Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: rileycat on November 18, 2020, 02:35:49 PM
-
I noticed that the quite distinctive fretted grill design used by Oakwood and Oakwood / Dino Baffetti Bincis has appeared on an Ebay seller's instrument of different heritage, I think (always happy to be corrected by the 'knowledgeable'). It seems an identical grill design to my eyes and I don't know about the quality, of course, as I haven't seen or played it and there's no maker attributed Anyhow, I just thought that folks might have a view about whether such a distinctive design represents a celebration of the quality of the former instruments - imitation being a sincere form of flattery - or is it just serendipitous! I'll leave folks to find it for themselves on ebay and stress that I'm unconnected with the seller. If it is one of the above - snap it up guys!
-
It does look similar but much flatter.
-
Isn’t it a Sandpiper, ie like this one
https://www.eaglemusicshop.com/prod/used-squeezeboxes/Used-Sandpiper-stint-DG-Melodeon.htm-128673 (https://www.eaglemusicshop.com/prod/used-squeezeboxes/Used-Sandpiper-stint-DG-Melodeon.htm-128673)
-
Could be from the same stable - it has some extra banding decoration and 2 stops, tho'.
-
And the ebay example has a raised grill, the Sandpiper has an inset grill.
-
This from the seller;
"I bought it last August at towersy festival from a melodeon stall. Unfortunately I can’t remember the name of the shop but know it wasn’t hobgoblin.
I bought it with the crack for £600 as it was reduced from the new price of £850."
I've no idea of the price of new things, but some of you lot might be able to work out whether this is a good buy or not from the two prices quoted.
I have no connection whatsoever with the seller, apart from emailing him and asking the question. Good luck.
-
I wonder if it is a prototype/pre-release version of the 3 voice Sandpiper Dunlin III, which has a raised grill and 23 buttons?
-
I noticed that the quite distinctive fretted grill design used by Oakwood and Oakwood / Dino Baffetti Bincis has appeared on an Ebay seller's instrument of different heritage, I think (always happy to be corrected by the 'knowledgeable'). It seems an identical grill design to my eyes and I don't know about the quality, of course, as I haven't seen or played it and there's no maker attributed Anyhow, I just thought that folks might have a view about whether such a distinctive design represents a celebration of the quality of the former instruments - imitation being a sincere form of flattery - or is it just serendipitous! I'll leave folks to find it for themselves on ebay and stress that I'm unconnected with the seller. If it is one of the above - snap it up guys!
I don't think it's flattery, or serendipity. It's cynical plagiarism of a respected design feature.
-
.... or could it be the Music Room using their own design for their lower end range?
-
The Music Room have not been in business for 2 or 3 years now. A model with stops would be more expensive than the basic Sandpiper so hardly a downgrade.
-
"I bought it last August at towersy festival from a melodeon stall. Unfortunately I can’t remember the name of the shop but know it wasn’t hobgoblin..
I remember the stall, pretty sure I know which dealer it was connected with (none of the regulars here). I recall not being impressed with the boxes, quite possibly the same stock I'd been unimpressed with earlier in the year at Chippenham.
-
"I bought it last August at towersy festival from a melodeon stall. Unfortunately I can’t remember the name of the shop but know it wasn’t hobgoblin..
I remember the stall, pretty sure I know which dealer it was connected with (none of the regulars here). I recall not being impressed with the boxes, quite possibly the same stock I'd been unimpressed with earlier in the year at Chippenham.
I think I visited the same stall, with the same conclusion. I bought a Bal Folk tunebook there. Can't remember the grill design, though. I was thinking of buying an LMM at the time. Gave up the idea after visiting a few stalls.