Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Polkadot on September 21, 2020, 08:50:20 AM
-
Hello
I have been enjoying my restored single row G and D melodeons at home and was wondering. Does anyone take a single row G to a session. Is is just too low to be heard or do you play in the upper octave? It has 4 stops.
-
A one-row four-stop in G is indeed low pitched and growly (gloriously so (:)). As you mention, the sound can get lost in sessions, so playing in the upper octave helps, as the sound will cut through more.
As a general rule, it's often helpful and good practice to play in the upper octave of one of these instruments anyway. The range and fingering then becomes akin to the G-row of a two-row G/C box.
Overall, the one-row four-stop in G is a curious beast. Playing in either the upper or lower octave will sometimes mean that you run out of notes on certain tunes, and you will need to switch octaves or otherwise adapt the tune to the instrument. It's a great journey; hope you enjoy it!
-
Hello
I have been enjoying my restored single row G and D melodeons at home and was wondering. Does anyone take a single row G to a session. Is is just too low to be heard or do you play in the upper octave? It has 4 stops.
A one-row four-stop in G is indeed low pitched and growly (gloriously so (:)). As you mention, the sound can get lost in sessions, so playing in the upper octave helps, as the sound will cut through more...
Would there be a future in Polkadot taking his D box to the session and faking the C naturals?
-
Further to my last post, and to illustrate the switching octaves thing, here's a video I made earlier in the year of 'The Railway' played on my one-row four-stop in G.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fbTiWTLqdNI
I play the A-music in the upper octave, as I would run out of notes if I played it in the lower octave, as normally written. I am playing the B-music at the written pitch (also in the upper octave), So the overall range of the tune becomes sort of compressed when playing on this instrument, but I don't think it matters.
-
Would there be a future in Polkadot taking his D box to the session and faking the C naturals?
Hmm... Not sure about that. For me, I'd stick to the G box for tunes in G and 'fake' any octave switching.
If I only had the two one-row boxes, one in G and one in D, I'd take both to sessions.
-
I've certainly noticed more D 1 rows in sessions these days....usually when I've taken my C... :'(
-
i find a one row G box works well in 'English' sessions where most stuff is played in G or D as much of the D tunes can be played in just the same way as playing in A on the D row of a DG box.
Missing 'accidentals' can be 'faked' or otherwise skirted round which is part of the fun of playing a one row - and it doesn't have to have 4 voices in gear for every tune!
george
-
I’ve sometimes brought my 4-stop in G to sessions (in addition to my 4-stop in D) for the occasional tune. I don’t play it any differently than any other one-row, and I’ve not had any trouble being heard. Personally, I think the low, grunting sound is part of its charm and I feel that cutting out the low voice would be a shame. Fits in lovely with other instruments.
-
I agree about the wonders of the low voice ( played with t'other 3) but also like the single high voice for haunting slow aires
george
-
Would there be a future in Polkadot taking his D box to the session and faking the C naturals?
Hmm... Not sure about that. For me, I'd stick to the G box for tunes in G and 'fake' any octave switching.
If I only had the two one-row boxes, one in G and one in D, I'd take both to sessions.
Irish (and Cajun) one-row players would play a D melodeon in G,D and A. The Irish would definitely fake all the missing notes (the Cajuns don't need to as there aren't any).
-
Irish (and Cajun) one-row players would play a D melodeon in G,D and A. The Irish would definitely fake all the missing notes (the Cajuns don't need to as there aren't any).
That is precisely why, for the most part, I will only bring the one 4-stop in D to a session.
-
Irish (and Cajun) one-row players would play a D melodeon in G,D and A. The Irish would definitely fake all the missing notes (the Cajuns don't need to as there aren't any).
That is precisely why, for the most part, I will only bring the one 4-stop in D to a session.
But then you lose out on the growly richness of the one-row four-stop in G.
-
Irish (and Cajun) one-row players would play a D melodeon in G,D and A. The Irish would definitely fake all the missing notes (the Cajuns don't need to as there aren't any).
That is precisely why, for the most part, I will only bring the one 4-stop in D to a session.
But then you lose out on the growly richness of the one-row four-stop in G.
In that case you can play in G, C and D.
-
I have a Savoy in G, which is ferociously growly, and nothing really occupies that part of the tonal spectrum in our sessions, so I guess it gets heard well enough. It's right, tho,' that you do need to choose your tunes to avoid some of the limitations of the keyboard's range, that is if you don't want to slide about on the octaves. However, I enjoy the challenge of the octave shifts, as they relieve occasional tune 'boredom', compared with taking the autopilot 2-row way out, when joining in with a familiar tune for the n'th time ;)! I think I re-connected with 4-stops, in English music, after a Halsway weekend with Polkaworks - very gutsy music also Tony Engle when re-watching 'The not the Finger in the Ear Show' on Youtube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OOlunxBdw2M at about the 26 minute mark for the final ceilidh.
-
Irish (and Cajun) one-row players would play a D melodeon in G,D and A. The Irish would definitely fake all the missing notes (the Cajuns don't need to as there aren't any).
That is precisely why, for the most part, I will only bring the one 4-stop in D to a session.
But then you lose out on the growly richness of the one-row four-stop in G.
Yes, that’s true! That’s one reason why there’s no such thing as one box that does it all! Sure, I can play G tunes on my D one-row, but some of them just work better on a G box for that rich sound (particularly in the lower octave ;) ). Same goes for G tunes played on my two-voice D/C#...The Teetotaller’s Reel is a good example of a tune that just wants to be cranked out on the 4-stop! Hup! :D
-
Looks like you have a pretty clear answer Polkadot. Take both your 114s they'll both work and both have a place.
Now, what to do with my 1040C?
-
Thank you all for your advice!
-
"Now, what to do with my 1040C?"
Now that's a silly question when there are folks like me, hovering. I'm currently missing mine after having to sell it to a (new melodeon convert) folkie friend.
-
"Now, what to do with my 1040C?"
Now that's a silly question when there are folks like me, hovering. I'm currently missing mine after having to sell it to a (new melodeon convert) folkie friend.
It's not for sale. It's just that I'm the only person I know, locally, who plays C and CF. I think Dm is a great key, but no melodeon players, round here, seem to have discovered this. I have one friend who has acquired a 2.5 row CF, but it's still a project for the future.
-
Take a trip to Tyneside when sessions restart. Fiddle players here love Dm.
-
A one-row four-stop in G is indeed low pitched and growly (gloriously so (:)). As you mention, the sound can get lost in sessions, so playing in the upper octave helps, as the sound will cut through more.
As a general rule, it's often helpful and good practice to play in the upper octave of one of these instruments anyway. The range and fingering then becomes akin to the G-row of a two-row G/C box.
Overall, the one-row four-stop in G is a curious beast. Playing in either the upper or lower octave will sometimes mean that you run out of notes on certain tunes, and you will need to switch octaves or otherwise adapt the tune to the instrument. It's a great journey; hope you enjoy it!
What Steve writes above ("A one-row four-stop in G is indeed low pitched") is true of the post-WW2 Hohner HA-114G and other models, but not universally true.
It's tricky to abbreviate the octave for reeds in G because the G row of a GC box voiced "MM" is one octave below the G row of a DG voiced "MM." But let's assume that the former (the low version of "G row in M" ) makes the most sense. In that case, the Hohner HA-114C is voiced LMMH and the Hohner HA-114G is (mostly) one-fourth lower and we'll also call that voicing LMMH (the exception is the bassoon reed for the lowest button, that jumps up an octave). Michael Kennedy, an Irish emigrant who lived in the US, recorded all his repertoire on such a LMMH Hohner G box, from the 1950s.
However, here's an interesting and not-always-known fact: 1-row, 4-stop boxes in G were also sometimes made in MHHH. And, for some of the best and most influential 4-stop boxes ever made- the prewar Globe and International boxes made in Germany and imported to the US - the "normal" voicing for an example in the key of G was MMHH.
Those same Globe and International models are usually voiced LMMH when we find them in the key of D or C, but MMHH when in the key of G. Thus the G Globe 4-stop melodeons don't have reeds that sound as low, nor as high, as the extreme reeds of a C or D box. They do have a great "double octave celeste" sound when played for Irish music with all stops out. I've seen many of them and currently have several examples, and this is typical. I know of players who used such a box, a G melodeon in MMHH, to play all their repertoire. (One example: John Conroy R.I.P., father of my great friend Jack Conroy R. I.P.; John bought his International 4 stop box in G from the O'Byrne DeWitt shop in Boston in 1925 and played it for decades and the box is here with me).
