Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Chris Marriott on November 12, 2020, 03:44:10 PM
-
The C bass note on my Pokerwork is a lot "lighter" than the other 7 basses - ie it needs much less force to press the button. Presumably this is down to the tension on the bass spring. Can this be adjusted, or is it likely that the spring needs replacing? An easy or difficult job for the incompetent DIYer?
Thanks,
Chris
-
It does sound as if a spring needs to be replaced. It’s a fiddly job which usually involves removing the complete bass mechanism in order to withdraw the axle rod to thread a new spring onto the rod.
-
It does sound as if a spring needs to be replaced. It’s a fiddly job which usually involves removing the complete bass mechanism in order to withdraw the axle rod to thread a new spring onto the rod.
Thanks, Theo. It's not really a problem; the note plays fine and there's no air leak, so I can live with it. At some point I intend to have the box converted to a 4th button start, which certainly isn't a job I'd take on myself, so I'll get it sorted when I have that done.
Cheers,
Chris
-
For anyone who is inclined to tackle springs on a Hohner, the job is fiddly and time consuming but easy to understand once you take a look. My experience was gained on the treble end of a Chinese Pokerwork which seemed to break a spring every month for a year - since then all has been good.
The first thing is to remove the tension in the system by unhooking each spring, otherwise their combined strength will be trying to wrench the action out of the box while you're unscrewing it and the tiny mounting screws will pull out rather than unscrew. I used a crotchet hook with a notch filed into the back so one side allowed me to push a spring whislt the other side (the original hook) would pull a spring. With the tension removed the screws can be removed and the whole action lifts out. I then screwed the action onto an old wooden bread board to keep everything in line. Pulling the pivot rod out slowly, each components can be caught and laid out ready for reassembly until you reach the broken spring. Simply reassemble and refit to the box before popping all the springs back onto the levers. With an old box, there may be some benefit in completely dissassembling and cleaning the rod before rebuilding as they do get a bit dirty, but don't use any abrasive that would make it a slack fit.
Rob.
-
It does sound as if a spring needs to be replaced. It’s a fiddly job which usually involves removing the complete bass mechanism in order to withdraw the axle rod to thread a new spring onto the rod.
Thanks, Theo. It's not really a problem; the note plays fine and there's no air leak, so I can live with it. At some point I intend to have the box converted to a 4th button start, which certainly isn't a job I'd take on myself, so I'll get it sorted when I have that done.
Cheers,
Chris
Be prepared for the spring to fail completely, withhout further warning. It's an easy job (that even I can manage). Charlie sells the springs. They cost bugge very little. Why not just do it?
-
...Pulling the pivot rod out slowly, each components can be caught and laid out ready for reassembly until you reach the broken spring.
Additionally, as you pull out the pivot rod (axle), follow it down with a piece of stiff but flexible copper wire from the other end. It keeps all the components together and makes the reassembly job easier, as you simply reverse the process, withdrawing the copper wire as you re-insert the axle.
-
Be prepared for the spring to fail completely, withhout further warning. It's an easy job (that even I can manage). Charlie sells the springs. They cost bugge very little. Why not just do it?
Fear, basically 😀.
If I dad decide to have a go, is this the spring I’d need?
http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Springs.html#8
Thanks,
Chris
-
Be prepared for the spring to fail completely, withhout further warning. It's an easy job (that even I can manage). Charlie sells the springs. They cost bugge very little. Why not just do it?
Fear, basically 😀.
If I dad decide to have a go, is this the spring I’d need?
http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Springs.html#8 (http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Springs.html#8)
Thanks,
Chris
Nope. it will look like this one
http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Springs.html#7 (http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Springs.html#7)
But be stronger, I can let you have a correct weight one if you decide to give it a go
-
Two things not mentioned above:
You also have to deal with the pushrods. Either remove the bent nail that that acts as a pivot. It's best to replace these as they often break when being being straightened and bent again. Make sore the replacements are exactly the same thickness or you you will end up with sloppy joints and more mechanical noise if they are thinner.
Depending on the location of the spring it is sometimes possible (after releasing spring tension) to shift the axle rod far enough to remove the end spring without first taking out the mechanism.
-
If I dad decide to have a go, is this the spring I’d need?
http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Springs.html#8
Thanks,
Chris
There are different weights of spring for the inside and outside rows. If you get a spring, off Charlie or Lester, if they know which button it is they will know which one to supply.
Two things not mentioned above:
...remove the bent nail that that acts as a pivot. It's best to replace these as they often break when being being straightened and bent again. Make sore the replacements are exactly the same thickness or you you will end up with sloppy joints and more mechanical noise if they are thinner...
Model railway track pins worked well for me. You need a good grip on them to bend them, though.
-
Model railway track pins worked well for me. You need a good grip on them to bend them, though.
I think Lester uses veneer pins (like small fine panel pins). He kindly sent me some a few years ago and they did the job perfectly. (:)
-
I very much appreciate all the advice - thank you. I've started getting some basic tools for maintenance and repair tasks (my first was a pair of end cutters to pull the bellows pins), and I look forward to doing some work on my Pokerwork. I'm going to leave the spring replacement until I've tackled some easier jobs first to build up my confidence. First job will be replacing the top and bottom grille cloth.
Chris
-
Thanks for correcting my ommission, Theo. I found it far easier to snip the pins out of the joint, even though my only foray into the bass end was to replace a couple of broken buttons. Incidentally, for some unknown historical reason Hohner cut the two shoulders at different heights so the new buttons only sit on one support rather than two diametrically opposed. If I were to do it again I'd file the higher one down to match the lower one. I was advised to use Hornby track pins as replacement pins and they worked well. They are plastic coated though and this doesn't like being bent to lock them in place.
Rob.