Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Squeaky Pete on November 22, 2020, 08:51:20 PM

Title: Bellows corners
Post by: Squeaky Pete on November 22, 2020, 08:51:20 PM
I'm doing maybe my 4th or 5th bellows retaping and following other people's observations on the taping thread.
But what do you do when the corners are a bit loose and the edges stick up from the bellows folds?
It creates that ridge that starts to wear the tape.
It's easy to push the metal corners off, but should I?
I've opened them up so they push on easier and I've reglued them before crimping them on, but even after filing the corners of the bellows they don't fit as well as I'd like.
I'm thinking I might have to make a little aluminium die to force the corners nearer to 89° than 90°. They are too difficult to bend by hand.
Title: Re: Bellows corners
Post by: Pat McInnis on November 23, 2020, 03:28:23 AM
Although I don't have a response for you old Pete, I'm really looking forward to hearing what the mob has to say since I'm doing the exact same thing...for the first time. Here we go.
Title: Re: Bellows corners
Post by: Pat McInnis on November 24, 2020, 10:55:29 PM
No one else has had this issue? Looks like it's just you and me Pete. Let me know how you make out. I'll be doing mine this week.
Title: Re: Bellows corners
Post by: malcolmbebb on November 24, 2020, 11:02:26 PM
Surprised there are so few responses, bellows corners have been discussed in the past with methods like carefully crimping them and using, if I recall correctly, something like PVA of similar adhesive to help fix them in position.
I get the impression that your problem is not simply fitting them back on, you are having problems getting them to sit or align correctly? I'm  not clear about the "edges stick up from the bellows folds".
Title: Re: Bellows corners
Post by: Peadar on November 24, 2020, 11:14:13 PM
My perception is that yes the tape that laps over the metal corners is a bit proud of the rest of the tape and does wear first. I think of it as the canary in the coal mine. When the worn off bit of tape on the worst worn fold gets to the end of the metal replace that bit of tape- If the wear goes any further it's into the beating cardboard heart of the instrument. Whether you retape one fold or the entire box is a matter of aesthetics.
Title: Re: Bellows corners
Post by: Squeaky Pete on November 24, 2020, 11:24:12 PM
I've made up a little jig of oak and ply and an aluminium former. It does close the angle to around 89° and the ends of the metal corners fit almost flush now.
When the corners are in a little pile on my bench I force them slightly more open with the blunt end of a twist drill. 2.5mm I think.
I've refitted the metal corners using fast PVA and crimped the ends. I didn't do the middle round the fold as I thought it might open the angle again. I'll close this a bit when the glue has set. It looks okay and the new tape should fit a bit better.
Title: Re: Bellows corners
Post by: Anne Croucher on November 25, 2020, 10:32:59 AM
I needed a replacement but when I tried it the curve was not quite right. I set it on a firm surface holding it vertically and a single gentle tap from a dainty hammer and it was almost correct, so another go and it was perfect.

I painted the inner surfaces with PVA glue slid it into place and then pressed on the corner to hold it in place as I narrowed the U to grip the bellows using pliers which I suspect were intended for jewellery making - they have no ridges and so don't mark even shiny surfaces, though a tiny bit of cloth or even tissue should protect. I pressed the ends and about the middle of each leg, it did not require anything more than a gentle pinch.
I left the glue to dry overnight and all was perfect.
Title: Re: Bellows corners
Post by: Squeaky Pete on November 25, 2020, 11:44:24 AM
Here's the rough and dirty jig. It seems to work fine.
The main screws holding the oak are on the other side, so it's not as flimsy as it looks.
The aluminium I cut it from is 2mm thick and I found I didn't need to open up the corners with a drill bit. Just tapping the alu former smartly with a hammer opens it up at the same time as closing the angle.
The pencil line you can see on the bottom board is because I didn't cut the end true enough and there's another line marked in case I turn it over.
Title: Re: Bellows corners
Post by: Rob2Hook on November 28, 2020, 03:52:51 PM
The other day I happened upon a Youtube video of a Russian guy making bellows totally from scratch - can't find it again now, of course.  He was cutting steel (?) sheet with tin snips, folding it into a U-section and then using a home-made bending tool, much like a pipe bender in principle, to bend to a rightangle.  I was amazed at how little wrinkling resulted!

I guess it's true that a very slight over bending is better than too little as the ends of the corner will then lie flush.

Rob.
Title: Re: Bellows corners
Post by: boxcall on November 28, 2020, 04:37:41 PM
When doing one corner on my recent 1040 repair I glued it then bent with pliers ( lightly I thought) which made the corner lift up and go out of round. So I pulled it off bent it back to round , then re glued it and then while holding it in place , used the bellows to put pressure on it to seat it.

As Peader pointed out the metal corners are always going to be above the bellow card.

I would keep it at 90 if match existing and the metal doesn’t grab on to much card/ paper , so by altering even a little it will grab less. Just a thought.
Title: Re: Bellows corners
Post by: playandteach on November 28, 2020, 05:08:24 PM
The other day I happened upon a Youtube video of a Russian guy making bellows totally from scratch - can't find it again now, of course. 
Rob.
Was it this one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6nmUhz7ciwk
Title: Re: Bellows cornersSh
Post by: Rog on November 28, 2020, 06:10:23 PM
I’ve replaced quite a lot of bellows corners so I'll throw in my opinion. I’ve noticed that some new corners are slightly less than 90 degrees, so they sit slightly angled down towards the fold edge, which is sort of the opposite of your problem, where the edge of the corner isn’t flush with the card.
If a corner is proud it means it’s not sitting far enough down onto the card/fold corner. Old ones slip off and don't always go right back on, and if the corner is a bit mashed up if it’s old getting the corner to go right back on can be tricky. You might need to squish the card corner flat with a clamp or something. My solution is to get hold of new corners rather than refitting old ones, as these haven’t been crimped and will give plenty of room to get it back in place without bits sticking out. I glue them back on with wood glue, and crimp them *after* the glue has dried, otherwise they can easily slip proud when the glue is wet and you crimp them. I actually have a Carini supplied bellows crimping tool, which allows you to set the depth of the crimp. But you could use plies, although this tends to squash the whole corner rather than just the edge of the corner.
Title: Re: Bellows corners
Post by: Rob2Hook on November 29, 2020, 01:11:27 AM
Was it this one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6nmUhz7ciwk

Yes, that's the one!  I found it fascinating to see how he has made his own jigs and tools for everything - enough that it shows a way to overcome any missing tooling when doing any jobs yourself.  Actually, I'm not so sure he was using steel for the corners.  The sheet looked far too shiny, but seemed to require more effort to cut than say aluminium.  Just watching him snip through card with pincers leads me to believe that he is also expert at sharpening his tools.

Rob.
Title: Re: Bellows corners
Post by: Rog on November 29, 2020, 07:03:24 AM
Russian (assuming he's Russian...) ingenuity. It’s what you do when you have no access to parts. Time consuming as hell though, esp given how cheap they are to buy. There’s another video of him making the long Bayan style reed plates with a jig/hammer/chisel. Like you say...he’s probably a tool maker and obvs has access to a machine shop.
Title: Re: Bellows corners
Post by: Anahata on November 29, 2020, 01:23:37 PM
Just watching him snip through card with pincers leads me to believe that he is also expert at sharpening his tools.

Yes, I suspect that kind of skill is common amongst craftsmen working on a shoestring, and maybe with difficult access to replacement tools. Cheaper to sharpen your blade (drills, snips etc...) than buy a new one, and worth the time spent if you are using them all day.
Title: Re: Bellows corners
Post by: Winston Smith on November 29, 2020, 04:52:28 PM
To be perfectly frank, I'm rather perplexed by the seriousness of this thread!

Being the skinflint that I am, I have collected a goodly number of "used" bellows corners of various radiuses, and have never (so far) had to buy (spit spit!) new ones. I just open the U shape up a touch, squeeze the corner of the bellows and knock the pre-glued metal corner on. If it's not quite right, I adjust it with my trusty knocking stick (or whatever) and do it again, finishing off by crimping it a touch when I'm happy. It's certainly NOT rocket science, and I'm surprised that Squeaky had to resort to making a former!

But then, I just want my things to work and not to spend my entire retirement farting about to very little purpose. (No offence whatsoever is intended in this posting, and no melodeons were injured in anyway.)
Title: Re: Bellows corners
Post by: Pat McInnis on November 29, 2020, 05:27:46 PM
To be perfectly frank, I'm rather perplexed by the seriousness of this thread!

Being the skinflint that I am, I have collected a goodly number of "used" bellows corners of various radiuses, and have never (so far) had to buy (spit spit!) new ones. I just open the U shape up a touch, squeeze the corner of the bellows and knock the pre-glued metal corner on. If it's not quite right, I adjust it with my trusty knocking stick (or whatever) and do it again, finishing off by crimping it a touch when I'm happy. It's certainly NOT rocket science, and I'm surprised that Squeaky had to resort to making a former!

But then, I just want my things to work and not to spend my entire retirement farting about to very little purpose. (No offence whatsoever is intended in this posting, and no melodeons were injured in anyway.)

Well someone is a bit of a wet blanket. I like the idea of overengineering and I do build a lot of my own tools but for this particular instance I did end up just giving my new corners a light squeeze in the vice until the angle was to my liking.
Title: Re: Bellows corners
Post by: Squeaky Pete on November 29, 2020, 05:50:54 PM
This particular box was causing me a bit of head scratching. Just bending the corners was hard to control sometimes all that happened was that the middle of the bend flared open and when it was crimped tight, it went back to the same wrong angle.
After trying a few methods I settled on the little jig. It takes seconds to do. I cramped up the bare cardboard corners and sanded them hard with 80 or 60 grit paper taking them back 1mm or so, removing the old hard dried glue. This gave a much better chance of the metal corners sitting nicely.
All 4 corners look ok but the one I did last after making the jig looks the best.
Title: Re: Bellows corners
Post by: Winston Smith on November 29, 2020, 05:57:11 PM
"All 4 corners look ok but the one I did last after making the jig looks the best."

I'm sure they're spot-on! Well done for that extra effort. I know that many members need to have things just "right", especially when they have the skill sets to do just that. Take no notice of my kidding.
Title: Re: Bellows corners
Post by: Peadar on November 29, 2020, 06:43:46 PM
Russian (assuming he's Russian...) ingenuity. It’s what you do when you have no access to parts. Time consuming as hell though, esp given how cheap they are to buy. There’s another video of him making the long Bayan style reed plates with a jig/hammer/chisel. Like you say...he’s probably a tool maker and obvs has access to a machine shop.

The difference between (time served)  craftsman and tradesman is that the craftsman makes his own specialist tools and the tradesman does not. The Boilermaker is a craftsman, the joiner is a tradesman. Your man is undoubtedly a craftsman.
Title: Re: Bellows corners
Post by: boxcall on November 29, 2020, 08:51:53 PM
Craftsman tradesmen is there a difference? Really, I’m a tradesman and make specialty tools all the time to make my jobs go easier, its called a - one job jig. Certainly there would be an overlap in both directions when needed. If there is a difference. Ps I also considered myself a craftsman at times ;)
Title: Re: Bellows corners
Post by: Winston Smith on November 29, 2020, 11:11:14 PM
"The difference between (time served)  craftsman and tradesman is that the craftsman makes his own specialist tools and the tradesman does not. The Boilermaker is a craftsman, the joiner is a tradesman. Your man is undoubtedly a craftsman."

Neither can I agree with that, Peader, sorry! Along with the Russian bellows (etc.) manufacturer, I'm of the steadfast opinion that "Necessity is the mother of invention". No matter the standing or training of the person involved, squire or serf, this saying is self-evidently true. No one holds a certificate in ingenuity!
Title: Re: Bellows corners
Post by: Peadar on November 29, 2020, 11:37:45 PM
It doesn't matter whether anyone likes it or not - the distinction was a matter of fact in Scottish industry into the 1980's. That's tradition for you. :neigh:

Title: Re: Bellows corners
Post by: Winston Smith on November 30, 2020, 10:00:22 AM
I know that we're straying away from bellows corners here, and that one of our carers will be along any minute to put us in order; but...

What sort of specialist tools would a boilermaker make for himself, and in which camp would a toolmaker stand in all of this?

Of course, we accept that terminology and use may well be different in Scotland. Indeed, there may well be differences in different counties and industries!.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal