Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Phil Jones on September 18, 2020, 05:46:39 PM

Title: Pariselle Course - March 2021, what layout?
Post by: Phil Jones on September 18, 2020, 05:46:39 PM
Hi all - first post coming up.

I started on the melodeon early in lockdown with my son's discarded Hohner D/G 2 row, having Zoom lessons from Mel Biggs.  I'm really enjoying it and seem to be getting on OK but it's still early days and I'm feeling frustrated that there aren't opportunities at the moment to dip a toe into a session. Hopefully that won't be too long coming though.

In a flush of enthusiasm I've booked a place on the melodeon building course at Halsway Manor next March and am now faced with the tricky decision (like others before me as I can see from past threads) of what layout to go for.  Ideally I want to minimise the differences between the Hohner and the new box to avoid stressing the synapses, and going largely with the recommended D/G layout seems to make sense.  I still have a few questions though:

All info and ideas very welcome.

Thanks, Phil
Title: Re: Pariselle Course - March 2020, what layout?
Post by: Gena Crisman on September 18, 2020, 06:16:00 PM
When do you need to have decided by?
Title: Re: Pariselle Course - March 2020, what layout?
Post by: Phil Jones on September 18, 2020, 06:29:41 PM
By the end of next week.
Title: Re: Pariselle Course - March 2020, what layout?
Post by: Theo on September 18, 2020, 06:30:34 PM
A 2.5 row system with 14 basses is a different system from a 2 row and needs to be played differently,  unless you plan to ignore the extra buttons.  So don't worry too much about having some differences, you will be learning new fingering patterns in exploring the additional features.   Emmanuel's layout is well tried and tested and unless you have specific things that you know you want for your repertoire and playing style then stick with what he suggests.  Same sort of thing applies to the question about 11/10/4 or 10/9/6.  Emmanuel's style is very much built on right hand chords, if you are happy to be more of a single melody line player then you might want to arrange things differently, especially at the low octave end of the keyboard. 
Title: Re: Pariselle Course - March 2020, what layout?
Post by: Gena Crisman on September 18, 2020, 07:45:36 PM
And the default layout would be from

https://halswaymanor.org.uk/event/melodeon-building-course-2-5-row-with-emmanuel-pariselle-3/
set up as a D/G thussly:
https://halswaymanor.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/claviers-D-G-stage.pdf
?

The choice presented in this pdf is between 10/9/6 and 10/9/4, but the website says between 10/9/6 buttons or 11/10/4. Also, I don't think it includes which octave the notes are in?

Would that chin end E be a 2nd E4, or a low E3, does anyone know?
Title: Re: Pariselle Course - March 2020, what layout?
Post by: Fred on September 18, 2020, 08:22:36 PM
Let me tell you my tale:

I thought I knew what I wanted.
Then I talked with Emmanuel about my layout ideas.
Then I decided to go with his layout.
Now I'm convinced this is the best layout I've ever played.
Title: Re: Pariselle Course - March 2020, what layout?
Post by: Phil Jones on September 18, 2020, 08:37:07 PM
A 2.5 row system with 14 basses is a different system from a 2 row and needs to be played differently,  unless you plan to ignore the extra buttons.  So don't worry too much about having some differences, you will be learning new fingering patterns in exploring the additional features.   Emmanuel's layout is well tried and tested and unless you have specific things that you know you want for your repertoire and playing style then stick with what he suggests.  Same sort of thing applies to the question about 11/10/4 or 10/9/6.  Emmanuel's style is very much built on right hand chords, if you are happy to be more of a single melody line player then you might want to arrange things differently, especially at the low octave end of the keyboard.

Thanks for this, I'm sure Emmanuel's layouts are the right thing to go for in principle but I still don't understand how I should choose between 11/10/4 and 10/9/6? Is there an 11/10/4 layout on the web somewhere?

And any advice about whether to go for 14 or 12 bases?
Title: Re: Pariselle Course - March 2020, what layout?
Post by: Phil Jones on September 18, 2020, 08:39:02 PM
And the default layout would be from

https://halswaymanor.org.uk/event/melodeon-building-course-2-5-row-with-emmanuel-pariselle-3/
set up as a D/G thussly:
https://halswaymanor.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/claviers-D-G-stage.pdf
?

The choice presented in this pdf is between 10/9/6 and 10/9/4, but the website says between 10/9/6 buttons or 11/10/4. Also, I don't think it includes which octave the notes are in?

Would that chin end E be a 2nd E4, or a low E3, does anyone know?

Yes that's the only layout I've seen, there doesn't seem to be an 11/10/4 layout on the Halsway Manor site.
Title: Re: Pariselle Course - March 2020, what layout?
Post by: Phil Jones on September 18, 2020, 08:40:39 PM
Let me tell you my tale:

I thought I knew what I wanted.
Then I talked with Emmanuel about my layout ideas.
Then I decided to go with his layout.
Now I'm convinced this is the best layout I've ever played.

Which layout did you go for? Thanks.
Title: Re: Pariselle Course - March 2020, what layout?
Post by: Squeaky Pete on September 18, 2020, 08:47:30 PM
Go for the 14 basses.
It'll be recognised as a Pariselle system and you'll be surprised where the extra buttons can be used.
I have a Pariselle box that was made for someone else by Emmanuel. I'm slowly changing the bass to almost match his system and the right hand is now close to his too.
Go with his recommendation. Then explore what you can do with it.
Title: Re: Pariselle Course - March 2020, what layout?
Post by: Phil Jones on September 18, 2020, 08:58:37 PM
Go for the 14 basses.
It'll be recognised as a Pariselle system and you'll be surprised where the extra buttons can be used.
I have a Pariselle box that was made for someone else by Emmanuel. I'm slowly changing the bass to almost match his system and the right hand is now close to his too.
Go with his recommendation. Then explore what you can do with it.

Thanks - what layout is on the right hand?
Title: Re: Pariselle Course - March 2020, what layout?
Post by: Squeaky Pete on September 18, 2020, 09:14:31 PM
Here's mine.
I haven't done it to the Pariselle box yet but I'm using it on some Hohner projects.
I suits my playing but I wouldn't say it would work for everyone.
I've documented it a bit in my silly lockdown thread.
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=25468.0;attach=30836;image
Title: Re: Pariselle Course - March 2020, what layout?
Post by: Squeaky Pete on September 18, 2020, 09:17:33 PM
The one mod to the bass is I've changed the push A on the extra buttons to a push F#.
It's not set in stone though and I might yet sacrifice the push E instead. Probably not though.
Title: Re: Pariselle Course - March 2020, what layout?
Post by: Gena Crisman on September 18, 2020, 10:37:28 PM
Let me tell you my tale:

I thought I knew what I wanted.
Then I talked with Emmanuel about my layout ideas.
Then I decided to go with his layout.
Now I'm convinced this is the best layout I've ever played.

Well, you might be uniquely positioned then - Philip maybe has the disadvantage of not knowing what he wants, at least with any real degree of confidence, which mostly leaves only guesswork. When you're in that situation, it could be hard to have a conversation with someone (in this case, Emmanuel himself) and really feel fully confident that they're steering you better than some old post you found on a forum. You might be able to explain/demonstrate the advantages of the system as a counter point to ideas you'd previously had otherwise. However, I assume you'd becoming at it from a G/C perspective? That might complicate matters.

I'd love to know what some D/G people, especially if they already play a 2.5 row, have chosen for the course boxes they made - do they gravitate to Emmanuel's layout?

Cause I mean, I gotta say: I am left with some questions. Like, legit, that can't be a 2nd draw E4 at the chin end? It can't be, right? And, the D on the half row, I think I'm correct in guessing that's gonna be D5? ie, a pull 'middle of the rows' D? And we're looking at an F5, and D#5 and 6, and, no F4 or D#4? And no draw D4?

IIRC there's the choice of LM or MM for the instrument. I think that choice could be really pretty influential in how one opts to layout these instruments.

Philip: with the choice of 11/10/4 vs 10/9/6, the main reason I can come up with to choose the former over the latter is that it can allow you to 'weigh' any extra notes you wanted to add (eg, accidentals or reversals) more towards one end of the instrument's musical scale. With 10/9/6, your 10 and 9 rows are (probably) all normal scale notes, and the 6 button half row is located fairly 'centrally' - look at how F is near F#, and Bb is near B, for example. With 11/10/4, 2 buttons have been moved from either end of the half row to either the 'start' or the 'end of the scale notes, so, you can either pick to have more scale notes, or, have the 2 chin end buttons or 2 knee end buttons be accidentals, which can have some benefits if that lets you put your buttons near similar ones.

Well, that logic only really stays true if you can't just start the half row where ever you want - if you observe the images on the page here (https://halswaymanor.org.uk/event/melodeon-building-course-2-5-row-with-emmanuel-pariselle-3/), the right most instrument wit the black buttons that is slightly out of frame has a 4 button half row that starts in the same location as the 6 button half row would have, which may look lopsided but there you go.

So more likely, it would be something you picked as a result of knowing what extra notes you wanted.
Title: Re: Pariselle Course - March 2020, what layout?
Post by: Fred on September 18, 2020, 10:38:11 PM
Let me tell you my tale:

I thought I knew what I wanted.
Then I talked with Emmanuel about my layout ideas.
Then I decided to go with his layout.
Now I'm convinced this is the best layout I've ever played.

Which layout did you go for? Thanks.

http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/GC%20Pariselle.png

This is the standard layout that he proposed and that I built.
10/9/6 with 14 basses. Just marvellous.
Title: Re: Pariselle Course - March 2020, what layout?
Post by: Fred on September 18, 2020, 10:45:01 PM
However, I assume you'd becoming at it from a G/C perspective? That might complicate matters.

Yes, that's true.

However, that wasn't what I wanted to tell with my little tale. I just wanted to say that Emmanuel's judgement on questions of layout can be trusted, especially for someone who hasn't any specific ideas about how their new layout should look like.
Title: Re: Pariselle Course - March 2020, what layout?
Post by: Roger Howard on September 19, 2020, 07:38:09 AM
My advice would be to go with Emmanuel’s standard  layout with the six button half row and fourteen basses. When you hear him play it, you’ll have no doubts about its effectiveness!  ;)

The only change I made was to substitute a C for the low pulled E on the inner row, to give a G scale at the chin end.

You’ll have an interesting week - I hope you enjoy it as much as I did last year.  (:)
Title: Re: Pariselle Course - March 2020, what layout?
Post by: Jeremy Burnett on September 19, 2020, 09:58:07 AM
I went on Emmanuel's course in France some years ago. As an up and down the row beginner I didn't have any firm ideas about all the extra buttons, as they seemed to be, I did ask Emmanuel if I could have only 12 basses as I found 8 hard enough, no no he said stick with the 14, so I did, I still dont use the 14 but as Theo says you can not worry too much about them and stick to your normal style. A few years later,searching as ever for the perfect box ,and enjoying anything Emmanuel, I asked him to make me a 2 row 8 bass which he did. He asked me what layout I wanted, I sent him my ideas, this is "Bizarre" he said.So I stuck to his suggestion. The box is fine and very enjoyable to play. I think anyone going on one of the courses gets far more than just the box.I would love to go on another one particularly in France.
Title: Re: Pariselle Course - March 2020, what layout?
Post by: Elouan Imbeaud on September 19, 2020, 10:02:44 AM
Since I learn about that building stage, I dream of doing it.
Seems so perfect !
Title: Re: Pariselle Course - March 2020, what layout?
Post by: Theo on September 19, 2020, 10:05:45 AM
Just don't do what one builder did several years ago and ask a very helpful two row player to redesign the layout.  The result caused Emmanuel to use much more colourful language than "bizarre".  To save blushes I won't mention the advisors name.
Title: Re: Pariselle Course - March 2020, what layout?
Post by: Phil Jones on September 19, 2020, 12:04:26 PM
Thanks all, lots to think about - may come back with more questions...off to Beardy today!
Title: Re: Pariselle Course - March 2020, what layout?
Post by: Gena Crisman on September 20, 2020, 04:09:01 PM
The lowest buttons on the Hohner have D and A on the pull whereas Pariselle goes for E and B.  Why is that and what's the advantage? Should I stick with D and A?[/li][/list]

To respond to this question:

These buttons are effectively constituting what's normally called 'low notes'. There are a variety of options for these that serve a variety of purposes. A lot of tunes do not venture down to these notes, and so a great many instruments simply do not even include them, and often replace them with accidental buttons instead - notes that are not part of the regular scales of the instrument. Some tunes do, however, use these low notes - D/G players in particular seem to have a fondness for the low-note including layouts.

There are a few ways to think about the pros/cons of options available for these buttons. You can think of it melodically - ie, does this choice allow me to play melodies that otherwise I could not? Does it allow me to play certain melodies much more easily? Or, you can think of it from a harmony playing perspective - does it allow me to play a chord I otherwise couldn't? Does it allow me to play harmony notes easily & naturally, and include my basses, without having to think too much, or plan?

The most important take away is that: You can have an instrument that is great without any of these extra things. And typically, they can be changed relatively easily if you decide you want to make a different choice, later. The hardest thing to change is where scales start/end, but changing the notes of an individual button is usually quite possible. So, if you're not sure, there's nothing wrong with saying 'actually, I don't know yet' and accepting that you can figure things out later.

To talk about the subject at hand, though: I can tell you that, almost all low note layouts on a D/G will include a low B3 note of some kind. This B note can be a very helpful note in G major, D major, and E minor, which are the most common keys to play in on this instrument. A number of E minor tunes can call for this note. For the key of D major, its presence allows you to complete the a scale of A B C# D, which allows you to play some melodies in your low D octave (if you think of somehow you will look for an E note when playing in G major, this B fills that role for D major). Additionally, it is a helpful harmony note for G major, and, some G tunes do indeed venture down to this note - the Grand Old Duke of York's opening bar, for example. It's probably the low note you'd use the most for melody playing.

Beyond that common ground, though, there are different approaches. No one really refers to them by 'names', though, instead they usually just list what the notes would be.

Your Hohner instrument with low notes is using something called Richter Tuning (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richter_tuning) (I think, anyway). On a D/G, this normally provides you with low notes F#/A and B/D. On the D row, A is typically a push note, but offered here as a pull note - and likewise D is typically a push note on the G row.
From a melody perspective, these don't actually offer you very much vs other options - you already have these notes, but, not in that direction. The low F# is quite uncommon (typically, a tune that moved in that way would sit in the middle of the D row). One advantage is that it allows you to play a pull D over a pull D basses (and a low pull A over a pull A basses) which can simplify playing many common tunes in G. If you've ever swapped to your D basses when playing a low D note in a G tune, you could instead use this pull D note, and your stay on your draw D basses.
The largest advantage is in harmony playing. While you can form a push D major chord, this pull D allows you to form a low pull D major chord, and easily include a D in harmony lines without having to rethink the way you play a tune. The low F# on the push works similarly to the B in terms of forming very low D chords. The low draw A combines easily with the draw C# and E notes to form an A chord.

Comparatively, the layout on the 'default' D/G course layout pdf appears to be extending the normal scales down by an extra button: the draw scale of the D row is C# E G B C# so it adds an F#/B button, and the draw scale of the G row is F# A C E F# so adds an B/E button. This maintains the patterns of the rows, and may facilitate the use of the same techniques in both octaves of the instrument. The push notes, B and F# are as previously described.
From a harmony perspective, a pull low B note can be very helpful for E minor playing. Most choices offer no assistance for E minor harmony below E4, which is often the home note of your tune, but give lots of options for every other note, which can be a frustrating dichotomy.
From a melody perspective, this is not a very helpful set up IMO. The F# will rarely see use in a melody, you gain the useful B note twice but few adjacent notes, and, the low pull E on the G row, if it is indeed the same E as on the 3rd button of the D row, seems to me to be pretty redundant?

A 3rd option not yet directly mentioned is Low G scale, or Anahata, layout. This instead seeks to offer you another full octave of G major notes. This offers low G/A on the D row, and low B/C on the G row. This is a more melody oriented choice, and gives you a G major scale the below where you might normally start a G major tune.
From a melody perspective, this has many benefits as it gives you coverage for the keys of D and G matching the lowest note on the Violin, which has had a huge influence on music & melodies. For the G major tunes you find that do use the low B note, many will also look for a low C natural note that the other layouts don't provide.
From a harmony perspective, this layout is only pretty ok. The low C can sometimes be used as a harmony note over a D chord, but it isn't as universal as a D in that case, but also: it's a low C natural so you can use it for C chord harmony where otherwise there would have been no option. The low G can also be used for harmony but like the F# it probably won't come up much. You can still play a low A note over your normal A basses, and form a full low A major (and A minor) chord.

I hope that this describes some of the advantages and disadvantages of the options for these low notes. Critically, the extra basses that the 14 bass provides, and the reversals likely found on the half row, do influence some of these notions. In particular, you are provided a low push A bass, which renders the low draw A less useful. You are similarly provided a push E bass, rendering a draw B a bit less useful.

What the correct choice for you is, ultimately depends on what kind of player you are, or will become, as Theo pointed out here in far far fewer words (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,25967.msg309719.html#msg309719).
Title: Re: Pariselle Course - March 2020, what layout?
Post by: Phil Jones on September 24, 2020, 11:10:34 PM
Thanks for such a full response Gena, I appreciate you taking the time to do that.

I've decided to go for 10/9/6 to keep the accidentals within easy reach (I have quite small hands) and can't see any reason not to have 14 bass buttons, although I'll need to get used to resting one pair up.

The low buttons are a bit of a puzzle as I don't know what I'll find easiest to learn, although I'm tempted to go for G/A and B/C as you suggest.  I see that Roger Howard also substituted pull C for pull E on the G row.  It's good to know that changing this won't be a big issue if I ever want to though.

Phil
 
Title: Re: Pariselle Course - March 2020, what layout?
Post by: Phil Jones on September 29, 2020, 12:48:07 PM
So I've chosen - and with the help of Andy Cutting, via Emmanuel Pariselle, I've gone with Gena's suggestion of G/A and B/C bottom buttons.  Thanks for coming up with that idea Gena.

Now I just need to build the thing and learn to play it!

Phil
Title: Re: Pariselle Course - March 2021, what layout?
Post by: Gena Crisman on September 29, 2020, 06:07:44 PM
Hey, the layout isn't named after me! I just tried to give some fair pros and cons to each option, at least so far as I'm able to see them.

As another 'helpful two row player', really I was hoping it would help you find some more of your own questions to ask, apparently of Emmanuel and Andy Cutting, so, I mean I imagine they can give some pretty good advice.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal