Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Thrupenny Bit on November 24, 2020, 11:24:14 AM
-
Dear All,
Idle curiosity in play here.
I'm just looking at tune with a key signature of C, but it is obviously in the relative minor key of Am.
Living eternally in DG Land, I transposed it, upped it two half tones and am learning it in Bm, the relative minor of D on my 2 row 8 bass DG.
I'm just looking at the tune as written in Am, and the composer has added chords variously Am, C, G, F and Dm across the tune.
It has occurred to me that if you had a 12 bass box with 'Castagnari' layout of basses, you then have extra bass/chords of Eb, F#m, Fnat and Bb built in.
On my 8 bass, I cross row the basses and am used to using A bass and C chord for 'Am' and B bass and D chord for 'Bm' approximations.
With the given extra basses and chords as above, how does that open up similar cross rowing to give useful 'other' chord combinations or approximations?
Curious of Devon.
-
Can't answer your question but I'm full of admiration for your approach. I'd have learned it in Em on the D row, borrowing the C nat from the G row, with fewer fudged chords (I think): Em, G, D, C and Am. Or does the range of the tune make that impossible?
-
Hi
Obviously I don't know the tune, but Am tunes are common on GC boxes, which reinforces the Em choice on a DG box. It may not answer your question about cross rowing, but knowing the tune might help.
-
if you had a 12 bass box with 'Castagnari' layout of basses, you then have extra bass/chords of Eb, F#m, Fnat and Bb built in.
On my 8 bass, I cross row the basses and am used to using A bass and C chord for 'Am' and B bass and D chord for 'Bm' approximations.
With the given extra basses and chords as above, how does that open up similar cross rowing to give useful 'other' chord combinations or approximations?
The two case you cite are using a major chord to produce a minor 7th chord as a substitute for a minor chord.
So using that pattern, you could do
C with Eâ™ chord for C minor
G with Bâ™ chord for G minor
D with F chord for D minor
You can also do D with F♯min chord as a Dmaj7 if you need one...
I would use a Castagnari layout more to make different inversions of the chords I already have:
B bass under G chord and E bass under C chord are available on 8 bass anyway.
12 bass adds: F♯ under D chord, A under F chord, G under E♠chord, A under F♯ minor chord.
...and some 2nd inversions, left as an exercise for the reader...
-
Hi peeps,
I've got Rob Harbron's tunebook and was looking at Rain in the woodpile.
It's in Am and my logic transposing it 2 half tones produces it in Bm. The tune is written with his choice of chords, and as he plays an English Concertina, they are often more varied than we'd use on a melodeon.
I transcribed it into abc and transposed so it changes chords and all, and it's giving me a nice little workout with some different fingering. All good in fact, the tune was just the vehicle in my mind posing the 'what other question.
I can happily play it ib Bm on my 2r8b DG but, as per title, the thought occurred to me about playing it as it was written in Am for which I would need more basses, and those are pretty much what a 12 bass Castagnari would give me.
Then ' what other chord options are there by cross rowing?....' hence my post.
Thank you Anahata. This is something I've not understood , and not sure how to work out. Looking at your list I can see the logic.
Looking back at the chords in the tune I can see how you could play it on the 12 bass, and cross rowing for Dm.
I think could you cross row for Dm was the thought that triggered my post!
Q
-
Going back to CAB's post, with Bm I'm using the transposed chords wot he wrote
Bm, D, A, G, Em and a F#m once which I fudge!
-
... and a F#m once which I fudge!
How are you making the F#m, Q? Right hand chord?
-
Sometimes a lower F# pull on the G row ( just below 4th button G) and a pull D chord....
Sometimes popping in a pull D chord or A chord if it sounds ok.
It is impossible really on a 2r8b DG so just try and do something that sounds roughly right.
Not the best right hand chorder so I tend to fudge as above on my left hand.
-
Sometimes a lower F# pull on the G row ( just below 4th button G) and a pull D chord....
That's just an inversion of a D chord. Or do you mean an A chord with a right hand F# - which would give you F#m7?
Choice between Em and Bm for me depends partly on whether you have B major or B minor chord. From your original post, you seem to be using Bm7, which I would want to avoid for the fundamental.
-
Oh... here goes my shaky knowledge.
I attended one of Squeezy's workshops and he recommended a left hand pull D chord with a right hand lower F#, but as you say, it's a D chord with an extra F# added.
Never worked that out before.....
Will try a pull A chord with the lowright hand F#.....
Thanks for making me think of it.
I have a B major chord on my left hand, so cross row the B fundamental and D chord for a substitute 'Bm' chord.
Q
-
Well, the point isn't to actually to necessarily be making an f#m chord, but, to keep the bass line moving, right? So, whatever works.
I'm with CAB though, I don't like the tonic chord being Bm7, so I'll generally use a thirds stop. If you don't have one, or, you just prefer to have to have yours in, I can suggest trying combining both A and D pull chords as an additional alternative for F#m, as this ends up as a bunch of noise that could be interpreted as F#m7add6, F# A C# D E. Its not great but maybe alright for a quick blast. Obviously though with no thirds in, there's no f# in it, so, not really all that useful.
I never really understood why F#m is added to so many boxes when you could cross chord F# + A chord. So, surely F# major would be way cooler??
-
Sorry - still subverting your original question (which has now been answered I guess) but I too have now started learning a Bm tune this evening (having been reminded of it by the Begley programme Stiamh posted). Never really tried Bm on the DG box before but I've realised there are two fingerings: 1. the easy one all on the D row; and 2. the cross-row one which needs more thought but allows more left hand chording (basically pinching the pushed B from the G row). A straightforward tune on any instrument that doesn't offer alternatives (I've played it often enough on the flute) but a slight dilemma on a 4th apart melodeon. Decisions decisions!
-
CAB, I virtually always cross row, so pinching the push B on the G row comes naturally. Just what I do!
As you say, it opens up a bit more left hand options.
Good luck with your exploration!
-
Three things affect this
1. Your base scale here that is DEF#GA BC#DEF#GAB …
2. IMPORTANT Which of the common minors are you in?
3 The chords are then simply alternate notes
You have chosen Bm, the “relativeâ€, “church†or aeolean minor. (The other is E dorian (thanks Greg👍) put that out of your mind)!
Chord is BT D3 F#5 A7 C#9
Bm9, except you need extra row to have all the notes in same direction
I like going down the base B, A, G F#, with the G chord particularly poignant. Think it only works for Em on 2 rows
you do have a ii V i of sorts Bm C#m7b5 F# => Bm but (like Gina) for my stuff I prefer F#(major) as the turnaround. The minor is a bit … Curate like?
C#m7b5 is easy, 4 fingers on D row … pull. And most of the associated scale cross rowing.
Try sus chords for turnaround. Pull and tap 2 fingers across both rows. Experiment! Good hunting
-
You have chosen Bm, the “relativeâ€, “church†or aeolean minor. (The other is C# dorian, put that out of your mind)!
I'm confused. I thought it would be E dorian
[Bm (aeolian mode) and E dorian both have two sharps in the scale. C#dorian has 5.
Or, am I missing something?]
-
I attended one of Squeezy's workshops and he recommended a left hand pull D chord with a right hand lower F#, but as you say, it's a D chord with an extra F# added.
Never worked that out before.....
Will try a pull A chord with the lowright hand F#.....
You can make a RH F♯ minor chord on pull with C♯ from D row and F♯ and A from G row. The best bass to add to that IMHO
would be an A (bass note only, not chord) which is a perfectly good first inversion of an F♯ minor chord. I use it right at the end of Brian Peters' Mill Race Waltz (https://youtu.be/CnHPdzLZRZE?t=208). (link is to a couple of bars before the chord in question, you don't have to listen to all of it!)
Maybe Squeezy meant an A chord (the pull chord that goes with the D push chord) which combined with a RH F♯ would make Am7 F♯m7.
-
Thanks Anahata, will give your suggestion a go.
Squeezy might well have meant that. It was several years back, I'd think my memory is more suspect than his advice ::)
-
If the tune has an F♯ or an A at that point, you could always just substitute a D chord anyway. This is what Brian suggests in parentheses in that tune, for boxes that don't have the F♯.
-
Yes, the tune did have a F# and I was pulling D chord with it.
-
...Maybe Squeezy meant an A chord (the pull chord that goes with the D push chord) which combined with a RH F♯ would make Am7.
Is that Am7 a typo?
-
...Maybe Squeezy meant an A chord (the pull chord that goes with the D push chord) which combined with a RH F♯ would make Am7.
Is that Am7 a typo?
Er, yes, I meant F♯m7. Corrected in original post now, thanks for spotting.
-
OK, to go away from F#m and back to my general question:
I have never worked out the possible keys you can play in given the extra basses on a 12 bass box.
With the Castagnari 12 bass set up we have:-
Normal 8 bass = G, A, Bmaj, C, D & Em.
