Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Other Free Reed Instruments => Topic started by: Larry Anthony on January 21, 2008, 12:39:34 PM
-
Are there any members who have experience of a CBA-C system, and if so, what are their impressions?
Thanks
-
I assume you mean the C-system for continental cromatic button accordion?
This is the most common symtem (the others are the norwegian B-system and the strange russian system).
It consists of 3, 4 or 5 rows, but basically, it's just 3 rows. The inside 2 rows on a 5-row are duplicate of the outer rows. This makes for a nice even system, and allows for shift of key by just moving the hand. Said in another word - the distances are the same and scales are played the same way no matter where on the keyboard you are.
I find it a bit difficult to play fast runs, since you have to move your fingers and hand a lot more than on a melodeon. Furthermore, I find that I need to use my right hand thumb for this system do do the things that I like to.
BUT: This system is much nicer than piano accordion IMHO. I've played both when I was a kid.
When playing this system as a melodeon player, I think it's very very difficult to play this system "light". That is, since it plays same note in and out bellow-wise, and the fingers move larger distances.
//Lars
-
No personal experience, but here is a clip that surprised me. (http://fr.youtube.com/watch?v=Mx4QVouu8qI)
-
I tried one once at the Music Room and if I was to play an accordion I'm sure it would be one of these. From memory though, I thought the first and fifth rows were the helper ones not the fourth and fifth.
Melodeons rule though :P
-
Probably the most logical sqeezebox of the lot a lot & easier to learn to finger than a piano accordion as less travel involved so perhaps a better bet for a would be piano accordion player with no piano type keybord experience. Come in 3 , 4 or 5 rows (C system) and some B system have 6 rows. Everything playa ble on outside 3 rows the 2 inside rows being duplicates of the two outside rows. French favour 4 rows.
With 5 rows all major keys can be played using exactly same fingering, just starting somewhere different but learning on 3 rows preferable. 4th or 5th rows can by useful to simplify some tricky fingering in much the same way as the 3rd row can be used on a British Chromatic.
george
-
No personal experience, but here is a clip that surprised me. (http://fr.youtube.com/watch?v=Mx4QVouu8qI)
Can anyone distinguish what the make of the accordion is?
-
Are there any members who have experience of a CBA-C system, and if so, what are their impressions?
Thanks
I have one (two, actually; one is in a music shop waiting to be sold). George has summed it up very well in his post above. It's a very logical layout - 1 1/2 tones between buttons along the row, 1 tone on one diagonal, 1/2 tone on the other diagonal. Also has advantage of Stradella bass (or free bass on some models).
Since it's not really a melodeon subject, if you have some specific queries, please feel free to PM or email me (see profile).
-
What about this hybrid than? Seems to make the best of both worlds.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sWXIBH7T1gc&feature=related
-
What about this hybrid than? Seems to make the best of both worlds.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sWXIBH7T1gc&feature=related
Aha! That's actually a just a 3 row CBA... disguised to look like a piano box... all the black notes are duds/fake, and you can see the outer two rows...
But why disguised? Goodness knows... there are quite a few of these old boxes out there... guess it must have looked cooler to play a piano box, perhaps?
Ed J
-
Or maybe a PA that’s been converted to a CBA and the PA keys were left in situ out of convenience.
In fact, having had a second look, it appears the white PA keys are somewhat shorter than would normally be the case.
-
Or maybe a PA that's been converted to a CBA and the PA keys were left in situ out of convenience.
Nope - this was definitely built this way. Just to look this way.
Ed J
( ;D...editid faw speling... ;D)
-
Is definately stronger than definitely? Just asking ;)
-
Reminds me... there are also melodeons made to look like piano accordions.
Ruth Askew has a few in her huge collection - 11 white keys, 10 black keys, arranged as with a two row. And I'm fairly sure I saw one on the front of a CD of the Flanagan Brothers (photo taken c1920s).
So the piano box aesthetic must have been fairly pervasive...
Ed J
-
Or maybe a PA that’s been converted to a CBA and the PA keys were left in situ out of convenience.
Nope - this was definitely built this way. Just to look this way.
Ed J
( ;D...editid faw speling... ;D)
What makes you so sure?
-
What makes you so sure?
I've seen them before.
