Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Tone Dumb Greg on November 13, 2020, 06:05:33 PM
-
What items would you include in a Tool Kit dedicated to melodeon repair?
Including modified standard tools...such as a notched pair of end cutters for removing bellows pins.
-
Telephone number of local fettler
Ron
-
Telephone number of local fettler
Ron
:D
I have that already!
-
I have a small piece of 2x1" batton, about 2" long.
I've drilled holes in it 'bellows pin size' and sketched the bellows onto it.
I remember several fettlers here saying that with Italian boxes ( my Castagnaris ) you should endevor to put the bellows pin back in the same hole it came out of.
My bit of wood helps me to do this!
-
A reed pinger.
Small screwdrivers various
Scalpel
Small standard screwdriver with slot cut in blade to use as a spring tool
-
I have a small piece of 2x1" batton, about 2" long.
I've drilled holes in it 'bellows pin size' and sketched the bellows onto it.
I remember several fettlers here saying that with Italian boxes ( my Castagnaris ) you should endevor to put the bellows pin back in the same hole it came out of.
My bit of wood helps me to do this!
Very true. Italian bellows pins can vary fractionally in the diameter, even on the same instrument.
-
Elastic bands, to jury rig broken springs
SJ
-
A Small crotchet hook with a notch filed into the back of the head. One side for pulling springs, the other t push them.
The length of any list will depend on how far you want to go into repairs. Most field repairs can be done with little more than a Swiss Army knife, but on the bench the tool kit can be quite large and with many different tools for the same job, depending on personal preference.
Rob.
-
A toothbrush and a magnet.
-
A reed pinger.
What do you use
Small standard screwdriver with slot cut in blade to use as a spring tool
Is this better than a set of spring hooks?
-
A reed pinger.
What do you use
Small standard screwdriver with slot cut in blade to use as a spring tool
Is this better than a set of spring hooks?
For reed pingers I buy brass sheet off ebay and cut them out, need to go to the shed to measure how thick it was
As to the spring tool you can see what I'm talking about here
https://youtu.be/5st25y_0wEY?t=431 (https://youtu.be/5st25y_0wEY?t=431)
-
A reed pinger.
What do you use
Small standard screwdriver with slot cut in blade to use as a spring tool
Is this better than a set of spring hooks?
I was just doing this job and releasing was easy enough with a small screwdriver, this didn’t work as well putting them back on ( Lester’s blade would work much better and so would a small stick of wood with a notch), I ended up using my fingers and had no problem putting them back on a Hohner one row.
Probably a bit tighter on a two row to start so I wouldn’t be able to do this with my fingers?
Edit to add : you need patience ;)
-
The length of any list will depend on how far you want to go into repairs. Most field repairs can be done with little more than a Swiss Army knife, but on the bench the tool kit can be quite large and with many different tools for the same job, depending on personal preference.
Rob.
The essential standard tool kit is of interest but I am most interested in tools adapted for and tools specifically designed and made for doing work on melodeons. All part of, but not all of, what I would call knacks.
Actually, I'm also interested in the other aspect of knacks: Ways of doing things that make a hard job easy. For instance, I worked as a TV engineer for about eight years. They were notorious for being full of screws in hard to locate positions. While some fixings were steel and all you had to was magnetise the screwdriver, others were non-ferrous. Special grips on screwdrivers were commercially available, but I always managed to lose these. They were useless anyway, half the time. One trick that helped was wrap a bit of solder around the end of the screwdriver and the screw, holding it on the blade while it was located. Another favourite was to gather a bit of ear wax on the blade and press the screw into it, holding it for location. Gross, but it worked a treat.
It was Steve D's suggestion of sliding a bit of wire in as you withdraw a shaft, when replacing springs, to keep the assembly intact that put me in mind of this. Little things that make life easy.
-
Another favourite was to gather a bit of ear wax on the blade and press the screw into it, holding it for location. Gross, but it worked a treat.
Gross indeed.
You will have some spare reed wax in your toolkit, scrape a bit of that onto the tip of the screwdriver and the screw will hold nicely.
-
Another favourite was to gather a bit of ear wax on the blade and press the screw into it, holding it for location. Gross, but it worked a treat.
Gross indeed.
You will have some spare reed wax in your toolkit, scrape a bit of that onto the tip of the screwdriver and the screw will hold nicely.
No worse than spitting on a drill bit to stop it overheating.
-
Earwax .... and a bit if a pain if you don't produce it ::)
-
Another favourite was to gather a bit of ear wax on the blade and press the screw into it, holding it for location.
A small piece of blu tack works well for that job.
-
Another favourite was to gather a bit of ear wax on the blade and press the screw into it, holding it for location.
A small piece of blu tack works well for that job.
Enough ear wax ;D
Just an example of what I mean by "knack". Like Q's bellow pin block.
-
For reed pingers I buy brass sheet off ebay and cut them out, need to go to the shed to measure how thick it was
I use the soft steel from the flattened sides of baked bean tins to make reed steadies (as opposed to reed lifters/pingers). The small tins do not have the reinforcement corrugations, so are better for the job. I cut the steel to size, about 10 cm x 1.5 cm, using old scissors, then smooth the sharp edges with a file, also file the ends nearly to a sharp edge.
I should say that for reed lifters, I nearly always use the Italian hook type of tool. I can get on with that. Some people can't, and they use the brass or phosphor bronze Hohner-type lifter such as Lester makes/uses. It's a matter of personal choice and what suits you best.
I have two Italian style reed lifter hooks, one large size from Charlie Marshal like the one in the top of this picture (http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Reed_Tuning_Tools.html#10), which is good for the large bass reeds. For the smaller reeds (nearly all the others) I use a smaller version, home-made, from a long blue steel saxophone needle spring (https://www.dawkes.co.uk/woodwind-repair-supplies/springs/needle-blue-tempered) stuck into a piece of wood dowel as a handle. The needle spring is thin, but strong and springy (as you would expect) and it slides under the reed tongues easily.
Using either the Hohner or the Italian reed lifter takes a bit of practice, but once mastered, becomes very quick and easy.
-
Files and scratchers:
Charlie Marshall sells reed scratchers here (http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Reed_Tuning_Tools.html). But I made my own years ago from an old round needle file with the teeth ground away and the end filed down to a cylindrical profile about 10 mm long and about 1 mm dia. The end is then squared off on a diamond plate (https://www.arceurotrade.co.uk/Catalogue/Diamond-Tools/Diamond-Stones/Diamond-Stone-1x3x14-320---Vee-Groove) so that it shows a tiny circle when viewed on end. You don't want a sharp point as this digs into the reed tongue. In use it needs a quick touch-up on the diamond plate to keep it the end flat with sharp perpendicular edges.
For reed files I use fine 400-grit diamond files. They cut very gently and evenly, and last a long time. I use the 400-grit version of these (https://www.arceurotrade.co.uk/Catalogue/Diamond-Tools/Diamond-Needle-Files/5pc-Diamond-Needle-File-Set-2x100mm). Cheap as chips, but do the job well and last a long time.
-
Screwdrivers:
...For instance, I worked as a TV engineer for about eight years. They were notorious for being full of screws in hard to locate positions. While some fixings were steel and all you had to was magnetise the screwdriver, others were non-ferrous...
Many screws used in melodeons are ferrous. I have a set of magnet-tipped screwdrivers which work a treat. Like these (https://www.amazon.co.uk/Durable-6pc-Screwdriver-Set-Phillips-Head/dp/B07P514XK5/ref=sr_1_6?dchild=1&keywords=magnetic+screwdriver&qid=1605337683&sr=8-6).
-
Soldering iron, variable temperature:
I have one similar to this (https://www.amazon.co.uk/KATSU-Tools-312087-Electronic-Temperature/dp/B00KBPN1ZU/ref=pd_sbs_328_4/261-3133810-7181152?_encoding=UTF8&pd_rd_i=B00KBPN1ZU&pd_rd_r=3ea44b66-2009-4db3-9c8c-aef33e2a556e&pd_rd_w=LdZ0F&pd_rd_wg=lVxzI&pf_rd_p=2304238d-df78-4b25-a9a0-b27dc7bd722e&pf_rd_r=CKET995PB626C2A0KYZH&psc=1&refRID=CKET995PB626C2A0KYZH). I have ground down one of the replacement tips down to a fine point which can get between reed plates even just 1 mm apart.
Used for melting and remelting reed wax in stick form (http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Reed_Wax_Nails.html#1). The variable temperature control is essential, otherwise the iron can get too hot and burns the wax.
-
Masking tape, low-tack:
Like this (https://www.amazon.co.uk/Fixman-193178-Low-Tack-Easy-Peel-Masking/dp/B00FHXGO64/ref=sr_1_5_mod_primary_new?dchild=1&keywords=low+tack+masking+tape&qid=1605338777&sbo=RZvfv%2F%2FHxDF%2BO5021pAnSA%3D%3D&sr=8-5).
Absolutely indispensible. I reduce the tackiness even further by pressing the sticky side to a piece of fabric, e.g. T-shirt, jeans, etc. before applying it. I use it all the time for:
1. A temporary label across the top of reed blocks so you can write on the notes of the reeds, or other identification marking. Saves having to mark the actual wood of the reed block, which I hate to see.
2. Blocking off the underside of half the reed block in order to silence one row or set of reeds while working on the other.
3. Small pieces to block off the bellows pins holes to stop air loss on the tuning bellows.
4. Small pieces the size of the reed plate to silence an individual reed plate. This is the Marc Serafini method: apply the tape to the reed plate directly over the reed tongue and valve and smooth the tape over the edge of the reed plate. This is really useful to silence individual reeds e.g. in chords, while you work on the others. Be sure to reduce the tackiness first. To remove, just lift carefully from the rivet end of the reed and peel off in a parallel movement, like peeling a banana. Hold down the valve with a finger as you peel.
-
Other sundries:
Sharp scissors for trimming valves, etc.
Sharp craft knife or scalpel
Cocktail sticks for applying glue, adjusting the set of reed tip gap, etc.
Solvent-free contact adhesive for fixing valves
Cyano-acrylate 'superglue': Great for fixing worn, enlarged, threads in wood screw holes or enlarged bellows pins holes. Just put a drop of superglue on the tip of a cocktail stick and run it around the inside of the hole. Remove cocktail stick before the glue sets. Repeat if necessary.
-
I'm not very practiced in the art of investigating the bowels of a melodeon.
It is usually ( only! ) been restricted to freeing a reed from a speck of dust.
My tools are my trusty piece of wood, an end cutter with a hole filed to fit the bellows pins, a small set of pliers as sometimes easier to remove the pins..... and a new £5 or £10 note.
I find if I gently feed the edge of a bank note in under the reed tongue and pull it back it is sufficient to dislodge and dust in between the reed tongue and the reed frame.
A friend introduced me to the bank note idea, in my concertina days and I vividly remember my first real concertina being reduced to bits in a cafe in Exeter, then being asked for a bank note and realising to my relief that the re-assembled concertina now worked as before!
Dunno what the assembled expert fettlers think, but it has been my 'go to' speck removing tool (:)
-
...I find if I gently feed the edge of a bank note in under the reed tongue and pull it back it is sufficient to dislodge and dust in between the reed tongue and the reed frame.
A friend introduced me to the bank note idea, in my concertina days and I vividly remember my first real concertina being reduced to bits in a cafe in Exeter, then being asked for a bank note and realising to my relief that the re-assembled concertina now worked as before!
Dunno what the assembled expert fettlers think, but it has been my 'go to' speck removing tool (:)
Sounds good to me!
With any sort of melodeon or concertina work (or any other instrument repair) I always think of, and try to abide by, the paraphrase of the Hippocratic Oath: Primum non nocere; First, do no harm.
If it does no harm and if it works, then it's OK! (:)
-
Probably my most "handy" improvisation is a set of feelers. I've filed down the tip of an 8 thou blade, so that it slides easily beneath and between the reeds on top their plates for use as a support while cleaning or tuning and also for "pinging". Then I use a 2 or 3 thou one for sliding along the sides of reeds, when depressed into their slot, to check for clearance and/or to clear any debris, also for adjusting the reed sideways in the slot. Or a thicker one when the reed is displaced enough to not actually fit into the slot.
I expect that the professionals might be horrified at me using steel implements in case they damage something, but I'm reasonably careful and I find them invaluable, and very cheaply replaced at car boot sales and the like for 50p or so!
-
Probably my most "handy" improvisation is a set of feelers. I've filed down the tip of an 8 thou blade, so that it slides easily beneath and between the reeds on top their plates for use as a support while cleaning or tuning and also for "pinging". Then I use a 2 or 3 thou one for sliding along the sides of reeds, when depressed into their slot, to check for clearance and/or to clear any debris, also for adjusting the reed sideways in the slot. Or a thicker one when the reed is displaced enough to not actually fit into the slot.
I expect that the professionals might be horrified at me using steel implements in case they damage something, but I'm reasonably careful and I find them invaluable, and very cheaply replaced at car boot sales and the like for 50p or so!
No, not at all. Steel feeler gauges are good. I think the steel used for reed tongues is tempered harder than the feeler blades, so little risk of damage. So long as you go carefully (Primum non nocere), you'll be OK.
-
Shouldn’t there be a box of Yorkshire tea in your tool kit?
-
"I think the steel used for reed tongues is tempered harder than the feeler blades"
I had imagined that this was the case, thanks for confirming that, Steve.
"Shouldn’t there be a box of Yorkshire tea in your tool kit?"
Where's that shuddering emoji? No no, arty, I cannot stomach that stuff, give me a nice mild Ceylon or possibly a Darjeeling (Single Estates, of course!) My doc has just told me that I should cut down on the tea and drink more plain water, but he's obviously as daft as a brush!
-
My doc has just told me that I should cut down on the tea and drink more plain water, but he's obviously as daft as a brush!
When mine said something similar it was to avoid the biscuit temptation.
-
Nobody has mentioned a good source for the 'magic dust' that most professional fettlers have in their tool kit.
Someone said you can only get it from the well of experience, but......?
-
Nobody has mentioned a good source for the 'magic dust' that most professional fettlers have in their tool kit.
Someone said you can only get it from the well of experience, but......?
I've tried it but found it messy. It clogs up the reeds.
On the other hand, this works a treat (https://www.renderhub.com/dmitriykotliar/magic-wand/magic-wand-01.jpg).
-
;D
Of course, why didn't I think of that!!
-
Is that for the high notes, Pearce? Ooooooh!
-
Some of the pliers I use:
A) rod/lever bending pliers
Scott
-
B) spring compression/insertion pliers
Allows replacement of springs without pulling axle.
-
C & G Pin pulling pliers & pin hole reamers
Phenolic jaws prevent damage to soft brass pin heads like Castagnari.
-
G) making pin puller with diamond sphere rotary tool
-
D) convex / concave jaws for making small angle 'dent' in round rods and flat levers.
-
E) you tell me...
F & J Round rod pliers
H) curved jaw pliers with round rod notch added
I) wide reedplate pliers
K) commercial jewelry round jaw wire bending pliers
-
L) offset needlenose pliers
pin pusher- large nail set embedded into golf ball- has nice internal conical hole to stay on pin head
-
hole punch pliers
M) paper punch
N,O,P Bates forged metal hole punch pliers
Q) leather punch
R) 2mm punch
S) 2mm punch
T) 3mm cast iron parallel motion punch
U) 4mm cast iron parallel motion punch
V) hole punch & grommet setting pliers for bellows straps
W) parallel action punch
-
What a lot of lovely things!
-
Don't drool Winston.
Thanks for the postings so far. Especially Hickory and Steve. Quite an eye opener. That's the next 10 years Christmas presents taken care of.
Thanks everyone else, too. I think I might compile a list.
-
Chris Marriott's lovely little finger clamps have just joined the list
-
Veterinary syringes and needles (For injecting cuprinol into woodworm holes).
Wine/Whiskey bottle screw tops (useful for holding small amounts of tube glue while you use a cocktail stick to apply it). Unfortuneately they don't survive very long in use so you have to keep obtaining replacements.
-
Wine/Whiskey bottle screw tops (useful for holding small amounts of tube glue while you use a cocktail stick to apply it). Unfortunately they don't survive very long in use so you have to keep obtaining replacements.
It's a hard life, but someone has to do it.
-
Whiskey bottle screw tops ... Unfortunately they don't survive very long in use so you have to keep obtaining replacements.
Obtain replacements may not be too complicated ;D
-
Many screws used in melodeons are ferrous. I have a set of magnet-tipped screwdrivers which work a treat.
That would be the way to go, but I still keep a child safety dart in my tool kit that comes in handy occasionally:
(http://www.shrinkpictures.com/processed/phpCcqdt4AM.jpg)
-
no such thing as too many clamps
pistol grip (trigger) clamps are a pretty great newer tool
-
Pingers/reed supports that I made from hacksaw blades:
(http://www.shrinkpictures.com/processed/phpk2g8rGAM.jpg)
Scratchers made from old drill bits:
(http://www.shrinkpictures.com/processed/phphi6cefAM.jpg)
Reed lifter made from a strip of steel out of a car windscreen wiper:
(http://www.shrinkpictures.com/processed/phpSF4X9CAM.jpg)
Spring release tool:
(http://www.shrinkpictures.com/processed/php7NoUOdAM.jpg)
-
Homemade waxing tools:
(http://www.shrinkpictures.com/processed/php5ZkrsTAM.jpg)
A couple of experimental waxing tools:
(http://www.shrinkpictures.com/processed/phpsn2dMUAM.jpg)
-
When all else has failed and you can't get the reeds to sing or the leaks to seal, and the woodworm are
laughing at you:
(https://d2wwnnx8tks4e8.cloudfront.net/images/app/large/0834554002803_3.JPG)
-
When all else has failed and you can't get the reeds to sing or the leaks to seal, and the woodworm are
laughing at you:
(https://d2wwnnx8tks4e8.cloudfront.net/images/app/large/0834554002803_3.JPG)
sometimes they need to be repurposed
-
For testing boxes without shoulder strap brackets. Temporary shoulder strap.
-
scrapers
I find myself preferring the old red wood handle scraper as it spans treble and chord reedblock chambers perfectly.
Some are just butter knives with most of the blade ground away. One is Sterling silver- for use on royal instruments.
-
For testing boxes without shoulder strap brackets. Temporary shoulder strap.
I don't quite see how that fastens on...
-
Cork lined jaws prevent damaging the instrument.
-
Veterinary syringes and needles (For injecting cuprinol into woodworm holes).
Wine/Whiskey bottle screw tops (useful for holding small amounts of tube glue while you use a cocktail stick to apply it). Unfortuneately they don't survive very long in use so you have to keep obtaining replacements.
A syringe and needle can also be used to inject glue (e.g. PVA wood glue) into splits, cracks and joints in wood, and not just on melodeons.
-
Pearce, most of your pictures don't show for me, but might that just be me?
Hickory Wind, please stop, this torture isn't fair!
-
Pearce, most of your pictures don't show for me, but might that just be me?
Hickory Wind, please stop, this torture isn't fair!
Sorry Winston, I can't stop.
Thumb screw clamps. I'm always on the lookout for used clamps with the simple thumb screw. Never a need for the higher torque from the sliding rod screws.
I line bare metal with felt.
-
And you even resort to the dreaded thumbscrews! Have you no pity, man?
-
Pearce [Pearse], most of your pictures don't show for me, but might that just be me?
They were previously displaying correctly for me, but now there is just a rectangle with the advertisement "Resize your pictures and photos for free at www.shrinkpictures.com"
-
I love my two accordion vises. They open enough to hold a pokerwork case longwise. I've lined the jaws with 1/4" cork for a nice cushioned grip. They are quick acting so just slide closed and give it a partial turn of the handle to clamp. I can use my knee leaving both hands free for positioning. Bellows can be held open while inspecting for and repairing corner holes.
Scott
-
I love my two accordion vises ...
Scott
They look good. Did you make them yourself, or are they adapted commercial units?
-
Are you damping the old bellows tape first of all? It really helps and does not cause any damage so long as you don't saturate the bellows. Just use a moist sponge or cloth on the tape and leave for a few minutes before trying to peel and scrape off the old tape. Allow everything to dry out thoroughly before attaching new bellows tape.
And remember your granny's old butter knife is your friend... :|glug
...and another item from another thread. Granny's bellows butter knife.
-
...and another item from another thread. Granny's bellows butter knife.
Yes - I have one. Except that I found it in a jumbo sale. It's just the job for those times when you need a strong, thin, but not sharp, blade, e.g. for easing bellows away from the wood frames. It works very well and it's made in Sheffield, of course.
-
Granny's bellows butter knife.
Granny's bellows butter knife better be blunt because bloody blunders befall blundering blighters bent on bothersome bellows bodge.
-
"Granny's bellows butter knife better be blunt because bloody blunders befall blundering blighters bent on bothersome bellows bodge."
That's easy for you to say!
-
They look good. Did you make them yourself, or are they adapted commercial units?
[/quote]
Commercial units from early 1900's. I only added cork jaw lining and foam knee pad on handle.
Here is a third one that is smaller than the other two during restoration.
Scott