Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Sal Rotondo on December 23, 2020, 01:21:19 AM
-
Does any body know how these melodeons are tuned? Is it demiswing?
Thank you.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mEkma46TCH4
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GYF64kxWb2Q
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UUesjdysYgM
-
You also need to tell us whist your mean by Demi swing? It can mean either a something between swim and dry, or something a little wetter than swing, depending on who you are talking to. If you are looking for a way to tell your tuner how to tune your instrument then it’s better to use some kind of measurement. I like to use the spread between two reeds measured in Hz, because that translates direct to the frequency of the beat.
I can tell you how Andy Cuttings box is tuned: it’s a 1Hz swing.
-
They are all in my taste zone too which is a very light swing just shy of dry, but of course all tuning adjectives are subjective as Theo says. Huge punch in Brotto's box especially. I chatted with Marc Serafini and gave video links to confirm my tuning tastes.
-
I shall now always think of demi swing tuning as between swim and dry Theo ! ;D Not so much wet as slightly damp.
More seriously, I'd be interested in hearing the difference between one make of reeds and another, in the same box, but tuned in the same hz spread.
Julian
-
I note all these videos have very heavy bass playing. The tune sometimes seems a bit incidental to this kind of bass enthusiast. Noisy bass with treble accompaniment. I just don't get it, I'm afraid.
-
Richard, you say tomato and I sat tomato. It shall be ever so!
-
I note all these videos have very heavy bass playing. The tune sometimes seems a bit incidental to this kind of bass enthusiast. Noisy bass with treble accompaniment. I just don't get it, I'm afraid.
I just think they're using the whole box in a joined up way. Yes, Brotto's micing favours the fatness of the bass, but the use of it is (for me) entirely appropriate. For me it gives a complete instrument.
-
Getting back to the topic...
I'm not sure what I'm hearing on Brotto's box. Could he be using bandoneon (LM) voicing? I think its also possible he his box is not fitted with the same reeds as typically used by Castagnari. The the sound has an edge to it that I associate more with a mano reeds from Binci or Ciccarelli.
-
Getting back to the topic...
I'm not sure what I'm hearing on Brotto's box. Could he be using bandoneon (LM) voicing? I think its also possible he his box is not fitted with the same reeds as typically used by Castagnari. The the sound has an edge to it that I associate more with a mano reeds from Binci or Ciccarelli.
It sounds LM to me . . .
-
I note all these videos have very heavy bass playing. The tune sometimes seems a bit incidental to this kind of bass enthusiast. Noisy bass with treble accompaniment. I just don't get it, I'm afraid.
me neither! but each to his own of course
george
-
I note all these videos have very heavy bass playing. The tune sometimes seems a bit incidental to this kind of bass enthusiast. Noisy bass with treble accompaniment. I just don't get it, I'm afraid.
Proper melodeon playing. I especially like the Andy Cutting video.
-
Sal, I am afraid you are cooked.
Unless you are a budding virtuoso, you cannot have this sound.
I can tell you through 10 years of melodeon tears that a Steb will not make one play like Clive, the nicest Dino/Oakwood like Anahata, the sweetest Pokerwork tuneup like Honerous or Lester, etc. etc.
This is Casta is nice and dry. I have one too (it's a Laura at present) but it squacks because I am a mere mortal.
-- S
-
Thank you all for your input.
I'm planning to buy a Mory and this spec sheet is available for tuning: https://www.castagnari.com/doc/tabella_accordatura_generale_-_1.pdf
I think demi swing will probably match the tunings in the YouTube videos.
-
On that specification Andy Cuttings box is swing not demi-swing.
-
I can tell you how Andy Cuttings box is tuned: it’s a 1Hz swing. //
On that specification Andy Cuttings box is swing not demi-swing.
I had to use an online calculator to get from 440/441 Hz to a difference in cents... it appears to be around 4 cents. That seems like what I'd call demi-swing, but maybe I'm missing something.
-
I Hz or 4.5 cents is what Castagnari call swing.
-
You also need to tell us whist your mean by Demi swing? It can mean either a something between swim and dry, or something a little wetter than swing, depending on who you are talking to.
Bernard Loffet lists his Demi Swing tuning as being wetter than Swing, which is odd because Demi usually means half or less than.
https://diato.org/accord.htm
-
I suppose some see the demi-swing glass as half-dry, some see it as half-wet...
I'm in the second camp; I think of the "swing" as swinging away from dry, and toward "musette." But this is probably just a form of free-association on my part. I'm assuming the etymology has to do with the tunings used by swing bands in the US, since I also see the term "American swing" sometimes.