Rebuilding one of these from a piano accordion is physically impossible - the reed blocks serving the accidentals are spaced in twos and threes, as are the holes in the soundboard, and the mechanics "fan" out to fit the wide keyboard geometry. Totally different machine altogether...
I found some links to a Swedish museum collection...
(Apparently the Swedes call these machines a "fintocromo")
Bertone (http://www.karlssonsmusik.se/mm_dragspel_3.html)
Ranco (http://www.karlssonsmusik.se/mm_dragspel_7.html)
Skandia (http://www.karlssonsmusik.se/mm_dragspel_9.html)
Skandia (http://www.karlssonsmusik.se/mm_dragspel_10.html)
Aquila (http://www.karlssonsmusik.se/mm_dragspel_18.html)
Ed J
-
What makes you so sure?
I've seen them before.
Rebuilding one of these from a piano accordion is physically impossible - the reed blocks serving the accidentals are spaced in twos and threes, as are the holes in the soundboard, and the mechanics "fan" out to fit the wide keyboard geometry. Totally different machine altogether...
I found some links to a Swedish museum collection...
(Apparently the Swedes call these machines a "fintocromo")
Bertone (http://www.karlssonsmusik.se/mm_dragspel_3.html)
Ranco (http://www.karlssonsmusik.se/mm_dragspel_7.html)
Skandia (http://www.karlssonsmusik.se/mm_dragspel_9.html)
Skandia (http://www.karlssonsmusik.se/mm_dragspel_10.html)
Aquila (http://www.karlssonsmusik.se/mm_dragspel_18.html)
Ed J
Thanks EeeJay, I am enlightened.
-
Looking at those with buttons and a piano keyboard it struck me that the white piano keys are the first helper row and the black keys (with similar sized keys coloured white in the gap between the 2 group and three group black keys) is the second helper row. Is this correct?
-
Looking at those with buttons and a piano keyboard it struck me that the white piano keys are the first helper row and the black keys (with similar sized keys coloured white in the gap between the 2 group and three group black keys) is the second helper row. Is this correct?
Yes - apart from the first one (Bertone), where the black notes seem just for show.
Like Larry said... the white keys are made shorter to fit the geometry of the button keyboard - which is even more important if the black keys are acting as a helper row.
The guy on YouTube cites Pietro Frosini as an influence - here's his picture, complete with "fintocromo"...
(http://www.ksanti.net/free-reed/images/reviews/cds/pietrofrosini.jpg)
Ed J
-
the idea of trying to make one type of box look like another was used by the brilliant British Chromatic player, Will Starr. He had a fourth (inside) row of dummy buttons on one of his Shand Morinos to make it look like a continental chromatic!
george
-
There is also the chromatic that looks like a diatonic...
Like this one:
Celtique (http://cgi.ebay.fr/Accordeon-chromatique-Hohner-Celtique-Look-son-diato_W0QQitemZ330150587295QQihZ014QQcategoryZ104652QQtcZphotoQQcmdZViewItem)
-
There is also the chromatic that looks like a diatonic...
Like this one:
Celtique (http://cgi.ebay.fr/Accordeon-chromatique-Hohner-Celtique-Look-son-diato_W0QQitemZ330150587295QQihZ014QQcategoryZ104652QQtcZphotoQQcmdZViewItem)
Well, that "look" has been around for ages. Look at the old Soprani 3, 4 and 5 row diatonics from 1900-1930. They also featured wooden bodies, open stepped keyboards and stradella bass layout. Although the plastic-fantastic CBA design has been in favour since, that look is old, and was the common of the time.
Regarding the 'fintocromo', I've seen quite a few of them at accordion festivals here in scandinavia - especially when I once visited northern Sweden. And yes, they sound AMAZING. They have the sound of a blowtorch, without being screamy. I saw a Scandia once (aren't they swedish-made?), and it was a truely magnificent sound. Just yank the bellows, and it roars (in the nice way).
-
No personal experience, but here is a clip that surprised me. (http://fr.youtube.com/watch?v=Mx4QVouu8qI)
Why did it surprise you, Theo? Packs a punch, doesn't it? I sometimes wonder about a CBA but I just have to think of the weight of the things to cure any temptation.
The fellow was asking for hints on improving his playing on thesession.org btw. I hope risto has noticed that (as far as I can see) he uses only three fingers... :P
-
I hope risto has noticed that (as far as I can see) he uses only three fingers... :P
No, he uses four fingers, have a look at his pinkie.
