Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Robin on December 29, 2020, 12:25:40 PM
-
Hello,
I've been wondering how melodeon makers choose the notes for the left-hand chords.
There seem to be no fixed standard, even amongst instruments from the same maker.
For instance, I've played instruments with the G chord set up like this: G,B,D or B,D G or even D G B.
I'm guessing part of it is linked to the key of the instrument and its range (F/Bb vs D/G, for instance), and part of it is down to personal preferences. But sometimes it varies quite a bit amongst instruments in the same keys. And occasionally it's not even completely consistent with the other chords in the same instrument.
The reason I'm pondering about this is I have to choose third-less chords for a new instrument.
I'm pretty sure about these: F, C, G, D, A, E = | [CF] | [G,C]| [G,D] | [A,D] | [A,E] |.
But I'm trying to decide about these two: B and F# = | [B,^F] or [^F,B,] | [^C^F] or [^F,^C] |
And if I choose the version with the low F# ( i.e. [^F,B,] | and [^F,^C] | ), should I also change the F chord from [CF] to [F,C] ?
Your thoughts on this matter would be welcome (:)
Thanks for your help!
Robin
-
I just realised some of this has already been discussed here: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,23350.msg278543.html#msg278543
-
Usually (not always) the chord reeds are chosen to keep all the chord pitches within a range of a little over one octave. If all the chords were voiced the same eg all riot position then the highest chord (usually B) would sound noticeably high in pitch compared to the lowest (usually C). I’ve seen some Verde boxes set up like this, but mostly the chords are kept within the same range.
-
Here attached are the chord voicings for a D/G box from various manufacturers, previously posted in this thread:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,23350.msg278457.html#msg278457
-
Here attached are the chord voicings for a D/G box from various manufacturers, previously posted in this thread:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,23350.msg278457.html#msg278457
It's noticeable that the Hohner chords are generally lower pitched than all the "modern" boxes (Castagnari, Baffetti, Serenellini), for example the G is the root instead of first inversion.
This might explain why the chords often sound less intrusive and sweeter on them, the lower pitch means more separation from the right-hand pitch.
I wonder why all the newer boxes have moved the pitch up -- is this linked to the desire to get more reeds and/or basses in?
-
Usually (not always) the chord reeds are chosen to keep all the chord pitches within a range of a little over one octave.
Thanks Theo. Seems logical. But I'm confused about Hohner's system where the G and C chords have a low G but the Em chord has a high one.
Or with an other Hohner in A/D where there is a low F# in the Bm and F# chords but a high one in the D chord. And a high G in the G chord even though the E chord has a low G# (and the D/G version has G in the root position) :o
Here attached are the chord voicings for a D/G box from various manufacturers
Very interesting Steve. Over the last few years, I have been noting the chord voicings for various instruments too.
I never got round to making a chart with the gathered information though. Thanks for the work.
This might explain why the chords often sound less intrusive and sweeter on them, the lower pitch means more separation from the right-hand pitch.
I have the same feeling with old Hohner chords.
I think I prefer the B and F# chords with a low F#. But in that case, should I also ask for a low F in the F chord to make the chord voicing consistent? Is there a risk to take it this low? I guess the lower pitch also means less separation from the basses.
-
Then there's my Salterelle, with different G inversions on the pull and the push...
-
Then there's my Salterelle, with different G inversions on the pull and the push...
This is also true for the D chord on Pokerworks etc, see Steve's pdf above.
-
Both my van der Aa and Gaillard are 1+5 chorded, and both have some inverted. Hadn’t thought on why, so am grateful for Theo and Ian’s insights.
Both components are 2 reeds on the van der Aa. I use the register to cut low bass note out quite a lot. it makes rt hand chord extends sweeter as Ian suggests. I’m usually after a smooth “pavement†of cadence, as a singer. I appreciate that a more percussive doubled bass is often better against tunes.
Another register mutes the 5th in the chord button. So, using both I end up with just 2 notes, an octave* apart. Feasable for more complex bass runs, but not a step I’ve actually taken
*Except my push B chord 🤔. For some reason that down registers to 2 identical notes. I’d speculate that it might be something to with reed block size. B is the lowest note on my left end.
All my push or pull basses work identically. Ditto the duplicated C and D chords
-
Then there's my Salterelle, with different G inversions on the pull and the push...
This is also true for the D chord on Pokerworks etc, see Steve's pdf above.
I wondered what that strange feeling of deja vu was ;D