Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: chris hall on November 28, 2020, 06:40:38 PM
-
Anybody had any good results renovating the ends on an HA114. Renovated 3 over last few weeks. On the first one the silver papered ends responded well to a quick clean up. Signs of wear and paper discoloured but thats ok. Nothing wrong with a bit of character from use. Alas the second one had been hand painted rather badly and frankly just looked a mess and to make matters worse the paint was peeling off. i figured my only option was to strip off all the paper. Messy, very time consuming and not something i ever fancy doing again (although it looks pretty nice after a coat of Liberon ebony wood stain.) So what to do with the one i'm working on now. Someone glued the grille to the fondo with a liberal layer of what looked like araldite applied with a trowel. aghhhhh! Eventually managed to prise off the grille and all the glue. So what to do next. Its not pretty . I really dont want to remove all the paper again. Can i fill the damage to the paper with some kind of wood filler /fine filler to get a smooth surface that i can undercoat and then paint. If so anybody done it and know what the best products might be? Obviously it won't look like the original paper finish. Im thinking black paint of some kind. Im guessing it needs to have good opacity and be a hard finish. A brush on paint would be nice but I fear i may have to use spray in which case i've got 40 holes to seal somehow to prevent any spray getting onto the sliders or into reed chambers. Anybody got any top tips before i wade in with a trail and error approach.
-
Anybody had any good results renovating the ends on an HA114. Renovated 3 over last few weeks. On the first one the silver papered ends responded well to a quick clean up. Signs of wear and paper discoloured but thats ok. Nothing wrong with a bit of character from use. Alas the second one had been hand painted rather badly and frankly just looked a mess and to make matters worse the paint was peeling off. i figured my only option was to strip off all the paper. Messy, very time consuming and not something i ever fancy doing again (although it looks pretty nice after a coat of Liberon ebony wood stain.) So what to do with the one i'm working on now. Someone glued the grille to the fondo with a liberal layer of what looked like araldite applied with a trowel. aghhhhh! Eventually managed to prise off the grille and all the glue. So what to do next. Its not pretty . I really dont want to remove all the paper again. Can i fill the damage to the paper with some kind of wood filler /fine filler to get a smooth surface that i can undercoat and then paint. If so anybody done it and know what the best products might be? Obviously it won't look like the original paper finish. Im thinking black paint of some kind. Im guessing it needs to have good opacity and be a hard finish. A brush on paint would be nice but I fear i may have to use spray in which case i've got 40 holes to seal somehow to prevent any spray getting onto the sliders or into reed chambers. Anybody got any top tips before i wade in with a trail and error approach.
Picture of damage would help , are reed blocks removable on these? If so you could take them out and open the sliders to paint, possibly . I think some are glued and some are not, gang?
I have never dealt with hohner114 or the ends so I’m probably not much help.
-
The blocks on the HA114 on not removable, so the OP has to deal with them being glued in place while painting. I fixed up an old HA114 where someone had spray-painted black paint on the fondo, and you can see the black paint on all the metal sliders in the closed position (obviously, you wouldn't dream of doing this with the stops open!). It didn't have any impact on the functionality of the box, and it's not something you'd ever actually see unless you took the keyboard off, so I don't think it's a big deal...having said that, I'm not exactly suggesting it as the best option.
This comes down to personal taste, but the only HA114 that I've seen with modified casework that I thought looked OK was the one that was spray painted entirely black after most of the goldbrand finish had come off (and that includes an example where I stripped the finish and applied stain...wouldn't do it again). If I was you, I'd be tempted to just sand down the silver paper-ends and leave the rest of the box as it is. Using a palm sander works very well to remove the paper in a matter of minutes, as long as you're careful to apply it evenly across the fondo and not create any 'dips' that might prevent the pallets from sealing properly. It's actually pretty easy to do, though.
-
thanks guys. i did it today and decided after reading a few advice forums about wallpaper stripping. i applied a dab of goo gone in one of the corners to get started and then used a butter knife to get started. to my amazement the knife with a little gentle persuasion took the whole silver paper off in one piece. This part of the process was done totally dry with a warm knife blade. This left the underlayer of paper which came off after applying a damp sponge soaked in a mixture of hot water, washing liquid and soda crystals. i was careful to avoid too much moisture. just enough to enable the brown layer of remaining paper to come off with very very gentle scraping. not enough moisture and it was stubborn so a matter of getting just enough without over wetting the fondo. Wood underneath was pristine and just needed a gentle sanding before applying liberon ebony wood stain. Could have left it natural but there were a few stains from someone using glue to attach the grille. Left the black/gold finish on the woodwork as its not too bad. On a previous restoration someone had overpainted the body with gloss paint so had nothing to lose by stripping it all off. Worse job ive ever done. Made restoring bellows seem like a walk in the park. Lots of paint stripper and steel wool. Tried several paint strippers. Only one that got the job done was Starchem SynStryp. Use outdoors and wear gloves. its the real deal. I'll try and send pics. Its going to be dry tuned later this week and -15 on the 3rds and 7ths and spring tension eased. Reed chambers need modifying as it was a G and will be a C. I'll post a video too when its finished.
-
"Its going to be dry tuned later this week and -15 on the 3rds and 7ths"
Why's that then?
-
"Its going to be dry tuned later this week and -15 on the 3rds and 7ths"
Why's that then?
That's Cajun 'just temperament' tuning. It helps the thirds and sevenths sound much sweeter, especially when playing Cajun style in '5th position', i.e. playing in the key of G on a box tuned in C, or in the key of A on a box tuned in D.
-
"Its going to be dry tuned later this week and -15 on the 3rds and 7ths"
Why's that then?
That's Cajun 'just temperament' tuning. It helps the thirds and sevenths sound much sweeter, especially when playing Cajun style in '5th position', i.e. playing in the key of G on a box tuned in C, or in the key of A on a box tuned in D.
Steve, that's usually called 2nd position. Playing in F is 3rd position.
-
Steve, that's usually called 2nd position. Playing in F is 3rd position.
Ah - OK. I thought it was 5th position because it starts on button 5. :|bl
-
Steve, that's usually called 2nd position. Playing in F is 3rd position.
Ah - OK. I thought it was 5th position because it starts on button 5. :|bl
It's either based on the most common usage or the degree of difficulty. I'm probably making this up!
-
"Its going to be dry tuned later this week and -15 on the 3rds and 7ths"
Why's that then?
Basically its flattening the 3rd note of the chords of C and G. The C chord is notes of C, E, and G so flattening the 3rd note in that chord sweetens the C chord. Likewise flattening the B note sweetens the G chord. Since chords and blends (partial chords) are used all the time in cajun style within the melody this sweetens the chords used and in turn sweetens the scale. Most cajun boxes are tuned this way. Some tuners also sharpen the 4th a little but this seems less common these days. The box is a conversion for a musician who requested cajun tuning as he is hoping to get into that style. He also requested dry tuning. That means i'll be removing the tremelo by tuning all 4 reed banks to A440. Again a common tuning used by Louisiana players, though some still like the tremelo so its not a universal rule. These tweaks will go some way to giving it that louisiana sound. Guitar players (especially in open tunings or lap steel and pedal steel players) will often flatten their B string after tuning with an electronic tuner. A final tweak by ear for sweetness. That comes from the same place. And I assume its why pianos if tuned to sound sweet in one key sound out in all other keys and why they are therefore tuned to sound roughly "right" in all keys but really not "right" in any. Im extrapolating here as im not a piano tuner just a piano listener. Tremelo disguises the tuning but when tuning dry i find the sound more pleasing with the flattened notes.
-
That's a pretty comprehensive reply there, Chris. Thanks.
Also thanks to Rees and Steve for chipping in, especially with that touch of "confidence" from Rees, I like it when folk make it up as they go along!
-
Steve, that's usually called 2nd position. Playing in F is 3rd position.
Ah - OK. I thought it was 5th position because it starts on button 5. :|bl
It's either based on the most common usage or the degree of difficulty. I'm probably making this up!
yup i agree (mostly)...On a C one row 1st position is C. Playing in the home key. If you move up 5 notes from C and play in G on a C box you are in second position. technically an F# is needed to play in G to keep the tone tone semitone tone tone tone semitone arrangement of intervals we have grown to know and love. But you have an F and no F#. But that's OK. you either play the F instead or avoid that note. If you play the F you are flattening the 7th. You are now playing a blues scale. Blues harp players do that too. they pick up a C harp to play in G. Now if you do the same again going 5 notes up in G scale you land on D. Id call that 3rd position. Playing in D on a C box. You should have an F# and a C# to play in D. But thats ok. If you play F and C instead you are flattening the 3rd and the 7th. Thats also blues, but kind of more so. Now as Rees says you can also play in F on a C box. Its tricky but works just about especially if the tune only has 2 chords of F and C. In Louisiana cajun and Creole C and G are the most used major keys on a C box. Not many tunes in F or D but there are a few. Probably more in F than D. So F is 3rd position in terms of popularity. D is 3rd position in terms of cross key playing or playing backwards as its sometimes known. There's also minors. Am is i guess first position minor. Not many louisiana players use it though apart from for the odd tune like Mardi Gras. Em is much more popular though, especially in Zydeco, which i guess you could call 2nd position minor, 1st position in popularity stakes. Phew! these flattened notes of which i talk are semitone flats...nothing to do with -15 flats discussed earlier in this thread. Some sharp licks on that box if you hit the flats!!
-
I’ve always flattened the B string on a guitar after using a tuner just as you say, Chris. Ditto the piano never really being in tune!