Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Ollie on October 09, 2009, 08:59:39 PM
-
Why do Irish melodeon player favour the chromatic system, when Irish concertina players favour the diatonic system? Or vise versa? Something that has been puzzling me for a while.
-
Your question brings out just how confusing the terminology for describing the nature of accordion/concertina systems can be, in that both the semitone system "British chromatic" accordions, and the Anglo-chromatic concertina, are simultaneously "diatonic" in that they both play different notes on press and on draw, and "chromatic" in that they can play all the notes of a chromatic scale...
-
As suggested above, both accordion--sorry--and concertina players move towards a "chromatic" mode of playing Irish music. This is one reason why Irish players make such a strict division between accordion-two row-and melodeon-one row, the latter offering tons of push and pull.
I find the BC "accordion" system rather fascinating in making a "chromatic" out of a diatonic two row instead of moving to a true chromatic box. The usual explanation is that this is just the tradition that was established but it also has led to the appreciation of a certain sound that requires all the push-pull confusion in strange places. It is one thing to hear the beautiful smoothness of a Joe Derrane playing across the rows and to hear the smoothness of a true chromatic, which does not sound right at all.
-
I find the BC "accordion" system rather fascinating in making a "chromatic" out of a diatonic two row instead of moving to a true chromatic box. The usual explanation is that this is just the tradition that was established ...
You'll find my explanation of it here: Irish Button Boxes, from Scotland (http://www.concertina.net/forums/index.php?showtopic=2347)
-
What an amazing bit of history. Thanks, Stephen.
back to lurking in ignorance
-
Great "article" there Stephen, though in some ways if one were to say that the answer lies in history that's only part of the whole. History has reasons behind it! What are they?
It is intriguing. After all, apart from rows a fourth or fifth apart, the melodeon equivalent of the ubiquitous Irish concertina is a G/C two and a half row box, and how many of those do you see in an Irish session! (Yes yes, ok, I know, there's one in your session every week, but more generally......)
It would be interesting to compare numbers of players of D/G melodeons with players of G/D concertina in Irish music. Tim Edey and others demonstrate Irish music on the D/G box, and most D/G players I know have some Irish tunes in their repertoire, up to speed etc, but the concensus seems to be that the quint box is not for Irish music.
I do wonder whether part of it is in the fingering. The fact that the tune playing load is shared between hands on the concertina, does that, and the relatively static hand position, make it more suitable for Irish music than the D/G melodeon? I gather "half step" concertinas have been tried, but for sure it has never caught on widely! Instinct says that the fingering patterns of a half step box wouldn't work so well in the hand position of a concertina, but I have no evidence.
This is probably a question for a joint melodeon.net concertina.net thread!
-
Question: is there such a thing as a B/C or similar concertina?
Yes, it's called the English Concertina, a bit obvious I know - but maybe it's name was a bit of a put-off in Ireland hence the prevalence of Anglo-German 'tinas in Ireland?
AL
-
A fiend of mine who knows Noel Hill well says he tried G/D Anglo for quite a while but came down to the C/G as the best for 'standard' keys
I pay D/G melodeon but favour C/G Anglo for the combination of fluidity and bounce it gives ( I have a 26 button Jeffries, so still use that diatonic core to my playing)
-
This is probably a question for a joint melodeon.net concertina.net thread!
