Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Graeme on October 05, 2009, 09:01:04 PM
-
Does anyone happen to know the difference between the Trichord II and the Trichord III, apart from the extra I?
Graeme
-
The III is obviously a little heavier, but the extra set of reeds does make a difference. I was able to compare at Graeme's Button Box Workshop when Bill Young brought his Trichord III along, and I had my Trichord II. Bill's box has a beautiful sound, and he's limited the button action etc so it plays beautifully. My own box is of course lighter - and I'm very, very happy with it. The sound of two sets of reeds is ok and I get a nice pleasant traditional Hohner tremolo, ideal for Scottish music etc. But if I had the choice (which I don't) I'd probably plump for Bill Trichord III over my II. However, my little Trichord travels most places with me these days, it's light and very easy to play. Apart from that I'm not aware of any construction or design differences. Hope this helps.
AL
-
The simple answer is "more reeds"!
The Roman numbers II, III and IV are commonly used to denote the number of voices (i.e. reeds per note) in an accordion.
-
Triskel - is this true for the old wooden grille Club I's that occasionally pop up on ebay etc?
-
Triskel - is this true for the old wooden grille Club I's that occasionally pop up on ebay etc?
No, I'm afraid Hohner haven't been consistent in the use of such numbers and they're often more a sign of a model's ranking in a particular range. In fact the Club I was the most basic 2-voice Club instrument, and there were models with Roman numbers up to the Club X - which was still only a 3-voice...
-
I thought as much!
-
the Club X
Shame though huh? Think how great a 10 voiced intsrument would sound!
AL
-
Think how great a 10 voiced intsrument would sound!
/me thinks how clumsy and heavy it would be!
-
Think how great a 10 voiced intsrument would sound!
* Sebastian thinks how clumsy and heavy it would be!
Agreed of course - but the sound?
-
I wonder if it would actually be any good or if it just would sound mushy and too busy? You might even find there was some sort of destructive interference going on with that many voices canceling each others frequencies out leaving a quieter and less harmonically complex sound compared with a 3 or 4 voice box. But it might be amazing! I think it would also be very very different from 5 people playing 2v boxes together.
-
One can resort back to the Bronx boxes, as from what I heard, oft times the 6v models had more cut and might have even been louder than the 8v models, probably due to a number of factors such as amount of air needed and how much work the player would have to do to keep up with it :||: you can also take into effect duplicate sets of reeds at the same frequencies (I believe Lars told me that sometimes in a LLMMMMHH box that the highs and lows were all 440?)
I doubt you'd be able to keep up for long with having to pump air over 10 sets of reeds though! :Ph
-
doubt you'd be able to keep up for long with having to pump air over 10 sets of reeds though!
True!
I have a friend who has a 5 voice PA with one of the reeds being a 32' set, it gives the instrument an incredible range, though the box is incredibly heavy. Unlike my little Hohner Trichord II, which is seriously light (and back on topic). ;D
AL
-
Thanks for all this information (on and off topic!). This forum is an incredible source of learning.
Graeme
-
Thanks for all this information (on and off topic!). This forum is an incredible source of learning.
Graeme
Graeme
I'll second what you say. This site with its forum is very useful. Without it I would not have purchased a box. All novice queries, I raised, were graciously answered.
Brian