Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: pbsalt on October 18, 2020, 12:05:47 PM
-
I've had a 2.5 row, 12 bass D/G Lukinnen for nearly 2 years now , but apart from the occasional use of the extra accidentals and basses to fit in with a specific tune I still really play it as I would my 2 rows. I'm just starting to play basses using my little finger ( until now I've got away with 3 finger bass playing). Before old age and decreptitiude forces me to pass this box on I'd like to explore the full potential of a 2.5 row and wondered if anyone has suggestions for exercises for a 2.5 row to make use of the extra 1/2 row and the basses ( which are on push F# and F# minor and A/A and on pull F and G )
Thanks
-
As an exercise you can play scales on the bass. You have 6 out of the seven for a G scale on the standard 8 basses so that’s a good place to start and gets you using the F#. Then you can go to C and include the F.
-
I think the 3rd Milleret and Pignol book needs a 3 row - you'd have to transpose it, but it might be a serious way of getting to know those buttons.
-
I think the 3rd Milleret and Pignol book needs a 3 row - you'd have to transpose it, but it might be a serious way of getting to know those buttons.
I second the Milleret and Pignol recommendation.
And, the thing that has worked best for me is find tunes I love in unusual keys or with lots of accidentals and learn those. (Gilles Chabenat tunes are great for this.) Also, I never use my pinkie. Learning (and I'm still learning) to jump my hand around with (some) accuracy has been really valuable.
-
Assume you have a pull D on the right?
Pick some familiar tunes, particularly with notes D and E in them, so … most of the D,G,Am, Em repertoire, and force yourself to play longish phrases in there totally on push or pull. Adderbury “shooting†it a beauty for this
P&M call these “partial scales†but with your kit you might have a full pull scale.
Once fairly fluid … try playing these against different bass drones, or chords. Totally different “colour�
Once that’s working, weave in some of those base runs. You fingers already know where they are 😉
-
Thanks for the suggestions - now just need some will power to practice.
-
I'd like to revisit this topic to see if anyone else has suggestions for building left hand dexterity using the extra 4 buttons on a 12 bass.
My D/G Dony has the standard Castagnari left hand layout, ie Eb/F#m and Bb/F on the additional buttons http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/DG21plus5castagnari.gif (http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/DG21plus5castagnari.gif)
It would be good to find some interesting tunes that involve those chords I mentioned above. The only example I can think of in my repertoire is l'Impasse in Em, which uses an F chord.
thanks, Ian
-
Try playing some tunes in Gmin.
That'll bring in the F and Bb and possibly the Eb.
-
Being new to a 2.5 row 12 bass Castagnari, I immediately launched into a Gm tune.
I found some of the new sounds glorious, things like a pulled A melody note against a Fnat Chord.... a D melody with a Bb chord, things I've never experienced before.
It was painfully slow at first, a couple of weeks later it is starting to slowly hang together, especially if reading the dots as it's not quite in the memory.
I've also had a quick look at an Am tune which uses different chords and just the Fnat's in the melody side on the half row.
These different sound palettes are lovely and absolutely new to my DG tuned ears.
What goes on in the mind is always a mystery but I'm starting to realise is that my ear is learning these new sounds and heading the fingers at it... I think.
Tis always odd what goes on in my brain when playing ;D
-
Similar to what Thrupenny Bit suggests, it's fun to replace some Am chords with F nat chords in Am tunes. It can become corny but I love it - same effect as using a C chord in an Em tune.
An idea for getting used to finding the F# bass: a tip I picked up at last year's Stillington weekend (sorry to see it's not on this year but I'm one of those who didn't book this time round!) was to play one bass as a lead-in to another. For example, hit a B bass (rather than a chord of some sort) on the beat before playing a C bass. Well, the F# bass leads nicely into a G bass. I guess this depends on octaves, mind. I'm assuming your F# is just below your G and not an octave down. (It is on my Saltarelle).
As it's you, Smiley, how about some nice F nats in Irish tunes in G - e.g. Cook in the Kitchen, The Floggin
One more thought - if I had a 2.5 Castagnari with 12 basses I'd be practising the F scale and trying to play simple tunes in that key, including the basses. Lots of Christmas carols are normally sung in F. O Little Town... :||:
-
Oh thanks CAB, lots of titbits there to think about
-
Try playing some tunes in Gmin.
Oh, I stupidly asked for the Bb on my half row to be on the pull - while my G, Bb and Eb chords are all on the push. The tuner must've shook his head at my ignorance. So first I need to get a Bb on the right hand changed to suit the basses for playing in Gm.
As it's you, Smiley, how about some nice F nats in Irish tunes in G - e.g. Cook in the Kitchen, The Floggin
Nice idea, but I'm flat-out hitting the F nat on the treble side without stuffing up the basses too! You've given me some good ideas to work with, thanks.
-
What I've gradually done over the years since I acquired my first bigger box is to consider how a tune could be played more completely, more easily, or with better accompaniment, at the stage when you're starting to learn to play a tune. This means dissecting the tricky bits, and trying different options where you have reversal options, both on LHS and RHS, until you find the best. 'Best' can mean various things - it could be the easiest to play, the one with the most effective use of a steady bass accompaniment, the one with the most appropriate combination of 'smooth' and 'choppy' phrasing, or the one that best equalises bellows pushes and pulls. The important thing about doing it at the early stage is that it's crucial not to learn something that you then have to unlearn, because unlearning muscle memory is a pain! I went through a patch where I was playing everything wrong, because there were too many options, and my brain was trying to use the wrong muscle memory for that particular passage. But that stage passed, I think because my brain eventually learned preferred little runs of notes, which it was recognising from the score or the sound.
My preference, rather than trying out different chords for a tune, was very much to try to play more complex tunes that were beyond the two-row 8-bass. For example, playing Athol Highlanders in A on a DG two-row, with drive, is to my mind virtually impossible. You don't have all the notes, but worst of all, you run out of pull. Having a push A chord on a bigger box would help. I don't, but I found other ways of securing the crucial push passages, very effectively. That's the sort of journey a new big box player is starting out on. Since there are so many different layouts, I feel that any advice has to be on a 'general principle' level. When I started out on this journey, I realised it was going to be a lifetime's task. And so it is proving!
-
Thanks Chris, good points from someone further along the road.
I take your point about rather than trying to shoe-horn a tune onto a 2r8b but take it on board on a box with greater options.
Along the same lines, I have been doing this with 'Woodland Flowers' which has been squeezed onto a 2r8b by various people.
Looking at Felix Burn's original score, there's a lovely triplet in the A music of low E-D#-E and the C music modulates into the key of C, needing Fnats and G#'s in the melody and F chords in the accompniment .
It's a great trip around both ends of the box with key changes from G to D to C and accidentals thrown in.
A tune I'm familiar with but never attempted to squeeze onto a 2r8b.
Whether it sticks or not, it's a good vehicle to explore the box, a nice tune too.
-
I'd like to revisit this topic to see if anyone else has suggestions for building left hand dexterity using the extra 4 buttons on a 12 bass.
My D/G Dony has the standard Castagnari left hand layout, ie Eb/F#m and Bb/F on the additional buttons http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/DG21plus5castagnari.gif (http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/DG21plus5castagnari.gif)
It would be good to find some interesting tunes that involve those chords I mentioned above. The only example I can think of in my repertoire is l'Impasse in Em, which uses an F chord.
thanks, Ian
Considering the additional chords, in theory you should easily play in C anf F, and eventually in B flat. For the three keys you have the tonic, the subdominat and the dominant chords (C, F, G – F, B flat, C – B flat, E flat, F), and if you can mute the thirds all the three diatonic minor triads.
The problem is that, with the additional basses at the top of the LH keyboard, to play the tonic, the subdominant and the dominant in C an F you have to go back and forth from the four basses at the top to the four at the bottom all the time, and that's self defeating. To seriously consider to play in C and F, and eventually use a number of harmonic minor scales, the additional should have been added at the bottom of the LH keyboard.
The only chord that's useful at the top of the LH keyboard in this configuration is the F# minor chord, that 's useful playing in D major, and would be uncomfortable at the bottom of the keyboard.
-
My Saltarelle has the arrangement you mention with the Bb/F/Eb/F# at the bottom of the bass keyboard. This was once the standard arrangement. It does make the F# somewhat remote when playing in D but it gives Gm7, Dm7 and Cm7 using adjacent buttons. The F# is not too far from G for bass runs up or down from G.
https://youtu.be/D70sgolleo4 (https://youtu.be/D70sgolleo4) here’s a tune, Hommage a Jean-Paul Beaulieu, recorded a while ago which goes from G to D to Bb and uses all the “extra†chords. You will hear that I fell off the end after A, B, C parts then just A and B before getting to the C part in Bb again!
Mitch
-
Just to point out that button spacing can also make a difference. On my D/G Pastourelle 2, bass buttons (extras on bottom) aren't as close as on my Dony and Mory (extras on top). I've got used to both - but I think the Pastourelle layout is a bit better at least for the eccentric layout I have. Bottom buttons on that are C/G and F/C - the usual unisonoric C (middle buttons) is Em/Am instead. I just wish I could use all four fingers on my left hand more - but not all of us can.
Julian
-
https://youtu.be/D70sgolleo4 (https://youtu.be/D70sgolleo4) here’s a tune, Hommage a Jean-Paul Beaulieu, recorded a while ago which goes from G to D to Bb and uses all the “extra†chords.
Wow, the tune on that video is a real step out of the D/G comfort zone!
I'm also looking around from some slow tunes (waltzes etc) where I could gently introduce those extra bass chords.
-
The thread started as I too have taken onboard a new 2.5r 12b box hence me joining in the thread earlier.
I'm finding using the extra basses available on a Mory an interesting experience. I've chosen to start the learning process by going utterly beyond my DG comfort zone and trying a couple of tunes in Gm.
This forces me to use the Bb, Fnat and Eb bass/chord buttons, plus the accidentals to get Fnats, Bb and Eb on the melody side.
This has brought me back to Melodeon Zero, where I'm stumbling around to find each note and chord is as it was when I first started playing.
A few weeks on and the tunes are starting to hang together and I'm at the point where I'm half remembering, half glancing at the dots to remind me.
What I've really noticed is my mind 'wants a particular sound' and takes me to that chord whilst my treble fingers are trying to find the notes. The brain wanting a particular sound is something I've not known or been aware of before.
Learning is a fascinating process!
-
I had a Mory 2.5 row 12 bass for about 8 years, and yes, tended to play it as a rather heavy 2-row. Nor did it get me to “play like Andy Cuttingâ€
I tried some off piste keys, and that included G minor, which was great fun. The direction of the bases is really important in fluidity, and a big one reason for my Rodec project. You can test out what works with what before buying.
As ever, it depends on what you play. eg I have an F#/Eb plate on my accs/D/G vdAa. It’s in that direction to support playing in Bb, which suits my voice, but the opposite holds when I play on a D/G’s ‘built-in’ F# Blues scale. Which is why the people in Grenoble have that plate in completely the opposite direction. Stéph Milleret put me right on his layout last week 🥴
I think the 2.5 layout is mainly ‘extra accidentals’. Your main exercises should probably involve playing ‘right through’ scales on the pull, taking advantage of any reversed note(s).
And mastering harmonic minor over both octaves. It’s a great source of improvised lines when playing in your melodeon’s minor keys
-
Yes, playing in Gm is fun!
I have a pull D in the middle of the half row and didn't realise its' use until going off piste with Gm.
I'm starting to practice scales and with reversals there are so many options to play a scale.
I feel my mind is expanding exponentially... just hope it doesn't go pop ;D
-
Lets face it - scale exercises aren't very much fun but I wish I'd spent more time on them before the last weekend at Halsway when I spent much of the time sight reading tunes in the more off piste keys - Gm, Dm, Am, C etc on my D/G Dony. Challenging and exposing.
What I should do now is go back to those difficult tunes and try again - and maybe also pick a tune at random from one of my favourite tunebooks (which include a lot in Gm). Then there's trying to play along with recordings - maybe working out bass and chord accompaniments and variations - good for practice in learning by ear.
And interestingly, my band mates have proposed playing one of our usual sets in C rather than G - now I could simply reach for the G/C, or perhaps I should use this as a learning experience and have a good workout on one of the D/G accs.
Julian
Ps Yes Q - D and E reversals are incredibly useful !
-
I need to practice more scales too.
Though I'm more comfortable with Gm, I haven't tried those other keys and not tried learning by ear.
Currently, dots are my friend, and I want to become comfortable with my selected tunes before moving on.
