, or anywhere else.
-
would I be better purchasing a high quality USB mic?
The sound quality of the H2n's microphones is very good indeed. But if you really think you want better quality, you would need to be looking at recording studio quality mics and set up.
Agreed, and to clarify further: you are not going to find many top quality USB mics. If you're going for studio quality, you need the flexibility to place the mic in the best acoustic position, not tied to a computer by the length restrictions of a USB cable, so you're looking at a separate USB audio interface (there are many!) and then the sky's the limit on mic choice and you can put it on the end of 100m of XLR cable if you must.
For YouTube video melodeon recording, a device like the Zoom recorder is significantly better than using most camera's built-in mics, it has other applications for portable recording (sessions etc.) and it records in stereo, which many dedicated USB mics don't. It's very good value. (not that I have one myself, but that's only because I have an Edirol R-09 bought before the Zoom existed.)
-
In principal, if you take the money for an eg h2n and put it into a 'pure' USB mic, you ought to get more mic for your money, since you're getting less... well, everything else? By extension that means you should be able to put less money in and achieve the same result, if that is your only goal.
Prices seem (to me) to be generally 'up' for home audio equipment - though I still would imagine that for the price of an h2n (eg £160 on amazon right now) you can likely buy a USB audio interface and XLR mic/s that would beat it out in a A/B test. But correctly using that equipment requires more knowledge and time and has more 'bits' that all need to be put together and connected up and fuss, muss & etc. I must admit I'm on the edge of finally taking that plunge and getting some nicer XLR mics, though.
I think it should also be noted that it can also be more cost effective to make a better environment to record audio in, than it is to spend money on 'better' microphones - particularly if you're not using an instrument mic all up close and personal like.
-
For YouTube video melodeon recording, a device like the Zoom recorder is significantly better than using most camera's built-in mics, it has other applications for portable recording (sessions etc.) and it records in stereo, which many dedicated USB mics don't. It's very good value. (not that I have one myself, but that's only because I have an Edirol R-09 bought before the Zoom existed.)
Using the zoom H2n as a stand-alone recorder, i.e. recording to the SD card and not via a USB connection, it can record in 4 channel surround sound - there are 4 mics in the device. The gain on each channel can be adjusted independently, either at the time of recording, or subsequently. I have found this feature very useful in recording my clarinet quartet rehearsals. We sit in a square, facing each other and put the H2n in the middle.
Once happy with the recording and levels, I can mix-down to my computer hard drive in 2 channel stereo sound for further editing (e.g. EQ, reverb, etc) if needed.
-
Hi All,
I'm resurrecting this thread as I think a usb microphone might help me.
I've been invited to a Zoom instructional and need to be able to play and be heard reasonably well through a Zoom call.
My webcam's sound is poor.
I have tried messing with my webcam mic today, and to be fair have got it sounding better by turning the volume slider from 100% to 15% in the Microsoft Settings > Sound > microphone setting.
It stops overloading the webcam mic and now sounds sort of ok rather than awful!
So.... I'm looking for recommendations as per Helena at the start of this thread, for a usb microphone that I can simply plug in and use to allow me to use during a Zoom melodeon instructional for under £100.
The simpler the better as I have had no experience of microphones.
I would think I'll be about 1-2m away from the pc when using it.
I did look at Thomans website as recommended earlier but simply had no idea what to look for in a mass of different mic's and was overwhelmed at the choices, hence me asking again.
Thanks in advance.
Q
-
Someone who does lots of excellent mic reviews on YouTube did a roundup of budget USB mics and the Samson C01 was judged the best.
No USB mic is full studio quality, but it will be in a different league from your webcam, and it should not have any show-stopper vices.
Looks like typical price £69. You may need a mic stand - a desktop stand should suffice.
-
I use a Blue Yeti. Very solid and straightforward. It does have a few setting options, but it's not like you need to fiddle around much with it. Around £120
-
Oh thanks, that's two recommendations to look at.
I don't need studio quality, just 'better than the webcam'!
-
I had an SE USB2200A USB Microphone, until I got careless and dropped it. It worked very well. I mainly used it for recording female vocals. Did sound sweet, though.
