Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Other Free Reed Instruments => Topic started by: Chris Rayner on September 08, 2020, 09:50:09 AM
-
Came across this on another site. Remarkable. Not sure it would be suitable for pub sessions, and definitely not Morris.
http://bandoneon-maker.com/foot-bass/ (http://bandoneon-maker.com/foot-bass/)
-
I have enough trouble co-ordinating left and right hands, lord knows what sort of fankle I would get into with a foot bass to struggle with as well.
SJ
-
Funny coincidence, I saw this video that was posted yesterday, of Baroque music played on the musette and diatonic accordion, with pedal bass
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CZRL8Ftv2J4
-
It would seem to offer a similar effect as pipe organ foot pedals, but with reeds. Is that right? Some lovely low notes there, mind you.
-
Really enjoyed that!
I'd have to invest in a whole new wardrobe of socks before taking that up. I've missed out on a fair few pints offered whilst I was playing (can't talk as well). I suspect over the years I've destroyed too many braincells to cope with both at once - shame.
Rob.
-
I took delivery of just such a "basse aux pieds" from the builder Harry Geuns in 2015 after a wait of about a year. Mr. Geuns is located in Brussels, Belgum and I live in New Hampshire, USA. That distance presented some logistical challenges, but nothing that couldn't be overcome. The Geuns foot bass is a remarkable sounding, well made instrument. It is what I think would be called a "single action" free reed. In other words, it only sounds on the "press" and the bellows are returned by stiff springs. It's a good design for the intended purpose.
My original thought was to play it in conjunction with my accordion. It does work very well in that role, but I'm now playing accordion less often and I'm more likely to combine the bass with my nyckelharpa or sometimes the mandolin. It took a bit of experimentation to find the right shoes to use while playing the bass. I finally settled on organist shoes, specifically designed for the pedal board of a pipe organ. They have a suede sole that allows for just the right amount of stiffness while still providing tactile feedback.
As much as I enjoy having such a beautiful, unique instrument, it's likely I'll have to let it go in the not too distant future. My wife and I will be moving into senior housing with less room for my considerable collection of instruments.
-
"My wife and I will be moving into senior housing with less room for my considerable collection of instruments. If anyone has an interest in owning a foot bass, get in touch....."
That's a sad statement to read, but it will come to all of us instrument hoarders, eventually. Best wishes to you both in your new environment, when it comes.
I'm sorry I couldn't possibly offer for your foot bass. But I'm pleased that you've enjoyed having and using it so much that you're willing to give the instrument such a glowing review here.
-
See also this story about a foot bass made by Harry Geuns (https://treewind.co.uk/melnet/footbass.html) , written by Simon Haines, who makes occasional appearances on this forum.
The one that YouTube video make the whole band sound huge!
-
Funny coincidence, I saw this video that was posted yesterday, of Baroque music played on the musette and diatonic accordion, with pedal bass
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CZRL8Ftv2J4
I've always thought the free reed sound would mix really well into a Baroque ensemble, however anachronistic.
-
I've always thought the free reed sound would mix really well into a Baroque ensemble, however anachronistic.
I was at a Piva weekend at Halsway a couple of years ago playing Baroque music. Several of us had ECs with us and played some Dowland (Renaissance, in fact) in the concert. People were amazed how appropriate it sounded.
-
I found this video featuring a Harry Geuns foot bass on YouTube some years ago, it's still in my favourites list.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AzTzXT2pa_s (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AzTzXT2pa_s)
-
https://youtu.be/CZRL8Ftv2J4
-
https://youtu.be/CZRL8Ftv2J4
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,25940.msg309206.html#msg309206
;)
-
Oops :D
-
I was at a Piva weekend at Halsway a couple of years ago playing Baroque music. Several of us had ECs with us and played some Dowland (Renaissance, in fact) in the concert. People were amazed how appropriate it sounded.
That's wonderful! I love Dowland. Glad to know I wasn't too off in my perception. I play some Early music dances on my EC from classical guitar scores. I always enjoy them a good bit!
-
I may have imagined it but didn't Danny Stradling play some sort of pedal bass way back in the very early days of The Old Swan Band?
-
And then there’s this rather older implementation of a similar idea. https://youtu.be/uBME_J0pf3o (https://youtu.be/uBME_J0pf3o)
-
Fotdella is a foot-operated string bass musical instrument. Invented and constructed by Jesse "The Lone Cat" Fuller, an American one-man band musician. Fuller is best known for his song San Francisco Bay Blues.
-
Named after his wife, Della.
-
And then there’s this rather older implementation of a similar idea. https://youtu.be/uBME_J0pf3o (https://youtu.be/uBME_J0pf3o)
Thank you for the pointer to that fantastic Jesse Fuller clip! Fabulous!
However, what I wanted to ask (pardon my ignorance) is: How close is this to being a foot-operated Shruti box?
(Olivia Chaney playing one here (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Evp-clThEaY) - or is it a harmonium?)
It seems like it's a not unrelated idea, but the sound samples on Harry Geuns' website sound a lot lower in pitch.
I ask because I've been thinking about a Shruti box, this might be an alternative...
-
I don't think that's a Shruti box, Roger.
-
Shruti box and foot bass both use free reeds but otherwise they are fundamentally different. The foot bass plays single notes in the bass register and is designed to play bass lines as you might do on other bass instruments. Shruti box is designed to play drone chords, usually in the lower treble range. It does have switches to select which notes are in play which enables the player to make simple chord changes, but they are not set out in away that would allow you to play a melody line or a bass line.
-
You can get foot pedals for shruti boxes, but they can cost more than some Shruti boxes, which seems odd. These sorts of things seem to be quite popular as drones.
The switches on a Shruti latch, so they're on until you switch them off. The foot bass switches are momentary, so you don't need to switch them off.
https://www.shrutibox.co.uk/foot-pedal/
-
I don't think that's a Shruti box, Roger.
Yeah, I'm never quite sure with these things - I talked to some-one who knows more about this stuff
than me, and he swore that it's a Shruti box - it looks more like an Indian harmonium to me, because
at some points you can actually see the keyboard...
Shruti box and foot bass both use free reeds but otherwise they are fundamentally different...
And I now understand why they sound different. Ta!
-
Hello, All. I am trying to find more about how the Basse aux Pieds (foot bass) works/looks inside. Anyone have any pictures? I imagine big reeds (of course) in individual (rectangular?) chambers, with spring buttons for the toes connected by rods/wires to some flapping pad for each note. Is that about right? If I wanted to DIY one, would accordion bass reeds work?
And, Mandomentch, I tried to PM you about yours for sale, and didn't hear from you. Perhaps my lack of fluency in this software made the message go away?
Any thoughts about where to find any more information will be greatly appreciated.
Thanks!
-
If I wanted to DIY one, would accordion bass reeds work?
They don't even work in accordions ;D Too small for low notes.
You want something adequately sized - get a set of harmonium reeds.
-
I found these images earlier this year, which are very useful. Thank goodness for digitised libraries/archives!
(https://bibliotheca.sambreville.be/thematiques/culture/musique/tamines/auvelais-theodore-vassart-facteur-de-basse-aux-pieds/20200929140911633_0008.jpg)
(https://bibliotheca.sambreville.be/thematiques/culture/musique/tamines/auvelais-theodore-vassart-facteur-de-basse-aux-pieds/20200929140911633_0002.jpg)
(https://bibliotheca.sambreville.be/thematiques/culture/musique/tamines/auvelais-theodore-vassart-facteur-de-basse-aux-pieds/@@images/image-0-ad1d9bcc5e524dcb615056f0914a2457.jpeg)
-
Wow, that's amazing, and turns a folk ensemble into a full acoustic range band. I think I want one! Wish I'd known about this instrument for playing in a dance band, donkey's years ago.
-
Hello! I have one (well, half a one!)….Mel Biggs and I co-own one having purchased it after being inspired by a week at Halsway with Benjamin Macke, of whom there are lots of videos on YouTube of him playing his!
Those interested and attending Melodeons in Wolvercote will get to see it in action as part of the tutors concert! (and for anyone that applies to, please feel free to come ask me stuff about it!)
As described you use it to add an extra bassline - ours plays one fully chromatic octave - the highest note is B1 which is also the lowest note on the G/C box I play it with.
It plays only on the push - it has huge springs inside that return it the home position and the reeds are probably 5-6 inches max but resemble massive melodeon reeds…I don’t have a photo to hand of the insides which aren’t that easy to access.
Anything specific I can help with, just let me know!!
Vicky
-
Thanks Vicky.
Does it allow for holding long organ-like pedal notes, or is it more of a staccato pump?
How quickly does the spring return the bellows into start position?
-
Those interested and attending Melodeons in Wolvercote will get to see it in action as part of the tutors concert! (and for anyone that applies to, please feel free to come ask me stuff about it!)
It is a wonderful thing to behold, less fun to carry though. So I won't be volunteering for that again (:)
-
Thanks Vicky.
Does it allow for holding long organ-like pedal notes, or is it more of a staccato pump?
How quickly does the spring return the bellows into start position?
Hi there, I’ve just timed it - the longest possible note you could hold is about 5 seconds but it’s hard to sustain and sounds a bit wobbly - as you say it’s much more of a staccato type thing, best at things like bass runs. It returns from fully depressed to home position in no more than a second - the reality is you tend to play somewhere in the middle of those two extremes, though as I’m sure you can imagine given the size of the reeds they take a good long while to sound.
All the best,
Vicky
-
Thank you.
I guess it's a good way to add the missing chromatic bass fundamentals to your box.