-
No personal experience, but here is a clip that surprised me. (http://fr.youtube.com/watch?v=Mx4QVouu8qI)
Why did it surprise you, Theo?
Because the few times I've seen a CBA the players seem to like playing quite formal, almost classical arrangements with lots of lush chords, left hand counter melodies (one was a freebass) and while there were lots of things going and it was technically accomplished playing there was not much life in the music.
-
No, he uses four fingers, have a look at his pinkie.
Well, I was!
-
Because the few times I've seen a CBA the players seem to like playing quite formal, almost classical arrangements with lots of lush chords, left hand counter melodies (one was a freebass) and while there were lots of things going and it was technically accomplished playing there was not much life in the music.
I looked at a number of YouTube performances of La Noyée played on diatonic boxes. (The tune was used in a public television promotional spot here in the states.) For sheer musicality, this version played on a CBA blows away all of the others.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FRb3SIvV6ZY
FWIW, it looks like a B-system instrument.
-
.... I hope risto has noticed that (as far as I can see) he uses only three fingers... :P
Didn't pay attention to that at the time (as I was more interested in what the accordion was. On our local site it was recognized to be 'Accordiola') but now I have, and yes, what I can see it looks like if he's using just three fingers. Btw, I'v heard that the French players using four row accordions commonly keep the thumb on the edge of the keyboard like diatonic accordion players do. Can anyone confirm?
Is that a C or B system accordion?
EDIT: He also seems to have no use for the fourth inside row....
-
I looked at a number of YouTube performances of La Noyée played on diatonic boxes. (The tune was used in a public television promotional spot here in the states.) For sheer musicality, this version played on a CBA blows away all of the others.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FRb3SIvV6ZY
FWIW, it looks like a B-system instrument.
Yes - I found this clip a few weeks ago and I agree it is the best of the bunch by a long way (and she is indeed playing a B-system).
However, there is also a quite good version played on a D/G melodeon here:
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=eGFXXE-ZpyU&feature=related
-
Is that a C or B system accordion?
If the accordion has black buttons for accidentals, it's easy to tell...
When looking at the keyboard in a horizontal position, if the black buttons rise up the rows from left to right it's a B system; if the black buttons descend the rows from left to right, it's a C system.
If the accordion has all white buttons, you can't tell just by looking!
-
The ultimate heresy on this forum ? ;)
At 55, I reckon I'm too old now to learn new tricks, but if I were to have my time over again, I would want to play the CBA. It's a fantastic instrument! :)
-
If the accordion has all white buttons, you can't tell just by looking!
many 'all white' continentals have a thin black line on the top edge of the 'black' buttons facing up towards so that only the driver can see them.
george
-
If the accordion has all white buttons, you can't tell just by looking!
Did I need to be told that. ;)
Someone who plays well one or the other system will recognize the fingering patterns and can tell.
-
I looked at a number of YouTube performances of La Noyée played on diatonic boxes. (The tune was used in a public television promotional spot here in the states.) For sheer musicality, this version played on a CBA blows away all of the others.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FRb3SIvV6ZY
FWIW, it looks like a B-system instrument.
Yes - I found this clip a few weeks ago and I agree it is the best of the bunch by a long way (and she is indeed playing a B-system).
However, there is also a quite good version played on a D/G melodeon here:
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=eGFXXE-ZpyU&feature=related
Well its interesting how our tastes differ. The diatonic version appeals to me more than the CBA. I agree that the CBA player is more technically accomplished but I still get a little something indefinable from the diatonic player that I don't get from the CBA. Not trying to criticise others musical preferences, or convince anybody to agree with me. :D
-
The ultimate heresy on this forum ? ;)
At 55, I reckon I'm too old now to learn new tricks,...
I'm soon 54 and just got from stringed instruments to melodeons which is a much deeper conversion. You all ready have the dextrity. I started a second masters degree in the university in 2005 with some other fellas of the same age and right from the start we were doing better than the youngsters.
-
I still think he’s using four fingers.
-
I've looked at quite a lot of CBA-players (standard, besides the PA here in Denmark), and from what I've been told, the 'not using thumb' was popular about 40-50 years ago. Thus, many of the players learning back then would use that system when learning from records or other players. Carl Erik Lundgaard Jensen, one of the finest traditional players of CBA in the Danish style once told me, that it was merely a matter of fashion when he started.
