Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Luke Alexander Holstein on December 26, 2020, 03:29:40 AM
-
Can I use a brass brush to clean the reed tongues or would that be to harsh. If not I'll buy fiberglass pens online.
-
A brass brush is OK to use as the metal is softer than the steel of the reed tongue and will not scratch the steel. For cleaning the top surface of the reed tongue you need to supprt the tongue with a thin metal shim.
However, a brass brush is not so good for cleaning the underside of the reeds as the bristles don't reach into the reed plate slot very well. There is also the problem of the bristles tending to get caught between the reed tongue and the slot, which is inconvenient but also could lead to the reed tongue getting pushed sideways out of alignment.
A fibreglass pen is a good alternative tool but be sure to wear gloves and a face mask, because the pen sheds irritating fibres in use.
For cleaning the inside surface, I use an old jeweller's screwdriver which can reach down through the reed plate slot. Use the screwdriver blade to gently scrape the reed tongue, working from rivet to tip. Be careful and gentle near the tip of the reed tongue, especially on the thin high-pitched reeds which are very delicate. Always ensure the reed tongues are supported by a shim (when cleaning the top surfaces) or placing the reed plate on a hard surface (when cleaning through the slot).
You could also use a very fine diamond file (400 grit or finer) but be careful not to overdo the filing as you will start to affect the reed tuning too much.
You will probably need to retune the reeds anyway after cleaning the rust off, although badly rusted reeds might return to something near to their original pitch after cleaning.
-
Not probably. You will definitely need to retune after removing rust!
-
I always use a fibreglass pen, not because a brass brush is too harsh but because all the brass brushes I've tried - including some quite expensive ones - have shed bits of brass. Fibreglass sheds too, but the bits are much easier to remove. I echo Steve's advice re protection of hands, eyes and airways.
Graham
-
Has anyone tried the proprietary rust removing fluids which seem to be readily available? I recently tried some Evaporust stuff on an old Hohner treble mechanism and it worked pretty well.
-
I have been using the fine screwdriver method, plus the rust remover, and it seems to be OK
SJ
-
i've had reeds end up a semitone or more flat using the scraping method if rust is particularly bad at the rivet end. how about vinegar ? is that safe to use? works well on other metal parts but not tried it on reeds.
-
You could also use a very fine diamond file (400 grit or finer) but be careful not to overdo the filing as you will start to affect the reed tuning too much.
these can be handy if cut down to fit the slot
https://www.ebay.co.uk/i/184534215024?chn=ps&norover=1&mkevt=1&mkrid=710-134428-41853-0&mkcid=2&itemid=184534215024&targetid=1000147647020&device=c&mktype=pla&googleloc=1006586&poi=&campaignid=10199419126&mkgroupid=101401894545&rlsatarget=pla-1000147647020&abcId=1145984&merchantid=7258514&gclid=EAIaIQobChMInZzGiNnr7QIVCuztCh3NpA0REAQYASABEgI9SPD_BwE
-
For the inside, scraping with narrow flat screwdrivers and also brass tool I made for purpose (brass is softer than steel). Abrasive block and Emery cloth for the exterior. Small steel brush scrubbed sideways across the rivet. Use of feeler gauge to support the Reed and occasionally to clear right down to the base...but beware cos I have sliced my fingers several times with a feeler gauge. If a Reed is actually pitted/tracked by heavy corrosion it’s a goner. Scraping will mess up the tuning and more often than not the set/profile, both of which will need correcting. Personally i don’t use a file. In fact I’ve seen a whole set of reeds ruined by someone who 'cleaned' off the rust with a file.
-
i've had reeds end up a semitone or more flat using the scraping method if rust is particularly bad at the rivet end. how about vinegar ? is that safe to use? works well on other metal parts but not tried it on reeds.
Acid corrodes steel.