But the Melnet info page at http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/page,voices_tunings.html agrees with Loffet, whether by chance or design:
Demi-swing: about 2 to 3 beats per second (8 - 12 cents at A=440)
Swing: a light tremolo of 1 to 1½ beats per second (4 - 6 cents at A=440)
-
But the Melnet info page at http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/page,voices_tunings.html agrees with Loffet, whether by chance or design:
Demi-swing: about 2 to 3 beats per second (8 - 12 cents at A=440)
Swing: a light tremolo of 1 to 1½ beats per second (4 - 6 cents at A=440)
Yes - I wrote that page, quite a long time ago now. At the time I did quite a lot of research into how the various makers described their tremolo, and also based on the experience of my own instruments and those of my friends and colleagues.
-
Steve, it looks like sound research from what I can tell, and it can't have been a simple task, given the variety of ways makers go about it.
So, Castagnari (as well as B. Gaillard) places "demiswing" between "dry" and "swing," and their definition of "swing" is at ~1Hz. To my mind this puts their "demiswing" at 2c/.5Hz or what I know as "off dry" or "concert tuning" -- for when you don't really want any discernable aural beating, but you also want a better/less thin timbre.
So to Sal's question... I'd say the only box in the three videos posted that sounds anywhere near that dry is perhaps Brotto's, and that's perhaps only due to the at-pitch L reed. So I understand why swing is the safer bet as far as Castagnari is concerned. I'm sorry if I muddied the waters earlier with my question about the 4c -- I see that it entirely depends on the maker in question.
-
Maybe what I meant to say was that Castagnari's "swing" is dry, dry, dry.
It does not cover up for any player deficiency.
-
But Castagnari’s swing is not dry, it’s near dry, damp if you like, but it’s not quite dry. Blurring the meaning of words like that makes it more difficult for players to communicate their wants to makers and tuners.
-
Theo, it does dry out considerable on the long air trip over the Pond.
That's why, I guess, things have gotten further obfuscated by the addition of "tremolo Americano" and such.
Sticking with Hz. is good but the sound of the reeds, box, voices, skill pitch, etc. etc. makes this subject one of the most "subjective" topics on the Forum.
-
Agreed that assessing the sound is subjective, but it’s still beneficial to use a numerical measure of pitch difference/beat rate as a starting point.
-
I note all these videos have very heavy bass playing. The tune sometimes seems a bit incidental to this kind of bass enthusiast. Noisy bass with treble accompaniment. I just don't get it, I'm afraid.
That's odd, all I'm hearing is tunes that are very central on the contrary, and basses that have the right amount of presence and balance with the right-hand side.
-
-Y-, I think it’s mostly a matter of musical culture. Richard Flemming plays in the Irish tradition where melody is king, other European traditions make much more use of chords and harmony.
-
No doubt - Bandoneon (LM) register, no vibrato - my favorite (:)
Getting back to the topic...
I'm not sure what I'm hearing on Brotto's box. Could he be using bandoneon (LM) voicing? [...].
-
You're right Theo, I guess everyone has his listening habits, but even with that in mind I don't really find the initial comment really fair to the music played, that is rather at the service of the melody. Even Irish music is not a stranger to harmony, and I find that in the videos cited it was far from noisy, rather examples of subtlety.
But, as you said, regarding tastes, to each his owns.
Sorry for the off-topic deviation, matter closed for me.
-
Apart from the aesthetics of drier vs wetter tuning, drier tuned instruments sound more 'in tune' with their reference pitch (which may or may not be 440Hz), e.g. their basses and also with other instruments, like a fiddle or geetar, which has obvious advantages if you play a lot with other musicians. Listen to some Scottish dance music with a ‘Scottish tuned' accordion playing along. It sticks out like a sore thumb.
-
Wet or dry strikes me as very much a matter of personal preference. The very moist tuning of a Pokerwork makes it cut through any other sound (musical or otherwise) in a way many others don't. My own preference is for a very light swing as is typical of a Castagnari - just enough to mask the dissonances of equal temperament tuning. I had a Lilly which was a lovely little box, but the single voice made certain intervals rather grating on the ear.
As a guitar player, Roger, you'll have the same experience with tuning that. I guess no-one really tunes their guitar to equal temperament, tuning the open strings to pitch and then tempering them to suit the keys in which you are going to play. I always find a marked difference in tuning is required for chord playing in G or C compared with that which suits E or A, particularly in first position. More to the point in discussing wet vs dry, any instrument with dual courses, e.g. 12 string, mandolin, etc can be perfectly unison tuned and like a 6 string guitar will suffer the same problems of tempering, but if it is less than perfect in its tuning, the jangle created masks the imperfections just as a tremolo tuned box does.
Enough! Merry Chrisymas,
Rob.