BUT: I've also noticed a different style. Those using the thumb tend to play "heavier", and painting a darker image of the music, because the thumb often is a bit slower in movement than the others, and naturally being situated a note or two lower than the other 4 on the keyboard. Those players I know who almost never, or indeed never, use thumb on the CBA have quite a more light sound to them.
Any other opinions on this, although we as melodeonists would think of using the thumb as quite ackward.
-
The ultimate heresy on this forum ? ;)
At 55, I reckon I'm too old now to learn new tricks, but if I were to have my time over again, I would want to play the CBA. It's a fantastic instrument! :)
I’ve had my three score years and ten but I’m still happy to learn a new instrument, currently a G/C/F, and if I could find a CBA to suit my pocket I would buy one. I take great pleasure in learning new things.
-
The ultimate heresy on this forum ? ;)
At 55, I reckon I'm too old now to learn new tricks, but if I were to have my time over again, I would want to play the CBA. It's a fantastic instrument! :)
Steve,
You're the youngest looking guy on the site. (Sorry Pip). You have played woodwinds to a high standard. You then took up bellows-blown-gob-irons and achieved fame in that genre. Now if a no-nothing twit like me can take up melodeon at 68, flute and tenor saxophone at 69 and flügelhorn at 70, you will have no problems with a Continental or British Chromatic. (I had to put in the Brit bit so George doesn't come looking for me.)
Go for it teenager and stop running yourself down. Let others have a go and ignore them.
Wish I had a tenth of your talent.
Old Bill.
-
I’ve had my three score years and ten but I’m still happy to learn a new instrument, currently a G/C/F, and if I could find a CBA to suit my pocket I would buy one. I take great pleasure in learning new things.
It just so happens I've got one to sell. I demurred from posting it in the Buy and Sell forum here since it's not a melodeon but since this thread's about them, here goes. It's one of these:
http://www.jimlaabs.com/scripts/prodView.asp?idproduct=6121
which was where I got it from, it's black, B system with case and straps. It's had very little use, I don't have time to play all my boxes, hence the sale. I'm open to offers, and I'm in Hampshire (UK) if anyone wants to try it out.
-
I’ve had my three score years and ten but I’m still happy to learn a new instrument, currently a G/C/F, and if I could find a CBA to suit my pocket I would buy one. I take great pleasure in learning new things.
It just so happens I've got one to sell. I demurred from posting it in the Buy and Sell forum here since it's not a melodeon but since this thread's about them, here goes. It's one of these:
http://www.jimlaabs.com/scripts/prodView.asp?idproduct=6121
which was where I got it from, it's black, B system with case and straps. It's had very little use, I don't have time to play all my boxes, hence the sale. I'm open to offers, and I'm in Hampshire (UK) if anyone wants to try it out.
I’m interested. Could you e-mail me with some sort of idea how much you are looking for and maybe we can get together.
-
Since there seems to be some interest in CBA's among our members, I've posted info on the 5-row 120 bass C system Excelsior I have for sale in our "For Sale" section:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,265.0.html (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,265.0.html)
-
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,265.0.html (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,265.0.html)
Can you tell about the Roland FR-3sb, I have been wondering about that for some time now. There is also the lighter model FR-2 without internal speakers.
-
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,265.0.html (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,265.0.html)
Can you tell about the Roland FR-3sb, I have been wondering about that for some time now. There is also the lighter model FR-2 without internal speakers.
Yes, I could write a book about it, if I had time. Fortunately Roland has already done so. Start here:
http://www.roland.co.uk/accordion_room_catdet.asp?ID=FR3B (http://www.roland.co.uk/accordion_room_catdet.asp?ID=FR3B). You can download the Owner's manual as a .pdf for a lot of info, or get summarised info on the website. Use the drop-down menu to get info on the FR-2. There may well be a Roland Finland website - worth checking.
(Yes, just found it :http://www.roland.fi/product.asp?id=169&productid=1336 (http://www.roland.fi/product.asp?id=169&productid=1336))
There is also a very active Roland V-accordion group on Yahoo: http://launch.groups.yahoo.com/group/rolandv-accordions/?yguid=195349173 (http://launch.groups.yahoo.com/group/rolandv-accordions/?yguid=195349173)
(Sorry, I've forgotten how to do these URLs as short coloured words).
Once you've had a look at Roland's information, if you have any specific questions about the FR-3sb, send me a PM/email and I'll try to help.
-
Once you've had a look at Roland's information, if you have any specific questions about the FR-3sb, send me a PM/email and I'll try to help.
Bill I have read those before, I was actually interested in your personal opinion, are you pleased with it?
-
I’m interested. Could you e-mail me with some sort of idea how much you are looking for and maybe we can get together.
Larry, I've sent you a Personal Message.
-
Once you've had a look at Roland's information, if you have any specific questions about the FR-3sb, send me a PM/email and I'll try to help.
Bill I have read those before, I was actually interested in your personal opinion, are you pleased with it?
Sorry, I misunderstood your original question.
Yes, I'm very pleased with the Roland FR-3sb. Points I like:
Silent practice with headphones.
Size and weight - only marginally bigger than, but lighter than, my Paolo Soprani 3-row.
Ten different accordion simulations (which change both treble and bass reed sounds) to chose from; within each, 12 treble and 7 bass register settings (there are 10 treble couplers, but 2 of them have 2 settings). Of course, I don't use nearly all of them. For my type of music I'm mostly using the German (Hohner Morino) or French (Maugein) settings, to get a nice-sounding Scottish musette setting. The musette tuning offset can be varied in 15 steps from 0 to rather more than I like - funnily enough, this is the setting described as "Scottish".
Battery operation is good - about 3 hours from a set of 10 2700mAh NiMh AA batteries. I have a spare battery holder with another 10 ready charged - changeover is about a minute. 2800mAh batteries are also available, from our favourite Guernsey supplier (7dayshop.com), and chargers at a good price. I hardly ever bother to use the mains adapter.
Some of the built in orchestral sounds are useful. The string bass is good, and the tuba bass with flute over accordion treble sounds good for Tyrolean tunes.
Treble and bass outputs are available for connection to an amplifier. The instrument probably sounds better through good headphones or a good amplifier than through the built-in speakers, though they are adequate for a small space. The on-board amp is less powerful than in the "big brother" FR-7.
MIDI out for bass and treble to attach to an expander unit. I have an older Roland RA-90 expander, but I just can't find the time at present to get to grips with the whole outfit.
I'm not using anything like the complete set of features available on the FR-3sb, but I'm sure that most users will settle on a sub-set that suits whatever they want to play.
The only con - the treble button diameter is probably a little smaller than on a full-size acoustic instrument. It doesn't seem to give me a problem, however.
So, for the equivalent of about €2000 you get a 4-voice treble, 5-voice 120 bass instrument, compact size, light weight, 10 different accordion settings, orchestral sounds built in, amplifier out, MIDI out. And a 3-year warranty.
-
Yes, I'm very pleased with the Roland FR-3sb. Points I like:
Bill, thanks for the detailed post. A couple of things, do you think it could be used for Irish music and how do you rate the feel of the keyboard compared to acoustic accordions? On our local accordion site there are divided opinions, some are using Rolands in live gigs and praise them while others just don't like them, like with the Strebs on this site.
-
Yes, I'm very pleased with the Roland FR-3sb. Points I like:
Bill, thanks for the detailed post. A couple of things, do you think it could be used for Irish music and how do you rate the feel of the keyboard compared to acoustic accordions? On our local accordion site there are divided opinions, some are using Rolands in live gigs and praise them while others just don't like them, like with the Strebs on this site.
I like the keyboard just fine - nothing wrong with near instantaneous response. I'm not aware of any great difference when going from the Paolo Soprani to the Roland.
You've probably seen the video of Uwe Steger playing a piece on a Jupiter Bayan (considered the best) and the same piece on a Roland (plus another piece). It's here:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9jfJJOdWsAQ (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9jfJJOdWsAQ).
As for Irish music - the Roland button accordion could be used for anything a piano accordion can do. Here's the same chap with a light-hearted Irish piece: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZnRYdMWuSCw (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZnRYdMWuSCw).
You should try to get your hands on one for a demo.
-
...Uwe Steger playing a piece on a Jupiter Bayan (considered the best) and the same piece on a Roland .
I'm speachless, that is from another planet. :o
EDIT: The small size FR-2b is interesting. These can probably be progammed to any diatonic accordion layouts as well, the extra rows wouldn't hurt.
