Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: dino.pafftti on September 06, 2020, 07:47:09 AM

Title: 1-row F-major
Post by: dino.pafftti on September 06, 2020, 07:47:09 AM
Hi .. I would like to manufacture 1-row melodians, in F major ,,
I would like to know Keyboard Layouts ,, treble and bass  ??
can you help me ?
Title: Re: 1-row F-major
Post by: Steve_freereeder on September 06, 2020, 09:00:28 AM
There are one-row keyboard layouts here:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/page,keyboard_1_row.html

There isn't one for the key of F but you could take the layout for the key of G (http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/keyboards/1%20Row%204%20Stop%20-%20G.jpg)* and transpose the notes down by one whole tone.

For the M and M+ reeds this would become:

[A2/C3] [C3/E3] [F3/G3] [A3/Bb3] [C4/D4] [F4/E4] [A4/G4] [C5/Bb4] [F5/D5] [A5/E5]

Chords and basses:
[F maj / C maj]  [F/C]

Note that the voicing of the one-row in G is already low pitched; the third button start is G3, so in the key of F that would be F3.
If you are building a one-row four stop you will have a low octave (L) set of reeds too whoch would be an octave lower than shown, and a high octave (H) set of reeds which would be an octave higher than shown.

The low pitch of the G and F one-rows mean that you need to factor in the longer reed chambers to accommodate the long reed plates for the lowest notes, especially the lowest A1 and C2 reeds in the low octave voice.

A few years ago I made a one-row four-stop in G on Emmanuel Pariselle's melodeon-building course. The key of G is very low and growly with large reeds and perhaps just about on the practical limit of conventional one-row construction. A one-row four-stop in F might just be OK but the low reeds will be very long and perhaps too slow in their response to be acceptable.

I would recommend contacting your reed makers first to obtain the dimensions of the reed plates, then design your reed blocks accordingly.

Good luck!


* NB - the octave numbers as shown for the G layout are wrong. For the M and M+ voices they should be an octave lower than shown.
Title: Re: 1-row F-major
Post by: Jeremy Burnett on September 06, 2020, 10:19:28 AM
Would it be possible to make one the same as the F row in a C/F?
Title: Re: 1-row F-major
Post by: Anahata on September 06, 2020, 11:11:17 AM
Would it be possible to make one the same as the F row in a C/F?
I think that amounts to making it an octave higher. Assuming it's 4-stop one row, with a low octave voice, that might work. The lowest note would be the A below middle C. It would be quite a high pitched instrument at the top end.
Title: Re: 1-row F-major
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on September 06, 2020, 11:15:02 AM
Would it be possible to make one the same as the F row in a C/F?

Do mean a 1040 type pitched like the F row on a CF (i.e., MM)?
Depends on what the OP is planning, I suppose. Might work rather well. Especially as a 4th button start with a low D added.
Title: Re: 1-row F-major
Post by: Jeremy Burnett on September 06, 2020, 11:34:11 AM
Yes I had thought it would be the 1040 model with 4 bass.
Title: Re: 1-row F-major
Post by: Steve_freereeder on September 06, 2020, 12:39:50 PM
Would it be possible to make one the same as the F row in a C/F?

Do mean a 1040 type pitched like the F row on a CF (i.e., MM)?
Depends on what the OP is planning, I suppose. Might work rather well. Especially as a 4th button start with a low D added.

Yes - a 2-voice MM Hohner 1040 type instrument in F would probably work quite well, but the 4th button start would limit the range rather. The key note (3rd or 4th button start) would be F3 not F4, i.e. an octave lower than the F row on a standard C/F box. In other words the layout for the MM+ rows would be as I gave in my original reply:
[A2/C3] [C3/E3] [F3/G3] [A3/Bb3] [C4/D4] [F4/E4] [A4/G4] [C5/Bb4] [F5/D5] [A5/E5]

As Anahata has pointed out, a one-row at the same pitch as as the normal F-row on a C/F box would probably be too squeaky and limiting.
Title: Re: 1-row F-major
Post by: chris hall on September 06, 2020, 02:03:00 PM
i recently came across a Cajun musician (wilson savoy) playing a high F Cajun one row box on facebook. Since my D box is already pretty high i expected it to sound super high and thin. On the contrary it did not. Its not a key heard very often though. In fact I dont think i've heard another in that register. I also coincidentally (also on facebook) came across a Zydeco player playing a low F box. Since a G is already pretty low i expected it to sound super low but it didn't. It would however take some muscle to play and the guy playing it looked over 6 foot tall and not short of upper body strength. The sound suited the genre. Low and plenty of grunt. The high F would have been totally wrong for his style. Similarly Wilson would probably have found the low F to not really suit his playing. So in short F is an extreme key. Extremely low or extremely high. I feel a big difference when i play my one row in C and put it down to pick up a D, and an equally big difference when i pick up my Bb. I can only imagine how an F would feel as i never tried one. These things need to be taken account of though. Its clearly possible to put F reeds in a one row. The choice of low F or high F depends on what you want to do with and how much upper body strength you have to spare. On the same path of thinking i have wondered whether a high F four stop would work well as LMMM instead of the more usual LMMH but thats a discussion for another thread on another day i think. The 1040 one row is a different beast. i just finished a total restore on one in G. With new valves and wax and reed setting its pretty responsive. I reckon that would go to F without too much trouble and still be not too difficult to play since it has 2 registers instead of 4.
Title: Re: 1-row F-major
Post by: Jeremy Burnett on September 06, 2020, 02:49:09 PM
I'm probably getting out of my depth here, but I'm not sure why the F as in a C/F box should be considered too high. Many play tunes in G on a D/G box that is higher and is indeed squeaky. Surely the F as in a C/F box is lower and perhaps more mellow in tone.
Title: Re: 1-row F-major
Post by: Steve_freereeder on September 06, 2020, 04:41:32 PM
I'm probably getting out of my depth here, but I'm not sure why the F as in a C/F box should be considered too high. Many play tunes in G on a D/G box that is higher and is indeed squeaky. Surely the F as in a C/F box is lower and perhaps more mellow in tone.

It all depends what sort of sound you want from your instrument. If you are simply going to have a two voice MM box at the same pitch as a C/F box, you may as well just stick to the C/F box!

For me anyway, the joy of a one-row box is to do with the richness of the sound, hence my own preference for the main scale starting on F3 (either 3rd or 4th button start).

A one-row four-stop LMMH box in F based on the scale starting on MM = F3 would be a glorious low sound indeed. With a 3rd button start you would then still have sufficient range in the upper part of the keyboard to base a lot of your playing in the upper octave*, which would also give you room for a full scale down.

*as is generally needed for one-row four-stop boxes to avoid the 'missing notes' where you would normally go to the outer row on a two-row box.
Title: Re: 1-row F-major
Post by: rees on September 06, 2020, 05:21:01 PM
I have made one-row, four-stop boxes in high F and high G. Admittedly they don't have the low growl but they do sound perfectly fine.
Title: Re: 1-row F-major
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on September 06, 2020, 05:30:04 PM
I'm probably getting out of my depth here, but I'm not sure why the F as in a C/F box should be considered too high. Many play tunes in G on a D/G box that is higher and is indeed squeaky. Surely the F as in a C/F box is lower and perhaps more mellow in tone.

I'll second this what Jeremy says and Rees seems to get.  it's lower than the G row on a DG....which few English players complain about. I would never be likely to use the squeaky end button. A low F scale 4th button start which included a low F, Bb and D and got rid of the shrillest notes, might work rather well for a CF two row player. I think the pitch would be pretty acceptable to most. Not too growly or too squeaky.
Title: Re: 1-row F-major
Post by: dino.pafftti on September 06, 2020, 06:18:24 PM

sorry for the bad english language
I have purchased reeds many years ago, (Tipo A Mano)
I would like to make sure that I can make 1-row of them. 3 voices .. I am very ignorant ,,,
Keyboard Layouts my reeds :

reeds blocks number 1 :
[ C3/ E3 ] [ F3/G3 ] [ A3/Bb3 ] [C4/D4] [F4/E4 ] [A4/G4 ] [C5/Bb4 ] [F5/D5 ] [A5/E5 ] [C6/G5]


reeds blocks number  2 : 2x
 [ C4/ E4 ] [F4 /G4 ] [A4/ Bb4 ] [C5/D5] [F5/E5 ] [A5/G5 ] [ C6/Bb5 ] [F6/D6 ] [A6/E6 ] [C7/G6]

Is this right ?? I don't understand if high or low F ??    I try to study
Title: Re: 1-row F-major
Post by: Steve_freereeder on September 06, 2020, 06:37:36 PM
I have made one-row, four-stop boxes in high F and high G. Admittedly they don't have the low growl but they do sound perfectly fine.
Those H reeds at the top end of the range must be really tiny. A b***er to tune, I guess. You'd only have to touch them with a feather to alter the pitch  :o
Title: Re: 1-row F-major
Post by: Steve_freereeder on September 06, 2020, 06:39:47 PM

sorry for the bad english language
I have purchased reeds many years ago, (Tipo A Mano)
I would like to make sure that I can make 1-row of them. 3 voices .. I am very ignorant ,,,
Keyboard Layouts my reeds :

reeds blocks number 1 :
[ C3/ E3 ] [ F3/G3 ] [ A3/Bb3 ] [C4/D4] [F4/E4 ] [A4/G4 ] [C5/Bb4 ] [F5/D5 ] [A5/E5 ] [C6/G5]

reeds blocks number  2 : 2x
 [ C4/ E4 ] [F4 /G4 ] [A4/ Bb4 ] [C5/D5] [F5/E5 ] [A5/G5 ] [ C6/Bb5 ] [F6/D6 ] [A6/E6 ] [C7/G6]

Is this right ?? I don't understand if high or low F ??    I try to study

That would be three-voice LMM 'high' F, with a 2nd button start. Should be OK!

PS - your English is perfectly intelligible. Don't worry!  (:)
Title: Re: 1-row F-major
Post by: dino.pafftti on September 06, 2020, 06:59:17 PM

sorry for the bad english language
I have purchased reeds many years ago, (Tipo A Mano)
I would like to make sure that I can make 1-row of them. 3 voices .. I am very ignorant ,,,
Keyboard Layouts my reeds :

reeds blocks number 1 :
[ C3/ E3 ] [ F3/G3 ] [ A3/Bb3 ] [C4/D4] [F4/E4 ] [A4/G4 ] [C5/Bb4 ] [F5/D5 ] [A5/E5 ] [C6/G5]

reeds blocks number  2 : 2x
 [ C4/ E4 ] [F4 /G4 ] [A4/ Bb4 ] [C5/D5] [F5/E5 ] [A5/G5 ] [ C6/Bb5 ] [F6/D6 ] [A6/E6 ] [C7/G6]

Is this right ?? I don't understand if high or low F ??    I try to study

That would be three-voice LMM 'high' F, with a 2nd button start. Should be OK!

PS - your English is perfectly intelligible. Don't worry!  (:)

Thank you very much! (:)
Title: Re: 1-row F-major
Post by: rees on September 06, 2020, 10:42:42 PM
I used DIX reeds throughout for the high F and G boxes. The highest reeds were indeed very tiny but easy to work on and very loud, much more responsive than TAM, etc.
Title: Re: 1-row F-major
Post by: mselic on September 07, 2020, 02:33:34 AM
i recently came across a Cajun musician (wilson savoy) playing a high F Cajun one row box on facebook. Since my D box is already pretty high i expected it to sound super high and thin. On the contrary it did not. Its not a key heard very often though. In fact I dont think i've heard another in that register. I also coincidentally (also on facebook) came across a Zydeco player playing a low F box. Since a G is already pretty low i expected it to sound super low but it didn't. It would however take some muscle to play and the guy playing it looked over 6 foot tall and not short of upper body strength. The sound suited the genre. Low and plenty of grunt. The high F would have been totally wrong for his style. Similarly Wilson would probably have found the low F to not really suit his playing. So in short F is an extreme key. Extremely low or extremely high. I feel a big difference when i play my one row in C and put it down to pick up a D, and an equally big difference when i pick up my Bb. I can only imagine how an F would feel as i never tried one. These things need to be taken account of though. Its clearly possible to put F reeds in a one row. The choice of low F or high F depends on what you want to do with and how much upper body strength you have to spare. On the same path of thinking i have wondered whether a high F four stop would work well as LMMM instead of the more usual LMMH but thats a discussion for another thread on another day i think. The 1040 one row is a different beast. i just finished a total restore on one in G. With new valves and wax and reed setting its pretty responsive. I reckon that would go to F without too much trouble and still be not too difficult to play since it has 2 registers instead of 4.

Could you link us to some examples of the low and high F boxes? I’d love to hear them!!!!
Title: Re: 1-row F-major
Post by: dino.pafftti on September 07, 2020, 05:26:06 AM
I would also like to hear ..
Title: Re: 1-row F-major
Post by: Steve C. on September 07, 2020, 01:07:21 PM
I had my C/F Erica retuned to "f-scale" (the 4th button start with low F to high F) and it is nice. 
Play it like a D/G without the squeak.
Not much use in average session, but nice for at home.
Title: Re: 1-row F-major
Post by: rees on September 07, 2020, 11:06:50 PM
I would also like to hear ..

I don't have a recording of the high F instrument but here is a YouTube link to the high G box (a tone higher than F!)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mPCD0l1X1Oc (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mPCD0l1X1Oc)
Title: Re: 1-row F-major
Post by: pgroff on September 08, 2020, 12:45:42 PM
I would also like to hear ..

I don't have a recording of the high F instrument but here is a YouTube link to the high G box (a tone higher than F!)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mPCD0l1X1Oc (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mPCD0l1X1Oc)

Great sound Rees, I like that style of playing the tune (Boys of Blue Hill) in the normal key of D on a box with a  "high G row." As you know that fingering would  give the key of "low A" on a D box and is not an uncommon way for melodeon players to play some tunes.

I'm interested in exactly that approach, especially for some "concertina settings" of Irish traditional tunes, to set them "in the low range  on boxes that are tuned in high keys."

My preference though would be to add more lower notes of the G scale and drop some of the higher ones. In the terminology of this forum, that would be switching from a "3rd button start" for the full diatonic scale to a "4th button start" or even a "5th button start."   I realize that might trip up some melodeon players who haven't learned the fingering for the diatonic scale extended further downward.

Some Paolo Soprani DG boxes with 23 button keyboard, made at least from the 1960s, have no accidental notes and no duplicated notes within a row, so their 11-key G row has a "4th button start:" *

G/C  B/E  D/F#  G/A  B/C  D/E  G/F#  B/A  D/C  G/E  B/F#

Irish players of the BC and C#D systems are familiar with the way that such a diatonic scale works in that lower range ( the low buttons giving G/C B/E here; or C/F E/A on the C row of a BC box etc) and the fingerings aren't so hard to learn.

I quite like the idea of a "5th button start" for a high G row, to pick up the low A note used in some fiddle tunes, and giving the option to grab a doubled octave of the low D for an accent:

D/A  G/C  B/E   D/F#  G/A  B/C D/E  G/F#  B/A  D/C   etc  (Note that even with only 10 buttons, this placement of the "high G" scale gets all the way up to the high C and D notes that are some of the highest notes played in traditional Irish tunes. I'm not sure I would often use the higher buttons for G/E,  B/F#, etc).

The latter is what I have in mind for the G row of an F#/G project.

Back on topic for a minute, in the key of "high F" that last layout would be:

C/G  F/Bb  A/D  C/E  F/G  A/Bb  C/D  F/E  AG  C/Bb  ( for more than 10 buttons, it would continue:  F/D   A/E etc)

Many players on this forum would have to learn, or re-learn, the notes for the lowest 3 buttons of that layout, but as the example of the DG Paolos shows, it's really not that "far out"

PG


* Edited to add a pic of 2 of those 1960s Paolo D/G boxes with 23 melody keys.


Title: Re: 1-row F-major
Post by: Rob2Hook on September 08, 2020, 01:00:51 PM
I'm quite surprised that no-one seems to have considered extending to maybe 11 or even 12 buttons within the design concept of a 4 stop box.  Surely this would be of particular benefit in just such a high pitched instrument, allowing the scale to be extended downward?

Sacrilege!  Burn the heretic!

Rob.
Title: Re: 1-row F-major
Post by: pgroff on September 08, 2020, 01:21:50 PM
I'm quite surprised that no-one seems to have considered extending to maybe 11 or even 12 buttons within the design concept of a 4 stop box.  Surely this would be of particular benefit in just such a high pitched instrument, allowing the scale to be extended downward?

Sacrilege!  Burn the heretic!

Rob.

One-row boxes with 11 or more buttons  have been made (both with the extra buttons in the same row, and with extra buttons in a second partial row*).

I agree it's a great idea  but these  boxes  are always a compromise between features and size.  And conservatism is common in some traditions that have continued playing the 1-row box.

PG

* yes, I know, if there is a second partial row they aren't literally 1-row boxes but . . .
Title: Re: 1-row F-major
Post by: rees on September 08, 2020, 08:18:16 PM
I would also like to hear ..

I don't have a recording of the high F instrument but here is a YouTube link to the high G box (a tone higher than F!)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mPCD0l1X1Oc (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mPCD0l1X1Oc)

Great sound Rees, I like that style of playing the tune (Boys of Blue Hill) in the normal key of D on a box with a  "high G row." As you know that fingering would  give the key of "low A" on a D box and is not an uncommon way for melodeon players to play some tunes.


Thanks Paul. I was lucky enough to spend a week with Johnny Connolly before he passed. He showed me how to play Boys of Bluehill in A on D box.
It's a week that I will always treasure. Johnny Connolly R.I.P.
Title: Re: 1-row F-major
Post by: pgroff on September 08, 2020, 09:29:24 PM
Great stuff Rees,

A great memory and a great tradition for you to carry forward. R.I. P. Johnny Connolly.

 The Connachtman's Rambles is another classic "D" tune that the old melodeon players often played "in low A on a D melodeon," which again means that you'd need a high G melodeon to play that particular setting but also to get the tune to come out in its "normal" key of D.

Bobby Gardiner plays "The Wind that Shakes the Barley" also in that position, "low A on a D melodeon, or low Bb on an Eb row, or in D on a high G row"

I have some actual 10 key boxes in high G here or near enough, but maybe we should just start a new thread for that topic.

Back to the topic, a high F row with a 4th or 5th button start would be just lovely too for all these tunes, the paradox being that this key higher than D would still give the lower "key of C" for these tunes, if they were played in that low position on the row.

PG

SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal