Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Sebastian Trudgian on December 27, 2020, 09:27:53 PM
-
Hello
I am a complete beginner. I’ve been very kindly lent a great DG melodeon to practice on (am loving it!) but at some point the owner will want it back and have been looking at options... By lucky chance a multi-instrument player has actually given me a very old and tatty DG pokerworks as it didn’t work.
I followed instructions here (playing notes hard, tape, gasket etc) and managed to get all keys (I think) working again to some extent which is great.
However it looks like one of the bass G chord Reeds has snapped off (see photo) so I’ve temporarily covered it with electrical tape which makes it playable but, I imagine, out of tune.
Do you happen to know if it’s possible (where?!) to buy this specific missing reed to fit?
I’ve attached a photo. In it you can also see a suspicious bit of black plastic (bottom of photo) I found in the bellows which looks worryingly like it’s come off another Reed but to my (beginner) eyes I couldn’t see where it came from so hoping it’s a left over bit from somewhere?
Alternatively do you think it’s best I just leave that G chord Reed blocked off with tape and use the melodeon to practice with (when the owner takes back the working one) and save up to get a fully working one some time in the future?
Thanks for your help/advice
-
CGM musical -Charlie Marshall will sell you a single reed plate. I would go for Cagnoni standard type - they sound similar to Hohner.
http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Welcome.html
-
I’ve attached a photo. In it you can also see a suspicious bit of black plastic (bottom of photo) I found in the bellows which looks worryingly like it’s come off another Reed but to my (beginner) eyes I couldn’t see where it came from so hoping it’s a left over bit from somewhere?
That looks like part of a valve - those black and white plastic things next to the reeds. They are prone to break with age. Losing part of one like that is harmless if it doesn't get stuck under a reed or pallet, so just remove it and throw it away. On an old instrument, other valves may start disintegrating over time.
The reed you have wrapped round with tape won't sound at all. if it's part of a chord, that chord won't necessarily be out of tune, but it will have only two notes out of the three it should have and consequently may sound a bit thinner than the other chords. If the instrument is playable now, and it's not yours, it will do no harm to keep playing it.
To replace a broken reed would mean replacing the small rectangular metal plate which actually has two reeds, one on each face. That is held in with wax, and rewaxing it is slightly ambitious if you've never done it before.
-
That’s brilliant thank you both that answers my question perfectly :-)
-
If I read your first post correctly you have been lent a D/G in good condition and also been given a tired one for keeps.
I would say while you've got the two play them both.
The one in good condition will be a lot easier to learn tunes on but using the other at the same time (well swopping over half way through your daily practice session or every ten minutes, whichever is shorter) will do wonders for your basic ability to get a tune out of any box that someone puts in your hands.
When you get your replacement bass reed from Charlie Marshall also buy a 100g block of reed wax - it may seems expensive for what it is but it is an essential for replacing the broken reed. Charlie's website has a video of the reed waxing technique he uses. As long as you have a reasonably steady hand it is a very easy thing to do. It was quite literally the first box repair I did myself - after a box bought from another member ( in fairness it was sold as a project box) arrived with a reed loose.
Charlie also does packs of assorted valves for a few pounds - get one of those and forget about saving up for another box for a couple of years.
-
When you get your replacement bass reed from Charlie Marshall also buy a 100g block of reed wax - it may seems expensive for what it is but it is an essential for replacing the broken reed. Charlie's website has a video of the reed waxing technique he uses. As long as you have a reasonably steady hand it is a very easy thing to do.
Yes, and Charlie's video depicts a highly unsafe and hazardous way of melting the wax. You should NOT melt the wax in a pan over an open flame (a camping gas stove in this case). It's a serious accident waiting to happen. Please don't do it. Use an electric hot plate instead.
But for simply replacing one reed plate, it's far more convenient to use reed wax in stick form, which Charlie also sells. The wax can be melted using an electric soldering iron, preferably with a variable temperature control. Otherwise let the iron heat up, then switch off and allow to cool for a few seconds before use.
-
Your best option could well be to get the older pokerwork professionally fettled while you have the temporary use of the other one.
It could well be that there is not that much wrong with it and you would end up with a very good working instrument, nicely in tune, for far less than the price of a second hand pokerwork.
If you are hell bent on doing the work yourself have a good look at Lester's hot rod videos
CGM musical -Charlie Marshall will sell you a single reed plate. I would go for Cagnoni standard type - they sound similar to Hohner.
http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Welcome.html
Why do you recommend buying a Cagnoni reed? Why not buy a Hohner one?
-
I get my individual Hohner plates from here - http://www.hohner-cshop.de/ they have closed their on-line shop until 01/01. You will need to know which plate you want ie. the combination of notes on the plate. They may be the same, they may not - others ( me included!) should be able to tell you from their box if you don't have a tuner, but you will see how you order from a drop-down menu. They come valved.
I am not sure Charlie sells individual Hohner plates as opposed to sets.
If you want enough wax for one plate, drop me a PM & I'll send you some. I have plenty and have pretty much gone over to gasket/screws for my own resto. work. You may find you end up getting kitted out and doing the whole kaboosh before you are happy with it.
I have not seen many reeds prone to break, or to have broken in the relatively limited number of Hohner boxes I have done, but, worryingly, if I have found 'a' broken reed ( or had one break ) it has tended to be a "trend" within that particular box, ie. there is an overall issue of metal quality in that reed set, no doubt related to manufacture.
-
[/quote]
Why do you recommend buying a Cagnoni reed? Why not buy a Hohner one?
[/quote]
Fair point - Hohner or Cagnoni would work.
-
If you know which of the chord's reed (which pitches) it is I have probably got one you can have along with some wax.
-
I can see quite a few rusty spots on your reeds. If your goal is to end up with a playable, nicely tuned box, I'd suggest you contact a skilled accordion technician, such as Theo, Lester and others in the same league.
-
Thanks everyone again for your kind help and advice and also the incredible offer to possibly send me a spare Reed if you have one (happy to pay for it/put a donation into a charity for it).
I’ve tried to identify it by the, probably not correct method (!) of taking the bass plate off and putting tape temporarily over each of the three holes under the button (G chord) that doesn’t work and seeing what my iPhone tuner says.
I’ve drawn the results as a picture, does this look right/help identify which one is broken?
Thanks again
-
Yes that is correct. The broken reed would have been G. So you need an G/F# reed.
This particular reed breaks more often than others because its a chord that is used frequently, and the reed is one of the lowest pitch chord reeds on a DG (only the F# is lower) so its rather thin which makes it more prone to failure.
-
That’s brilliant thanks Theo.
I’ll try to find a G/F# Reed!
-
This is where it's useful to get hold of an old piano accordion as a source of spare reeds. Find an F# or G of the correct octave and tune the other tongue up or down by a semitone as required.
Something like this Hohner Tango IV for £60. https://www.facebook.com/marketplace/item/1465264040349438/