Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Andy Cleveland on October 26, 2020, 03:42:46 PM

Title: Low G on 21 button c#/d box
Post by: Andy Cleveland on October 26, 2020, 03:42:46 PM
I'm attempting to retune an Erica c#/d box on my own (It's much harder than I thought and I've made 15 violins) It bugged me that it was at A 442. My question is I miss having the G (is it G3?) the low string of the violin. I'm thinking of changing the G# on the C# row to G. What do you think? Apologies if this has been answered somewhere before, this is my first post.
Title: Re: Low G on 21 button c#/d box
Post by: folkloristmark on October 26, 2020, 03:49:14 PM
hi
dont confuse the trem with the instrument not beng in tune if a box registers 442 not 440 on a tuner that may just reflect the tuning rather than the a440 reed base.May I be as bold to say No accordeons are in tune.Except mine >:Ethere is a lot of differences in accordeon tuning.i
Title: Re: Low G on 21 button c#/d box
Post by: Stiamh on October 26, 2020, 04:10:12 PM
I'm thinking of changing the G# on the C# row to G. What do you think?

I think there's no perfect solution! People most often sacrifice the low A#, which is not used often, but when it is, it is likely be as a Bb. One question is, which would you rather be without, low Bb or low G#?

From a tuning perspective obviously it would be easier to retune the G# reed but I wouldn't like that for two reasons: one, your low G will be on the push, and two, it becomes a random note or accidental that is not on the lowest button.

In your position I would choose to scrap the reeds on the lowest button and get hold of replacements pitched low D/G.

A better possibility, and since you can make violins the carpentry involved might not faze you, is to extend the reedblocks and add an extra button at the bottom of the D row and put D/G on that. Mike Rowbotham has done that for me on two Double-Rays. Bit of a squeeze but he managed it.
Title: Re: Low G on 21 button c#/d box
Post by: Andy Cleveland on October 26, 2020, 04:19:42 PM
I'm thinking of changing the G# on the C# row to G. What do you think?

I think there's no perfect solution! People most often sacrifice the low A#, which is not used often, but when it is, it is likely be as a Bb. One question is, which would you rather be without, low Bb or low G#?

From a tuning perspective obviously it would be easier to retune the G# reed but I wouldn't like that for two reasons: one, your low G will be on the push, and two, it becomes a random note or accidental that is not on the lowest button.

In your position I would choose to scrap the reeds on the lowest button and get hold of replacements pitched low D/G.

A better possibility, and since you can make violins the carpentry involved might not faze you, is to extend the reedblocks and add an extra button at the bottom of the D row and put D/G on that. Mike Rowbotham has done that for me on two Double-Rays. Bit of a squeeze but he managed it.
[/i]

Thanks, I appreciate all of the suggestions. I think The A# for now maybe the way to go and maybe I'll be brave enough to attack the reed blocks at some other time. Really enjoyed your C#/d tutorials Stiamh, I keep going back to them as I get a little better at this beast.
Title: Re: Low G on 21 button c#/d box
Post by: Andy Cleveland on October 26, 2020, 04:23:08 PM
hi
dont confuse the trem with the instrument not beng in tune if a box registers 442 not 440 on a tuner that may just reflect the tuning rather than the a440 reed base.May I be as bold to say No accordeons are in tune.Except mine >:Ethere is a lot of differences in accordeon tuning.i

I pretty sure it was 442 I altered my tuner to be A442 and it was generally in tune with that. As far as no accordions being in tune except mine, that goes for any instrument i think but Fiddles are mostly in tune if you have Hilary Hahn play it
Title: Re: Low G on 21 button c#/d box
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on October 26, 2020, 04:42:01 PM
hi
dont confuse the trem with the instrument not beng in tune if a box registers 442 not 440 on a tuner that may just reflect the tuning rather than the a440 reed base.May I be as bold to say No accordeons are in tune.Except mine >:Ethere is a lot of differences in accordeon tuning.i

I pretty sure it was 442 I altered my tuner to be A442 and it was generally in tune with that. As far as no accordions being in tune except mine, that goes for any instrument i think but Fiddles are mostly in tune if you have Hilary Hahn play it

Unless you checked the reeds individually, the difference between A=440 and what you read on your tuner is, possibly, the difference between the on tune reeds and the sharp reeds. To put it another way, a normally tuned melodeon will read sharp on a tuner. There are threads on here that go into detail on this.

If the perceived pitch is a problem for you, you might prefer Mr Dedic's system, or something similar.
Title: Re: Low G on 21 button c#/d box
Post by: Andy Cleveland on October 26, 2020, 06:07:03 PM
hi
dont confuse the trem with the instrument not beng in tune if a box registers 442 not 440 on a tuner that may just reflect the tuning rather than the a440 reed base.May I be as bold to say No accordeons are in tune.Except mine >:Ethere is a lot of differences in accordeon tuning.i

I pretty sure it was 442 I altered my tuner to be A442 and it was generally in tune with that. As far as no accordions being in tune except mine, that goes for any instrument i think but Fiddles are mostly in tune if you have Hilary Hahn play it

Unless you checked the reeds individually, the difference between A=440 and what you read on your tuner is, possibly, the difference between the on tune reeds and the sharp reeds. To put it another way, a normally tuned melodeon will read sharp on a tuner. There are threads on here that go into detail on this.

If the perceived pitch is a problem for you, you might prefer Mr Dedic's system, or something similar.

I had considered the dedic method but I thought as a novice it would entail too many adjustments. Thanks, I'm pretty picky on tuning  I'm usually the one that stops in a session and says can we all retune :)
Title: Re: Low G on 21 button c#/d box
Post by: folkloristmark on October 26, 2020, 06:34:22 PM
I think then you would like dedic tuning.
Title: Re: Low G on 21 button c#/d box
Post by: Theo on October 26, 2020, 07:34:15 PM
Better still I think you might like dry tuning.   For a first time tuning that is the system that needs the greatest precision to sound good.
Title: Re: Low G on 21 button c#/d box
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on October 26, 2020, 07:55:46 PM
Or buy a concertina.
Title: Re: Low G on 21 button c#/d box
Post by: Andy Cleveland on October 27, 2020, 04:16:39 PM
Better still I think you might like dry tuning.   For a first time tuning that is the system that needs the greatest precision to sound good.
I think that's what I'm aiming for, dry with a little bit of bloom to it
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal