Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: dino.pafftti on December 21, 2020, 04:56:57 PM

Title: glued reeds block
Post by: dino.pafftti on December 21, 2020, 04:56:57 PM
Hi .. advice is needed .
I inquire what a good / best way  remove Hoher's glued reeds block ? maybe hot water ?
Title: Re: glued reeds block
Post by: Steve_freereeder on December 21, 2020, 05:26:20 PM
Hi .. advice is needed .
I inquire what a good / best way  remove Hoher's glued reeds block ? maybe hot water ?

It's best not to try. You will only cause more damage than is worth while. Why would you want to remove the reed blocks anyway?
Title: Re: glued reeds block
Post by: dino.pafftti on December 21, 2020, 05:34:13 PM
Hi .. advice is needed .
I inquire what a good / best way  remove Hoher's glued reeds block ? maybe hot water ?

It's best not to try. You will only cause more damage than is worth while. Why would you want to remove the reed blocks anyway?
two reeds blog, it is difficult wax reeds
Title: Re: glued reeds block
Post by: Kimric Smythe on December 21, 2020, 05:55:58 PM
I have removed bass reed blocks on accordions where both blocks were glued in (WHY!).
I used the heated waxing knife to cut the glue joint and tiny drops of water here and there, it works but takes patience and time. Depending on the layout , a flush saw might work for stubborn bits but the saw can wander so it is not always good for bigger things.

 I also made bass plate for the block I removed and made mounts and gaskets for it because I am not an animal.
Title: Re: glued reeds block
Post by: dino.pafftti on December 21, 2020, 06:06:52 PM
I have removed bass reed blocks on accordions where both blocks were glued in (WHY!).
I used the heated waxing knife to cut the glue joint and tiny drops of water here and there, it works but takes patience and time. Depending on the layout , a flush saw might work for stubborn bits but the saw can wander so it is not always good for bigger things.

 I also made bass plate for the block I removed and made mounts and gaskets for it because I am not an animal.

Thanks Kimric .. Tonen Reeds Block would already help if it got off ,, I have to think ::)
Title: Re: glued reeds block
Post by: Nigel.H on December 21, 2020, 07:26:18 PM
I use ( for similar vintage instrument tasks ) a small, cranked, Cake Decorators palette knife.  Sharpen the edge of the blade, heat the blade on a hotplate - or whatever is to hand, and moisten the joint as you go.
Title: Re: glued reeds block
Post by: dino.pafftti on December 21, 2020, 07:54:27 PM
Thanks Nigel (:)
Title: Re: glued reeds block
Post by: diatonix on December 21, 2020, 10:48:15 PM
Why anyone would go through the trouble and remove glued-in reed blocks just to make waxing "easier" is beyond me.
Title: Re: glued reeds block
Post by: dino.pafftti on December 22, 2020, 03:10:18 AM
Why anyone would go through the trouble and remove glued-in reed blocks just to make waxing "easier" is beyond me.

sorry when i ask,, but that's why I ask when I don't know ,,
The pitch of the Hohner 113 treble blocks is intermediate very small ,,
surely everyone else knows how to wax reeds, I do not , but I'm a hobbyist,
I thought, I would get information here about what I was doing ,,
May I ask you, what kind of tool best reeds for waxing ?? ( Hohner 113 treble Reeds) inside the box ,
I'm an old hubby, but I still want to learn
Title: Re: glued reeds block
Post by: Gonk on December 22, 2020, 03:50:48 AM
Hi Dino,

I prefer the half-moon shaped wax spoon, but it does take practice.  If it's a tight space, and difficult to get at with a wax tool, you can roll or cut bits of wax into small tube shapes, and press them where you need them.  Then use a small heating tool to melt the wax.  I use a "Top Flite Trim Seal Tool" made for heat-shrinking model airplane parts.  I like it because the "low" setting is just right.  I think most tools (like woodburning pens and soldering irons) run too hot, but if that's all you have on hand, you could try to manage the temperature by turning them on and off.

If we're talking about the bass, I think it's fine to remove the block, and then either re-glue it or (even better) make a nice gasket as Kimric described.

If I understood right, this is not your situation, but if it's only one bass block that's glued, you can remove the other to get a good deal of access to it.  That's how one that I'm working on now (a little Galotta) is set up.

PS - re-reading your last post, it sounds like you're talking about the treble side reedblocks in an HA-113.  I would not remove those!   :)
Title: Re: glued reeds block
Post by: dino.pafftti on December 22, 2020, 06:50:15 AM
yes, treble, but i think i get it done , I have to practice a bit ,, i think i need to make a suitable tool ..
Title: Re: glued reeds block
Post by: Kimric Smythe on December 22, 2020, 07:12:20 AM
Here is what I did on the evil accordion https://www.instagram.com/p/BuxxN6sBLqZ/ .

I make a electric waxing with a brass blade that works well, I hook it to a lamp dimmer to control the heat.
Title: Re: glued reeds block
Post by: dino.pafftti on December 22, 2020, 07:38:57 AM
Here is what I did on the evil accordion https://www.instagram.com/p/BuxxN6sBLqZ/ .

I make a electric waxing with a brass blade that works well, I hook it to a lamp dimmer to control the heat.

looks good (:) i think block removal is difficult ,, I'm afraid I'll break something :(
Title: Re: glued reeds block
Post by: Lester on December 22, 2020, 07:52:52 AM
My method of reed waxing on 113/114s is to apply some wax to the bottom of the reed plate with the plate out of the box and then quickly slide the reed into place before the wax hardens. Once the reed is in place I run wax down the sides of the plate and across the top using gravity. I do all this with a temperature controlled soldering iron.
Title: Re: glued reeds block
Post by: dino.pafftti on December 22, 2020, 09:07:56 AM
My method of reed waxing on 113/114s is to apply some wax to the bottom of the reed plate with the plate out of the box and then quickly slide the reed into place before the wax hardens. Once the reed is in place I run wax down the sides of the plate and across the top using gravity. I do all this with a temperature controlled soldering iron.

Thanks Lester  (:) :||: so  good ,, I practice first ..
Title: Re: glued reeds block
Post by: Kimric Smythe on January 02, 2021, 06:08:47 PM
Why anyone would go through the trouble and remove glued-in reed blocks just to make waxing "easier" is beyond me.

It also makes tuning a lot easier.
Title: Re: glued reeds block
Post by: Theo on January 02, 2021, 07:14:59 PM
I suppose it depends on individual methods of working, but I do all my tuning with the reed blocks in situ,  apart from the really coarse adjustment like tuning up from 435 to 440 where I pre-tune with the reeds off the blocks.
Four stopper boxes are almost easier to tune than typical 2 row 2 voice because the stops let you isolate every reed so easily. 
Title: Re: glued reeds block
Post by: invadm on January 02, 2021, 08:30:16 PM
If you ‘must ‘ remove the blocks acetone works OK  to dissolve the glue but you’ll damage the slides for sure, best to leave the blocks alone..I have done it on 2 Hohner 114 and both ended up in spear box.
This is how I do and works well for me -as non pro like your self-   
If you use soldering iron for waxing ; all you need is longer tip, you can make your own tip yourself from bras or suitable metal rod and bend it slightly , make sure it is longer than your reed blocks so you can apply wax from outside /top of the block     
Work one of the inside reeds first & finish waxing all 10 reeds.
use a few MM thick card to cover/mask the side you have finished, make sure card covers all your reeds and taped to stop moving(masking tape works ) so you don’t  damage any of the valves and wax..move on to other side wax& finish once you are happy remove the card and move on to outside reeds.
If you need to go over to tidy up the wax use you long tip and cover the opposite reeds with a card  as you go.
All you need is longer tip for soldering iron and L shape thick card to cover up one side of the reeds.
Title: Re: glued reeds block
Post by: rees on January 03, 2021, 10:28:25 AM
If you are intent on removing the reed blocks remember that the aluminium stop-slides are an integral part of the blocks.
Unscrew the stop knobs and steel rods and remove them so that the slides are free to come out with the blocks, otherwise there is a danger of snapping the slides.
I speak from experience!
Title: Re: glued reeds block
Post by: Winston Smith on January 03, 2021, 11:02:07 AM
Just out of interest, Rees; are your blocks glued or screwed?
Title: Re: glued reeds block
Post by: rees on January 03, 2021, 11:55:29 AM
Blocks on the Clipper and Corvette are glued but they are two flat and two upright (Cajun style) so easy to access. Also the reed-plates are screwed on gaskets, no wax.
The Windjammer has two upright blocks which are removable.
Title: Re: glued reeds block
Post by: Winston Smith on January 03, 2021, 01:13:39 PM
Thanks for that answer, Rees.
I am, however, surprised that there seems not to be and artisan builder who mounts his/her reedplates directly onto the block. I've mentioned this before now, on here, and Mr Freereeder responded that the screws made the same solid connection between the two, but I still have my doubts as to the effectiveness of that.
Title: Re: glued reeds block
Post by: dino.pafftti on January 03, 2021, 01:19:07 PM
If you ‘must ‘ remove the blocks acetone works OK  to dissolve the glue but you’ll damage the slides for sure, best to leave the blocks alone..I have done it on 2 Hohner 114 and both ended up in spear box.
This is how I do and works well for me -as non pro like your self-   
If you use soldering iron for waxing ; all you need is longer tip, you can make your own tip yourself from bras or suitable metal rod and bend it slightly , make sure it is longer than your reed blocks so you can apply wax from outside /top of the block     
Work one of the inside reeds first & finish waxing all 10 reeds.
use a few MM thick card to cover/mask the side you have finished, make sure card covers all your reeds and taped to stop moving(masking tape works ) so you don’t  damage any of the valves and wax..move on to other side wax& finish once you are happy remove the card and move on to outside reeds.
If you need to go over to tidy up the wax use you long tip and cover the opposite reeds with a card  as you go.
All you need is longer tip for soldering iron and L shape thick card to cover up one side of the reeds.

Thanks, I guess I'm not trying to remove the blocks ,, maybe i practice on old reeds blocks  (:)
Title: Re: glued reeds block
Post by: rees on January 03, 2021, 02:06:41 PM
Thanks for that answer, Rees.
I am, however, surprised that there seems not to be and artisan builder who mounts his/her reedplates directly onto the block. I've mentioned this before now, on here, and Mr Freereeder responded that the screws made the same solid connection between the two, but I still have my doubts as to the effectiveness of that.

It works for me.
Title: Re: glued reeds block
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 03, 2021, 02:07:51 PM
Thanks for that answer, Rees.
I am, however, surprised that there seems not to be and artisan builder who mounts his/her reedplates directly onto the block. I've mentioned this before now, on here, and Mr Freereeder responded that the screws made the same solid connection between the two, but I still have my doubts as to the effectiveness of that.

How about the astounding idea that reed plates screwed on to olovisc gaskets bed down very nicely and, on the cajun-style instruments especially, with two flat reed blocks and one vertical double-sided reed block, you get a good seal all round the reed plates. There is also less risk of distorting the reed plates (stopping the reed from sounding) as less screw force is needed to create the seal. Finally, there is the fact that, despite using the olovisc gasket, reeds secured in this way give out a very strong and powerful sound.

Perhaps try it for yourself? Olovisc is really, really cheap to buy - £4.95 from Charlie Marshall.

It works for me.
Works for me too.
Title: Re: glued reeds block
Post by: rees on January 03, 2021, 02:20:16 PM
I was taught by Emmanuel Pariselle. all melodeons made on his courses have screwed reed-plates i.e. no wax.
Title: Re: glued reeds block
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 03, 2021, 02:52:20 PM
I was taught by Emmanuel Pariselle.
Me too.
Title: Re: glued reeds block
Post by: Winston Smith on January 03, 2021, 03:04:02 PM
I know that it works effectively and that Rees's boxes are good and loud, as well as having a good seal etc etc, along with many others (I'm sure) that have the reeds mounted this way. I'm not after an argument here!
Title: Re: glued reeds block
Post by: rees on January 03, 2021, 03:58:54 PM
I think that the main reason that wax is used so extensively is that it's so much quicker to apply.
I've watched workers in Castelfidardo wax a whole side of a big piano accordion reed-block in under 30 seconds
Fitting gaskets, drilling pilot holes and inserting screws would take a lot longer and add to the labour costs.
Me, I've all the time in the world.
No argument intended Winston  ;D
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal