Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: tentonaveling on October 08, 2009, 08:37:36 PM
-
Heya -
Fairly new to melodeon.net, at least in terms of posting threads.
Seriously contemplating the purchase of a new box having bought a pokerwork for morris last year and not really got on with it too well.
I want something light for festivals, so I can cart it around all day without too much effort, which was originaly the theory behind the pokerwork purchase, it being a lot lighter than my other D/G which is a Mengascini 2D2E.
Options at the moment that im considering are really a Lilly, a Saltarelle Epsilon or an Excelsior Mini, or possibly a Dino Baffetti Carnival II. All a similar price range, all bar the Dino are single voice, and all fairly lightweight. Cost aside I was wondering if anyone had any opinons about one box over another, or preferences as its a pretty much dead heat at the moment for me trying to decide what to go for?
Obviously theres a big element of trying them all out and find something I get along with, but wondered if anyone had really had any very good or bad experiances with any of the above?
Cheers
Chris
-
I have an excelsior and bought it because I prefered it to the lilly. I would definetly recommend it, but give it a try and see what you think.
-
For single voice also worth considering the B Loffet Touptit
-
Thanks for the replies - hadn't considered a Loffett to be honest, are they easily avaliable in the UK or would it be a case of waiting for the euro to become more favourable?
-
I think you would need to get it direct from Bernard. Even with the strong Euro its likely to cost you considerably less than a new Lily, and AFAIK the Epsilon is no longer in production.
I briefly had a Touptit this summer and I was quite taken with it. I'm not a Lily fan because I don't like the strident tone, the Touptit is more mellow.
-
Heya -
Fairly new to melodeon.net, at least in terms of posting threads.
Seriously contemplating the purchase of a new box having bought a pokerwork for morris last year and not really got on with it too well.
I want something light for festivals, so I can cart it around all day without too much effort, which was originaly the theory behind the pokerwork purchase, it being a lot lighter than my other D/G which is a Mengascini 2D2E.
Options at the moment that im considering are really a Lilly, a Saltarelle Epsilon or an Excelsior Mini, or possibly a Dino Baffetti Carnival II. All a similar price range, all bar the Dino are single voice, and all fairly lightweight. Cost aside I was wondering if anyone had any opinons about one box over another, or preferences as its a pretty much dead heat at the moment for me trying to decide what to go for?
Obviously theres a big element of trying them all out and find something I get along with, but wondered if anyone had really had any very good or bad experiances with any of the above?
Cheers
Chris
How about a vintage Preciosa (or Lilliput) rebuilt and converted to D/G by Theo?
I've had more admiring comments about mine than any modern box I've ever played...
Ian
-
... and AFAIK the Epsilon is no longer in production.
The Epsilon is still on the Saltarelle website, and the website of a music shop in Cleckheaton is advertising new ones. I nearly bought one once. Spoke to Saltarelle in France and was told 'cinq mille francs'/ - at the time £500. He asked how much was it in the UK and was out-raged when I told him 'huit mille francs'.
-
I stand corrected, I think there may have been a pause in production a while back.
-
Cheers guys - yeah looking at their website the Bernard Loffetts are working out at between 800 and 900 euros, so basically 800-900 quid, so considerably cheaper than the lilly, and still cheaper than the Excelsior and the Saltarelle...
Getting a rebuild was something else I hadnt considered, and certainly something else to have a bit of a think over.
-
I'm very happy with my Lilly, £900 new after some hard bargaining last April. I tried several and the one I bought had a less strident tone, which I preferred to the Excelsior I tried at the same time. The other Excelsiors were a little less harsh than the rest of the Lillys and I would have had one quite happily, but my Lilly just spoke to me. The Excelsiors are a little larger.
I have a friend (not a fiend) with a bigger Loffet box and I really like the tone of that; it would have been nice to try a Loffet or Saltarelle when I bought the Lilly. The Saltarelles I've seen have been selling for a lot more than suggested above, although the price would be about right if you could get a similar deal to the one I negotiated on my Lilly.
-
Welcome to the madhouse... ;D
Ahh, right... I know who you are now... from what I'm remembering, there was some mechanical probs with the Mengascini... and quality issues with the Pokerwork...?
I owned a Lilly for a while (I recall the notorious Mr John Williams of your parish squeezing the snot out of one ;D) - and while I love the sound from a distance, I just could not get on with one under the chin - the snarly shrillness of the thing... Offed it to another morris player who's as happy as larry with it - which proves not everyone hears like I do. Then, few years later (on a damn stoopid festival whim ::)), I bought a Matty (a pretty rare bird, a 3 row Lilly) in C#/D/G. Same again. Snarly. Offed that too... ::)
Mind you, I think it could my sensitivity to high frequencies... few years back, I tried a G/C Lilly and I found that just hummed like a beehive. Not snarly at all. Just sweet. 8)
Not as I'm saying don't get one - after all, I needed to live with one for a while to decide it wasn't for me. And at the end of the day, if you decide to off it, the market for used Lillys is still fairly OK...
The Touptit... there's a good owner's view on these here (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,2322.msg25251.html#msg25251)... which takes issue with the more muted tone (which might be perfectly OK setup as a G/C box). It also takes issue that the (pine) wood finish was considerably softer/more liable to dings/dents.... which not quite so durable for morrising...
The Excelsior... it's supposed to have a more 'rounded' tone... less nasal/snarly... Epsilon is supposed to be similar. Not as I've seriously tried either, 'cos I'm not that interested since I sold the Lilly...
As regards 2 voicers...
Seeing as the Carnival is basically a denuded BP2... I've owned a couple of Dino BP2s... one was OK, but the other was not so good, to be honest... so I can't wholeheartedly recommend them - some are better than others. They're very bass heavy too, so if you can't get the one with two L/H stops, it's something to bear in mind.
The best light 'off the shelf' Italian 2 voice I can vouch for at the moment is the Serenellini Sellà (N.B. - the bass mechanics are good old fashioned direct pushrods). The bass is more balanced (to my ears, at least), and the R/H closed keyboard gives a more positive feel IMHO.
Anyhow, that's a few more ideas...
Ed J
-
[...] takes issue that the (pine) wood finish was considerably softer/more liable to dings/dents.... which not quite so durable for morrising...
I'm not so sure about the comments in the review that cite the wood as spruce. Someone could ask Bernard which woods he has for the Toutpit. The website photos look like cherry and in the past I recall seeing pics of s walnut Toutpit.
It might be the case that the owner felt that the cherry dented easily -- but that criticism would then apply to the Lilly as well, unless it is still available in maple as well?
-Andy
-
The Touptit I had earlier this year appeared to be cherry, certainly not spruce.
-
I'm not so sure about the comments in the review that cite the wood as spruce.
Neither am I... indeed, Bernard's website quotes Cherry (Merisier).
...in the past I recall seeing pics of a walnut Toutpit.
According to Bernard's current tarrif (http://diato.org/tarif_accordeons.htm) (and unbeknown to me 'till now), the Touptit is available in Walnut (Noyer) for a little extra... which for durability is by far the pick of the bunch. Walnut can also sound better...
Another thing worth asking about might be a reed upgrade/different reeds... to give more power... certainly, Bernard should be able to advise in optimising the machine (re. volume/depth/brightness) as a morris D/G...
Ed J
-
Popped up the music room in Cleckheaton over the weekend and had a good play with some of the boxes they had there. Decided that I really liked the excelsior mini (normal model not with the hand finished reeds) and have therefore invested in one!
Really delighted with it so far and prefered it to the Saltarelle Epsilon which didnt seem as well finished and not quite as nicely laid out. Also prefered the Excelsior over the Mini Special which didnt seem quite as bright a sound.
Chris