-
I'm a bit of a musical wanderer--string player for 35 years (virtually all but viola and cello), drums, sax, concertina...
I've long searched for the "perfect" instrument--meaning, the most expressive, best sounding, most utilitarian.. As guitar is my first instrument, and of course it is most versatile, it will always be my "backup." The past couple of years i've chosen fiddle. But since I am only a fiddle layer and not a violin player, it is a limited instrument in my hands.
Lately, I've taken to playing for contra dances. One does not want to fiddle for dances--at least I don't, as it's an awful lot of work.. Additionally, I have become smitten with squeezeboxes: I have a few concertinas and a few PA, but what I really wanted was a two row. But since I've been unable to find one in D/A, I just recently lucked into a used CBA C-griff. This, I feel, is the "perfect" instrument: it assuages my taste for EC--which I struggle with as it immobilizes the pinkys, and has stradella bass. I have no experience with CBA, but I anticipate that it will be consonant with my expectations :)
-
One does not want to fiddle for dances--at least I don't, as it's an awful lot of work..
:o
Being primarily a fiddle-player, doing plenty of playing both for ceilidhs and step-dancers I'm highly intrigued!
You wouldn't care to elaborate?
Tom
-
Other than upright, fiddle playing requires (for me anyway ) the most large muscle movement than any other instrument (I take that back--flamenco guitar is probably my most vigorous besides upright). Not to mention the stricture of the most static posture of probably ALL non-wind instruments...YMMV
Realize, that i with that sweeping generalization, am not dissing fiddles (how could one? :-[) and am only speaking for myself and my elderly fiddle playing partner who was worn out after playing his last four-hour dance... Myself, I would rather arm myself with a loud squeezebox to keep a floor full of people happily moving :D...
-
Fair enough! :D
Tom
-
There is Squeezbox newsgroup, that is still alive, and this kind of question is better asked there.
There are a bunch of professional players still there.
For you "melodeon" players (boy, are you English oriented), a CBA is Continental Button Accordion as oppose to BCA or British Chromatic Accordion (although it is not official, because the World at large can't care less about Shand system).
They came in about the same time, and in all three possibilities, B, C and another one.
OOOOOOOOOO - C note - B system
OOOOOOOOOO
OOOOOOOOOO
OOOOOOOOOO
OOOOOOOOOO - C note - another one
OOOOOOOOOO
OOOOOOOOOO
OOOOOOOOO
OOOOOOOOOO - C note - C system
They all are the same basically and none is better nor worse, and the Russian system is not any stranger than German, as they are the same and one.
Russian free bass may be a little different, because it descends from down-up on the left and contunues from top-down on the right. But it's more logical than German free bass, where both sides mirror each other.
It is incorrect to assume that CBA is any easier to learn than PA, as PA has nice and simple linear system, and CBA is "3-dimentional", which often throws your keyboard orientation off, as there is no tangible anchors to find where you are by the feel. The distance between the tones may matter only for proffessional players, competing in those strange Accordion Championships, where speed is the king.
It does seem like your fingers have to travel a bit in zig-zaggy manner, so it helps to start young. A DBB is easier in this regard, I find, but adds unfathomable for some people necessity for left hand push/pull precision.
And DBB is less capable of smooth moody music, and almost ridiculous when classical piece is attempted.
So, for each - it's own, off course.
-
Interesting CBA currently on eBay Australia, http://cgi.ebay.com.au/Co-operativa-Accordion-C-System-Button-Accordian_W0QQitemZ330224023350QQihZ014QQcategoryZ308QQssPageNameZWDVWQQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem (http://cgi.ebay.com.au/Co-operativa-Accordion-C-System-Button-Accordian_W0QQitemZ330224023350QQihZ014QQcategoryZ308QQssPageNameZWDVWQQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem)
MC
-
There is Squeezbox newsgroup, that is still alive, and this kind of question is better asked there.
There are a bunch of professional players still there.
The Squeezebox newsgroup is a bit limited, and is inhabited by at least one troll. Better is the Yahoo Group AccordionFreedomForum (http://launch.groups.yahoo.com/group/AccordionFreedomForum/) with 1800+ members.
A DBB is easier in this regard, I find, but adds unfathomable for some people necessity for left hand push/pull precision.
And DBB is less capable of smooth moody music, and almost ridiculous when classical piece is attempted.
So, for each - it's own, off course.
What's a DBB?
-
[
What's a DBB?
[/quote]
Quite! -- I can't understand the need for 'coded' descriptions when plain English would be fine & understood by all. Similarly I have difficulty in understanding why some individuals need 'code names' when most are quite happy to say who they are- I will now take cover!
egroeg
-
"Don't you just hate TLAs?"
(Three letter acronyms.)
Though technically, they're not acronyms, (I'm told.)
Presumably Diatonic Button Box?
If we're talking about PA and CBA, presumably DBA would be more "logical"
I didn't understand the rows of Os, (but I'm not sure I need to.)
Tom
-
"Don't you just hate TLAs?"
(Three letter acronyms.)
Though technically, they're not acronyms, (I'm told.)
[Pedant]
Acronyms are pronounceable as a word - NATO, AIDS etc
Initialisms are pronounced as leters - CBA, DBB
There are, of course, acronym–initialism hybrids such as JPEG and MS-DOS
[/Pedant]
There I feel better now
-
[quote , they're not acronyms, (I'm told.)
Presumably Diatonic Button Box?
quite likely its detractors (i.e. them who can't play one) would see it as standing for diabolical button box
george
-
What's a DBB?
Quite! -- I can't understand the need for 'coded' descriptions when plain English would be fine & understood by all. Similarly I have difficulty in understanding why some individuals need 'code names' when most are quite happy to say who they are- I will now take cover!
egroeg
George,
You know who I am and where I live, it's just I don't want the Police to.
Old Bill.
post script:-I signed on with the new board before Theo, who also knows who and where, posted the normal name request.
BTW we all know who you really are, Osama. ;D
-
AC - Anglo Concertina
EC - English Concetina
CBA - Chromatic Button Accordion or Continental Button Accordion
PA - Piano Accordion
DBB - Diatonic Button Box.
It's just simpler to quickly type those than long words, that are always the same: "Accordion", "Diatonic"...
Rows of OOOO are simply buttons in three rows.
PA, DBA are middle C oriented, so it's position indicates the "system".
Three row give three possibilities for placing the middle C, so we have three systems.
Those CBAs with piano keys are made out of necessity, Button Accordions were more widely used before Guerrini Brothers in San Francisco created Piano Accordion, still used today, with 41 key and 120 Stradella basses.
Then PA became all the rage and for CBA players it has become difficult to land a gig, they lacked the desired look.
So these instruments were inteded to fool the public. There actually are hybrids, having both systems in one instrument, but most are CBAs in PA disguize. Many have buttons in the shape of square piano keys.
But why this discussion here, on DBB forum?
There are many other forums, where players of PA and CBA of any systems are happyly congregate. They have what to share, great ans wonderful music, compositions and performances are abundant, DBAs are more oriented towards amatieurs. But they are closer to tradition, more fun, easier to learn, at least on the beginner's level, and mostly used for folk music, which is simpler and more inclusive. I have excellent book by Gary Dahl, "Harmony Application", applicable for PA, CBA and any kind of chromatic instrument, capable of harmony playing, but the amount of work and excercises in it just astounding. And it will make you a beginner! If you didn't start young and don'g have extraordinary talent, good teachers and time - go with Diatonic.
-
DBAs are more oriented...
I think everyone understands and concedes initials (or acronyms ::)) to denote various boxes...but why employ different terms (DBB and DBA) for presumably the same class of instrument?--which, I believe, was the question...
-
Does it present a dilemma of any worth, to call an instrument Diatonic Button Accordion or Diatonic Button Box?
-
Does it present a dilemma of any worth, to call an instrument Diatonic Button Accordion or Diatonic Button Box?
I feel that the instruments that we all claim to be so fond of are worthy of their full title rather than mere initialisms, in much the same way as most pilots refer to their flying machines as 'aeroplanes' rather than just 'planes'. Whether we call them diatonic buton boxes, diatonic accordeons, melodeons or whatever is of less importance. It also saves confusion between e.g anglo concertinas and arsole creepers!.
george
-
I feel that the instruments that we all claim to be so fond of are worthy of their full title rather than mere initialisms, in much the same way as most pilots refer to their flying machines as 'aeroplanes' rather than just 'planes'. Whether we call them diatonic buton boxes, diatonic accordeons, melodeons or whatever is of less importance. It also saves confusion between e.g anglo concertinas and arsole creepers!.
It's been tried once on Squeezebox newsgroup a few years ago. No avail. Some PA players got frustrated. The problem was, as I see it, that they weren't aware of the many types of accordions still in existence, and felt that the wold "Accordion" has been hyjacked, and replaced with some DBB, CBA, "squeezbox" derogatories.
The derogatories still here and will remain. old PA players are dying out and new coming in. DBB players are a picturesque bunch, but less high brow, AC players complain to the prices, EC players ask about those pinkies - life goes on. Not to worry. If you feel like typing long sencentces (like I do) - go ahead and enjoy yourself, others may feel different.
I don't think an instrument deserves anything as such, just like guns don't kill, people do.
And I have never heard people say: "David Oistrakh plays fiddle", or that "Ricardo Tesi plays button box".
Respect comes in it's due time.
-
Does it present a dilemma of any worth, to call an instrument Diatonic Button Accordion or Diatonic Button Box?
Only inasmuch as I didn't know to which instrument you referred, if that counts..
-
Does it present a dilemma of any worth, to call an instrument Diatonic Button Accordion or Diatonic Button Box?
I feel that the instruments that we all claim to be so fond of are worthy of their full title rather than mere initialisms, in much the same way as most pilots refer to their flying machines as 'aeroplanes' rather than just 'planes'. Whether we call them diatonic buton boxes, diatonic accordeons, melodeons or whatever is of less importance. It also saves confusion between e.g anglo concertinas and arsole creepers!.
george
Spot on George - good for you, Marrer.
In any case I think this thread is getting 2BS4Ws.
Thinks: I wonder why this website is called 'melodeon.net' ? What can it mean?
-
Ha ha ha! :D TVFI Steve.
Rum tee tum tee tiddly tum, rum tee tiddly tie doh ..................
Who needs words anyway? ???
-
I wonder why this website is called 'melodeon.net' ? What can it mean?
You are absolutely right, accept the question was about CBA, and why not discuss it here as well, esp. when CBA's cousin, British Chromatic is considered a "Melodeon".
I'd like to add that "Melodeon" as British name for push/pull diatonic accordion is very cool, but not common, so we should accept any denominations of the instrument, and in some cultures it's even called "Concertina", of all names.
To Larry's original question about CBA C system.
Me and my friend played with both, B and C systems. I chose B, and he - C. His point was that C is "Thumbs friendly" and is more natural for Piano player, such as my friend. I felt that C is "Upside-down" and B felt more natural. I even hired a teacher and spent 5 years studying it, but unfortunately, in the midst of tenchnical excercises we have forgotten about the reason, and I didn't feel moved or motivated by the chosen music. My teacher was incapable of changing the standard accordion repertory, and insisted that first I have to "learn to play", then I'll play anything I want. We had to part and to repair the damage to my playing I went back to Diatonic, but this time with accidental row - Hohner Overture.
My experience is that with CBA you can play anything, but not anytime.
It is also not very suitable for folk, as diatonic accordion is set up so it's easy to pick the simple tune and accompaniment. Such accompaniment will include some jumping on the Stradella. Push/pulling also gives quick chord change - very cool feature of DBB.
-
perhaps a separate section entitled something like 'other types of sqeezebox' would be appropriate for the inevitable occasional mention/discussion of concertinas, continental and piano accordions & of course mouthies. The free reed family have greater commonalities than differences and a great deal of joint 'family history' and of course there are many melnetters who play to a greater of lesser degree other free reed instruments.
Even the 'melodeon' thing covers diatonic button accordions as most of the rest of the world call them and of course the British Chromatic which is also roughly speaking diatonic! but is also as chromatic as is anything else that is chromatic. - then there is the one row which to some is the only type of box called a melodeon but which to others is just an accordion.
just a thought (or two)
george
-
Someone here asked how to recognize two systems. I can distinguish them from the first look, it's very easy. I use this simple trick: B has three white buttons in the outer row, while C has them in the inner row. If three whites are inside then it's Finnish.
-
Mine has all white buttons.
-
and some have all white buttons with crafty black lines on the chinmost edge of the ''black'' buttons that are only visible to the player if he has a quick gander down at the keyboard
george
-
Some CBA accordions have the F and C buttons serrated so you can feel them even if you can't see them.
-
A wee example of our 5 Row Chromatic....