-
I use a Zoom H2n for Zoom lessons and I do find it somewhat frustrating trying find the correct gain setting that picks up my voice loud enough but doesn't distort the melodeon. Sometimes I listen back to a recorded Zoom meeting and I'm aghast that my voice is simultaneously too low but the melodeon is squawking and bleating.
The H2n works well for making YouTube recordings (the reason I originally bought it), but it seems kind of touchy as a USB mic. But that might just be down to a hamfisted operator more than the device itself.
-
I'm aware several people use a Zoom recorder as a mic.
I have an Olympus for recording audio and though I have worked out it can be used as a mic for audio, it is such an incredible faff to set up. I tried it then had such difficulty in re-setting it to it's 'normal' recording mode that I swore blind I'd never mess with it again!
Nice thought Jesse, but I think a straight usb mic will suit me better.
-
I suspect I may be revisiting old, rejected solutions, but I still think a half decent sound card, such as the M-Audio M-Track Solo 2 Channel USB (many other similar devices are available, but this is a good one) plus a half decent condenser mic, such as the Rode NT1A Condenser (many other alternatives available, but this has withstood the test of time) is the best way to go.
-
A couple of advantages of the Blue Yeti is that the input volume and mute controls to your computer are easily operated being on the front of the mic. Also, it has multiple pickup patterns including stereo, which means that it can grow with you as your experience and needs change. It has its own desktop stand and the facility to attach it to a mic stand. The BY has been around for a long time now, check out some of the (usually good) YouTube reviews.
-
Thanks Bob, good to hear another positive review with both you and p&t having experience from the melodeon world..
I have had a quick look at BY and the others mentioned in the thread.
It seems to be the most expensive but does come out well in a lot of reviews.
The main debate is the stand, which is a +/- depending if you need to move it or whether to keep it as a desk top mic.
My feeling is that it would live by the pc so making it a +ve for me.
I'm still thinking about it, but the Blue Yeti seems to be looking favourite at the moment.
-
I was going to buy a Blue Yeti but there were none to be had at the time so I ended up getting an Audio Technica AT2020USB mic. I've had it since last October and I've been really pleased with it. I've used it for Skype (family and friend chats) and Zoom (online music sessions etc.) I also use it for my TOTM recordings and now record sound direct to Audacity without the faff I used to have transferring it from my portable Olympus digital recorder. Fortunately my PC seems to run silent (not sure how!) so I can record in the same room. In general having the USB mic has been more useful than I would have imagined.
-
That 's reassuring Mcgrooger, I think I will still head for the Yeti...
If your experience is anything to go by, it will help me on several fronts.
A question for mic users:
do you find if it is set up for melodeon, do you need to turn down the gain for voice/chats/friends zooming etc. or do you simply just talk, switching between box and chat?
-
The settings for mine are within the 'apps'. In Zoom I use manual as opposed to auto mic sound settings using the sound check faciltiy but after that I don't adjust it between melodeon, speaking, singing with guitar or whatever. I only had to do this once rather than every time I use Zoom. In Audacity you can see visually the recording level your mic wants to be at. For Skype chats I think I just rely on the in house auto setting. You do have to be nearer to the mic than you might expect and your 'slider' might need to be higher than you would think but mine isn't on maximum in any software. Recording straight to my PC has meant that I can add extra tracks very easily as Audacity then takes care of the track synching. If you have a listen to my YT recordings of Coleman's March or Brother Trip Foot you can hear the result of a bit of multi tracking.
I have a feeling that some people think that the auto sound processing in the Blue mic isn't to their liking which was part of what took me to the Audio Technica but I doubt I'd have noticed much if any difference.
Hope this helps. (:)
-
OK thanks, I like things you don't need to constantly twiddle with!
-
Bear in mind that the Zoom platform (and similar) was designed for VOICE conferences, and sometimes music is being considered as noise and filtered!
-
Thank you, yes very aware of the limits of music on Zoom following previous lockdown Morris practices!
We've found that selecting 'original sound' gives a better response and less like you are playing in a muffled sack.
The mic will have other primary duties rather than just Zoom so the quality for Zoom need not be brilliant, just acceptable.
-
I have also went for the Blue Yeti USB Microphone. Seems fairly decent. Have used it with moothie and melodeon. In both cases I used it with the gain turned well down to avoid picking up too much extraneous noise. Could definitely have done with a pop guard / filter for the moothie. I improvised with a kitchen sieve for a pop guard which made a difference but I should probably still get something a bit better. Used the makeshift guard with the melodeon as well but it is probably not so important for it. To get the best out of it an anti vibration mount might also be a good idea. - At which point, of course, it all becomes a bit more complicated and expensive.
-
Well, the order has been sent!
I thought I'd see how I got on with the basic kit, as I plan to play a little way away from the pc, and not touching the pc station so see how the vibrations go, but a pop guard and maybe a next purchase.
-
I thought it worth reporting back having now received the Blue Yeti.
I spent a little while sorting it and my webcam out, as I also seem to be recording video into the light, thus putting me in shadow.
I also tried the different types of mic arrangements, front, front and back, all round, and found the stereo setting the best I think. That and checking in Audacity I wasn't overloading things when playing, by looking at the waveform.
This might need fine tuning, but it seems to be ok and considerably better than just using the webcam mike.
Anyway, after having a play around with the pc kit, I then had a play around with the box!
All I've done is top and tail it to remove me sitting down and getting up at the end.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hIZURVuruxY
-
I spent a little while sorting it and my webcam out, as I also seem to be recording video into the light, thus putting me in shadow.
I also tried the different types of mic arrangements, front, front and back, all round, and found the stereo setting the best I think. That and checking in Audacity I wasn't overloading things when playing, by looking at the waveform.
All the above was was exactly what a professional recording engineer would do. You have to trust your ears to make the judgement about which sounds best of course, but I doubt you could improve much on that. And that Jilly sounds lovely!
-
Thank you for the feedback Anahata, much appreciated!
-
It sounds fine and I'm happy that it's worked out for you. The USB mic format is a great way of getting things done, by not being paralysed with multiple gear choices. (Like me..)
Bob.
-
Thanks Bob.
Having moved house just over a year ago I've been wondering how to resolve the issue of recording, plus on-line Zoom sessions or workshops should I wish to join in, but not really knowing where to start. Looks like acquiring a USB mic was the key!
-
Dumb question from decidely non-techy person:
I've relied on an old USB mic for melodeon recordings. It was cheap many years ago and probably designed for speech anyway. It does the job but I thought I'd try to get a better sound. I have a lead which lets me plug my SM57 into the USB socket but the signal isn't great.
So I finally decided to dig out my old Zoom H1 and try that as a USB mic. I note that several contributors to this thread say they use an H1.
The recording sounded fine until I added it to the video. Before I had muted the camera's sound track, I heard the two recordings simultaneously. Cacophony! The Zoom recording was nearly a semitone sharp. I assumed I'd done something to the Audacity settings but everything was fine once I'd returned to the old Logitech mic.
So what am I doing wrong? (One answer might be RTFM but I can't ffind the FM.)
-
So what am I doing wrong? (One answer might be RTFM but I can't ffind the FM.)
Had the same problem. The sample rate on your H1 is probably set to 48Khz and the default sample rate assumed by Audacity is 44.1Khz. So check the H1 sample rate (you may have to RTFM to find out how) then set Audacity to the same Audacity>Preferences>Quality>Sampling (sorry that is MAC view of life but Windows will have similar.
-
Thanks Lester. I'll give that a try. Good to know I wasn't missing something really obvious. (:)
-
I changed the PC's sound settings for the device to 44.1 and that's done the trick. Thanks again.
-
That happened to me once during a music lesson via Zoom (the videophone software). I had my Zoom H2n mic set to 44.1Hz but Zoom the app was expecting 48Hz, and everything came out about a semitone sharp, and when I watched the recording back I sounded a bit like Mickey Mouse. ;D
-
...everything came out about a semitone sharp, and when I watched the recording back I sounded a bit like Mickey Mouse. ;D
Like Paul McCartney on when I'm 64?
-
Like Paul McCartney on when I'm 64?
Uh, yes, but he did that intentionally!