Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Recordings and Videos => Topic started by: BobM on September 29, 2020, 07:39:52 PM
-
This is so well played..
An interesting use of thumb on the accidentals as well.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NFYIONrQZTA
This pieces is in E min on a G/C box, but she's playing a B bass in the LH?
-
;D thank you for posting the link, a lovely tune beautifully played 🎶😄👍
-
This is so well played..
An interesting use of thumb on the accidentals as well.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NFYIONrQZTA
This pieces is in E min on a G/C box, but she's playing a B bass in the LH?
Finnish keyboard configured to play in Em.
Not your "stock" G/C.
She is quite good. I think Dia Tonic (Kim Risberg) has a video of that piece as well.
Edit:
https://youtu.be/kwzuBFvOlpI
Stock G/C, played in Am.
Edit:
One more on the Finnish system, more basses.
https://youtu.be/GR6DesJwSFw
-
She's so understated in her playing, dead relaxed while so lovely playing happening. Impressive.
I remember George Garside of this parish talks about using the thumb for the chin end accudentals.
I've tried it but simply can't!
I use my thumb to firmly anchor the box and as a reference point for my hand. If I take it off the side of the keyboard, to me it feels like I have a wobbly box!! I loose that firm feeling abd reference point, despite being a two strapper.
I've got used to regularly using the chin end accidentals with my first finger and rotating my hand to pop up to them. Works for me despite having very small hands.
But we are all different.....
Q
-
Definitely learning this tune. It would help if anyone has the dots, including chords. I have just so much work on at school to work it out. But I will if no-one has it to hand.
Pete
-
Found it on a previous thread.
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=16229.0
-
That is so good. Might have to transpose it - could really do with that low D# on the half row.
Maybe learning Polska could be the next lockdown project...
J
-
I've just printed off the dots after putting it into D.
Looks like a good accidentals workout (:)
Haven't tried it on the box yet....
-
But is 3 the right time signature for this, or is it more subtle than that?
-
But is 3 the right time signature for this, or is it more subtle than that?
Yes. It is a 16th note polska, one of the many variants of polskor sorted by their interior rhythmic structure.
-
But is 3 the right time signature for this, or is it more subtle than that?
The Bass is on beats one and three, and chords on the quaver "ands", and I'd write it out in 3/4, no messing'.
(That is, if I HAD to.. )
-
Having somewhat cavalierly said ' I've transposed it into D...' I've tried it this morning.
I'm still unwrapping my fingers ;D
Keeping it in Em but up an octave looks to be a bit more sensible for those in DG land with a sense of adventure ;)
You still might need to iron your fingers afterwards ::)
Just goes to show that the 'G' of a GC is an octave lower than the 'G' on our DG's.
I should have remembered that before transposing!
Good luck peeps!
Q
-
I've been trying it an octave higher, in Em, on my D/G Dony. A few weeks of effort might be required ! But one question - should the final note in bar 2 (and bar 6) be D# or Dnat ?
Expert ear required to confirm...
J
-
I don't know about expert ear, but the implied harmony at that point is taking it to the relative major - so the melody fits a D chord (leading to G) - therefore a D natural.
-
I don't know about expert ear, but the implied harmony at that point is taking it to the relative major - so the melody fits a D chord (leading to G) - therefore a D natural.
I thought so ! Many thanks !
Julian
-
Julian and I were chatting about this earlier today.
I'd assumed it would have followed the rule that the first D in the bar is sharpened and so should this one. I didn't realise it wasn't necessarily a given rule.
Thanks p&t, I've learnt something else!
( and Julian and I have an answer to our question! )
Cheers
Q
-
It is a given rule that the sharp applies to the whole bar, but that assumes that the person transcribing it remembered what they meant to write. I think it's just an oversight.
-
Oh ok....thanks.
-
What about the pesky B chord, is this doable on a D/G then?
Bob.
-
If it's saying 'B' then I just press the B bass button and see how it sounds.
Adding the B chord can sound ok, sometimes too much so I might leave it out and just play the B bass with no chord.
'Depends' is my answer!
For Bm then I cross chord and press the B bass and D chord which gives us a 'rough' Bm .
-
If it's saying 'B' then I just press the B bass button and see how it sounds.
Adding the B chord can sound ok, sometimes too much so I might leave it out and just play the B bass with no chord.
'Depends' is my answer!
For Bm then I cross chord and press the B bass and D chord which gives us a 'rough' Bm .
So it's playable on D/G but in a higher octave?
-
Yes, it's just a B or Bm whatever the octave.
But.... remember we can't play it as it's written in the link to the score.
That is in Em, but.... the scale of G on a GC ( what she's playing ) is an octave lower then our DG 'G' scale.
If you move the notes up an octave then we can play it on our DG's.
-
If it's saying 'B' then I just press the B bass button and see how it sounds.
Adding the B chord can sound ok, sometimes too much so I might leave it out and just play the B bass with no chord.
'Depends' is my answer!
For Bm then I cross chord and press the B bass and D chord which gives us a 'rough' Bm .
So it's playable on D/G but in a higher octave?
I posted a link earlier with two more examples, one of which is in Am on a G/C box.
-
I think Dia Tonic (Kim Risberg) has a video of that piece as well.
https://youtu.be/kwzuBFvOlpI
Stock G/C, played in Am.
That's lovely. Wish I had a pull G# for a version like that -with the substitute chords too.
-
I shall happily admire this performance from a distance.. 8)
-
Do on a D/G, it seems like if you've got a push D# you can do 'high' E minor (it's not that high honestly, I think a 2v would be ok), but if you have a middle pull G#, you could do A minor? (edit, and a 3rds stop, obviously)
Something like this for Am?
X:1
T:Haudanmann Haapolska
M:3/4
L:1/16
P:AABB
Q:1/4=108
K:G % (Written in G to highlight accidentals, but, is basically in A minor)
P:A
|:"Am"E2F^G A2Bc "Dm"dcBA | "E"^GABc B2d2 "G"d2B=G|
"C"cBcd e=fed "Dm"ccBA | [1 "E"^GABc BAGF G2E2:|\
[2 "E"^GABG "Am"A4 A4 ||
P:B
|:"C"e2GF G2e2 "Em"(3e=fe dc| "G"d>edB GGBc "E"d2B2 |
"Am"cBcd e=fed "Dm"ccBA | [1 "E"^GABc BAGF G2E2:|\
[2 "E"^GABG "Am"A4 A4 |]
You wouldn't normally have the F chord but I mean idk it doesn't seem like a grand casualty with D5 as Dm picking up the slack?
-
I've just had a go at this using the sheet music in the other thread. After humming it all morning I just had to!
I really like it and it fits well on my box played in low Emin.
I'm only missing a pull low B (the first note) and have to hit a G or B bass note instead. I will have a E bass note eventually and that should really make it.
Otherwise everything runs really nicely, apart from my hesitant playing.
-
This is so well played..
An interesting use of thumb on the accidentals as well.
Wow, yes, beautiful playing! I hadn't thought of placing the thumb up further on the edge so it's right there for the chromatic! The normal place for my thumb is lower on the edge so I have to move further to get to the accidentals.Thanks for posting!
-
I'm sure in another post somewhere fairly recently, another Scandinavian player was using their thumb for accidentals on a 2 row box which drew comments.
Another person on the thread said it was a common usage of the thumb for larger 5 row beasties.
The best advice is to try it and see.
I find I loose control of the box so I opt for the thumb on the keyboard edge and roll up my little finger for the accudentals.
But we're all different!
Q
-
The fiddle version is interesting. I don't know much about polskas but the first notes seem to slow before getting back to speed. Is this part of the dance step?
https://youtu.be/OsFkYuT32AQ
-
The fiddle version is interesting. I don't know much about polskas but the first notes seem to slow before getting back to speed. Is this part of the dance step?
https://youtu.be/OsFkYuT32AQ
Fiddle version? This IS a fiddle tune. The tempo dynamics at the outset is a stylistic feature found in Finland as well as other countries. Tempo/pace settle in after a bar or two.
Keep in mind this is an instructional video, not live performance.