Haven't found a use for a push E yet, but love a pull D ;)
-
I'm in the same boat. My chosen Gm tune to attempt is Metsakukkia aka Finnish Forest Flower (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ImrlB-Mzpow)
-
And interestingly, my band mates have proposed playing one of our usual sets in C rather than G - now I could simply reach for the G/C, or perhaps I should use this as a learning experience and have a good workout on one of the D/G accs.
I found playing tunes in C major (and D dorian mode) on a D/G/acc with a low C note on the G row was a good way to start getting to grips with a 2.5 row's extra functionality. The effort was worth it just to avoid lugging around another "C" box to sessions and gigs.
-
I have found really working on G min and C Maj worthwhile.
These are early attempts, but they explore the possibilities of D/G/Acc
https://youtu.be/RXq55V4daBg
https://youtu.be/Znepc29W4Ps
https://youtu.be/J0FIKCZRk34
-
I particularly like your Camembert Waltz, that looks to be a very good trip around the box!
Thank you for sharing, and shows what happens when you persevere. My current attempts are probably best described as 'embryonic ' at present ;)
-
A quick personal update:
It's a little while since Paul started this thread, which coincided with me starting along the same journey of wondering what to do on a 2.5r 12b.
A few weeks on, I seem to be taking two parallel paths.
One is learning a couple of tunes in a totally new key.
Therefore having to use new basses and the accidental row and creating new non - DG sounds. My ear is getting acclimatised to these new sounds, which I find exciting.
The other path is using it as a 'super DG'.
Julian mentioned the tune 'If you will not have me, you may let me go' in another similar thread, and after the reminder I'm now looking at that too.
It introduces using other basses such as F#m and reversals on the accidental row. Not sure if I'll stick to the tune, but it is a good exercise in itself.
With both paths I'm trying to expand my knowledge beyond what is normal to me and getting to know the box. I'm finding the challenge good fun!
-
It introduces using other basses such as F#m and reversals on the accidental row.
I've been exploring the use of that F# bass in bass runs - D, E, F# or F#, G, A for example - for my current ThOTM submission. Lots of fun!
-
One thing that I keep trying is to play everything in the original key. It isn't always possible and most times I will think it not worth the effort, but it's a way of constantly exploring the less used corners of a 2½ row.
The latest FBk Tunesday group tune is in A and although slow and a bit deliberate, I've managed it reasonably well. A bit more practice to get fluency and a tad more speed and it'll be a nice tune in the armoury.
I'll edit this with a link when I've put it on YouTube.
https://youtu.be/pP2KXkGQc1Y
And here it is.
-
Yes, I've discovered a run in another tune Bm > Am > G > *F#m* > Em ... great fun!!
I too am trying to get out of the 2r8b habit of shoe - horning a tune onto it, which one has to in order for fit it onto the box.
As you say, 'play as writ'. It's quite liberating not having to compromise the tune to fit a 2r8b and yes, helps to explore the currently unknown corners of the box ;)
I also realise that some tunes are not what is commonly played. Looking at 'Woodland Flowers', the A part is in G, B part in D then the C part in.... C! It's quite a fun exercise and helps with exploration too.
It's all good brain fodder even if my fingers can't quite keep up yet, and it does show me those out of the way corners of the box.
-
Dancing Dustman is a good workout for 2½ row too.
Plenty of accidentals and C music in C.
-
Thanks Pete, I have it printed off and waiting (:)
-
Sometime during lockdown feeling particularly masochistic I set about learning an 11 part 3/2 hornpipe 'Spinning Jenny' - which I transposed from the original Gm to Em.
But it's playable in Gm on the Mory - and it makes a great exercise piece - much more interesting than scales !
And I just happen to notice Cheshire Rolling Hornpipe is in Dm in John Offord's wonderful book...
Julian
-
Handsome young Maidens uploaded as promised
https://youtu.be/pP2KXkGQc1Y
-
Julian, I'm still recovering from Saul Rose's workshop on the Cheshire Rolling Hornpipe, when armed with just a 2r8b :o
-
I'm in the same boat. My chosen Gm tune to attempt is Metsakukkia aka Finnish Forest Flower (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ImrlB-Mzpow)
I realize this is an old thread....but I'd like to follow up with a question viz this tune Metsakukkia.
I've got the sheet music for it in Am and Em, which I can play on the PA but I'm fumbling around translating it over to the diatonic boxes I have (GC, DG, CF) none of which are giving me the notes / chords I need in those keys in the necessary push / pull options.
But I may be going at it in the wrong way.
There are YouTube videos of folks playing it on the box but I haven't been able to unpack what key / which box they are using.
Any leads who be appreciated.
I'm playing it on the mandolin in the meantime.... ;)
Theo are you playing the tune in Gm on a straight up DG box...or one with 3rd row accidentals, etc.?
Thanks!
-
The fiddler lady is in simple aolian G minor, but puts in an F# in her B music. I hear that as a passing, rather than leading note. Central Europeans do that on fiddle. You should be able to get close to it playing across the rows against pull G drone (of 3rds out) on your C/F. The high F# will be a bit of a stretch to head end accidentals, and will often be wrong way, but should sound all right against C chord. Or just stay pulling and play an F note?
But I think you might better in the main row minor. eg A minor on your G/C is not too far from G? The passing note there would be G# and is usually push agains its E chord inner top left end. If you choose to play the note as a simpler G natural then Em = Gchord on Bbass (push) would work better. Or you could mix them in different stanzas as variations?
Amin is very fluid on a GC, but be careful to use the F note on in a row with this tune. The outer row F# is an avoid note!
Another easy variation is to passing-note Eb (usually outer row, pull accidental) for a "touch of blue".
There's a nice soft Fmaj7 on left too = Amchord on pull Fbass. With a bit of practice you can alternate it with the Em cross-bass chord mentioned above. just shift the two fingers by one space and change direction.
Another trick (conveniently all on pull) it's to hold the Am chord and "run" your bass. A => G => F and then finally reverse direction => either of the push E chords. you'll find that you can usually fit in the tune (or something very close to it) against them. don't be afraid to change the odd note. It doesn't matter.
if you stick to a left end style like that, or the equivalent on your other instruments you will be playing with the box rather than against it. Always a good idea on melodeons!
-
Theo are you playing the tune in Gm on a straight up DG box...or one with 3rd row accidentals, etc.?
Thanks!
DG with accidental row. I'm still struggling with it! The finger patters are well outside my usual range.
-
I really like G minor. Lovely soft key. But on my accs/D/G the scale is totally on the pull and traces a sort of "knights tour" across the keyboard.
As I have all of the notes on pull then I automatically get all of the diatonic chords relating to that scale. But personally I would go for push D7 harmonic chord … where she puts in that passing note. Just to stop my left arm from dropping off! 🥴
3-rows and an expanded bass is very liberating with respect to melodic music. On a 2-row machine you really do have to "go with the box".
-
Yes, it's a lovely key to play in until I hit the B rather than the Bb :|bl
Playing 'beyond' the DG keys really means you need to be accurate. Gone is the 'harmony' concept of hitting a wrong note but it's ok as it blends in.
-
The "avoid notes" that I refer to above are ones that are a semitone away from the mode in which you are playing.
But B, in a G minor of any genre => a major 3rd in a minor tune. It's a massive enough faux pas to set teeth on edge. A "never' note!
Mysteriously doesn't work the other way. Major key tunes are remarkably tolerant of a minor 3rd. It's almost fundamental to Blues.
A minor's "never" note is C#. E minor's "never" note is Ab.
-
Yep, sets my teeth on edge too.
I do *try* and avoid it but sometimes...! I suppose it's reverting to the 2 row keyboard 'habit' for just that split second that does it.
Practice makes perfect, and scales do help.
-
There are YouTube videos of folks playing it on the box but I haven't been able to unpack what key / which box they are using.
Any leads who be appreciated.
Well, I suppose that if you are interested in any useful suggestion about playing a tune – not just Metsäkukkia – you should first make clear which variant of the melody you wish to follow, eventually posting an abc transcription.
I haven't tried to make a comprehensive analysis of all the variants of Metsäkukkia you can find on YouTube, nor even of the whole tunes, but what I can hear/see in some of them, just considering the first of the three parts, suggests that you have plenty of choices.
As Chris Ryall says, the fiddler lady in the video of your link tries to play the first part in a G natural minor scale, or, if you stick to the funny Greek names, in a G Aeolian mode. And I deliberately says she tries because in a number of cases her intonation, or to say better her lack of it, honestly makes my ear bleed.
Yet in a number of transcriptions you'll find on the web you will see that in the 13th bar of the first part there is a sharpened 7th degree, that actually means that the part is played using a tonal harmonic minor scale. And a number of viedeos reflect this.
Look at the following one. The instrument is clearly a G/C box, and the tune is played using an Am chord as the tonic, but you can both hear and see that in the 13th bar the player uses the G# in the chin accidentals.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vLx1hFeJ6UE
Now have a look at this other video. The left hand is most of the time hidden behind a table, but the box is in A/D, and int the video the tonic is a Bm chord, and in the first part you can distinctly hear both an E and an F# chords. Yet, no accidentals this time.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CRtMc4dfDwM
The two row box players, when there is note in the melody that's not available on the RH keyboard, or that is too tricky to reach, simply introduce a minor variant in the melody and don't play it. That might end up in a dramatic alteration of the melody, or almost remain unnoticed. It depends partly on the tune, and partly on the note(s) they use to replace the ones(s) they decide to avoid.... ;)
-
GB...
That's me in the first link. It's such an expansive tune that I rarely play it the same way twice.
Here's another (wonderful) take:
https://youtu.be/8IVMymVg5p4?si=jEy0bARLC9wPUOyS
-
GB...
That's me in the first link. It's such an expansive tune that I rarely play it the same way twice.
That's fine, and I admit that there are a few tunes that I've been playing for a long time, some for more than forty years, that seem to get a life on their own every time I get back to them.
Yet they are exceptions, and like most of the players I know I tend to play most of my tunes starting with a defined melodic line, and a defined harmonic progression, even if I then add a number of variations. And at least for the melodies they usually remains the ones I did choose, considering the different variants I heard and/or found in a written source, when I first learned them, although the harmonic progressions tend to evolve progressively along the years.
-
It's mostly counter-melodies, harmonies and a few melodic re-statements that change. I could probably play it straight, though. I do know the common statement.
-
The fiddler lady is in simple aolian G minor, but puts in an F# in her B music. I hear that as a passing, rather than leading note. Central Europeans do that on fiddle. You should be able to get close to it playing across the rows against pull G drone (of 3rds out) on your C/F. The high F# will be a bit of a stretch to head end accidentals, and will often be wrong way, but should sound all right against C chord. Or just stay pulling and play an F note?
But I think you might better in the main row minor. eg A minor on your G/C is not too far from G? The passing note there would be G# and is usually push agains its E chord inner top left end. If you choose to play the note as a simpler G natural then Em = Gchord on Bbass (push) would work better. Or you could mix them in different stanzas as variations?
Amin is very fluid on a GC, but be careful to use the F note on in a row with this tune. The outer row F# is an avoid note!
Another easy variation is to passing-note Eb (usually outer row, pull accidental) for a "touch of blue".
There's a nice soft Fmaj7 on left too = Amchord on pull Fbass. With a bit of practice you can alternate it with the Em cross-bass chord mentioned above. just shift the two fingers by one space and change direction.
Another trick (conveniently all on pull) it's to hold the Am chord and "run" your bass. A => G => F and then finally reverse direction => either of the push E chords. you'll find that you can usually fit in the tune (or something very close to it) against them. don't be afraid to change the odd note. It doesn't matter.
if you stick to a left end style like that, or the equivalent on your other instruments you will be playing with the box rather than against it. Always a good idea on melodeons!
Very helpful...thank you!
-
There are YouTube videos of folks playing it on the box but I haven't been able to unpack what key / which box they are using.
Any leads who be appreciated.
Look at the following one. The instrument is clearly a G/C box, and the tune is played using an Am chord as the tonic, but you can both hear and see that in the 13th bar the player uses the G# in the chin accidentals.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vLx1hFeJ6UE
GB...
I did not play a g# in that video. I DID use a d# in the bar you cited.
I don't expect you to take this sitting down. You should stand...corrected. :P
-
I did not play a g# in that video. I DID use a d# in the bar you cited.
You played that piece beautifully!
Is the music available for this piece?
-
I did not play a g# in that video. I DID use a d# in the bar you cited.
You played that piece beautifully!
Is the music available for this piece?
Thank you. (Kiitos)
I play this by ear.
-
Paul...
Check your PM's. I've attempted to send some dots.
-
Have only just revisited this thread - thanks all - I've added the suggestions to a to-do list for the 2.5 row but it will be competing with the to do list for improving my anglo , to do list for the 1 row , learning the tunes recorded at Whitby, work - there's not enough time !