Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Sal Rotondo on November 12, 2020, 02:44:28 PM

Title: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Sal Rotondo on November 12, 2020, 02:44:28 PM
Good day all.

I'm narrowing my search for a new box and it's between the Castagnari 1914 and the Mory in G/C.

I play Irish, English, Italian, French and songs from Brittany currently on my two-row G/C Dino Baffetti.  The issue I have is that the accidentals are on the chin side of the box and I have trouble playing some tunes because of this.  The 1914 or the Mory will remedy this problem.

I feel all I need is the 1914 (with its two accidental buttons) however, I see plenty of musicians on YouTube playing the Mory (or something like it), i.e. extra 1/2 row and extra basses.  I'm just wondering if I'll ever need all those extra buttons at the expense of the Mory's extra bulk and weight. 

Any ideas on this?  I just don't want to purchase a 1914 and then in a year think I should have gone with a Mory b/c of x.

Thank you.

Sal
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Gena Crisman on November 12, 2020, 03:39:27 PM
I believe new 1914s come with 12 basses now, too, if that helps make your search that much more complicated.

Casta's extra basses are usually configured to help you play outside of your regular G and C key signatures. If you wanted to start doing that, typically you'll also be wanting for more accidentals, too. I'd say that the two kind of go hand in hand?

So I guess, ask yourself why you're already using the accidental buttons you have. What are they currently doing for you? More accs and reversals and basses may lay on that same pathway.
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on November 12, 2020, 04:20:58 PM
As Gena says, it depends on what you want to play.
If you just want accidentals at a more convenient position, the 1914 with 8 basses fits the bill.
If you want to increase the range of keys available to you, then head for a Mory.

Steve Freereeder of this parish will be along very soon in sure!
His knowledge and opinions will be worth a listen as he has a Mory and a 1914.

Personally, I love the sound of a Mory. It has a massive all round warm sound that is lovely.
I have two areas of concern over my personal choice which might be of interest in your choice.
I have taught myself to use the chin end accidentals, though recently, playing with my Hohner Erika, I have been using the Erika's half row. With practice I'm sure I'd be able to use accidentals half way along the grill. It doesn't feel that odd after a few days of practice, though I still use the chin end from choice.

I am not sure I'd use the extra bases, with the tunes I normally play. This is a classic 'you don't know until you've tried it' situation and I cannot help you there, as I can't help myself on this subject!
I have a feeing that though I love the Mory sound, this use of the extra basses will keep me on a 2 row 8 bass, but who knows?

I was hoping to resolve these questions this year at workshops where I'd have the opportunity of having a good play on a Mory but a nasty little virus messed up my plans.

Hopefully people with more experience in this area will be along soon, but these are the thoughts currently swimming inside my head!
Cheers
Q

Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: -Y- on November 12, 2020, 04:46:24 PM
Sal,
I don't know whether in your area you could have the opportunity to try them, because the feels will be different to what you're accustomed to.

If you compare the two models pricewise, it's hard to justify the 1914 price compared to the musical possibilities of the Mory, IMO. They are roughly the same price, sometimes the 1914 is more expensive, but has fewer notes and fewer registers available than the Mory.

"Manoeuvrability" aside, it's a no brainer.
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Sal Rotondo on November 12, 2020, 05:00:42 PM
Thank you all for your input.

Can anyone speak to the added size and weight of the Mory since I'd be jumping from a standard two-row box?

I live in the U.S. so it will probably be impossible to test drive the Mory or 1914 before I buy, hence all of the questions.

Thank you!
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Theo on November 12, 2020, 05:13:42 PM
The significant difference internally is that the Mory has separate reed blocks for the 1/2 row, the 1914 does not.  As a consequence the Mory is noticably bigger and heavier. 
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on November 12, 2020, 05:17:43 PM
Yes the Mory is larger.
It has a larger case than the 1914 and is heavier. When I did briefly try one a year ago it seemed OK to me, but I am aware other people have found it too large. Talking to friends I think this extra size goes some way towards it's sound . I have two other Castagnaris of the same case size as the 1914 and the jump to the Mory doesn't seem excessive.

People often say playing a larger instruments is a style thing.
Playing across the rows more, rather than up and down the rows. It reduces bellows waggling so you don't need to move a larger bass end around as much.

I too, like -Y- notice the price differential between the 1914 and Mory. It doesn't make a lot of sense to me, I guess it's on sales volume and they sell more Morys maybe?

Ah, further info from Theo as I type, he's been inside the beasties whereas I haven't!
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Julian S on November 12, 2020, 05:38:33 PM
Are the left hand ends much different (apart from the 1914 being available in 8 and 12 bass layouts I believe ?)
I would suggest that it's the weight and balance of the bass end which is pretty important. To me, those extra accidentals/reversals make the Mory much more attractive (got one on order !) though I haven't personally tried a 1914 for comparison. My other thought is whether the new box is going to be used for all tunes - I often switch between my 2.0/2.4/2.5 instruments because one or another is better for some tunes, in terms of accidentals, basses, playability and sound.

Julian
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Sal Rotondo on November 12, 2020, 05:48:30 PM
Julian: I plan to use one box for all tunes.
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Gary P Chapin on November 12, 2020, 06:14:09 PM
I am a well established Mory-phil on this board, but I think you'd be happy with either.

I also took a long time to get used to those four extra bases, but just this year (possibly because the pandemic has triggered an obsessive playing and practicing spree for me) I find them  falling easily under my fingers. I just wrote a tune with a Bb/Dm/F sequence in the b section.

When I switched to two and a half row from a 2row8bass, I did not find the extra weight to be a problem at all. I mean, I play a three row, a 2.5 row, a 2 row, a one row, and a tiny one row ... each have their unique qualities, but shifting between the weights has never caused me trouble.

I'm in Maine, if you're anywhere near, you can come and try mine.
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Steve_freereeder on November 12, 2020, 06:34:11 PM

Steve Freereeder of this parish will be along very soon in sure!
His knowledge and opinions will be worth a listen as he has a Mory and a 1914.

Personally, I love the sound of a Mory. It has a massive all round warm sound that is lovely.

Yes, as Q says, I have a Mory and a 1914.

The Mory indeed has a lovely warm sound and very even throughout. It is the ideal box for ensemble playing or solo gigging. In car terms it is a Daimler or Rolls Royce.

The 1914 is like a sports car: fast and lively. I use my 1914 in many situations: teaching, morris, sessions, ceilidh bands, etc. It is lighter and more maneuverable than the Mory; important for me as I'm definitely a small-sized person and don't have the physique to hoy a Mory around for morris. Although the 1914 accidentals are on the 2-button half-row (just where you need them in fact), it actually feels like you're playing a two-row box.

The grille switches to control the LMM voices are also very conveniently situated on the 1914; they are in plain sight, so they are easy to aim for when you need a sudden voice change mid-tune. On the Mory, which has the voice switches out of sight behind the fingerboard, I do sometimes hit the wrong switch by mistake.

The 1914 sound is immediate and focussed and yes, it tends to be louder than the Mory, mostly due to the smaller cross-sectional area of the bellows; yet it is still capable of playing softly. Mine is the 8-bass version; I don't miss the extra bassess and chords found on the Mory.

I love both my boxes, but if I had to be restricted to just the one, it would be the 1914, without a doubt.

Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Sal Rotondo on November 12, 2020, 07:09:49 PM
Gary: Thank you for the offer.  I'm in New York so it's a long trip up to Maine.

I checked out your blog and it's excellent.  I really enjoyed your playing!
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Michael Montcombroux on November 12, 2020, 07:30:39 PM
Sal
The Mory is an outstanding instrument. I owned one for a short while. It was bought. sight unseen from the Button Box in Sunderland, Mass. Had I been able to test drive it I would not have bought it. I was drawn to melodeons because of their light weight and simplicity. I found the Mory to big and too heavy for me. If I was prepared to go heavier, I think I would have opted for a CBA and the ability to play anything. As it was, I traded it in for a smaller, lighter Castagnari, and am quite content to work around its limitations.
I am pretty much a beginner. So maybe the Mory was too much for my level.
Michael
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Sal Rotondo on November 12, 2020, 07:54:25 PM
Steve and Michael: Thank you for your input.  It's very helpful.
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: -Y- on November 12, 2020, 07:56:28 PM
Also, I think it's a heavy price to pay to have both the low notes and the accidentals on a 2+2 rows. Another Castagnari box with 2+2 where it's the same reeds than on the top of the keyboard will be as capable as a 1914, as well built, and significantly cheaper. Seeing that you'll rarely use the low notes anyway, as you're wanting a G/C, I don't think it's worth the price difference.
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: heartshaped1 on November 12, 2020, 10:19:39 PM
I switched from a Hascy to a Mory. Fine, I thought, I’m already at the heftyish end of two rows so I’ll hardly notice. I was very wrong! For the first eight months I absolutely hated my Mory and it was probably only my stubbornness that stopped me swopping straight back to a two row. I’d pick up my pokerwork or my Lilium time after time in preference to the Mory, which I found heavy, slow, and a bit, well, bland to be honest. I would play it for about twenty minutes and then abandon it in favour of my ‘fun’ boxes.

Two years on, my perspective has entirely changed. I’ve come to terms with the extra weight, and there are so many benefits, not only the extra keys and voices of course, but also there’s something about it, I don’t know if it’s the bellows capacity or the left hand weight, or what it is really, gives you an amazing range of expression. It helps me say what I want to say with a tune in a way my other boxes don’t.

Good luck with whichever box you choose as they are both excellent, but if it’s the Mory, I found that sometimes the best love stories take time to develop! 😀

Vicky
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Steve_freereeder on November 13, 2020, 01:10:43 AM
Also, I think it's a heavy price to pay to have both the low notes and the accidentals on a 2+2 rows. Another Castagnari box with 2+2 where it's the same reeds than on the top of the keyboard will be as capable as a 1914, as well built, and significantly cheaper. Seeing that you'll rarely use the low notes anyway, as you're wanting a G/C, I don't think it's worth the price difference.

With respect, have you actually played a 1914? Until you have actually tried one, you have no way of telling how good they are. Also it is the only Castaganri 2-row +2 which has the chin end notes independent of the half-row notes. The other models e.g. the Stephania and the Alain have mechanical linkages connecting the chin-end buttons with the half-row buttons.
 
I have a G/C 1914 which is 3rd button start. The half-row accidentals are in the upper octave [G#4/Bb4] [D#5/C#5]; the chin end accidentals are in the lower octave  [D#4/C#4] [G#3/Bb3]. You can specify when ordering whether you want low notes or accidentals at the chin-end.

My D/G 1914 is also 3rd button start, giving me the full range of the keyboard at the top (knee) end, with low notes at the chin end. The half-row has the normal accidentals [Bb4/G#4] [D#5/F5] again just in the most convenient place.

Both of them really nice instruments, and very responsive and versatile.
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Julian S on November 13, 2020, 07:44:34 AM
Would I be right in thinking that the closest equivalent to a Casty 1914, but with the part row being linked to the first button accidentals rather than extra reeds, is the Alain ? This box lacks the extra features of the 1914 in terms of handily positioned stops and registers, and I don't know the price difference - or how they might compare in sound. Unless the Alain is very much cheaper or has other advantages, to me the 1914 has big pluses.
My first inclination was to say Mory purely because of the extra notes - but then I put myself  in the position of choosing the best all round instrument for the wide range of music I also play (which can include English, Irish, French, Breton, Scandi etc etc), and everything from morris dance outs, ceilidhs, concerts and sessions - if I ever lost my other instruments which I can choose between as required ! And whilst I've never played a 1914, Steve's comments might well convince me to go for that (whilst I know I'd miss the extra notes which I use more and more).
Anyway, as Vicky said - good luck with your choice.

Julian
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: -Y- on November 13, 2020, 08:27:11 AM
Steve, I don't have to try the 1914 to know it's a good box, it's the high end of Castagnari two rows, and owning a Castagnari myself, I'm already aware of the quality, reliability and consistency of the brand.
I was not minimising its qualities, but merely commenting on the fact that it may well be the most expensive box in the category of 3 voices 2+2. But I suppose, as Julian pointed out, that you pay for the register options (that would be 500$ for the registers and the two additional notes, compared to a Alain).

So in the end, as the two models (Mory and 1914) are somewhat similarly priced, maybe it comes down to what box size Sal will be most comfortable with in the long run (as the Mory is superior in the options it offers, but also bigger - which may be more influential on the feeling when playing than the raw weight).
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on November 13, 2020, 08:46:26 AM
I didn't realise the 1914 could have chin end accidentals as well, I always thought it was low notes only.
With the left hand pistons to bring in or take out thirds and low bass notes and a 8 or 12 bass option, plus now the choice of accidentals, then this makes it an incredibly adaptive melodeon. Adaptive to suit your personal choice.
A lighter option than the Mory if you go for the 12 basses maybe?
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Steve_freereeder on November 13, 2020, 11:16:44 AM
Steve, I don't have to try the 1914 to know it's a good box, it's the high end of Castagnari two rows, and owning a Castagnari myself, I'm already aware of the quality, reliability and consistency of the brand.

Yes, you are right, but in my opinion the 1914 has a quality which sets it apart from the others, in terms of focussed sound, as well as the playability and features. It's difficult to define exactly but immediately you pick one up and start playing it you become aware that it is something rather special. Maybe it's to do with the internal design of how the reed blocks and the volume/capacity of the RH side and the comparative lack of extra gubbins, thanks to the placement of the grille switches mechanism. I don't know. All I can say is that they are extraordinarily good instruments, better than the specification would appear to indicate.
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Winston Smith on November 13, 2020, 11:26:56 AM
Steve, you should become a salesperson for Castagnari! If I had the spare wherewithal, I'd be onto Pete and have one ordered by now. You make that 1914 thing sound like a "must have"!
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: -Y- on November 13, 2020, 11:30:21 AM
And I fully trust your judgement. It's good to have outstanding 2r boxes I think, makers can have a tendency to focus their attention regarding sound and possibilities to bigger boxes at the expense of 'simpler' (for lack of a better word) models (in the sense that boxes like the 1914 are by no means simple accordions). There are great boxes here and there, that's not what I'm saying, but more often than not, you'd have to go for bigger boxes to have this level of options.
My only regret is that you can't have the L voice alone, especialy on a Castagnari.
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on November 13, 2020, 11:54:00 AM
Um.... surely you can have the L voice alone on the Mory?
I know I've been told you can have it on the 2 row Trilly too....
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: -Y- on November 13, 2020, 12:04:01 PM
On the Mory and Trilly, yes, on the 2914, no.
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Steve_freereeder on November 13, 2020, 12:14:25 PM
My only regret is that [on the 1914] you can't have the L voice alone, especialy on a Castagnari.
Yes, you are correct. The 1914 switches enable you to select M, MM, LM and LMM, but not L on its own. But the lack of the L voice on its own has never been a disadvantage for me; all the other plus points of the 1914 more than compensate!  ;)
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: -Y- on November 13, 2020, 12:18:50 PM
Glad it suits you. I think on my G/C the L register might be the register I use the most. At least as much as the MM register. So I guess it depends on how/what you play. But it starts to drift us a bit too far from the original post  ;D
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Steve_freereeder on November 13, 2020, 12:33:58 PM
Glad it suits you. I think on my G/C the L register might be the register I use the most. At least as much as the MM register. So I guess it depends on how/what you play. But it starts to drift us a bit too far from the original post  ;D

These recent exchanges have been most interesting and I think it highlights the difference of approach between D/G players and G/C players, their respective music traditions, and what they mainly seek from a melodeon. All good stuff and thanks for your own insight!  (:)
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on November 13, 2020, 01:21:31 PM
Ah yes peeps, apologies for my misunderstanding.
The 1914 grill switches are the same on my Hascy, and yep I cannot select the L reed on their own.
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Sal Rotondo on November 13, 2020, 01:23:41 PM
Thank you all for your input.

I just need to make up my mind regarding box size.

I do have a further question and it's regarding the Mory layout.  Any recommendation: standard layout or the Cutting layout?  (I realize that Castagnari's website indicates that the Cutting layout is available only in D/G.  I would like a G/C box so maybe Castagnari can give me a Cutting layout in that key).

Sal
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: pete /acorn on November 13, 2020, 02:59:17 PM
If I may have a small input into this thread,
Instruments are very personal things,I see many customers who come with ideas of what they would like but in practice when they get hold of the instrument it just does not feel right when they play it.
I would not like to say how many people have gone away with a different model to what they intended to buy.

The Mory and 1914 are very different animals.

I have most Castagnari models in stock in the GC format and small layout alterations are always possible,I will be adding  a GC Mory in December .

The 1914 is as standard in 12 bass now.

www.acorninstruments.co.uk (http://www.acorninstruments.co.uk)

Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Gena Crisman on November 13, 2020, 03:23:50 PM
Links:
G/C Mory Casta Standard (https://www.castagnari.com/doc/modello_215_-_12b_-_g-c.pdf)
D/G Mory Casta Standard (https://www.castagnari.com/doc/modello_215_-_12b_-_d-g.pdf)
D/G Mory Cutting layout (https://www.castagnari.com/doc/modello_215_-_12b_-_d-g-cutting.pdf)
D/G 4th Button Start on the Acorn Instrument website, since the link on castagnari's website appears to be dead (https://www.acorninstruments.co.uk/images/instruments/2019/mory_dg_4th_layout.jpg)

The focus of a D/G layout, and I suppose by extension, Andy Cutting's layout, is likely to be directed to the lower octave, rather than the higher octave that G/C players tend to hang out in. You may want to check the options that it gives you are of any interest to you. Also the (D/G speak) extra E/A bases are... idk I want to say kind pointless given it has a 3rds switch?

Like, any given 2.5 row layout tends to extend your range in a specific way. Andy's layout has a different intent than Casta's standard layout for this box. An example might be, when Andy wants to play in Gm or Dm, I believe he swaps to a C/F box from a D/G. The extra basses of Casta's standard layout are kind of designed towards playing in Dm/Gm on its D/G box. Then again it's probably nicer to play in Am on Andy's D/G box by comparison to Casta's one, so, maybe he has more versatility when he drops a tone to the C/F. But if you want one box to rule them all, then, you need to be keeping that in mind.

So, remember that pretty much everything is traded against something else. You've noted that you do use your current accidentals - can I ask, do you use all of them? Or, do you use some of them more than the others? What direction are those accidental notes in, because, they may be in a different direction than you expect on these other layouts, and that change might be very off putting to you.

I noted you currently play a Dino Baffetti, what, if anything, drew you to the specific model of box you're playing? Is it a 2v or 3v instrument? Does it have a thirds stop?
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Sal Rotondo on November 13, 2020, 03:47:03 PM
Gena,  

Thank you for your insight on the Cutting layout.

I mainly use the G# accidental on the push for songs like "Greensleeves" and "Principessa".

I really can't see myself venturing into other keys like Andy Cutting.

I chose my Dino Baffetti due to its price and availability in the U.S. as well as its features: three-voice LMM and a stop to take out the L and a bass stop to remove the 3rds.

Here's the box: http://baffetti-accordions.com/fisarmoniche/art-85-lcgb/

Sal
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: CAB on November 13, 2020, 04:06:33 PM
Also the (D/G speak) extra E/A bases are... idk I want to say kind pointless given it has a 3rds switch?

Definitely.  I had Am and EM basses/chords put on the Dony I ordered back in the 1980s but I certainly wouldn't bother now.  Were there 3rds out switches back in those days?  I certainly didn't know about them.
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: -Y- on November 13, 2020, 04:45:13 PM
]As a G/C player, I find that the standard Castagnari right-hand layout makes sense: you have all the missing accidentals on two octaves, plus the G/A reversal. If you chose the Mory (but that's true for any layout), you'll get used to anything, really. And as Gena pointed out, Andy Cutting's layout is aimed at a specific player, and with a specific configuration (another box for other keys and so on). So maybe the standard layout is better for an "all-round" box.

For the left-hand side, it also depends on the music you'll want to play: what is your interest? It should be mentioned that most methods or printed repertoires of French "bal folk"/"bal trad" would might use the standard layout with Eb/Bb and G#/B. In that respect, the right-hand standard layout is designed so that it fits with this arrangement.

Also the (D/G speak) extra E/A bases are... idk I want to say kind pointless given it has a 3rds switch?

I think they make perfect sense if you want to play modal music, or any music/musical arrangement that makes use of drones.

I would not like to say how many people have gone away with a different model to what they intended to buy.
The Mory and 1914 are very different animals.

Pete is right, the feeling when playing is everything. Is there any shop or owner near you?  Would the one shop in Philadelphia be close enough (not that well aware of the diatonic accordion shop in the US)? Maybe they have a similarly sized box in stock?
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Sal Rotondo on November 13, 2020, 05:23:25 PM
Y: I play English, Irish, French, Italian and some American folk songs. 

Also, I've just heard back from the Button Box in Sunderland, Mass. and they have a Rik which is around the size and weight of the Mory so I'll try that out and see how it goes.
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Gary P Chapin on November 13, 2020, 05:50:03 PM
These recent exchanges have been most interesting and I think it highlights the difference of approach between D/G players and G/C players, their respective music traditions, and what they mainly seek from a melodeon.
Yes, you are right, but in my opinion the 1914 has a quality which sets it apart from the others ... It's difficult to define exactly but immediately you pick one up and start playing it you become aware that it is something rather special.

Good thoughts. I've had that experience of becoming "aware that it is something special" and it's such a personal feeling. I haven't played a 1914. It happened when I stopped by the Button Box and tried a D/G Tommy ... just so fleet and right, like the instrument wanted me to play it well ... I had to really talk myself out of buying it. And the D/G and G/C difference can't be overstated. I have found it very interesting to observe. Also, I have a special affection for the 2row8bass setup that has me keeping my eyes out for "the last accordion I'll ever buy" even though I am all full up with same.
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Steve_freereeder on November 13, 2020, 05:54:41 PM
Y: I play English, Irish, French, Italian and some American folk songs. 

Also, I've just heard back from the Button Box in Sunderland, Mass. and they have a Rik which is around the size and weight of the Mory so I'll try that out and see how it goes.
The Rik is a good box; very versatile, especially in G/C tuning where it is perhaps not so crucial to have the L voice. 
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Gena Crisman on November 13, 2020, 05:55:50 PM
I mainly use the G# accidental on the push for songs like "Greensleeves" and "Principessa".
I really can't see myself venturing into other keys like Andy Cutting.
I chose my Dino Baffetti due to its price and availability in the U.S. as well as its features: three-voice LMM and a stop to take out the L and a bass stop to remove the 3rds.

Cool, the 3v Art 85. I think in terms of size and behaviour, that should be in more or less in the same kinda ballpark as the 1914? I thought I would really like the 1914, but I found playing them (& all full size Casta boxes) to be a strangely passionless experience - but, I prefer smaller instruments and have a non dissimilar experience with the Art 85. I had much better luck with the Castagnari Tommy, but ended up looking elsewhere.

Anyway, the good news is that your G# on the push is the same as these Castagnari instruments. Effectively you're using it to play in something called A harmonic minor. You're currently probably in possession of a G#4, so your accidentals right now are: (probably this orientation) Eb4/C#4 and G#4/Bb4. If wishes were horses, and you had another G# on the instrument, would you want one that was higher (G#5) or lower (G#3) than the one you currently have? I believe the standard Castagnari G/C layout for a Mory offers you one that is higher than your current.

The 1914 appears to come in two G/C layouts as standard:
Layout 1, with standard low notes (https://www.castagnari.com/doc/1914_g-c_1.pdf)
Layout 2, with extra chin accidentals (https://www.castagnari.com/doc/1914_g-c_2.pdf)

The 2nd 1914 there with extra chin accidentals probably offers you an extra G#3 that is lower than your current one. Well, I certainly hope so, or you'd have the same problem you already do. I can only assume that it offers a low G#3/Bb3 and a high Eb5/C#5, but, maybe not? I personally would expect the order on the half row to be G#4/Bb4, Eb5/C#5, but instead the diagram has the Eb/C# first. I any case, the layout that I personally would have expected for layout 2 is as per the layout that Steve Freereeder described here (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,26229.msg312793.html#msg312793).

So you can see that if you were driven by just that one motive, that one extra G#, you're looking at potentially a night/day difference between the two choices in what it might add for you, even if every other aspect of the experience was the same.

I should note that, what with the exposed wooden keyboard of the Dino being as it is, there may some amount of money that is significantly less than the literal thousands of dollars for a new instrument that could be paid to some local enterprising individual that might set up the arrangement found on eg this castagnari Vicky (https://www.castagnari.com/eng/prodotto.html?id=4&k=72), where a half row is connected also to the chin buttons, so they are physically just the same button. It might not feel completely perfect as the Art 85's keyboard doesn't yield as much space for it, but it might be possible, and a cost saving half measure? Just a thought for you.
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Steve_freereeder on November 13, 2020, 06:04:29 PM

The 1914 appears to come in two G/C layouts as standard:
Layout 1, with standard low notes (https://www.castagnari.com/doc/1914_g-c_1.pdf)
Layout 2, with extra chin accidentals (https://www.castagnari.com/doc/1914_g-c_2.pdf)

The 2nd 1914 there with extra chin accidentals probably offers you an extra G#3 that is lower than your current one. Well, I certainly hope so, or you'd have the same problem you already do. I can only assume that it offers a low G#3/Bb3 and a high Eb5/C#5, but, maybe not? I personally would expect the order on the half row to be G#4/Bb4, Eb5/C#5, but instead the diagram has the Eb/C# first. I any case, the layout that I personally would have expected for layout 2 is as per the layout that Steve Freereeder described here (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,26229.msg312793.html#msg312793).

The 1914 and its various layouts are probably a fairly new concept even for Castagnari. Gena, you are correct that on the G/C 1914 that the chin-end accidentals should be an octave lower than the half-row accidentals. Otherwise it would just be a pointless duplication. To be on the safe side, anyone ordering a new G/C 1914 should really, really, make sure that Castagnari know what you want in terms of octaves for the accidentals.

For what it's worth, here's my G/C 1914 layout attached. It works really well for me.
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: pete /acorn on November 13, 2020, 06:26:02 PM
If anyone is interested,
I have just ordered reeds to convert a standard GC 1914 giving the option on my stock boxes with standard layout to accidental layout.

Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Steve_freereeder on November 13, 2020, 06:33:38 PM
For the sake of completeness in this discussion, here are my layouts for my D/G 1914 and my D/G Mory.

See how the D/G 1914 differs from the G/C 1914 (see previous post attachment), in terms of accidentals and low notes. The difference reflects the separate playing styles typical of D/G boxes and G/C boxes.

The D/G Mory layout differs from the 'standard' Castagnari layout. The latter is a simple transposition by Castagnari from G/C to D/G, but it does not work particularly well on a D/G, because you don't have the 'low octave' accidentals of D#4/F4. However in 'my' layout (what Pete Ward terms 'Eb accidentals' on the Acorn website), you do have the low octave accidentals and the upper octave accidentals and the Dutch reversal E/D in the middle of the half-row.
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: melodeon on November 14, 2020, 04:07:00 PM
"Also, I've just heard back from the Button Box in Sunderland, Mass. and they have a Rik which is around the size and weight of the Mory so I'll try that out and see how it goes."


That accordeon is a C#/D/G
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on November 14, 2020, 05:28:11 PM
"Also, I've just heard back from the Button Box in Sunderland, Mass. and they have a Rik which is around the size and weight of the Mory so I'll try that out and see how it goes."


That accordeon is a C#/D/G

I thing the Rik is an MM box, rather than LMM. Don't know if that would be an issue.
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Steve_freereeder on November 14, 2020, 05:40:17 PM
"Also, I've just heard back from the Button Box in Sunderland, Mass. and they have a Rik which is around the size and weight of the Mory so I'll try that out and see how it goes."


That accordeon is a C#/D/G

I thing the Rik is an MM box, rather than LMM. Don't know if that would be an issue.

Yes - the Rik is two-voice MM+
Also, if Jeff is right about the tuning, it won't be what you are looking for.
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: -Y- on November 14, 2020, 05:47:11 PM
If I understood correctly, it's more about experiencing the feeling of a bigger box, the Dony being somewhat closer in size to what the Mory is, rather than having a perfect match regarding the key and voices.

Sal, it's worth mentioning that The Button Box seem to have Hohner Panther in stock, which is roughly the same size than a Mory, although lighter.
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Sal Rotondo on November 14, 2020, 07:59:50 PM
If I understood correctly, it's more about experiencing the feeling of a bigger box, the Dony being somewhat closer in size to what the Mory is, rather than having a perfect match regarding the key and voices.

Sal, it's worth mentioning that The Button Box seem to have Hohner Panther in stock, which is roughly the same size than a Mory, although lighter.

You are correct: it's more about trying something close in size to the Mory and the Rik is around the same size.  I'll be sure to try the Panther as well.
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: pete /acorn on November 16, 2020, 10:17:48 AM
I Have GC Morys due in in December.
They should have been here November but were delayed

VAT free for export to US,ie 20% cheaper than list price.

List price updated in next day or 2.

www.acorninstruments.co.uk (http://www.acorninstruments.co.uk)
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: melodeon on November 16, 2020, 02:57:35 PM
FWIW

I have owned many accordeons, 15 of them Castagnaris. Of those 15 all were excellent a few were and only one was a dog.

As to choices of number of rows, number of reeds etc.. this is where I have landed..

My first choice If I were to have only one accordeon would be a 1 row Melodeon. Likely in D but I prefer the sound of a C box.

As to two rows, I have not played the 1914 but my last Hascy  ( of 2) was a brilliant D/G from 2010/11  and one of the finest accordeons I have ever played.

I like the two row for its simplicity and, if you are clever and talented you can play some extraordinary pieces of music.. As an example look up toraderM of youtube (and here) and see what he does with a 2 row 8 base.  I believe his current 2 row may be a Weilly (sp).  Here's an example  and then check out Take 5 on his channel.

 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jdn1KCGii-E

I would also suggest that a two row in GC may not need a low not set of reeds but I prefer them.
I would own a two row rather than a 2 1/2 row. See below.

2 1/2 row boxes..
I have owned 2 Mory models.  Both in GC. If I were to get a multi rowed box again I would not get a 2 1/2 row,
I would go to a 3 row.

I would get  either RIK or EVO  or a 12 bass Benny  all  MM  because the low range is  not necessary in G/C,, already low enough. I would want  a bass stop for the thirds. This would be as light as a Mory, if not lighter, and all the notes you would ever need.

And I would consider a GCF.. yes GCF.  Listen to Conjunto/Tex-Mex players with two reeds and GCF play chromatically in many keys.
This is done by playing mostly on the pull. Great music. And GCF for American folk, Quebec, French etc.. The universal box.

Here is an example of GCF from Remco Sietsema.. he is known to hang here on occasion:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3FJ0bPDqt6U


Just my current thoughts. Subject to change.
 





Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Sal Rotondo on November 16, 2020, 03:27:10 PM
Melodeon: Thank you for the input.  I checked out the two videos and these guys are incredible.  Way out of my league!
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: melodeon on November 16, 2020, 03:42:02 PM
Out of mine too but they play that way because... the played. and played and played some more.
This is what a 2 reed Hohner three row can do in a GCF  (or other 4th/5th apart ) configuration can do.

Here is Dwayne Verhayden of Holland..

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1QtEfJ9byN0&t=43s

For a bit of French.. roll forward to 3:40.

The point here is that you do not need more than 2 reeds, or accidentals or a Castagnari.

My preference in brands is very wide spread.
I very much like Hohners and Castagnaris and not much in between

And an observation.. you are either a box player or you are not.  I have tried not to be,, but I lost.. I must play. Even though I have been lame now for over two years and not really able to play, I am getting back to it. Slowly.
I sold all of my Accordeons except my GGFs  1920 Swiss made 2 1/2 row D/G and a very fine 50s/early 60s Black Corona II in GCF.

And as an addicted box player you will own more than one accordeon in your lifetime. I know I will own more.

I am in the same position you are now, making a decision.

I like quality, light, fast and flipable.   : )

If money is not the first consideration and you are willing to wait get a 1914... or a 3 row with 2 reeds.

Or get a good modestly priced HOHNER and play the hell out of it while considering the next box ( and the next box and the next one)

But get one  and play. I suggest GC as it is universal.
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: -Y- on November 17, 2020, 08:22:35 AM
all MM because the low range is not necessary in G/C, already low enough.
I've already talked about this earlier but I would'nt want my main box in G/C, without the L voice, and the ability to have it alone. Regarding the number of voices, there is an increasing trend for 2 voices models, LM. I guess it's also a good compromise wrt to sound possibilities, if you're not fixed on the tremolo sound. (but I may not be a reference, my ideal box would have LMMH on a 3r). If that's not an issue for you Sal, the Mas model from Castagnari is a very good choice : full 3r, with the whole range of sound possibles, with the exception of the tremolo (that is L, M, and LH), 18 basses, same size than a Rik.
That being said, melodeon is right, a full 3 rows is also a good idea, and not really much heavier or bigger than a 2.5r: most of the time, 3r models are something like 100-300g heavier than their 2.5r counterparts (that's true for MM or LMM).

I would want  a bass stop for the thirds.
Personaly, I'm all in favour of not having the thirds at all, and having a stop to remove the low bass instead.

two reeds and GCF play chromatically in many keys.
Well, the chromaticity is mainly due to the presence of accidentals on top of the keyboard on these models, which is a bit far from the reason Sal started this post, that is having them in a more useful place.
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Sal Rotondo on November 17, 2020, 03:06:12 PM
That's correct: I definitely need the accidentals in the middle of the board.  Also three-voice is a requirement for me.
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: melodeon on November 18, 2020, 02:04:29 AM
"Middle of the board"..

Do you mean the third or 2 1/2th row ?

If you mean middle of the board, sounds like you have made a decision on a 2 1/2 row.

Also look at the Mory.   11 /10 / 5

Three row Castagnari... 12/11/10

For another few bucks, dinars, pesos, pounds    and a few more ounces.. 3 row.
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Gary P Chapin on November 18, 2020, 01:53:37 PM
I would want  a bass stop for the thirds.
Personaly, I'm all in favour of not having the thirds at all, and having a stop to remove the low bass instead.

Playing Breton music is the one place where, consistently, I remove the thirds from the bass. I find it very much suits that repertoire.
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Sal Rotondo on November 27, 2020, 08:20:49 PM
I've visited the Button Box in Sunderland, Mass., USA and tried the Rik which is approx. same weight and size as the Mory.

I've found the difference from my two-row Dino Baffetti to not be substantial therefore, I've decided not to go with the 1914.

If I am to buy a new box, it would most likely be the Mory in G/C; if my MAD acts up in the new month or so, I'll move forward with a purchase.
Title: Re: Castagnari 1914 vs. Mory
Post by: Rob2Hook on November 29, 2020, 01:43:22 PM
Do it now!  As the years pass by all my misguided activities and subsequent injuries catch up on me, making it difficult to stand still, like when playing for morris.  My back locks up and I slowly keel over.  I'm currently playing a 1914 and that's all the weight I can bear when standing, though I can play sitting indefinitely, especially when suitably fuelled with muscle relaxant (beer).

Rob.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal