Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: BobM on September 04, 2020, 01:23:09 PM
-
Having just read a post in the "Buy and Sell", where the poster mentions a trend towards G/C boxes, is there one? And why would that be?
Bob.
-
Having just read a post in the "Buy and Sell", where the poster mentions a trend towards G/C boxes, is there one? And why would that be?
Bob.
Not sure if there's a trend but haven't they always been the weapon of choice for player of French music? Perhaps there are more players turning to that?
-
Just so long as there isn't a trend towards CF boxes. Best sounding reeds Hohner ever made. Be a shame if the prices went through the roof.
-
Just so long as there isn't a trend towards CF boxes. Best sounding reeds Hohner ever made. Be a shame if the prices went through the roof.
Some people would say Bb/Eb sound even better... ;-)
-
Having just read a post in the "Buy and Sell", where the poster mentions a trend towards G/C boxes, is there one? And why would that be?
Bob.
Not sure if there's a trend but haven't they always been the weapon of choice for player of French music? Perhaps there are more players turning to that?
In my case not French specifically. In hindsight the D/G may have been easier for me to get started on and to be easier to find instruments to upgrade to, but I do like the lower pitch of the G/C. All of the TOTM's have been playable in the written pitch and with valid chords in the few months that I've been learning. There would have to be a huge advantage for me to jump ship to a D/G now.
Bob.
-
G/C is the current weapon of choice for those interested in playing French/Euro Bal music.
But normally G/C/Accs and as many basses as possible!!!
-
Some people would say Bb/Eb sound even better... ;-)
A certain poignancy to it. Bb and C are close enough songwise but I much prefer Bb if it’s an emotional “As I went out …†sort of lyric, while C is much better for the “Nellie the Elephant†tunes..
🤔 … and that covers most of the folk repertoire.
-
Just so long as there isn't a trend towards CF boxes. Best sounding reeds Hohner ever made. Be a shame if the prices went through the roof.
Some people would say Bb/Eb sound even better... ;-)
Absolutely. but there are already a number of Flat sessions around. Actually, in spite of what I said, I would love to see some CF friendly sessions.
-
I must say, being French, that I still don't understand why G/C should be a weapon of choice for French music.
We're playing transposing instruments, so it doesn't really matter, I think.
Where I learned the accordion (Brittany), we play G/C as a force of habit, and not for anything else really (and compared to the lifespan of the diatonic accordion, it's a relatively recent trend). In some regions it may have to do with playing with hurdy-gurdy and some bagpipes (although it greatly depends on their keys too). But you could as well play any type of French music for accordion on any key. It's especially true seing that French tunes don't really come with a fixed key as it can do with traditional music from other countries.
-
When I have played with French dance musicians the band has included pipes, hurdy gurdy and big five row button accordion, so you would imagine a wide range of keys but not a bit of it. When I sat in the whole set was in C, so my little G/C Maugein was fine! That was in Correze.
-
Well I chose GC for my Pariselle box so I could join in sessions in France. But when I tried in Parthenay last year, they were playing everything in D.... So I would have been better off with my DG box which was in England. Frustrating.
For French sessions locally in G, D and C, (Pipes/gurdy etc) I mostly play my CF 12B box for minors and C, and DG 8B box for majors. Never felt the need for GC there.
I remember Frederic Paris saying that GC is a bit too low and DG is too high. So maybe Bb/Eb would be a good choice... except you'd probably be playing alone.
-
I remember Frederic Paris saying that GC is a bit too low and DG is too high. So maybe Bb/Eb would be a good choice... except you'd probably be playing alone.
I've no plans to take part in sessions, after all, the public haven't done me any harm. But generally as I prefer the sound of lower pitched instruments, I'm happy with my lot. (G/C).
-
Were you amongst the Bourbonnais bagpipers? Because of the drone they tend to play parallel major minors rather than shift modally like us,. Aided and abetted by the Gurdies 🤔
C/G should be happy enough there as it has most of the Dm scale inner row and D maj on outer, you’s want Bb and C# accidentals repectively, ot just miss out those notes. Suspect Fredu’s issue is that his both ways bass D is completely upstaged by the 4 foot bagpipe drone 🤔 but he does get by … rather well?
What did Cyril Roche play in his time with trio Bouffard?
-
"But generally........I prefer the sound of lower pitched instruments"
I'm pleased that I'm not alone in my dislike of the squeaky D/G! I love my G tuned 1 rows, and my D/G Liliput is bandoneon tuned to save my sanity. I bought a D/G Erica a while ago, needing a bit of work, and I've just finished it at the weekend; I hate it, it'll have to go!
I do like the pitch of the Bb/Eb, it seems to match my own vibrations. (If that's not too queer a thing to say?) One of my singing accomplices is going to check out the keys in which we sing our songs, to compare them with Little Eggy's list. Should be a laugh, eh?
-
I must say, being French, that I still don't understand why G/C should be a weapon of choice for French music.
We're playing transposing instruments, so it doesn't really matter, I think.
Where I learned the accordion (Brittany), we play G/C as a force of habit, and not for anything else really (and compared to the lifespan of the diatonic accordion, it's a relatively recent trend). In some regions it may have to do with playing with hurdy-gurdy and some bagpipes (although it greatly depends on their keys too). But you could as well play any type of French music for accordion on any key. It's especially true seing that French tunes don't really come with a fixed key as it can do with traditional music from other countries.
By the same token I find it difficult to understand BC a weapon of choice for Scottish (Gaidhlig) music or Irish music. But there it is.
-
By the same token I find it difficult to understand BC a weapon of choice for Scottish (Gaidhlig) music or Irish music. But there it is.
You'd say a fourth-apart system is more suited?
Because for French music, fourth-apart works well, irrespective of the pitch. The pitch is a matter of local customs, but is not by any means an intrinsic quality of the music. This is what I meant when I said it's not really relevant to say "G/C is for French music". Any pitch suits French music, actually.
-
"But generally........I prefer the sound of lower pitched instruments"
I'm pleased that I'm not alone in my dislike of the squeaky D/G! I love my G tuned 1 rows, and my D/G Liliput is bandoneon tuned to save my sanity. I bought a D/G Erica a while ago, needing a bit of work, and I've just finished it at the weekend; I hate it, it'll have to go!
Possibly showing my ignorance here, but isn't it possible to have a D/G with a lower row start? So more of a sonorous lower register and less of the "piercing" higher one?
-
Possibly showing my ignorance here, but isn't it possible to have a D/G with a lower row start? So more of a sonorous lower register and less of the "piercing" higher one?
That would be a G/D box, with the G-row on the outer row, at the same pitch as the G-row on G/C box. I think I'm correct in saying that the late Dave Roberts (of Blowzabella) had one like this. No doubt somebody will come along dreckly to confirm or correct... ;)
-
I think you're right Steve, and one of the first Castagnari's in this country?
I think Rees of this parish has chapter and verse, but I think it was a GC converted to a GD.....
-
I read, somewhere, that Stéphane Delicq played a D/G box tuned an octave lower than the D/G which is popular in Britain. I don’t know more than that. Anyone know?
-
arty, I think I've read the same, but cannot remember where either!!
-
Ive worked on one octave lower DG box. I was pleasantly surprised at how nice it was to play.
-
I have a 5th button start D/G box. Helper row with the usual accidentals, but main rows just carrying on downwards. I can very much recommend this set-up for D/G
-
Steve is definitely right about Dave’s box, an old 70’s friend. I played it in … late 90’s. He said it was more or less the first Casta in Britain, bought in Sidmouth from Sandro and Massimo. They had no DG’s whatsoever in stock, and so had taken the C row reeds out of GC and replaced with a D set => GD 5th apart, rather than 4th in effect. 😳
We’d met up in Newtown, guess Rees might have booked that gig? Sadly Dave died next year, but I’d had the chance to thank him for “changing the way melodeon is played in Britainâ€. He was very much the melodeon facet of the original Blowzabella.
-
Dave’s daughter Alice now plays this box, having had a quick go a couple of years ago I can confirm it is brain mashingly difficult to play across the rows if you are used to a standard box! :o
Vicky
-
Dave’s daughter Alice now plays this box, having had a quick go a couple of years ago I can confirm it is brain mashingly difficult to play across the rows if you are used to a standard box! :o
Vicky
From memory (this was a *very* long time ago before I got my first Castagnari, maybe the mid-80s?) I thought both rows were at "normal" DG pitch but just swapped over, which makes it even worse -- or is the G row low (like a G/C) and the D row high (like a D/G)? Anyway I couldn't play it either when Dave handed it over to me and said "Go on, have a go..."
-
-- or is the G row low (like a G/C) and the D row high (like a D/G)?
yes - I'm pretty sure it is voiced like that. Vicky - can you confirm?
-
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,19341.msg235067.html#msg235067
Looks like it might be the other way round from Rees’s comments in the thread above. I honestly can’t remember, I was too busy trying to work out how to get a tune out of it!
-
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,19341.msg235067.html#msg235067
Looks like it might be the other way round from Rees’s comments in the thread above. I honestly can’t remember, I was too busy trying to work out how to get a tune out of it!
Getting a tune out of it was dead easy, as long as you stayed entirely on one row ;-)
-
Possibly showing my ignorance here, but isn't it possible to have a D/G with a lower row start? So more of a sonorous lower register and less of the "piercing" higher one?
That would be a G/D box, with the G-row on the outer row, at the same pitch as the G-row on G/C box. I think I'm correct in saying that the late Dave Roberts (of Blowzabella) had one like this. No doubt somebody will come along dreckly to confirm or correct... ;)
A melodeon shaped concertina with tremolo?
-
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,19341.msg235067.html#msg235067
Looks like it might be the other way round from Rees’s comments in the thread above. I honestly can’t remember, I was too busy trying to work out how to get a tune out of it!
OK thanks Vicky. So, basically the same pitch as a normal D/G box, but with the G-row on the outside row, D-row on the inside.
-
By the same token I find it difficult to understand BC a weapon of choice for Scottish (Gaidhlig) music or Irish music. But there it is.
You'd say a fourth-apart system is more suited?
Because for French music, fourth-apart works well, irrespective of the pitch. The pitch is a matter of local customs, but is not by any means an intrinsic quality of the music. This is what I meant when I said it's not really relevant to say "G/C is for French music". Any pitch suits French music, actually.
Not really - but since the 18th century an awful lot of traditional music has been set for the fiddle, much of it in the key of D possibly because A myxelodian is the tuning of the Highland pipe chanter ( Range G-A'). Because of that the C#/D would make more sense to me as a semitone box - but B/C is the etablished Scottish tuning.
Outside of fiddle and pipe settings, any pitch will do - as becomes obvious from the transcriptions of music from traditional Gaidhlig singers.
That said, some accordion players play ADG and the AD melodeon "sits" in that space.
I have to say A&D meets my needs/aspirations pretty well....with a token C/C#to catch the things I can't otherwise play at all.
-
Steve is definitely right about Dave’s box, an old 70’s friend. I played it in … late 90’s. He said it was more or less the first Casta in Britain, bought in Sidmouth from Sandro and Massimo. They had no DG’s whatsoever in stock, and so had taken the C row reeds out of GC and replaced with a D set => GD 5th apart, rather than 4th in effect. 😳
Sorry Chris, but I have to set the record straight.
I began importing Castagnari melodeons in September 1984 after meeting the Italian band La Ciapa Rusa and Marc Peronne and Blowzabella at Pontardawe Festival.
Dave Roberts was my first customer. I ordered a G/D Hascy as per Dave's spec.
As you say, it came with low G outer row. Dave plays standard D/G box with the rows reversed, so needed high G row.
The Hascy went back to Italy for correct octave G row, I was left embarrassed as it was my first contact with both parties and Dave finally got his dream box in early 1985.
As far as I am aware Sandro and Massimo have never been to Sidmouth as I'm sure they would let know..
-
I began importing Castagnari melodeons in September 1984 after meeting the Italian band La Ciapa Rusa and Marc Peronne and Blowzabella at Pontardawe Festival.
I got my Dony from you (via Marcus) just 2 years after that. They were quite the novelty then.
-
I read, somewhere, that Stéphane Delicq played a D/G box tuned an octave lower than the D/G which is popular in Britain. I don’t know more than that.
I don't know about M. Deilcq, but I had a Castagnari Roma tuned like this which I bought from a musician in Italy about 10 years ago; I think that it was one of a limited run of Romas tuned in this way. It now resides with another member of this forum, but I believe from conversations with Mr. Wesson that he has a similar one in his possession, so may be able to shed more light on this...
Cheers,
Guy
-
This is my view in hindsight, but is valid for me nonetheless.
As one who plays "both hands to the middle", I prefer the linear rise of the bass notes from the C up through the A. Having worked as bassist, ceilidh pianist and backing guitarist, I'm distracted by basses "jumping" up or down the octave instead of a scalar transition.
To me, bass lines matter.
-
I read, somewhere, that Stéphane Delicq played a D/G box tuned an octave lower than the D/G which is popular in Britain. I don’t know more than that.
I don't know about M. Deilcq, but I had a Castagnari Roma tuned like this which I bought from a musician in Italy about 10 years ago; I think that it was one of a limited run of Romas tuned in this way. It now resides with another member of this forum, but I believe from conversations with Mr. Wesson that he has a similar one in his possession, so may be able to shed more light on this...
Cheers,
Guy
Yes indeed, I do have a low octave D/G Roma. It has the most gorgeous sound. Not much good in a session as the sound gets lost in the general melee.
As a concert box it's a cracker!
-
A bit like playing a regular D/G with the L voice, or do I understand something wrong?
-
To get back to the G/C boxes matter. . I like it because I use my boxes mainly as vocal support, and C is a better key for me to sing in than G. I have 2 G/C boxes, one of which is a Liliput build for me by Microbot, which also has a bass slide, and a small box like that is grand for schlepping round festivals, being so portable.
That said I do prefer Bb as a singing key, and as soon as I get my F/Bb Koch box sorted out, we will see which I prefer, for singing with. As has been said elsewhere, Bb is indeed an excellent key on a melodeon, whether it is ruined by my vocals or not ;)
Sir John
-
This is my view in hindsight, but is valid for me nonetheless.
As one who plays "both hands to the middle", I prefer the linear rise of the bass notes from the C up through the A. Having worked as bassist, ceilidh pianist and backing guitarist, I'm distracted by basses "jumping" up or down the octave instead of a scalar transition.
To me, bass lines matter.
Of course if you play [G A B C D] on the basses there's an octave jump down from B to C, there has to be one somewhere...
-
This is my view in hindsight, but is valid for me nonetheless.
As one who plays "both hands to the middle", I prefer the linear rise of the bass notes from the C up through the A. Having worked as bassist, ceilidh pianist and backing guitarist, I'm distracted by basses "jumping" up or down the octave instead of a scalar transition.
To me, bass lines matter.
Of course if you play [G A B C D] on the basses there's an octave jump down from B to C, there has to be one somewhere...
There is no B bass on a G/C...
The jump from A to C is mellowed in effect by being "relative" and does not effect linearity much at all. Every box has this in the LH to a greater or lesser extent. My G/C
and A/D Hohners have the "most favorable" config, the D/G the most awkward...although Anahata finds brilliant lines, possibly copped from his cello.
-
Other than one row boxes, I played primarily G/C boxes for years to include a dozen Coronas, half dozen Pokerworks, Lilly, Tommy, Mory, Corso, Hascy, Castagnari custom 12 bass etc. ,
After a few years unable to play I am getting some mobility back.. time to try something new.
I gravitated away from G/C and was considering another key system somewhere in-between D/G and G/C ..or the remote possibility of
one of the half step systems.
-
I gravitated away from G/C and was considering another key system somewhere in-between D/G and G/C ..or the remote possibility of
one of the half step systems.
Being new to the Melodeon, but not to music, I'm finding its closed system really interesting. Finding out what you can play, or what you could play with a little ingenuity is part of the fun. I have a basic 21/8 and sometimes I wonder about having a "fully featured" box, but isn't that called an accordion?
I recently realised that it's possible to play "Sailing By" (Binge), with decent chords and only one subtle melody note compromise, and I'm happy with that..
Bob.
G/C
-
Bob, you have illustrated the quandary of the melodeon!
With a 2 row 8 bass you have a light punchy transportable instrument, but has built in limits. As you say, trying the beat those limits is part of the fun!
As you increase in buttons, half or full third row, 12, 18 or more buttons then it becomes more versatile. With it comes weight, still compromising your ability to play in all keys, and so to the British Chromatic Box with full chromaticity but a huge beast, and begs the question 'do I need to play in all keys?'
Somewhere along the line from 2r8b to big beast lies us all 🙂
Q
-
With a 2 row 8 bass you have a light punchy transportable instrument, but has built in limits. As you say, trying the beat those limits is part of the fun!
As you increase in buttons, half or full third row, 12, 18 or more buttons then it becomes more versatile. With it comes weight, still compromising your ability to play in all keys
I have to disagree with this, it's a bit of a commonplace. There are light, nimble, punchy, and transportable half and full 3 rows. We (I refer to the whole melodeon players community) have a tendency to put too much importance on the weight of the boxes. Weight is but one among many factors that influence handling. Size, amount of air you have to move when playing, compression, flexibility of the bellows are other factors that are as (if not more) important than the sole weight.
We don't need to play in all keys, I think playing in the neighbouring keys is what is at stake (on a D/G, A and C, with a little bit of work E and F); and also being able to play in various modes based on the root notes of the boxes.
Saying that is not saying that 2r8b are bad choices, they're fine, but let's not oppose what needs not be opposed, or at least let's not make things appear more complicated than they are.
-
This is my view in hindsight, but is valid for me nonetheless.
As one who plays "both hands to the middle", I prefer the linear rise of the bass notes from the C up through the A. Having worked as bassist, ceilidh pianist and backing guitarist, I'm distracted by basses "jumping" up or down the octave instead of a scalar transition.
To me, bass lines matter.
Of course if you play [G A B C D] on the basses there's an octave jump down from B to C, there has to be one somewhere...
There is no B bass on a G/C...
The jump from A to C is mellowed in effect by being "relative" and does not effect linearity much at all. Every box has this in the LH to a greater or lesser extent. My G/C
and A/D Hohners have the "most favorable" config, the D/G the most awkward...although Anahata finds brilliant lines, possibly copped from his cello.
Duh, I meant that run on a D/G box. On a G/C box there's still an octave jump, and in one of the two keys it'll be part-way up the run starting on the tonic.
Even some manufacturers can't decide where to put the jump. Out of half a dozen supposedly identical D/G Baffetti Bincis I know of, several (including mine) have C as the lowest bass note, a couple have a low B, one has a low A. I did think of getting a box made with G as the lowest note, but this would probably need extra big reeds to stop them pulling flat under pressure which the box that goes down to A certainly does -- and also I often use simultaneous D and A basses when playing in G which sounds wrong with the low A...
-
...said the member with the Handry 18! :Ph
Isn't this the largest, heaviest diatonic box made?
(Riccardo Tesi envy...)
-
...said the member with the Handry 18! :Ph
Isn't this the largest, heaviest diatonic box made?
There are several larger boxes, but yes it's one of the biggest (:) I don't really mind its size and weight though, even playing single-row, but know that it's not the fact for everyone.
That being said, in what does it change or lessen what I said earlier? The thing is, and the reference to the Handry is relevant, we're long since past the point where a full 3 row meant necessarily having to play cumbersome, big sized accordions. Without going for compact models, you can find many, many accordions that are handy, lively, sonorous (qualities often, and with reason, associated with 2r8b models) and also offer larger musical possibilities. If a 2 rows suits you, that's by all accounts fine, but why always (as a reflex) point out that they are inevitably handier than boxes with more buttons, when it's, in actual fact, not the case?
-
My van der Aa full 3 row, 18 bass (see avatar) weighs about 4.3kg
-
There are light, nimble, punchy, and transportable half and full 3 rows. We (I refer to the whole melodeon players community) have a tendency to put too much importance on the weight of the boxes. Weight is but one among many factors that influence handling. Size, amount of air you have to move when playing, compression, flexibility of the bellows are other factors that are as (if not more) important than the sole weight.
Well, remember that what one person thinks of as light and punchy is going to be different from what another person would think - and, that nuance applies to both sides of that conversation. I've certainly played plenty of 2r8b boxes that didn't meet my criteria, but that other people adore.
It's also important to remember the range and availability of some types of instrument is very low. If you happen to not like the way some of them play, you can easily end up stuck - eg, what if you don't like the castagnari benny or hohner lilliput, but, want something similar?
For selecting keys for a box to play certain locales of music, I'd probably think more about which minors are popular, rather than which major keys are popular. The relative minor of your inside row is typically the one you have the most useful coverage of, so, E minor on a D/G vs A minor on a G/C, with the option to turn the dial towards dorian & harmonic.
-
There are light, nimble, punchy, and transportable half and full 3 rows. We (I refer to the whole melodeon players community) have a tendency to put too much importance on the weight of the boxes. Weight is but one among many factors that influence handling. Size, amount of air you have to move when playing, compression, flexibility of the bellows are other factors that are as (if not more) important than the sole weight.
Well, remember that what one person thinks of as light and punchy is going to be different from what another person would think - and, that nuance applies to both sides of that conversation. I've certainly played plenty of 2r8b boxes that didn't meet my criteria, but that other people adore.
I fully concur with that. These criteria are by far subjective ones. But the main thing I wanted to point out is that the commonplace that 2r8b are, by essence, the only ones to be manoeuvrable or punchy, is false, and conversely, that full three rows are, by essence, big clumsy beasts is also false.
It's also important to remember the range and availability of some types of instrument is very low. If you happen to not like the way some of them play, you can easily end up stuck - eg, what if you don't like the castagnari benny or hohner lilliput, but, want something similar?
I'm not sure to understand, you mean to say that if you don't like the Benny or the Liliput, you don't have much choice ? If so, I think that beginning with 2.5r and going to 3r there are, on the contrary, plenty of choice.
For selecting keys for a box to play certain locales of music, I'd probably think more about which minors are popular, rather than which major keys are popular. The relative minor of your inside row is typically the one you have the most useful coverage of, so, E minor on a D/G vs A minor on a G/C, with the option to turn the dial towards dorian & harmonic.
That's very true, but I fear it also depends on the repertoire you're playing (personaly, I think I rarely ever use harmonic minor for instance).
-
What suits one person's style of playing, may not suit another. The degree of attack by the player has a lot to do with whether a box is punchy, or not. Yes I know you can't get blood out of a stone, but the same box can sound very different when played by a different player. It's a value judgement I think.
Sir John
-
Box availability certainly does colour one's judgement on the '3 row means heavy' debate.
In the UK, the choice of boxes readily available locally is very limited once you want to venture past 2r8b with Castagnari dominating the 'higher end' market, perhaps due to our demand for D/G. So the Handry is the three row people will often try at a workshop.
However if you look across the Channel, then there are a number of smaller innovative makers producing instruments with a range of keyboard options and their weights vary considerably. Most are custom made and it is quite rare to see them in sessions and workshops in England. I guess Loffet is the one I've seen most.
-
I agree with Gena and others, size is relative and very personal and also dependant on what you use the instrument for.
I know of professional musicians one who have back problems from using a Handry and another using a Gaillard. Similarly there are current threads running about using a Lilly as a Pokerwork is too heavy due to back related problems.
Ok you could go to instruments like a Benny if you want a 3 row instrument but, the smaller instruments do not have the 'rounded sound' of the larger ones.
Our repertoire in England rarely ventures beyond G, D and their minors. Play a tune outside of these at a session and instead of otgers joining in, you will find you are playing a solo! Those who play tunes from farther afield such as some of the French repertoire often will gravitate to larger instruments to enable more keys to be played, but if you stick to the English repertoire, we are very much 'key led' so the 2r8b fits the bill.
-
I agree with nearly all that you said (didn't say weight wasn't an issue, just that it is a bad proxy of how an accordion manoeuvers). Also, no need to make me say what I never said: 2r8b are perfectly fine instruments.
Ok you could go to instruments like a Benny if you want a 3 row instrument but, the smaller instruments do not have the 'rounded sound' of the larger ones.
My point, precisely, is that you don't have to go for either the small format instruments or the heavy-weight ones. For instance, the Bernard Loffet accordion is the same size whether you have 2r8b or 3r12b, and weight only 14 onces more. My guess is that, unless you have back related problems (and in which case, as you pointed out, even 2r8b can be a problem), you woudn't really feel the difference.
-
Well, using http://diato.org/loffet_accordions.htm as a reference? The 2r8b listed here is a 3v, not a 2v instrument. All of these are about the size of a pokerwork: 28x16 cm - I think pokerworks come in at 28x15, based on the replacement bellows size (http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Hohner_Parts.html#46), anyway. It's not a huge surprise to me that a 3v 2 row and a 2v 3 row could end up in the same box. Obviously we know that a 2v 2r can also end up in the same size space as well, which is to say, the humble (& cavernously empty) pokerwork.
Since this chain of conversation was started off of by BobM's post here (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,25929.msg309503.html#msg309503), I think it pays to try and smooth out many of the nuances of what I think we've been trying to say: which is, 'weight' isn't really everything and there are actually kind of a lot of factors. That's uh, that's what -Y-'s been saying from the start so idk why I'm writing this post out really.
There's really a long, nuanced gradient for the impact of how closely everything is packed into a given instrument. Stuff being really crammed in doesn't really make the instrument better or worse, but it does tend to make it behave a particular way. That 'cram' factor combined with the features the instrument has, such as how many rows or voices, then tends to imply a given size, which in turn, often implies a particular weight.
Often this means that you can get an instrument with very different features, such as a whole extra voice or row, in perhaps the same weight and size category as some other instrument. However, if with that level of workmanship, skill & reed quality, you can put an extra voice in that same space as a pokerwork, that begs the question: what about if you did not? What would the result be if you made the best possible 2 voice that you could, in that same box? Or, could you make a 2 voice instrument that was a lot smaller?
There are actually a great many instruments that exist that satisfy a variety of people's desires, as people often have different answers to questions like the above.
So, yes, not all 3 row boxes are huge, heavy things. But there are some limits and some people, like myself, are already playing and prefer instruments that are the product of concerted efforts by their creators. Any 'slack' that remains is there on purpose, and in order to add more voices or buttons etc to them, there may have to be changes that result in the weight, size or behaviour being different and may in turn mean we'd no longer really enjoy them as much.
That often leads to, I guess, sort of confused conversations where two people can be talking about the same thing, while at the same time also be talking about different things.
I'm not sure to understand, you mean to say that if you don't like the Benny or the Liliput, you don't have much choice ? If so, I think that beginning with 2.5r and going to 3r there are, on the contrary, plenty of choice.
So, I actually mean to say that if you *do* like the benny and lilliput, but, don't like, eg the buttons, or the thickness of the keyboard, what can you try instead? I can't really think of any alternatives that are close in size to either of these instruments. If you know of some, that would actually help me out, because I kinda would like a 2.5 or 3 row some day.
-
Gina,
A respected 'Melnet Sage' very helpfully pointed me towards this excellent website which catalogues instrument makers and the attributes of their accordions when I was researching options for a new G/C box- https://dia.to/accordeons (https://dia.to/accordeons)
That could be a useful starting point when you are looking at 2.5r or 3r in the future (:)
PS It is in French.
-
Well, using http://diato.org/loffet_accordions.htm as a reference? The 2r8b listed here is a 3v, not a 2v instrument. All of these are about the size of a pokerwork: 28x16 cm - I think pokerworks come in at 28x15, based on the replacement bellows size (http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Hohner_Parts.html#46), anyway. It's not a huge surprise to me that a 3v 2 row and a 2v 3 row could end up in the same box. Obviously we know that a 2v 2r can also end up in the same size space as well, which is to say, the humble (& cavernously empty) pokerwork.
I think the English page may be out of date (I don't think the people carrying on the works of Bernard had not much time). I was comparing this : https://diato.org/WP/le-graet-e-breizh-2-rangs-et-2-%c2%bc-rangs-2-voix-21-2-touches-8-basses/
with this : https://diato.org/WP/le-graet-e-breizh-3-rangs-2-voix-21-9-touches-12-basses/, so 2 voices instruments.
Often this means that you can get an instrument with very different features, such as a whole extra voice or row, in perhaps the same weight and size category as some other instrument. However, if with that level of workmanship, skill & reed quality, you can put an extra voice in that same space as a pokerwork, that begs the question: what about if you did not? What would the result be if you made the best possible 2 voice that you could, in that same box? Or, could you make a 2 voice instrument that was a lot smaller?
Two things to consider here, I think : the making process, for which you have an interest in not multiplying the case sizes; and the choices the maker made : the models are not random things, they're made with an intent. Also, I think (perhaps with exceptions) that makers already do want to make the best possible accordions, and there's no absolute rule saying that smaller is better.
There are actually a great many instruments that exist that satisfy a variety of people's desires, as people often have different answers to questions like the above.
So, yes, not all 3 row boxes are huge, heavy things. But there are some limits and some people, like myself, are already playing and prefer instruments that are the product of concerted efforts by their creators. Any 'slack' that remains is there on purpose, and in order to add more voices or buttons etc to them, there may have to be changes that result in the weight, size or behaviour being different and may in turn mean we'd no longer really enjoy them as much.
You're perfectly right. I'm not for saying that any type of accordion is by essence a better one. What's best for someone may not be the best for someone else. So I think we (a general 'we') would gain in stopping with dealing absolute answers on this subject, and perhaps in developing somewhat of a reflex of ditching pre-conceived (and often false) ideas about boxes.
So, I actually mean to say that if you *do* like the benny and lilliput, but, don't like, eg the buttons, or the thickness of the keyboard, what can you try instead? I can't really think of any alternatives that are close in size to either of these instruments. If you know of some, that would actually help me out, because I kinda would like a 2.5 or 3 row some day.
A respected 'Melnet Sage' very helpfully pointed me towards this excellent website which catalogues instrument makers and the attributes of their accordions when I was researching options for a new G/C box- https://dia.to/accordeons (https://dia.to/accordeons)
That could be a useful starting point when you are looking at 2.5r or 3r in the future (:)
Hehe, that's my website (:). I'm currently working on having it translated to English, but it's slow work...
Gena, there are several makers that could do small sized 2.5 or 3r accordions, but maybe the main issue would be being able to try them out, because that's what will help you. As you pointed out earlier in this thread, opportunities to try other models than Castagnari or Hohner may be thin on the ground. Or it would require planning a trip to Ars at Le Son Continu (formerly Saint-Chartier) where you could try a good variety of accordions, and meet people who makes them. But that's neither easy nor cheap.
Lately I've been a huge fan of the Pariselle models, I think you may have less difficulties trying one out in the UK, as several people did the regular build-your-accordion workshop with him. He makes 10/9/6 models with 14 basses that are very versatile and quite easy to play with. The idea is that you sacrifice the 1st two accidentals buttons on row 1 and 2, to have more accidentals/reversals on the 3rd row. They have only 25 buttons, but hence are very close to the feel of a regular 21 buttons box.
Edit: added the Pariselle layout (transposed in D/G) to have an idea of how it looks, with either 3rd button start or 4th button start. Don't know if Emmanuel transposes directly from the G/C or if the D/G has other notes arrangements, but every custom layout is possible anyway.
-
Picking up Y's comment about the Pariselle instruments - I've found that the 2.6 3v G/C I bought from him last year a delight to play - and lighter to play (in feel at least) than my Dony. I can't compare weights as the Pariselle is currently being expertly tuned.
I think part of the reason is the thirdless bass end - which is smaller than the Dony in spite of having 14 rather than 12. And the 10/9/6 layout really works for me.
J
-
I think the English page may be out of date (I don't think the people carrying on the works of Bernard had not much time). I was comparing this : https://diato.org/WP/le-graet-e-breizh-2-rangs-et-2-%c2%bc-rangs-2-voix-21-2-touches-8-basses/
with this : https://diato.org/WP/le-graet-e-breizh-3-rangs-2-voix-21-9-touches-12-basses/, so 2 voices instruments.
Thanks, actually that 3r instrument @ 26,5x15x31cm is relevant to my interest. (and neither it, or it's similarly sized 2v 2r accomplice, appear to feature at all where I'd like to, previous). My objective seems to be compact, but, with full size buttons. Well actually because everything is either expensive, custom made, or both, I don't really have to worry about what my objective is.
-
"compact, but, with full size buttons."
I would have thought that any of our fettler wizards could manage to give you "full size" buttons on a small instrument. e.g. My Liliputs have buttons with 13.5 mm centres and would therefore take up to about 12.5 mm mushroom shaped buttons. I'm certain I've seen boxes with similarly closely spaced large buttons, possibly a Dino Baffetti?
Of course, it depends upon what size is your "full size"?
-
Having someone rebuild the keyboard of an otherwise healthy instrument doesn't sound like a great option, especially if you are buying the instrument at some kind of premium. Pursuing a bespoke instrument is also exhausting and something I'm in no rush to repeat.
I posted in the thread to offer some examples of instruments that are finely made, have few to no competitors, and indicate that even if you can have a 3 row that is the size and weight of popular 2 row boxes, that doesn't mean they have the feeling of the 2 row instruments a (career or otherwise) melodeon player likes to play.
If ever you want a confounding factor to a conversation, you need look no further than to have people talk about a common problem that holds true with condition A, but not with condition B.
-
I remember the previous 3 rows GC I had.
A small one very compact and not heavy at all from Castagnari.
I thought it was the Lily but it was in fact the Benny. I never call them by name 😁
Only two flute voices - to justify the small weight - but I remember the buttons were smallers after my 2 rows from Saltarelle and it bothered me a little (whereas I've got small and thin hands !) so as the limited sound, I really believe the buttons size is an issue to consider.
My two cents : if you like playing on a three rows, your gaming being less pull/push, the weight is not really a problem and I promess you still can give great rythm if it's on your dna.
Even if you want to play stand live and have back problem, which is my case, you can do it. And I play on a Handry 18 and I'm not strong at all !
That said, there are planty of things you can do to lighten the box without sacrifice especially on the left hand. And if you chose wisely your voices, only two on the right hand are enough. They are many makers in France capable of doing this.
To finish, if you like the very traditional french repertoire. If it's what you want to play, a 2r8b is good enough.
If you also like to write melodies, are interesting in eastern sound (balkan...), you need 3 rows, or at least 2 and 1/2.