Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Little Eggy on September 07, 2020, 06:57:21 PM

Title: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Little Eggy on September 07, 2020, 06:57:21 PM
Over on the thread about G/C boxes I enjoyed this comment

Some people would say Bb/Eb sound even better... ;-)

A certain poignancy to it. Bb and C are close enough songwise but I much prefer Bb if it’s an emotional “As I went out …” sort of lyric, while C is much better for the “Nellie the Elephant” tunes..

🤔 … and that covers most of the folk repertoire.

I have to confess I have never 'got' the notion that different major keys convey different emotions.  I don't think I even recognise different major keys unless I have some clues or context.

I came across this recently and it sets out an amazing differentiation between the different keys
http://www.gradfree.com/kevin/some_theory_on_musical_keys.htm

Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 07, 2020, 08:01:20 PM
It’s definitely a “feel” thing, all  the more so if the instrument is tuned to the specific diatonic scale rather than equal temperament. BBC Radio 4 explored 13 of the 24 “major”/“minor” keys about a decade back.

But there’s a stronger emotional effect in play. A folk major usually has the “white piano keys” scale we all know well, but jazzers and a tiny few of the more frenetic French tunes tend to raise note 4 by a semitone. Really lifts it! Miles Davis remarked that pianos should have a “middle F” rather then “middle C”.

Minors even more so. Minor 3rd is simple enough to understand, but in say Am (white notes again) you can sharpen the F to get a more positive feel “dorian” or flatten the B to Bb. The strange feel of Vaughan Williams symphony on theme by Thomas Tallis a wonderful example. Minorness isn’a a simple concept

Forgot the link https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b00tw55v/topics/Musical_keys Cheers Quentin 👍

Or flatten the  B, sharpen the C 😳 Gypsy, or Middle East feel. Emotion again 🤔 Is Flamenco major, or minor?

But within this wider key universe I still feel the tonic changes things. Brubeck’s “take 5” is in an exotic Eb minor, and frankly feels perfect there. I was trying various keys this morning 😕 but … most melodeon accessibles didn’t feel quite in groove.  Trust your gut 😉

Forgot the link https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b00tw55v/topics/Musical_keys Cheers Quentin 👍
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 07, 2020, 08:04:01 PM
There have been many similar articles regarding key characters, and I remember a Radio 4 series of  'short' programmes doing the same.
I have a BbEb melodeon as the only 'non- DG' box and  some tunes sound considerably nicer on it.

Further to this, Dave Sheppard of Blowzabella fame has penned many lovely tunes and is quite insistent they should be played in the keys he compised them in (Gm often ) and not shoe horn them onto  a DG box.
I think keys have a subtle and noticeable effect on the tune being played.
My thruppence!
Q
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Winston Smith on September 07, 2020, 08:06:19 PM
That's a bit of a coincidence, Little E. That very subject was part of the conversation at the little (mainly) melodeon get together in Darlington this afternoon.
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 07, 2020, 08:07:41 PM
Are you a Darlingtonian? Spent my formative years on Vane Terrace! Though you were in Felling?
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Winston Smith on September 07, 2020, 10:25:40 PM
"Are you a Darlingtonian?"

No no, I'm a Nooker, through and through! The Felling is just our near neighbour down the bank.
Current melodeoning circumstances mean that I have to travel to get to play with like-minded folk. It was most enjoyable.
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Julian S on September 08, 2020, 06:59:31 AM
I do wonder whether different people may get different impressions from various keys - maybe because of previous associations with particular compositions. And maybe a similar condition to colour blindness exists.
Something I enjoy doing is throwing in chord changes, through the tune repetitions - some tunes just lend themselves to different chordal approaches and why stick to fixed chords ? Certainly adds interest - not to say unpredictability sometimes !

J
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 08, 2020, 08:02:34 AM
I suspect as age affects hearing response, that comes into play when listening to music and our perception of the tune in  a given key.
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Chris Rayner on September 08, 2020, 09:38:19 AM
If tuned to modern, equal temperament there should be no difference between the sound of a tune played in one key or another apart from the pitch.  For singers, and instruments with a limited compass one key may be more favourable than another as it sits more comfortably in the range of the voice or instrument.  Until the advent of equal temperament instruments were often tuned to favour their use in one key rather than another.  Bach%u2019s Das Wohltemperierte Klavier was written partly to illustrate the possibilities of tuning to %u201Cwell temperament%u201D.  Not a completely equal temperament, but enabling a keyboard to play in all keys without serious dissonance.  Nowadays most orchestral instruments are tuned to a modern equal temperament.

How your melodeon is tuned, of course depends on the proclivities and skill of the last person to tune it, and the extent to which that tuning has been altered by events since it was tuned.  Given that many free reed instruments are tuned to give a slight dissonance between two or more sets of reeds, the precise note sounded by a key will be almost pure (dry) to various degrees of beating between intentionally out of tune reeds from a bit wet, to sets your teeth on edge Scottish musette.  How the Scots can tell when their accordions need tuning I don%u2019t know.
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: -Y- on September 08, 2020, 10:07:58 AM
I'm rather under the impression that there is no real qualitative difference between pitches, but that it's only a matter of cultural habits. If you only hear D/G pitched boxes, then anything out of these keys will sound exotic and will give the impression that they're "better" (or at least will appeal to you).
The romantic perception of keys (as in the link posted by Little Eggy) as transmitting different moods is for me nothing but a social construct. It's a big pitfall and or bad commonplace of musical analysis I think, projecting meanings into music, where we often confuse denotation with connotation.
Of course you don't have the same perception of low sounds compared to high sounds, but beyond that...
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 08, 2020, 10:18:12 AM
There has been many programmes on UK radio and possibly TV that have gone to great lengths exploring classical music and the effect that keys have on moods and the overall effect of the given piece of music.
Real in depth exploration of it in fact.....
It might not be as obvious in traditional music, but a firm idea in classical music circles.
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: -Y- on September 08, 2020, 10:35:20 AM
Which is nothing but a construct.
Classical music analysts (even recognised experts) are able to tell you that the Pastoral Symphony is evocative of... well... pastures... Which it is only because we took the habit of saying it is.
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on September 08, 2020, 10:58:56 AM
The idea goes back at least as far as the ancient Greeks.

I seem to remember finding something about Bach's Well Tempered Clavier, a few months ago, that seemed to have a bearing on this. To do with the way intervals worked out in pre-equal temperament tunings. The premise was that the intervals varied with the key, so the feelings invoked varied. There was one which was, effectively, unplayable...or, rather, unlistenable. The thinking differed from the conventional explanations of what Bach was doing with his pieces and how he tuned his instrument (he did his own tuning, I believe). Can't remember the details at the moment.  and can't find the link to the relevant pages. Does this ring a bell with anyone?
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Chris Rayner on September 08, 2020, 02:47:55 PM
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Musical_temperament (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Musical_temperament). This any help?
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Steve_freereeder on September 08, 2020, 03:01:22 PM
The idea goes back at least as far as the ancient Greeks.

I seem to remember finding something about Bach's Well Tempered Clavier, a few months ago, that seemed to have a bearing on this. To do with the way intervals worked out in pre-equal temperament tunings. The premise was that the intervals varied with the key, so the feelings invoked varied. There was one which was, effectively, unplayable...or, rather, unlistenable. The thinking differed from the conventional explanations of what Bach was doing with his pieces and how he tuned his instrument (he did his own tuning, I believe). Can't remember the details at the moment.  and can't find the link to the relevant pages. Does this ring a bell with anyone?

Perhaps it was Bradley Lehman's website? Worth an explore and a listen to, including the process of tuning the harpsichord.
http://www-personal.umich.edu/~bpl/larips/index.html

http://www-personal.umich.edu/~bpl/larips/videos.html
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on September 08, 2020, 03:03:47 PM
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Musical_temperament (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Musical_temperament). This any help?

Thanks Chris. Definitely closely related. I think the articles I have in mind of (not Wiki ones), went a bit further than this. It may be a false memory, though.

The point I was trying to make is supported by thi article, which does suggest that, from early times, instruments were tempered according to compromises that would have resulted in differently tempered intervals, when you played differently pitched keys (without retuning the instrument), which may have given a different emotional feel to the different keys.
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Theo on September 08, 2020, 03:30:55 PM
There is another aspect to this relating to how different instruments are constructed which might have a bearing.  Take fiddles first example.  If played in certain keys there is resonance between the bowed string and the ope strings.  This reinforces the notes of the open strings, ADGE and that clearly has different effects in different keys. Whether that amounts to an emotional difference I don’t know.

I did listen to a radio 4 piece a few years ago on the subject of linking keys to emotions and I thought it was a case of the kings new clothes.  All the participation were so sold on the idea the each key had a defined emotional character that nobody was able to express a contrary view.  The clincher fir me was a pianist who had convinced himself that there was a difference in feeling when a piece in D# major was then played in Eb major.  He played them in the two “different” keys to demonstrate but I couldn’t detect the slightest difference. 
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 08, 2020, 03:58:38 PM
Something I enjoy doing is throwing in chord changes, through the tune repetitions - some tunes just lend themselves to different chordal approaches and why stick to fixed chords ? Certainly adds interest - not to say unpredictability sometimes !

Totally! Works with most tunes to some extent with the most trivial example a chord extend eg G triad to G7 or Gmaj7, slightly harder substituting a relative minor for major. The two are very related in chord theory. I once astonished Morton Bay Morris by playing Adderbury Shooting on the pull against Em instead of G push. Exactly the same notes, but sounding  totally different!

A fab exemplar is last month’s TotM Jos.Dopwals. It just “eats” chord change. That cool 69 chord intro on guitar sort of suggests that. Main theme works against G, Gmaj7, G/Bbass=Bm6. second line against C, Am7, Cmaj7, even Em and Bm7, all cross chords on an 8 base; Except the push B Bass which needs 12 bass or a low B Rt end. And a load of sus, even quartal chords work too! It’s been on my too hard list for ages, but it’s a tune you can truly “surf” 😎

Back to topic, JDwals sounds much better in F, but on even 3 rows all those lovely chords either …  disappear or are awkward. Another example of practicalities trumping simple tonic effect. Melodeon is ever thus?
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on September 08, 2020, 06:09:08 PM
The idea goes back at least as far as the ancient Greeks.

I seem to remember finding something about Bach's Well Tempered Clavier, a few months ago, that seemed to have a bearing on this. To do with the way intervals worked out in pre-equal temperament tunings. The premise was that the intervals varied with the key, so the feelings invoked varied. There was one which was, effectively, unplayable...or, rather, unlistenable. The thinking differed from the conventional explanations of what Bach was doing with his pieces and how he tuned his instrument (he did his own tuning, I believe). Can't remember the details at the moment.  and can't find the link to the relevant pages. Does this ring a bell with anyone?

Perhaps it was Bradley Lehman's website? Worth an explore and a listen to, including the process of tuning the harpsichord.
http://www-personal.umich.edu/~bpl/larips/index.html

http://www-personal.umich.edu/~bpl/larips/videos.html

Thank you Steve. Not sure if it's the same  page but it makes the same point, very clearly. If I can quote:

"This process of minimal but necessary compromises makes the keyboard ready to play music in all 24 major and minor scales. Every scale has a subtly different expressive character, as the steps are not all exactly the same size. The harmonies have various tensions and spice, when the notes of the scales are built together into chords."

This idea wasn't original to Bach. The search had been going on since antiquity, though he seems to have had his own solutions.

I can't help feeling this "expressive character" may well have been a contributor, possibly the origin of, the idea that keys had their own character.

This distinction is completely lost with equal temperament tuning. Testing the theory practically is well beyond me, though.
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: playandteach on September 08, 2020, 08:09:30 PM
Nowadays most orchestral instruments are tuned to a modern equal temperament.
This isn't quite the case, if you don't mind me adding to the picture. Of course orchestral strings are the main group, and they are not tuned at all - it's the fingers that do the damage.
In the case of clarinets - well they are just out of tune in a managed way - generally wide tuning flat at the bottom and sharp at the top. This is a compromise and therefore favours certain keys. Flute makers are much more varied in their approach to the basic scale of their own instruments - the Cooper scale being quite popular. But of course these tuning variations are nothing (well largely nothing) to do with key choice of the music, which is of course, Chris' point.
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Anahata on September 08, 2020, 08:30:52 PM
If played in certain keys there is resonance between the bowed string and the ope strings.  This reinforces the notes of the open strings, ADGE and that clearly has different effects in different keys. Whether that amounts to an emotional difference I don’t know.
Handel certainly liked to use D major for a bright and triumphant sound. The extra brightness and ringing from all those open strings would have made an audible difference, and players will choose between open strings or the equivalent stopped notes depending on the character of the music.

I did listen to a radio 4 piece a few years ago on the subject of linking keys to emotions and I thought it was a case of the kings new clothes.
Strongly related to this is the association of colours with specific keys. For people with synaesthesia this definitely happens. Many people have at least some key-colour associations, though they aren't necessarily the same from one person to another.

Quote
a pianist who had convinced himself that there was a difference in feeling when a piece in D# major was then played in Eb major.
I agree that's pushing it a bit too far, especially on a piano. But composers (especially someone like Alkan) might make a definite choice of key when writing such a piece.
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Blake on September 09, 2020, 12:31:38 PM
I understand the business of equal temperament and how that washed out a lot of the flavor of the keys.

I wonder, however, even with these mean-tone (and similar more equally distributed) tunings, if people with perfect absolute pitch can discern a different flavoring of keys, than the rest of us mortals who have acceptable relative pitch only.

Do any among you have perfect pitch? What's your feel?
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on September 09, 2020, 12:40:39 PM
I understand the business of equal temperament and how that washed out a lot of the flavor of the keys.

I wonder, however, even with these mean-tone tunings, if people with perfect absolute pitch can discern a different flavoring of keys, than the rest of us mortals who have acceptable relative pitch only.

Do any among you have perfect pitch? What's your feel?

I think the differences are very detectable as differences in the way notes blend and harmonise even to those of us without perfect pitch, though we may not be able to say exactly what the differences are. It's quite a dramatic effect.

I am still looking through (and listening through) Steve's article and videos, below. Worth examining closely, for their own sakes.
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: -Y- on September 09, 2020, 01:05:15 PM
If played in certain keys there is resonance between the bowed string and the ope strings.  This reinforces the notes of the open strings, ADGE and that clearly has different effects in different keys. Whether that amounts to an emotional difference I don’t know.

I feel it's more related to how the instrument sounds than to the alleged instrisic emotion associated with a given key.

I understand the business of equal temperament and how that washed out a lot of the flavor of the keys.

Here is a thing I don't understand : the scale remains the same, irrespective of the base note you chose (you have the same difference in cents compared to the tonic). So why, apart from the pitch shift, should the keys have different flavours if the scale remains the same ?
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Gonk on September 09, 2020, 01:44:49 PM
-Y-, I think the answer lies in perception, which is less mathematically pure than any other method for measuring frequency.  Unfortunately, that's more of a rabbit hole than an answer.

There are so many mental factors that go into our perception of a sound, including memory and association.  Timbre is almost inseparable from these connections, and I suspect that informs our sense of a Bb/Eb box vs. a C/F.  How can we restrict our examination to pitch alone?  I expect the difference in feeling we're talking about would be diminished greatly if you used a pure sine wave as the tone, and modulated it using software instead of a real-world system of metal, wax, and wood.  The technology to make an experiment like that wasn't around when these theories of pitches/keys and their associated emotions were most popular.

Another oddity is the way the ear itself works to translate vibrations sensed by multiple hairs in the cochlea to what can be perceived as pitch.  Which isn't well understood, as far as I can tell.  From https://psych.athabascau.ca/html/Psych402/Biotutorials/25/part1.html:

Knowledge of how perceptual qualities of hearing are derived from neurophysiological events is weaker than our knowledge of visual perception. Amongst the three perceptual qualities of pitch, loudness, and timbre, pitch has been studied the most. Two theories have been offered to explain perception of pitch, the Place and Frequency Theories. Place Theory (Hermann von Helmholtz, 1863) maintains that perception of pitch depends on the vibration of different portions of the membrane formed by the receptive cells of the inner ear. That is, receptive cells in each region of the membrane are specialized for the detection of specific sound frequencies. Frequency Theory (Rutherford, 1886) holds that pitch perception corresponds to the rate of vibration of all receptive cells along the inner ear membrane. For example, a sound of frequency 2000 Hz would cause the whole membrane to vibrate at a rate of 2000 Hz. The brain then detects the frequency based on the rate of neuronal firing that matches the rate of vibration.
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 09, 2020, 01:55:51 PM
I think that when equal temperament was designed, some notes within the scale of a given key fitted mathematically better than others. Therefore in some keys the notes of the scale fit better and so sound easier on the ear.
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: -Y- on September 09, 2020, 01:58:43 PM
I don't say it's related to pitch only. But I've not seen any convincing evidence that, intrinsically, keys should convey any specific emotion. Which is not the same as saying that we perceive instruments differently, or that other factors are not notable.
I think for instance, that some boxes will sound better in certain keys, but it's not to say that it's related to the key itself.
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Gonk on September 09, 2020, 02:04:47 PM
To add to Thrupenny's comment, equal temperament is very rarely encountered in the wild.  Pianos, for example, aren't actually tuned to 12-TET.  They all have a modified system that tweaks those frequencies to achieve better resonance, harmonics, "color," etc.  So in practice they do exactly what Thrupenny describes - fit it to certain keys.  It's not unheard of to retune a concert grand for a specific performance, in a specific key.

I think the only way you're going to experience a mathematically pure 12-TET scale is through software.

And as -Y- says, in the real world, resonances are going to depend on many physical factors, like material density, thickness, shape and size of internal chambers, air column properties, on and on.
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on September 09, 2020, 02:08:34 PM
I'm not sure if Just v. Equal intonation is very relevant to MM with tremolo, anyway.
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Gonk on September 09, 2020, 02:12:42 PM
I'm not sure if Just v. Equal intonation is very relevant to MM with tremolo, anyway.

Totally true.  If you listen to the two scales superimposed with sine waves, it just sounds like a box that needs the tremolo tweaked.

https://pages.mtu.edu/~suits/scales.wav

I should add that the sound file comes from this page, which also lists the degree of difference in cents within the "middle" octave.  https://pages.mtu.edu/~suits/scales.html
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Gena Crisman on September 09, 2020, 03:18:22 PM
I understand the business of equal temperament and how that washed out a lot of the flavor of the keys.

To me, this is actually a bit like remarking on how different the water tastes depending on which pond you're drinking from - the flavour wasn't really there on purpose, and honestly it probably doesn't always taste all that great. But the perceivable differences created by unintended intonation differences would all be real things, but they're ones that you could have anywhere, at any time - just idk dip a frog to your cup of tea? (don't hurt frogs.)

I'm stuck with the mental dichotomy of;
a) 'Keys' don't exist.
b) However, keys are a relatively effective label for the particular expectations and experiences people who're saturated in western music generally seem to get from listening to music which occupies particular frequency ranges and is composed for certain instruments, and have implications for how it's played.
c) Therefore, keys can be a useful and sensible way to label likely true and observable trends in (our) music. Thus:
d) 'Keys' exist.

I came across this recently and it sets out an amazing differentiation between the different keys
http://www.gradfree.com/kevin/some_theory_on_musical_keys.htm

This, however, honestly reads like a horoscope. Plus is likely based on experiences and knowledge of western music from 18th century Europe.

When we say a tune is in G, we think about where we can expect melodies to be, pitch wise, and how they can occupy that space and how they'll interact with other instruments. We probably don't think about a tune that is pitched around either G8, or G1. But those are still G, aren't they? If we adjust our pitch standard for A down by a halfstep, and then play in G#, are we then playing in G again or is it still G#? What if we tune down by a quartertone? Would we have to find some new emotions to correspond with it?

Those are all rhetorical questions, really. There's a lot of unknowable things that it's easy to hypothesise about forever, and I don't really have any real answers.
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Gonk on September 09, 2020, 03:52:55 PM
All of this makes me think of Johannes Itten and his color system, or Wassily Kandinsky.  An attractive pseudoscience.  The theory is something like: the senses clearly affect emotion, and that means we can break the senses into their components and quantify exactly how they do this.  A periodic table for everything.  The term "spiritual" is thrown about a lot, as a sort of logical spackle.  It seems to me to dovetail nicely with some of the pseudoscience cults that appeared in the mid 1800s to early 1900s, with their claims to the ideal and most pure lifestyle, or the ideal diet.

I will say that a lot of interesting things can result from these convictions, even if they're a bit bizarre.  Whatever you think of Kandinsky, or Schoenberg, or anyone else who believes they have found "the code," their respective bodies of work have an internal consistency that I find appealing.
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: ursamyna on September 09, 2020, 05:21:29 PM
Why not try an experiment ?
Download a copy of a tune from youtube (quicker than doing your own recording). Choose a fairly obscure one which has no association with lyrics.
Load it into something like Riffstation or Audacity. Change the pitch (not tempo) and save it, so you now have different versions with the same dynamics etc but in different keys. Play them to someone without telling them anything which makes them pre-judge the situation, and get them to explain if they have different emotional responses.
I accept that different modes could have an influence on moods, but with equal temperament would a semitone shift from Gmajor (said to be rustic/idyllic etc) to Ab major (death/putrefaction etc) really be a significant  move.
Could be a good idea for some of the "pagan" border sides I suppose😉
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on September 09, 2020, 05:44:56 PM
Why not try an experiment ?
Download a copy of a tune from youtube (quicker than doing your own recording). Choose a fairly obscure one which has no association with lyrics.
Load it into something like Riffstation or Audacity. Change the pitch (not tempo)

Trouble is, key shifting creates artifacts which affect the way the music will sound. The farther you go from the recorded pitch, the worse they sound.

Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: CAB on September 09, 2020, 07:04:48 PM
Our modern A=440 can be a good semi-tone sharp or flat of some historical tunings so Handel's D, say, might well have sounded more like C# or Eb to us.
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on September 09, 2020, 08:17:42 PM
Our modern A=440 can be a good semi-tone sharp or flat of some historical tunings so Handel's D, say, might well have sounded more like C# or Eb to us.

That's one of the reasons why I think intonation, rather than absolute pitch, is behind the ancient theory. Otherwise it doesn't seem logical.
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Dick Rees on September 09, 2020, 09:18:51 PM
I do not have perfect pitch, but I do have very well developed "relative" pitch and can generally identify they key of any piece I hear.  When I hear a tune in something other than its usual or standard key, it can grate on my ear a bit.

A long-time friend (Bill) you was in a coma near the end of his life.  As a "godfather" of the local traditional music scene, he was visited constantly by dozens of his former band mates and students who would serenade him in his hospital bed. 

One accordionist started playing an old standard waltz and a few bars into the tune, Bill started groaning and twitching restlessly until another visitor said, "That's
a G tune, not Bb."

Upon switching to G, Bill quieted down and a smile crossed his lips.
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Steve C. on September 10, 2020, 01:16:32 PM
On a Streb, where you have over a hundred voices, certain ones sound "better" in different keys; especially notable in the free reed voices.
After having it for a couple years, I was interested/surprised to note that of the eight diatonic patches (installed switchable voices) I set up, two were in C/F, four in A/D, one in Bb/Eb and one in G/C.
None in D/G.
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 10, 2020, 05:33:56 PM
Spot on Steve!

We seem equally divided here between those who hear tune nuances differently on a different tonic, and those to who it doesn’t matter. Similar to … wine tasting in some respects.  Suggests to me that the sense is as much in the listener’s physiology as in the music itself. We might for example have different neurone distribution in inner ear?

But given that so many hear Eb as soft, D as bright it’s more likely cultural
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Little Eggy on September 10, 2020, 05:47:07 PM
I'm glad I started this thread. I've learned a lot from the very knowledgeable folk on the forum.  Thanks.
First - recognising different keys - It seems to me that you 'get it' fully; you get it in part or you don't get it at all.
I don't get it and I'm not sure you can be taught it.
Second - attributing emotional differences to different keys - this goes right over my head and out of the window I'm afraid!
But I have learned that tunes written in one key, with one particular instrument in mind should generally be played on that instrument and in that key.
My favourite story is the old man in hospital who could distinguish G from Bflat which is not really very far away on the scale is it!
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 10, 2020, 06:59:18 PM
Minor third, Eggy. That’s very different to my ear. Think of the Empire tune in Star wars.

The effect can be very powerful. eg In my Xray department every time the motor the tilted the table ran, I heard “Coronation Street” playing in my head. Brought in an instrument. It was spot on Bb!
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Little Eggy on September 10, 2020, 07:22:28 PM
Minor third, Eggy. That’s very different to my ear. Think of the Empire tune in Star wars.

The effect can be very powerful. eg In my Xray department every time the motor the tilted the table ran, I heard “Coronation Street” playing in my head. Brought in an instrument. It was spot on Bb!

?Hang on a minute? I tried on my guitar and I started the Corrie Theme Tune on a B which was in my head. Just played it on You Tube and it starts with a C.
(I mean the NAAAAAA, na na ni na na first note)   
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: CAB on September 10, 2020, 07:57:46 PM
Spot on Steve!
But given that so many hear Eb as soft, D as bright it’s more likely cultural

Shoot me down but, just to play devil's advocate and be a bit cynical… Are these perceived emotional differences felt by listeners who aren’t musically literate?  Looking at the link Little Eggy supplied and concentrating just on the major keys for the sake of simplicity, I can’t help noticing a relationship between the perceived emotion and the number of flats or sharps. 
C major (no sharps or flats) is described as pure, innocent, naive.
G major (1 sharp) is calm, gentle, peaceful
D major (2 sharps) is triumphant
A major (3 sharps) is suggestive of hope, love, innocent cheerfulness
E major (4 sharps) suggests noisy shouts of joy
B major – wild passions

Apart from A major, there seems to be a clear progression there: the more sharps in the key sig, the greater the excitement.

Going the other way, with one exception again (Bb), increasing numbers of flats lead us from complaisance and calm (F), through conversation with God (Eb), to death (Ab)!

Just thought I'd throw it out there  >:E
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 10, 2020, 08:11:04 PM
ie it IS cultural?
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: -Y- on September 10, 2020, 08:33:57 PM
Who would have thought
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: IanD on September 11, 2020, 03:03:40 PM
To add to Thrupenny's comment, equal temperament is very rarely encountered in the wild.  Pianos, for example, aren't actually tuned to 12-TET.  They all have a modified system that tweaks those frequencies to achieve better resonance, harmonics, "color," etc.  So in practice they do exactly what Thrupenny describes - fit it to certain keys.  It's not unheard of to retune a concert grand for a specific performance, in a specific key.

I think the only way you're going to experience a mathematically pure 12-TET scale is through software.

And as -Y- says, in the real world, resonances are going to depend on many physical factors, like material density, thickness, shape and size of internal chambers, air column properties, on and on.

Pianos have tuning which is "stretched" along the keyboard to make the octaves sound true; the bass strings are stiff so the harmonics are sharp compared to the fundamental, so they're tuned slightly flat. The same is done at the treble end but they're tunes sharp. If you plot pitch vs. ET pitch it forms a smooth "S" curve, curving flat at the bottom and sharp at the top. But this has no effect on the differences between keys, the basic tuning follows ET so there should be no difference. The only exception is of the piano is tuned away from ET for a particular piece in a particular key (closer to mean temperament or quarter-comma or...), but AFAIK this is not common.

There's a lot of rubbish talked about many things to do with music and instruments, for example the "differences between keys" used to be true (very!) in the days before ET was adopted but isn't any more -- IIRC English concertinas originally had separate D# and Eb keys (where the "wolf interval" was in the tuning used at the time). I could give a whole list of other examples but it would only start arguments, so I won't... ;-)
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: -Y- on September 11, 2020, 03:09:36 PM
Do you mean that for instance if you'd have to tune an instrument so that it was in tune in D, and then tune it so that it was in tune for G, thirds were not the same ?
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: IanD on September 11, 2020, 03:52:37 PM
Do you mean that for instance if you'd have to tune an instrument so that it was in tune in D, and then tune it so that it was in tune for G, thirds were not the same ?
Yes.
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: -Y- on September 11, 2020, 04:01:34 PM
Feels odd (don't really understand why you'd want to do that), but interesting to know.
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Gonk on September 11, 2020, 05:36:00 PM
Pianos have tuning which is "stretched" along the keyboard to make the octaves sound true; the bass strings are stiff so the harmonics are sharp compared to the fundamental, so they're tuned slightly flat. The same is done at the treble end but they're tunes sharp. If you plot pitch vs. ET pitch it forms a smooth "S" curve, curving flat at the bottom and sharp at the top. But this has no effect on the differences between keys, the basic tuning follows ET so there should be no difference. The only exception is of the piano is tuned away from ET for a particular piece in a particular key (closer to mean temperament or quarter-comma or...), but AFAIK this is not common.

This is interesting to me; I'm not a [real world] piano tuner, but I find it fascinating.  When I was younger, I used to have long conversations with the tuner who came too infrequently to tune the family piano.  He's the source of my claim that concert grands are sometimes tweaked to sound better in a certain key, even in ET.  My understanding is that the S-curve you describe, also called the Railsback curve, has the fortunate effect of also mitigating the effect of the increasingly dissonant fifths as one maintains ET and also consonant octaves.  But it doesn't do so perfectly, and there are still advantages in tweaking those resonances and colors slightly to produce good intervals within a key.  The rich harmonics produced by the strings means that fine adjustments can produce profound effects.  The shape of the soundboard, the shape of the bracing, and the ratios in string core/winding widths, lengths, and so on, are all real-world variables that complicate the problem to the point where predictive models can fail us.

I have an interesting electronic instrument (a Roland digital piano) that aspires to allow modeling of the sounds that different tuning systems produce, as well as virtual adjustments for things like degree of lid openness, damper resonance, soundboard bracing styles, and so on.  It also allows each note to be fine-tuned individually.  The Railsback curve is present in the preset tunings it offers, but it's not smooth - it's quite a spiky graph, actually, as certain bass notes are even raised to give the desired harmonic effects.  I don't imagine that these models are completely relevant to actual grand pianos, but I do think it's interesting that even in a digital instrument, those apparent "aberrations" are preserved.  I've made some tunings presets of my own, designed to actually reduce tonal color for a clear, crisp sound for use on stage.  I made them by tuning the middle octave to 12-TET, then using that octave to tune the harmonic over- and under-tones from the rest of the range, with a stroboscopic tuner.  It is likewise not the smooth S-curve that one might expect from a digital instrument.  It does achieve the desired effect very nicely: dry, little color, good for making a percussive and clean sound in muddy, echoing spaces filled with dancers.

I hope this isn't too much thread drift from melodeons and reeds.  As Greg said a ways back, a box with MM (or MMM) reeds is a very different beast.  But the discussion of the chaotic effects of string gauge and length are relevant to reeds, with their thicknesses, parallel or tapered sides, weighted tips, flat or vertical mounting systems, etc.  And certainly the box has an effect on the tone as well.  Despite the fact that the soundboard "shouldn't" resonate (soundboard in name only) it certainly does, and so does the rest of the instrument - and each vibrating surface has one or more pitches at which this effect is more pronounced.  I think the most relevant message I take back to the melodeon discussion is: in a physical system, we can't always use logic and math to make an accurate predictive model.  We can start there, but we also have to give the wood and metal its say.

I don't think this touches the question of emotions and keys, which is perceptual, except to say that if physical systems are this chaotic, one can only imagine trying to make a predictive model for the mind of an individual within a lifetime and a culture.
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 11, 2020, 05:55:48 PM
Thank you Gonk. I'm learning along the way!
Q
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: IanD on September 12, 2020, 05:22:18 PM
Any piano tuner who deliberately tuned away from ET to make them sound better in one key must be making an assumption (maybe wrong...) about what keys of music will be played on it, since by definition this will make it sound worse in other keys. There are instrument tunings which do sound better (especialy thirds and fifths) than ET in most of the keys related to the root, for example Aaron's quarter-comma meantone which I independently came up with about 30 years ago, only to find later that I'd been beaten to it by several hundred years.

If a two-row melodeon was tuned like this it would sound better in all the keys playable on it. The price to be paid is that each key away from the root key is slightly shifted in pitch away from ET -- for example if G was in concert pitch, IIRC going down the cycle of fifths (C...) they get flatter and going up (D...) they get sharper, which is great playing solo but hideous if you play with other instruments...

What Gonk is saying -- that different notes sound different on one instruments, and between different instruments -- is perfectly correct, also that a tune often has a "right" sounding key on a given instrument, which can of course be different for different tunes depending on which part of the scale they use relative to the tonic. But this is nothing to do with the "emotional feel" of different keys, for which there is no evidence or rational basis in ET tuning.
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 14, 2020, 03:47:05 PM
All of the above.

Are we back to the sad sound of Bb, or the bright quality of A, as generally but not universally agreed, being some property of the human ear or brain?
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Calum on September 14, 2020, 09:33:00 PM
I wonder, however, even with these mean-tone (and similar more equally distributed) tunings, if people with perfect absolute pitch can discern a different flavoring of keys, than the rest of us mortals who have acceptable relative pitch only.

My experience of people with perfect pitch is the opposite: they assign pitch labels to any sound they hear without reference to tuning (and for this reason they can often have terrible intonation).  I did some experiments with a student of mine with perfect pitch and they would label any pitch as a specific note if it was up to 40 cents sharp or 60 cents flat.  Only right on that border would they have any hesitation at all. 
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Theo on September 14, 2020, 10:13:57 PM
I have a counter example.  A friend of mine who plays concertina has perfect pitch.  I gave her a concertina to try that was not in concert pitch, as soon as she played it she reacted as if she had received a shock and refused to play it again.  She also plays fiddle and has superb intonation.
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Chris Rayner on September 15, 2020, 09:01:25 AM
As a long term (60 years) player of fretted strings (Guitar/banjo/ukulele etc.) I spent much of my musical career tuning my own instruments.  Initially using pitch pipes (Satan’s spawn) then to other players’ instruments, latterly using electronic gizmos, I have often found myself retuning slightly when switching from one key to another.  I had always assumed it was a feature of the deficiencies of the instrument and its strings, but I have now begun to wonder if it was my unconscious wish to tune to some more harmonious temperament.
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Calum on September 15, 2020, 11:18:53 AM
That's interesting Theo.  I wonder what way round the fiddle and the intonation skills went.  Certainly my student has improved drastically with practice, though I suspect I'm never going to manage to teach him to hear intervals by quality than by calculation. 
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 15, 2020, 11:36:16 AM
I remember years ago one of our Morris band members proudly played her new to her Overton whistle, only to be told quite firmly it was flat by another one of our musician friends who had perfect pitch. The wincing facial expression was incredible to see, and like Theo's friend, conveyed genuine pain on our musician friends' face.
 
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on September 15, 2020, 01:10:54 PM
I remember years ago one of our Morris band members proudly played her new to her Overton whistle, only to be told quite firmly it was flat by another one of our musician friends who had perfect pitch. The wincing facial expression was incredible to see, and like Theo's friend, conveyed genuine pain on our musician friends' face.

Something I don't understand about perfect pitch (actually, one of the many things) is why it should be calibrated at A=440 and why it makes painful listening to those cursed if it varies. Surely a variation to this, isn't imperfect, just conventionally different.
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 15, 2020, 01:39:44 PM
I dunno, but it seems to affect those 'gifted' (?) with it quite considerably.
Perhaps the affect is similar to us mere mortals when someone is singing badly out of tune sufficiently enough to wince.
I think we've all experienced it, and Les Dawson made an act out of playing way out of tune.
Q
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Theo on September 15, 2020, 01:50:32 PM
I’ve wondered about that too Greg. It must mean that perfect pitch is at least party learned - the part that calibrates it to the  current pitch standard.
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 15, 2020, 02:12:49 PM
I remember listening to a top violinist talking about her experiences in Yehudi Menuhin's music foundation as a young player.
Before breakfast, to loosen up for the day's lessons, they had an hour of identifying notes. A note was played and they had to say what it was. Doing this continually from an early age must instill an exactness to your perception of exactly what each note us.
Q⁷
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Anahata on September 15, 2020, 02:16:28 PM
I’ve wondered about that too Greg. It must mean that perfect pitch is at least party learned - the part that calibrates it to the  current pitch standard.
Yes, I think it's the audio equivalent of a photographic memory.

I assume if had you that sort of perfect pitch and spent some time listening only to music at some other pitch standard (e.g. A=432, New Philharmonic or baroque) you'd get used to it and pitch things accurately on that scale. There's no universal physical constant associated with A=440.
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Stiamh on September 15, 2020, 04:03:44 PM
I assume if had you that sort of perfect pitch and spent some time listening only to music at some other pitch standard (e.g. A=432, New Philharmonic or baroque) you'd get used to it and pitch things accurately on that scale.

My sister, a cellist, has always had perfect pitch. She started piano lessons at 5 but I don't think she ever did any particular exercises to help her develop the gift. (Apologies to anyone who may have heard the following story before...) I once decided to test her and plonked both hands and wrists randomly on the piano keyboard, holding down at least a dozen discordant notes, while she had her back turned. She calmly picked them all out correctly from lowest to highest with barely any hesitation.

When recordings of baroque music on original instruments and A=415 first started to appear, she complained that hearing familiar pieces pitched a semitone down was very disturbing. It doesn't seem to bother her much now, though, so perhaps something has worn off!
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Jackaspandy on September 15, 2020, 04:28:14 PM
I think I might try this https://tonedear.com/ear-training/absolute-perfect-pitch-test ........... to improve my ear
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 15, 2020, 05:20:02 PM
Stiamh, that must have been an amazing thing to see, quite incredible!
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Gena Crisman on September 15, 2020, 06:45:59 PM
I think I might try this https://tonedear.com/ear-training/absolute-perfect-pitch-test ........... to improve my ear

I used this exact website, and have become very good at being successful at recognising intervals, but so far only really when they are on this website.

Still feels like it was worth doing, though. A powerful approach that works for me is to associate the intervals with the opening notes of various tunes, perhaps that's the power of relative pitch in action.
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Calum on September 15, 2020, 09:38:07 PM
I assume if had you that sort of perfect pitch and spent some time listening only to music at some other pitch standard (e.g. A=432, New Philharmonic or baroque) you'd get used to it and pitch things accurately on that scale. There's no universal physical constant associated with A=440.

Indeed, I often have to remind people that 440Hz became a standard in Britain only well after 1945.

Some years ago I knew a pianist who had emigrated from Britain to Canada in the 1950s.  His perfect pitch was calibrated to 452, and when he moved to North America he took several years to relearn; he described the effect of hearing music in those early years as "flickering" between semitones. 
Title: Re: Qualitative differences between keys (off on tangent from the G/C boxes thread)
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 17, 2020, 02:02:52 PM
I think it’s learnable, but that some have better brain or cochlea for this than others. I’m … roughly right, usually, but then in folk circles the choice is limited

Interval training? Couldn’t recommend it more. In Isère’s Stage d’Improvisation every morning starts with that, and “name the chord” eg 7, minor 7, diminished etc.

Fantastically useful, and I became very conscious of playing or adding eg a major 7th, or 6th to my right hand chords. It also helps in playing a stripped down part chord when you run out of buttons. Basically you can dump the tonic and 5th as long as some one is playing bass. All the musicality in in the other 5 notes of the scale. G7’s essence is maj3+ min7, B+F
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal