Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: david caron on December 22, 2020, 11:41:43 PM
-
So I received a few days ago this exact melodeon from Liberty Bellows (its literally the one in the video) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=92F5PTSjWsM
There is a lot to like about it - light weight, great sound - but I thought that the thumb straps default position was very uncomfortable, so I set out to adjust it a little bit. Over the past few days, the screw has popped out twice and chipped the wood a little bit (its a very small chip). I am a bit upset at myself and afraid of further 'damaging' the instrument. But truth be told, I would rather just use a shoulder strap. I'm wondering how I would go about this? I'm still pretty new at this, I've only been playing a few months.
I noticed that Liberty Bellows also sells these https://www.libertybellows.com/shop/c/p/NEW-Shoulder-Strap-Bracket-for-Accordion-x33531662.htm, but 1. I don't know which one to choose
The instrument being the same one in the video, which one would you chose?
and 2. I'm afraid of damaging the instrument by doing the job incorrectly.
Please help!
-
Although playing with just a thumb strap is sort of 'traditional', many players find that is uncomfortable or unworkable and use shoulder straps, especially when standing up to play. There are no rules; do what is best for you.
Of the strap brackets which you have shown, I would recommend the type which is fixed by wood screws, unless you are happy opening up the instrument and drilling/installing the threaded bolts version. Even then, you might find the construction of the instrument such that there is not room for the bolts and nuts to be placed in a suitable position.
Of those designs shown, I would recommend types C, G or I, although I might be a bit too large. These types of brackets are designed to be mounted on the top and bottom surfaces of the ends. The 'V' or crescent shape points toward your body.
However, one-row four-stop instruments are frequently fitted with 'O' or 'D' ring type fixings at the top and bottom of the vertical face/end (i.e nearest your body), or these can also be fitted on the top and bottom surfaces of the ends, as above. Charlie Marshall (CGM Musical) sells these fixings and also ships overseas. Don't be put off by his location in Scotland. He's very good; highly recommended.
http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Strap_Brackets.html#13
http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Strap_Brackets.html#14
-
Further to my last post, here is a photo of my Wesson Clipper one-row four-stop which shows the 'D'-ring type fixing on the top and bottom ends.
-
as a 2 strapper I have always use the v type bracket 041H.
george
-
as a 2 strapper I have always use the v type bracket 041H. on 2 row boxed and the D ring with a single strap on 1 row 4 stop
george
-
D ring which is not shown in your selection is a good choice or I would choose B or E if your just playing with one strap.
My Beltuna one row has them similar to the B selection, meant for one strap only. They are screw type and set on the box at an angle so that the strap comes out of it in the right direction ( in line with shoulder / Elbow). I used one of these on one of my 1040’s works well.
-
D ring which is not shown in your selection is a good choice or I would choose B or E if your just playing with one strap.
My Beltuna one row has them similar to the B selection, meant for one strap only. They are screw type and set on the box at an angle so that the strap comes out of it in the right direction ( in line with shoulder / Elbow). I used one of these on one of my 1040’s works well.
My previous recommendations, which include 'D'-ring fixings, are designs able to be used with both one strap or two straps, thus keeping all playing styles open. The OP may find his playing styles evolve over time as he experiments with no straps, one strap, or two straps. Also keeping options open for playing sitting and/or standing.
-
I would follow that advice. Go for one that screws on rather than drills threw the box as these are harder to fit and may meet interior issues . Small three screws my preference and if you want one or the possability of one or two straps. More important are the screws that they are not too long big and sit nicely in the bracket as do pre drill or press the hole to a smaller size so you get it right first time if you change styles they will cover holes wich are are not that hard to cover later.Get it right first go is easier.Just make thing whats is under or inside as you place screw if you stick to the usual places on your make of instument will be fine.
B or c or g. I would say G(2) B(1) would be the likely style but some prefer rounder ones.
That is not too long or too big.Re the screws
-
Call Liberty and tell them you want to add a strap and they should send you the strap and suitable bracket at reasonable discount since you have just bought a new box from them.
Most dealers do this.
-
D ring which is not shown in your selection is a good choice or I would choose B or E if your just playing with one strap.
My Beltuna one row has them similar to the B selection, meant for one strap only. They are screw type and set on the box at an angle so that the strap comes out of it in the right direction ( in line with shoulder / Elbow). I used one of these on one of my 1040’s works well.
My previous recommendations, which include 'D'-ring fixings, are designs able to be used with both one strap or two straps, thus keeping all playing styles open. The OP may find his playing styles evolve over time as he experiments with no straps, one strap, or two straps. Also keeping options open for playing sitting and/or standing.
Steve , I was affirming your D ring suggestion saying it was a good choice and I put that type on the one row box I just built.
That is the type (if) used by most cajun makers so it can’t be wrong, but I prefer the B selection type.
I only use one strap sitting or standing so don’t need extra space in the attachment area.
I just started playing using just a thumb strap on my recent 1040 rebuild project, and after a bit of this doesn’t feel right, to, hey this is not so bad, to, I may not even bother putting a bracket on it now.
Must be that evolution you spoke of (:)
Could be the OP just needs to fix the thumb strap problem?
-
Many of the brackets are too wide for the fairly narrow (about 1 inch) frames on a one-row. I fitted type F brackets on 2 boxes for someone and it was a close fit. Personally I prefer the D-rings. If you mount the lower bracket at the bottom of the rear (rather than under the box), it won't interfere with standing the box on it's feet.