Extra 4 buttons = F#m, Eb, F nat, & Bb
We can use the normal '8 bass fudge' as Anahata says, making Am7 and Bm7 as substitues for a minor chord.,
Plus
So using that pattern, you could do
C with Eâ™ chord for C minor
G with Bâ™ chord for G minor
D with F chord for D minor
Giving us Cm, Gm & Dm as cross rowed chord 'fudges'.
Right, so looking at a chord key chard I've found, I'm trying to work out what keys the 12 bass layout above allows you to play.
It looks like C, D, F, G, Am, Bm, Dm, Em and bits of other keys depending on how the melody intertwines.
Is that right?
It is something I've never really got my head around.......
Though whether I want to play in those other keys begs a further question!
-
Right, so looking at a chord key chard I've found, I'm trying to work out what keys the 12 bass layout above allows you to play.
It looks like C, D, F, G, Am, Bm, Dm, Em and bits of other keys depending on how the melody intertwines.
Is that right?
A thirds out stop helps a lot here. With one of those giving you a neutral E chord, you can already play in A major on an 8 bass D/G, especially if you have a G# or two somewhere (avoid that note if not). Tunes like 100 Pipers and Athol Highlanders, for example, are very straightforward. The pattern is a bit like playing in Bm (as previously discussed in the other thread) but with reversed bellows - pulled A on the G row then onto the D row.
I'd also say a 3rds out A chord is preferable to a fudged Am7 if you're playing in Am. Ditto Dm.
With Bb and Eb chords on a 12 bass, I'm guessing you can also play in the key of Bb major - never tried it but it seems logical. Depends on right hand notes being in the appropriate bellows direction, presumably.
-
Thanks CAB.
I tend to be a 'thirds in' person but as you say, taking them out in some situations help. I've not used neutral chords much but if there's a good reason...
I'm aware that some tunes though in a given key, can be played where in theory it shouldn't such as Athol Highlanders.
I've got a couple in Am that I can get away with on my 2 row DG. I think if a tune takes your fancy, its always worth seeing if you can shoe horn it into your box without compromising the tune too much.
I think there must be other tunes and keys possible as you say. Again, like the Athol Highlanders example in A on a DG, that the melody 'allows' you to get away with on a 12 bass.
-
These days, I hardly ever play with thirds in (except on the pokerworks) - and the chords on my G/C are thirdless anyway. I like the F# chord more and more - but I hadn't considered whether it fits 'Rain' anywhere. Rob Harbron says in the intro to his tunebook 'Meanders' (highly recommended - only one month to Christmas !):
'A big feature of both my playing and my compositions is that I vary my chord choices constantly. Often I will start with just the melody, then introduce some sort of drone, then use the basic chords along the lines of what I've suggested here; then I might introduce some alternate chords, maybe relative minors or different drones, then I might drop all the chords out....and so on. I think chords and their development over several times through a tune are one of the key ways you can make a tune into a piece of music. Please don't feel you have to stick to my chords, I wouldn't! But try not to always play the same chords every time through a tune and save something for later rather than throwing all your ideas at the first time through.'
This is just the section about chords - but I reckon I could helpfully pin all his comments
about tune interpretation - keys, tempo, groove, swing, melodic variation, harmony, chords, and ornamentation up on my wall as a constant aide-memoire to playing.
Julian
-
Thanks Julian.
Rob has many more options than we do through his English Concertina, and so his limits are more around what he can think of.
I take the point about not slavishly following his given accompniment but it is good to try and follow it just to find another approach other than what I'd normally try and do.
Changing chords and varying the accompninent is something I'm poor at. I often will hatch a plan then stick to it. Maybe it comes with repetition. I find often the more I play a tune the more I find odd little variations. A classic situation telling me I need to really play tunes more rather than being diverted into new ones!
-
I believe a big goal of the D/G 12 bass layout with Bb and Eb bass/chord pairs is to facilitate having nuance when playing in G minor and D minor, as compared to the A/G reversal layout - even if (and probably ideally) you're playing with the thirds out. If you love the circle of fifths, you can figure out pretty easily that the pattern of 3 major and then 3 minor chords describes having a full compliment of diatonic chords for a given key signature, and that generally means being able to come up with more nuanced bass lines for any scale that uses that key signature
For G major, it's C G D, and we like to add Am Em Bm, the next 3 sharper notes as minor chords. The key signature we use is for G, the filling of our 3 chord trick sandwich.
For D minor, Gm Dm Am, we'd want to add Bb F C, the previous 3 flatter notes as major chords. The key signature we use is the one for F.
While you might begrudgingly be able to play in Bb major, it could feel much more of a reach vs playing in its relative minor, Gm. And honestly it'd be pretty nice to have Gm under the fingers: a lot of cool tunes key change to parallel modes (ie G major <-> G minor) instead of relative modes (G major <-> E minor). Even without thirds, having the fundamentals be able to spell out the scale in question makes a big difference. Like, when you get an F chord on your D/G box, playing in C major may still a bit of a bear, but Am might come out like a dream.
So, that's me saying that the basses are never going to let you actually play a tune in a key that your melody side keyboard is really unhappy about the idea of. But in simple terms, to know what keys you can play in, just formulate everything into the circle of fifths, and it becomes pretty obvious. So take all the basses, and arrange them in a circle of fifths order:
Eb Bb F C G D A Em B F#m
flat ------------- sharp
For cross chords, you can apply offsets to logic your way through all your options really quickly. Pick something you know, like if you have eg B bass, can you play the major chord of the note 3 to the left, ie, D major? If yes, then you can play Bm7. Then just step left or right along that line, so, this applies to E + G major (wrong directions, so can't do it, but it would be Em7), A + C major = Am7, D + F major = Dm7, G + Bb major = Gm7, C + Eb major = Cm7, oh and F# + A major = Fm7. Any major chord you have + the fundamental note 4 to the right is going to be eg G/B, so, over the third. D/F#, G/B, C/E, F/A, Bb/D, Eb/G should all be possible. Over the fifth is obviously any major or minor chord plus the fundamental 1 to the right. Minor chords over their minor third, just, work one out, so like F#m/A should work? So that's a minor cord with the fundamental 3 to the right, so, Bm/D... maybe? Em/G? nope. With thirds out you could do Am/C, Dm/F, Gm/Bb, Cm/Eb.
So like for real, circle of fifths!
If you want to know what keys you can play in, well, rule of thumb is, take what you know already, and shift it around the circle of fifths and see if you can still do it. You know you can get away in a pinch with just eg G and D major. So, maybe you can play in Eb, because you have Eb and Bb major. But... they're maybe kinda in the same direction, so, y'know that might not work out with just those on its own. But perhaps if you could get an F minor, C minor and G minor involved, it would be OK. You can apply that same logic all the way as deep as B major and F# major - so, with thirds out, you could probably get away with playing in B major. But, you'd have really no hope at all of playing any chords for B major's relative minor key of like, G# minor? and actually having those reinforce that tonic - so it's not just about key signatures. But like, we know you can get away with playing in B minor on a 8 bass box, without the chord 1 tick sharper, so, maybe on a 12 bass box with an F#m you can get away with playing in F# minor, too. Or maybe you can't - gotta check out that melody side. If you can play all the melody notes that compose a chord at the same time as the chord in question, then, generally you're pretty well set up. It's because of this that I think eg Bb might be hard to play, because you tend to have only have F going one way and Bb going the other...
But yeah, circle of fifths.
-
Wow! Thanks Gena.
Need to digest this and check circle of fifths!
-
I've just changed my bass end from the A/G system to the one with Bb and EB.
I play almost exclusively with 3rds out and yes Gena has summed it up well.
G minor is one of the revelations on my box. Admittedly the fruity basses are at the opposite end, but it just takes bit more practice.
-
And then there's always the question of accidentals and reversals...which get discussed so often !
My favourite Gm tune at the moment is An Italian Rant - I'm sure it's perfectly fine in other keys but somehow Gm just suits my ears.
J
-
My premise for this was asking the question about basses assuming you'd have a half row of accidentals to allow the keyboard to be chromatic. Yes I know that's another can of worms, which I am avoiding!
I was just trying to find out how those 12 basses allow access to different keys, and more specifically which keys.
Something I've never understood.
The next question is: ok, you've learnt a tune in Gm but where can you play that?
Certainly in my original long term session, if I played a tune in Gm it might be a solo!
Just before lockdown I discovered a more varied session where fiddles and English Concertinas give more options rather than just D and G.
I'm not sure if there are outlets beyond your simple personal enjoyment, though your own enjoyment is a fair reason.
I suppose the personnel of your session will dictate what key you might launch forth in.....
-
The next question is: ok, you've learnt a tune in Gm but where can you play that?...
With fiddle players and loads of others
Another favourite key is Dm. Much easier. =Em on a DG.
-
Thanks Greg, useful to know fiddlers are willing to step outside DG.
-
Afterthought:
I suppose if your session is shoulder to shoulder with DG melodeon, that's when the session tune becomes a solo!
-
My favourite Gm tune at the moment is An Italian Rant - I'm sure it's perfectly fine in other keys but somehow Gm just suits my ears.
Mine too. Just not comfortable playing it anything else.
I've been leading village band Zoom practices at least partly on melodeon, an instrument we don't normally have. Our repertory covers a wide range of keys so it's a good workout, even though I often chicken out and play EC instead. Italian rant is one we play.
As for sessions, it does depend who you play with. I've sessioned (and gigged) for many years with a mandolin and banjo-player who loves playing in Gm.
-
Perhaps I've been entrenched in DG Land too long!
I do remember ( vaguely in the dim distant past :'( ) my old session changing slightly. New tunes coming in with influences from people like Leveret and others where tunes can be in a choice of keys.
I did touch on this with a previous thread asking if changing tune repertoire were changing the boxes we wish to play. Another thread, another discussion so I don't want to replicate that here.
Mind you, on my BbEb box, playing Origin of the World in Gm is rather nice and resonant!
I seem to remember Dave Shepherd likes composing in Gm, as a lot of his fiddle tunes are that way if memory serves.
-
Just flicking through Rob Harbron's tune book and notice there seems to be several tunes in Gm.
Not an uncommon choice of key.
-
Euro-sessions such as those held by Les Panards Dansants at Hebden Bridge and the ones Chris Nash and I run at Whitby Festival frequently move away from the keys of D and G, with C major, A minor, D minor and G minor being well represented.
-
Mind you, on my BbEb box, playing Origin of the World in Gm is rather nice and resonant!
I seem to remember Dave Shepherd likes composing in Gm, as a lot of his fiddle tunes are that way if memory serves.
...and, of course, there is Dave Shepherd's irrated plea, wrt his tune, William Taylor's Tabletop Hornpipe:
"for all the clodhopping, galumphing border morris teams...It is in G minor, so fiddlers, stand your ground and don’t be browbeaten into playing it in E minor by the malodorous melodeons"
-
Hi Bob, the Loose Knit sessions at Sidmouth too have an open feel to them, not just DG Land.
I discovered a new session close by to me in February that was certainly varied in its' approach but.... lockdown prevented my further exploring it's potential.
I think it depends on the choice of sessions you have locally combined with the tunes you want to play. I'm not really into Euro tunes but recognise our English manuscripts throw up tunes beyond just the keys of D and G.
Thanks Greg, Dave's comments were at the back of my mind too. He likes his tunes played 'as writ' !
-
Thanks Greg, Dave's comments were at the back of my mind too. He likes his tunes played 'as writ' !
Trouble is, that has the opposite to desired effect on me.
I have an overwhelming urge to play Willie's TTJ in Em, with the clodhopping arpeggio and chord sequences.
-
perhaps some of us have an advantange in not being very good at or simply not being able to read ''as writ''
george (:)
-
The next question is: ok, you've learnt a tune in Gm but where can you play that?
Certainly in my original long term session, if I played a tune in Gm it might be a solo!
Well, perhaps imagine just being a person in the rest of the group in that situation - someone says they have a tune in Gm that they'd like to share with the group. Certainly seems a lot more fun to have some G minor chops and feel like you might be able to join in.
Plus, I could go grab my 2r8b and get by in G minor, without the extra basses - after all, I can use my thirds stop and accidentals to form the Cm, Gm and Dm chords that some might describe as the most important. I know I can make an F major, too, and while Bb major is gonna be sketchy, Eb major as Eb + G + Bb is an option on my RHS - there's something special about pushing two accidentals at the same time, I must say. You can often find a way to at least join in as basic accompaniment for tunes in unusual keys on a 2r8b, at least with a bit of luck & creativity. It's not like we don't already play some tunes that bring in a bit of Gm; Horses Brawl, for example? The Feathers?
Make friends with a hurdy gurdy player and you'll probably have a lot of opportunities to play in Gm.
-
yeah, I think being confident enough to play something unusual is they key, ( whichever key ;) ) and also know a group of people in a session who'd go along with it and try and join in. The fiddlers could at least given their chromaticity.
I've only ever once seen a gurdy appear at my local session, but I take the point!
As we've said up there, it really depends on your choice of session.
-
See http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,26307.msg313856.html#msg313856
Schnorbitz’s thread asked your question more directly. I’ve posted my own 18 bass layout, but a 12 bass is a subset of that.
Tried to explain why it needs 3rds OUT, in which case (DG)
E5/C is CMaj7
B5/G is GMaj7
C5/A is Am7
D5/B is Bm7 as much discussed here!
Plus whatever you can do with the extra 4 chords on a 12 bass.
You rebase down 2 tones for a Maj7 or 1½ for a min7
egs Eb5/C bass is C minor 7. It’s the bass that matters.
(x5 shorthand for tonic+5th)