Some context: Many of the pre-WW2 1-row, 4-stop boxes in many keys were tuned in MMHH. You'll often see this in Hohners from the 1920s and sometimes from the 1930s. This is most often seen in C boxes but I've seen that voicing in other keys also.
However the Globe C and D boxes in LMMH seem to have been so popular that when Hohner developed their postward HA models, the LMMH voicing was used as a standard for models in all keys (with the slight exception that I mentioned above).
I personally love the MHHH and MMHH voicings for a G melodeon and I think they really suit Irish music, played "low on the keyboard" - it's too bad those voicings weren't used in postwar Hohner G boxes (to my knowledge) and are so little known today.
If there's interest I could post pics.
PG
-
"If there's interest I could post pics."
Go on then, I'm sure that I'm not the only one who is eager to see them.
-
OK,
Here are 4 G melodeons: Lubich MHHH, Globe MHH, Globe MMHH, and International MMHH.
All of these lack the lowest octave (L) voice that's present on a post-war Hohner HA-114G. But none sound shrill because the key of G itself is so much lower than C or D.
Second photo: prewar Hohner 4 stop boxes in C MMHH. These are tuned overall one-fourth higher than the 4 stop G boxes on the right in the first photo.
PG
-
how interesting. got me thinking. i have a couple of HA114's in G. maybe i'll switch one to MMMH. And im falling over HA114's in A. maybe switch one to F with LMMM. might have to start getting out of bed earlier.
-
how interesting. got me thinking. i have a couple of HA114's in G. maybe i'll switch one to MMMH. And im falling over HA114's in A. maybe switch one to F with LMMM. might have to start getting out of bed earlier.
Chris,
My favorite result of studying and playing (and posting about) the old boxes is to suggest ideas to explore today, with reworked boxes or new boxes. :)
MMMH is rarely heard. But one way to hear it is to block off the L voice and one M voice of a 6-voice Baldoni in LMMMMH. It's a great sound in D, and I'm sure it would be nice in G also.
MMH is maybe more common to hear, and is one option with the 4-stop Hohner HA boxes, by pushing in the L stop. Also a great sound. I believe Jackie Daly uses MMH often.
The MMHH sound (which you didn't mention, but I did) is rare today as a standard box voicing - but the equivalent can be heard on a celeste/tremelo MM box by playing simultaneous octaves with two right-hand fingers.
LMMM would really be low if you mean "low F" (like the F row of a FBbEb box) but would be cool also if you mean "high F" (like the F row of a CF or GCF box). If you meant the latter, it would be one step below the Lubich G box that I described as "MHHH" in my photo above.
PG
-
how interesting. got me thinking. i have a couple of HA114's in G. maybe i'll switch one to MMMH. And im falling over HA114's in A. maybe switch one to F with LMMM. might have to start getting out of bed earlier.
Falling over 114s in A?!
-
"Falling over 114s in A?!"
I have to admit that that was also my initial reaction. But never mind, I have a partial solution, Chris; I'll willingly re-home one the little beggars for you!
-
I personally love the MHHH and MMHH voicings for a G melodeon... ... it's too bad those voicings weren't used in postwar Hohner G boxes (to my knowledge) and are so little known today.
Paul - interesting account of other one-row boxes in G, thanks. I wasn't aware of the MMHH or MHHH tunings but I understand the reasoning, with the basic G-row M pitch being in the same octave as a standard two-row G/C.
...and I think they really suit Irish music, played "low on the keyboard"
But when playing "low on the keyboard" on a one-row in G, how do you overcome the lack of a low E, without an odd tuning or faking the notes? That's why I prefer a LMMH box and playing in the upper octave, which does make all the notes available.
-
Steve, Irish players usually re-tune the first button pull to the sixth rather than the fifth. So B instead of A on a D box. This would give E instead of D on a G box.
If I'm making a one-row melodeon for Irish music I always set it up this way.
-
Steve, Irish players usually re-tune the first button pull to the sixth rather than the fifth. So B instead of A on a D box. This would give E instead of D on a G box.
If I'm making a one-row melodeon for Irish music I always set it up this way.
Exactly!
In fact, to quote myself from a recent thread on "1-row F-major," where you posted some great playing in the key of D, low on the keyboard of a 1-row Wesson in high G:
I would also like to hear ..
I don't have a recording of the high F instrument but here is a YouTube link to the high G box (a tone higher than F!)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mPCD0l1X1Oc (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mPCD0l1X1Oc)
Great sound Rees, I like that style of playing the tune (Boys of Blue Hill) in the normal key of D on a box with a "high G row." As you know that fingering would give the key of "low A" on a D box and is not an uncommon way for melodeon players to play some tunes.
I'm interested in exactly that approach, especially for some "concertina settings" of Irish traditional tunes, to set them "in the low range on boxes that are tuned in high keys."
My preference though would be to add more lower notes of the G scale and drop some of the higher ones. In the terminology of this forum, that would be switching from a "3rd button start" for the full diatonic scale to a "4th button start" or even a "5th button start." I realize that might trip up some melodeon players who haven't learned the fingering for the diatonic scale extended further downward.
Some Paolo Soprani DG boxes with 23 button keyboard, made at least from the 1960s, have no accidental notes and no duplicated notes within a row, so their 11-key G row has a "4th button start:" *
G/C B/E D/F# G/A B/C D/E G/F# B/A D/C G/E B/F#
Irish players of the BC and C#D systems are familiar with the way that such a diatonic scale works in that lower range ( the low buttons giving G/C B/E here; or C/F E/A on the C row of a BC box etc) and the fingerings aren't so hard to learn.
I quite like the idea of a "5th button start" for a high G row, to pick up the low A note used in some fiddle tunes, and giving the option to grab a doubled octave of the low D for an accent:
D/A G/C B/E D/F# G/A B/C D/E G/F# B/A D/C etc (Note that even with only 10 buttons, this placement of the "high G" scale gets all the way up to the high C and D notes that are some of the highest notes played in traditional Irish tunes. I'm not sure I would often use the higher buttons for G/E, B/F#, etc).
. . .
Many players on this forum would have to learn, or re-learn, the notes for the lowest 3 buttons of that layout, but as the example of the DG Paolos shows, it's really not that "far out"
-
"Falling over 114s in A?!"
my workshop is small, my shelves are full, ive got five ha114's im restoring. Dont worry im not literally falling over them and they are not in any danger. I was taught by my mentor rees wesson never to leave things on the floor! "falling over them" is a turn of phrase to mean ive got loads. Similar to "ive got HA114's coming out of my ears" or "im waist deep in HA144's" or "ive got a shedload" I'll be finishing a few soon and will put them up for sale. No point saving that many for a rainy day.
-
Steve, Irish players usually re-tune the first button pull to the sixth rather than the fifth. So B instead of A on a D box. This would give E instead of D on a G box.
If I'm making a one-row melodeon for Irish music I always set it up this way.
Ah, OK - thanks, Rees!
-
"Falling over 114s in A?!"
my workshop is small, my shelves are full, ive got five ha114's im restoring. Dont worry im not literally falling over them and they are not in any danger. I was taught by my mentor rees wesson never to leave things on the floor! "falling over them" is a turn of phrase to mean ive got loads. Similar to "ive got HA114's coming out of my ears" or "im waist deep in HA144's" or "ive got a shedload" I'll be finishing a few soon and will put them up for sale. No point saving that many for a rainy day.
I think you may have missed the point people were actually trying to make; HA114s in the key of A are *extremely* uncommon!! It’s surprising that you would have several, let alone even one!
-
Steve, Irish players usually re-tune the first button pull to the sixth rather than the fifth. So B instead of A on a D box. This would give E instead of D on a G box.
If I'm making a one-row melodeon for Irish music I always set it up this way.
Ah, OK - thanks, Rees!
In fact, you could say that Irish players don't necessarily "retune" that button (although that might be necessary with some modern instruments or sets of reeds) - rather, they use a layout that is quite old, and very consistent. You see that layout (that Rees describes as used by the Irish) on boxes going back to the early 20th century if not earlier.
It is what you would "expect" from a consistent application of the rule:
Press notes: #1, 3, 5 of the diatonic major scale, then repeat
Draw notes: #2, 4, 6, 7 of the diatonic major scale, then repeat
if extended both downward as well as upward from a "home" position.
It's actually the other layout ( with a redundant low fifth note of the scale on button #1 draw of a 1-row melodeon) that breaks the rule.
Admittedly, that inconsistent layout with the low fifth note on both #1 draw and #2 press has also been around for over a century on many types of boxes, and has become a standard, especially on Hohner 1-row boxes and for cajun accordions. The earliest Irish-American accordions from the 1920s seem to have it too, and it was usually used on the Globe and International melodeons.
But the "consistent" layout (without the redundant fifth note) was used in the early Miller and Galleazzi boxes ca 1900 and in many Italian quint-tuned boxes throughout the 20th century, as well as in the standard layouts for BC, CC#, DD#, BCC# Hohners, Paolos, etc. At least from the mid 1930s, you almost always see the "consistent" layout on Irish-American boxes such as Baldonis and Walters (with some exceptions); you can infer that as those very high-quality and innovative boxes developed, serious players wanted as many different notes as possible from 10 buttons
Also on some early 20th century German 1-row melodeons (for example some made by Weidlich) you'll see the 4th note of the diatonic major scale on the draw for button #1. This would give E / F then G/B etc for a 1-row box in C.
PG
-
I think you may have missed the point people were actually trying to make; HA114s in the key of A are *extremely* uncommon!! It’s surprising that you would have several, let alone even one!
[/quote]
I know its weird. A few years ago i needed one to play a gig with a famous rock n roll band in E so i needed an A. Couldn't find one anywhere but at last minute, much to my relief, i found one and i got to jam in E with some rock legends. Years went by and I never saw another. Then a fellow band member said he's got an old HA114. Turned out to be in A. I couldnt believe my luck. Then I bought 3 on ebay over last few months to renovate. All listed as HA114 by folks who didnt say what key. Guess what. All turned out to be in A!!! I need to get a few back in circulation for sure! Sorry i missed your point. more coffee needed!!
-
Chris, I see that mselic beat me to it. Although it remains to be said that I did fully understand what you meant; I have colloquialisms coming out of my ears as well as my mouth, and they often get me into trouble with folk who don't twig.
-
"Falling over 114s in A?!"
my workshop is small, my shelves are full, ive got five ha114's im restoring. Dont worry im not literally falling over them and they are not in any danger. I was taught by my mentor rees wesson never to leave things on the floor! "falling over them" is a turn of phrase to mean ive got loads. Similar to "ive got HA114's coming out of my ears" or "im waist deep in HA144's" or "ive got a shedload" I'll be finishing a few soon and will put them up for sale. No point saving that many for a rainy day.
I think you may have missed the point people were actually trying to make; HA114s in the key of A are *extremely* uncommon!! It’s surprising that you would have several, let alone even one!
That's Zydeco for you. Chris and I use them for playing in E major with a flat (blues) seventh.
-
I think you may have missed the point people were actually trying to make; HA114s in the key of A are *extremely* uncommon!! It’s surprising that you would have several, let alone even one!
I know its weird. A few years ago i needed one to play a gig with a famous rock n roll band in E so i needed an A. Couldn't find one anywhere but at last minute, much to my relief, i found one and i got to jam in E with some rock legends. Years went by and I never saw another.
I know it's bad form to name drop, Chris, but I wish you would. Are there any videos around?
-
Steve, Irish players usually re-tune the first button pull to the sixth rather than the fifth. So B instead of A on a D box. This would give E instead of D on a G box.
If I'm making a one-row melodeon for Irish music I always set it up this way.
Ah, OK - thanks, Rees!
Further to my last...
Now I realise that I actually have this pull low B on my one-row in D 'Golden Box', made on Emanuel Pariselle's melodeon building course in Stowmarket in 2008. It was one of EP's suggested options, so I went with it. Regretfully, as it turns out: it always trips me up when I try to go for those powerful pull A harmonies in the lower octave, which for me is an important aspect of one-row playing. Which is why I prefer my Wesson Clipper in D, which has the standard layout with a pull A on button 1.
I really ought to get the Golden Box re-tuned to a pull A on the button 1, but so far haven't got round to it. :(
-
I know it's bad form to name drop, Chris, but I wish you would. Are there any videos around?
[/quote]
there are a few on youtube. here's one. Thats not an HA114 in A though. Its a C Acadian played in G https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AhcTHJhvRhY . Hohner in A was used for "lets have a party"