Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: dino.pafftti on September 12, 2020, 02:54:56 PM
-
Hi,, I preparing the 2-row, (G / C)
I have Hohner-reeds (maybe a Chinese preparation)
I would have asked your opinion on quality,?? italian reeds certainly good,
but perhaps expensive for the retiree ,,
do you have experience with Hamonikas reeds (dix ) ??
-
Use the reeds you have and then you can judge for yourself. You can’t compare directly with “Italian†or “Harmonikas†reeds because they both include many different styles and qualities of reeds. The choice between them often comes down to personal preference, so as I said at the start, install the reeds you have and see how you like them. If they aren’t up to standard for you then you can think about getting something better.
My personal experience of Harmonikas reeds is that I don’t like them, but many people do like them which backs up my suggestion that it’s a matter of personal preference.
-
Ok, Thanks (:)
-
Use the reeds you have and then you can judge for yourself. You can’t compare directly with “Italian†or “Harmonikas†reeds because they both include many different styles and qualities of reeds. The choice between them often comes down to personal preference, so as I said at the start, install the reeds you have and see how you like them. If they aren’t up to standard for you then you can think about getting something better.
My personal experience of Harmonikas reeds is that I don’t like them, but many people do like them which backs up my suggestion that it’s a matter of personal preference.
Just out of curiosity, what don't you like about the Harmonikas reeds?
-
The ones I’ve seen which in one case were dural in another tipo a mano just didn’t respond very well and they were on the soft side when pushed to higher volume. That was after some very positive reviews here and they just didn’t live up to expectations. They had been carefully installed and tuned by Fraton Accordions, so it was definitely the limitation of the reeds that I was feeling. I’m interested to try other boxes that have Harmonikas reeds just to see if my experience was an outlier. I have used Cagnoni, Binci, VA and Ciccarelli reeds from new, so I have plenty of yardsticks to judge by.