Question: is there such a thing as a B/C or similar concertina?
a BCC# concertina would make a lot of sense rather than a GC with a row of odds & sods varying on different makes. At least it would to me! ;)
george
-
. It is one thing to hear the beautiful smoothness of a Joe Derrane playing across the rows and to hear the smoothness of a true chromatic, which does not sound right at all.
could it be because some notes are changed on the button & some on the bellows & this is random dictated to a large degree by the needs of a particular tune whereas on what you refer to as a true chromatic, presumably meaning a piano acc or continental chromatic all note changes are on the button. The difference is a very slight random unevenness taht is very hard to replicate on one note per button or key boxes. I would however make the point that both the BC & particulaarly the BCC# are true chromatics the former being much easier to play in all keys than the latter but both are nevertheless chromatic - an instrument is either chromatic or it isn't - there is no such thing as being a bit chromatic!
george (in pedant mode!) ;)
-
I would however make the point that both the BC & particulaarly the BCC# are true chromatics the former being much easier to play in all keys than the latter
If a BCC# is a BC with an added C# row, I would have thought that it would be as easy or easier to play a BCC# in all keys, or am I missing something?
-
. It is one thing to hear the beautiful smoothness of a Joe Derrane playing across the rows and to hear the smoothness of a true chromatic, which does not sound right at all.
could it be because some notes are changed on the button & some on the bellows & this is random dictated to a large degree by the needs of a particular tune whereas on what you refer to as a true chromatic, presumably meaning a piano acc or continental chromatic all note changes are on the button. The difference is a very slight random unevenness taht is very hard to replicate on one note per button or key boxes.
george (in pedant mode!) ;)
Does this relate, at least in part, the precise finger articulation that having bellows changes forces on the player? I think that what a lot of trad musicians dislike in PA or CBA playing is when you get "legato plus" playing where all the notes overlap a tiny bit and it all goes slushy. You wouldn't do this across a bellows change, and that affects the whole playing style?
-
This is probably a question for a joint melodeon.net concertina.net thread!
Question: is there such a thing as a B/C or similar concertina?
a BCC# concertina would make a lot of sense rather than a GC with a row of odds & sods varying on different makes. At least it would to me! ;)
george
I suspect (and possibly find) that that illogicality is at least part of the appeal of Anglo!
(But isn't this true of all push-pulls. Wouldn't logic say we should all be playing CBAs or English/Duet concertinas.)
Tom
-
I would however make the point that both the BC & particulaarly the BCC# are true chromatics the former being much easier to play in all keys than the latter
If a BCC# is a BC with an added C# row, I would have thought that it would be as easy or easier to play a BCC# in all keys, or am I missing something?
sorry - I got my formers & latters arseupards - I meant the BCC# is easier
george
-
I suspect (and possibly find) that that illogicality is at least part of the appeal of Anglo!
(But isn't this true of all push-pulls. Wouldn't logic say we should all be playing CBAs or English/Duet concertinas.)
Tom
I like to think of the the push pulls as ;D 'illogically logical!'
george
-
This is probably a question for a joint melodeon.net concertina.net thread!
Question: is there such a thing as a B/C or similar concertina?
a BCC# concertina would make a lot of sense rather than a GC with a row of odds & sods varying on different makes. At least it would to me! ;)
george
What you require is one of Mr Dipper's Franglos as played by Emmanuel Pariselle
http://www.concertina.info/tina.faq/images/dipp.htm (http://www.concertina.info/tina.faq/images/dipp.htm)
-
What you require is one of Mr Dipper's Franglos as played by Emmanuel Pariselle
http://www.concertina.info/tina.faq/images/dipp.htm (http://www.concertina.info/tina.faq/images/dipp.htm)
You may also need some of M Pariselle's charming musicality to get the full benefit!
-
What you require is one of Mr Dipper's Franglos as played by Emmanuel Pariselle
http://www.concertina.info/tina.faq/images/dipp.htm (http://www.concertina.info/tina.faq/images/dipp.htm)
You may also need some of M Pariselle's charming musicality to get the full benefit!
No I think you just buy the instrument and you are good to go. Worked for me I bought a Castagnari Mory and was instantly as good as young Cutting ???
-
No I think you just buy the instrument and you are good to go. Worked for me I bought a Castagnari Mory and was instantly as good as young Cutting ???
I thought that too, but when my Mory arrived there was definitely something missing :(
-
"Can we have a bit more talent in the foldback please?"
;D